Nukes in the next four months?

What do you think the chance of nuclear weapons being used in the next four months are?

  • 0%

    Votes: 21 56.8%
  • 1 - 25 %

    Votes: 7 18.9%
  • 26 - 50%

    Votes: 4 10.8%
  • 51- 75 %

    Votes: 2 5.4%
  • 75 - 100 %

    Votes: 3 8.1%

  • Total voters
    37

GreedyBoy

Well-known member
Nov 6, 2024
196
498
63
In my early twenties in the eighties I randomly asked people if they thought they would see the end of the world in their lifetimes. This is was when the USSR was still thought of as a credible nuclear threat, as was "Ronny Ray-guns". I was surprised by how gloomy people were. My illogical optimism proved out. But we are in crazy times again, and I am no longer a determined optimist when it comes to world leadership. Horrendous violence is becoming more and more normalized, and a surprising number of people think it is justified.

Both Iran/US/Israel and Russia/Ukraine are caught in escalation traps at the moment. Terrible things have already happened, the financial and physical safety of the world are in peril and no one is backing down. The world is run by stupid, irresponsible and evil people who want to keep their power, save face, and would rather their own citizens die than look weak or take a loss. One of the players may decide to deploy a "tactical nuke", and try to convince the world that is a practical and wise choice to make - but that will quickly escalate. It is unlikely that a savior will come along (China, aliens, AI) to save us. As far as I can tell it will take something random for things to turn around - for example one of the leaders dying of natural causes (or slipping on a banana peel). Or maybe an uncensored version of the Epstein Files will get released and we find out who is being blackmailed and by whom. Or maybe Trump will lose significant power after the midterms, and the funding for the Iran war will be pulled (which might be what he really wants - he can say that he did not lose the war, but got screwed by those evil Democrats).

 
Will your "" My illogical optimism proved out "" be wrong again?

Shouldn't this be in the political section?

It would be nice if all " stupid, irresponsible and evil people " would slip on a banana plus the two levels below them, and we would have a happy time. It has been proven in monkeys by accident.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GreedyBoy
Will your "" My illogical optimism proved out "" be wrong again?

Shouldn't this be in the political section?

It would be nice if all " stupid, irresponsible and evil people " would slip on a banana plus the two levels below them, and we would have a happy time. It has been proven in monkeys by accident.
I am not looking for a political discussion, just wondering how overwhelming world events are affecting people's outlooks.

My way out of the doom spiral is to realize completely unexpected things do happen. Here's hoping for some beneficial chaos!
 
The people in charge may have nukes at their command but they also realize the effects of using nukes would be financial suicide if used in the Iran area because it could dramatically affect oil rich countries. Using nukes anywhere would be world-wide political suicide to do so.

LTO_3
 
The people in charge may have nukes at their command but they also realize the effects of using nukes would be financial suicide if used in the Iran area because it could dramatically affect oil rich countries. Using nukes anywhere would be world-wide political suicide to do so.

LTO_3
That is rational, but we have not seen much in the way of rationality lately. Geriatric narcissists have different calculations of what is in their interest. Hopefully the people that serve them see their self interest tied to the greater good. Hmmm ... it is a grim thing to hope that the physical and financial interests of the world align with the self-interests of the powerful few!
 
  • Like
Reactions: xix
The people in charge may have nukes at their command but they also realize the effects of using nukes would be financial suicide if used in the Iran area because it could dramatically affect oil rich countries. Using nukes anywhere would be world-wide political suicide to do so.

LTO_3

Agreed

Ever since 9/11 and the economic impact it had I’ve always thought a nuke detonating in a populated area would be devastating to everyone (not the 1%) financially

I don’t like when leaders say it’s an option or reporters asking about it and I don’t like even having the discussion
 
  • Like
Reactions: LTO_3 and GreedyBoy
Why do you sound like you seen the movie "Digger"?
 
I really hope so but ... deterrence only works with rational actors. Just like Europe in June 1914, the Middle East is a powder-keg of rivalries and alliances.
Fair point on the rational actor thing. The 1914 comparison is a stretch though — modern nuclear powers have a much clearer idea of what full-scale retaliation looks like than anyone did before World War I. Still doesn’t make the risk zero.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GreedyBoy
Claude gave me an interesting response.

Me:
The middle east is a powder keg at the moment. If any of the major players (US, Israel, Iran) feel that the other side is going to start war again imminently, the other side will want to attack pre-emptively. With that in mind, are there any anniversaries or significant dates coming up in the next two weeks that any of them can use to start war on?

Claude:

Your premise is mostly right, though the situation is more complicated than a peace that might break down. The 2026 war began on 28 February, and while there have been ceasefires, fighting resumed on 8 July. The current state is a partial pause with a lot of low-level violence, including a US blockade, attacks on shipping, Israeli strikes in Lebanon, and Houthi-Saudi exchanges.

Dates in your two-week window (17-31 October)

20 October: voting at Israeli diplomatic missions abroad begins.
26 October: The anniversary of Israel’s 2024 strikes on Iran. It’s symbolic, but I’d weight it lightly.
27 October: Israeli election. Israel votes to elect all 120 Knesset members, and analysts expect Netanyahu’s government to take a harder stance on crises and conflicts to maximise political gains. The same analysis suggests military activity would stay at a scale that doesn’t impose high costs on the public. It also says only a major escalation could change the election date. A major strike just before the vote is possible, but the incentive points toward looking tough without risking mass Israeli casualties.

Dates just outside the window

3 November: US midterms. This is the most important date. Trump pledged on 8 October not to strike Iran before 3 November, and the blockade remains in force. He also said at a rally that the pause “might be running out in a few weeks”. That makes 3-4 November the likelier point for a US-led resumption than anything before it.

4 November: The anniversary of the 1979 US embassy seizure in Tehran, a major date in Iran’s political calendar.


So, while things are rapidly escalating right now, according to Claude the dates to look out for are October 26 to November 4. Halloween will be extra scary!