Woman on life support after surviving two lethal injections for death sentence

This will be a massive landmark case, and it will likely reshape the legal and constitutional landscape of capital punishment in the US.

There are several grounds to now overturn her death sentence -- most notably the ban on cruel and unusual punishment. The drug they gave her leaked directly into the soft tissue of her arms instead of her bloodstream because the people administering the drug couldn't get a vein and she ended up with serious chemical burns. From what I heard earlier, the prison also failed to follow their own execution protocols.

If I had to bet on the outcome, I would say a judge is now going to commute her sentence to life. I would also not be surprised if she files a major civil suit.

This is probably going to carry on for years.
 
I dont understand why they dont go straight to the guillotine. Its quick and effective

576cb32f05aae_louisette.jpg
 
Crazy lady afraid of the devil.
 
I dont understand why they dont go straight to the guillotine. Its quick and effective

576cb32f05aae_louisette.jpg


Despite its almost certain success rate, I'm sure if you suggested the guillotine to lawmakers they'd say, "oh, no,! We can't do that, cutting off someone's head is barbaric!"

My response to that is, well, at least it's honest and it's a painless, humane death, and if you don't believe in using the guillotine, then you shouldn't believe in the death penalty at all. Opposing the guillotine while supporting lethal injection is pure hypocrisy; it proves they don't care about a painless execution, they just want to sanitize the reality of state-sanctioned murder.

On death certificates, a person who is executed is listed as a homicide -- but interestingly enough, it's not counted as a 'murder' in official statistics, which I also find hypocritical. I've often thought an excellent accountability measure would be for the judge or the jury or whoever sanctions a death warrant to have their names listed as a the one/ones responsible for the "homicide" -- not criminally responsible, but responsible nonetheless. I bet death-penalty sentences would be cut to a fraction if that happened.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer
Despite its almost certain success rate, I'm sure if you suggested the guillotine to lawmakers they'd say, "oh, no,! We can't do that, cutting off someone's head is barbaric!"
You're spot on. I ran it through AI and this is what it came up with (the part in red made me chuckle a bit 😃 )

Q. Why dont they still use it (the guillotine) to this day especially since lethal injection doesnt always work

A. The reality that lethal injection has a high failure rate—often resulting in horrific botched executions due to collapsed veins, untrained staff, and experimental drug cocktails—has led many legal scholars and bioethicists to point out the exact irony you mentioned: mechanically, the guillotine is faster, more reliable, and less prone to prolonged physical torture. [1, 2]
Yet, modern governments do not use it for three powerful reasons: sanitized optics, legal barriers, and the global abolition of the death penalty.

1. The Conflict of Optics vs. Comfort
The primary reason states switched to lethal injection was not to make the death less painful for the prisoner, but to make it less disturbing for the people watching. [1]
  • The "Medical" Illusion: Lethal injection simulates a clinical, peaceful medical procedure. It allows the state to present executions as clean and sterile, masking the reality of the act
The Visceral Horror: The guillotine is inherently violent and bloody. Even if it is medically quicker, no modern government wants the public image of a decapitated head and liters of blood on a prison floor. Society values a death that looks peaceful over one that is mechanically efficient


Link: https://www.google.com/search?q=gui...Q&csuir=1&mtid=WlrAaqP0FqulptQP7KPmoQE&udm=50
 
  • Like
Reactions: JeanGary Diablo
Despite its almost certain success rate, I'm sure if you suggested the guillotine to lawmakers they'd say, "oh, no,! We can't do that, cutting off someone's head is barbaric!"

My response to that is, well, at least it's honest and it's a painless, humane death, and if you don't believe in using the guillotine, then you shouldn't believe in the death penalty at all. Opposing the guillotine while supporting lethal injection is pure hypocrisy; it proves they don't care about a painless execution, they just want to sanitize the reality of state-sanctioned murder.

On death certificates, a person who is executed is listed as a homicide -- but interestingly enough, it's not counted as a 'murder' in official statistics, which I also find hypocritical. I've often thought an excellent accountability measure would be for the judge or the jury or whoever sanctions a death warrant to have their names listed as a the one/ones responsible for the "homicide" -- not criminally responsible, but responsible nonetheless. I bet death-penalty sentences would be cut to a fraction if that happened.

A firing squad is pretty quick and efficient, but not really suitable for public viewing either, at least in North America.

I have also read that the guillotine is the least painful form of execution.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JeanGary Diablo
 
From AI:

Lethal injection has a botched or failure rate of 7.2%.


    • Lethal Injection: 7.2% failure rate (75 botched out of 1,054 attempts)
    • Lethal Gas: 5.4% failure rate (32 botched out of 593 attempts)
    • Hanging: 3.12% failure rate (85 botched out of 2,721 attempts)
    • Electrocution: 1.92% failure rate (84 botched out of 4,374 attempts)
    • Firing Squad: 0% failure rate (0 botched out of 34 attempts

Only 5 US states still use the firing squad:


States that Authorize the Firing Squad
    • Idaho - Made the firing squad its primary default method of execution under a law that took effect in July 2026.
    • Mississippi - Permits the firing squad as a backup method of execution when other drugs or methods are unavailable.
    • Oklahoma - Allows execution by gunfire as an alternative backup choice if lethal injection drugs cannot be found.
    • South Carolina - Gives condemned inmates the choice to die by a firing squad, lethal injection, or the electric chair.
    • Utah - Keeps the firing squad written into law as a backup option if lethal injection drugs are missing
 
  • Wow
Reactions: JeanGary Diablo
What about walking the plank as a form of execution? 😆

The guillotine wasn't used for its effectiveness. It was used to cause fear and intimidation.
 
Last edited:
I believe lethal injection became the "go to" execution method because it's supposedly the most humane way to kill someone. IMO shoot them or the guillotine would be best and screw the humanity part since the killer(s) certainly weren't humane to their victims. Better yet, sawtooth ice pics through the eyeballs to the brain (Hallowe'en execution?) or through the temple.

LTO_3
 
You're spot on. I ran it through AI and this is what it came up with (the part in red made me chuckle a bit 😃 )

Q. Why dont they still use it (the guillotine) to this day especially since lethal injection doesnt always work

A. The reality that lethal injection has a high failure rate—often resulting in horrific botched executions due to collapsed veins, untrained staff, and experimental drug cocktails—has led many legal scholars and bioethicists to point out the exact irony you mentioned: mechanically, the guillotine is faster, more reliable, and less prone to prolonged physical torture. [1, 2]
Yet, modern governments do not use it for three powerful reasons: sanitized optics, legal barriers, and the global abolition of the death penalty.

1. The Conflict of Optics vs. Comfort
The primary reason states switched to lethal injection was not to make the death less painful for the prisoner, but to make it less disturbing for the people watching. [1]
  • The "Medical" Illusion: Lethal injection simulates a clinical, peaceful medical procedure. It allows the state to present executions as clean and sterile, masking the reality of the act
The Visceral Horror: The guillotine is inherently violent and bloody. Even if it is medically quicker, no modern government wants the public image of a decapitated head and liters of blood on a prison floor. Society values a death that looks peaceful over one that is mechanically efficient


Link: https://www.google.com/search?q=guillotine&lr=&newwindow=1&sca_esv=1b9a0e92a4573b1d&sxsrf=APpeQnuH5tWyMcpbCUuwY7ipYR7OW9wHRg:1790990935679&source=hp&fbs=ABfTbFVyMZGZf1hfvX9uKjN_-G8c4u0nXx4bEIpwm1lnNH832cSpkWkfSwsmpNIrD_OQ-UdFAe4qAwsQWVbrtprjzBSpTP2pSHBuP2iAv5_W37Av-jVGmceWkQMlPDoZbq9qt1OA8ECMl7cy7Wi9cD1Bn_bf09lCJlW_A39Jm-pSZtI49Ywj3oD_DDR2v0ElloVdaXImrwzmiYlc4wrslgQsMNV8nr2gFg&vsint=&aep=1&ntc=1&cs=0&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwikkJGU2ZyXAxXNz_ACHe1TFSsQ2J8OegQIFRAD&biw=1472&bih=659&dpr=1.3&mstk=AUtExfDEdJAWEaL5nEUy97HVfdpFS6C5D524BOd7axrmCcOM2TerrQaQOu6lYXAO9b4UP-wLcDsNh-Xk6ebX_nBku3CjWMAn1MVp9xysje5QllD33G5oQ75a0KpeNeU7W_QwgYl45zkN2CxuGSHfIKOzr-XuHoOGzIycOhkX8kHOm3tmLQ0-ayR4vGuLcN5SVRmLZ_89xuCXtTPx_y2WGayT404FKGXhY5dgVvrT1Nmw8yvdqzrncZOZLQj5qNPqS2Q74Jdb0SaAUoEB5kQXkSd7boCbwbx8MSlNJ01j8eA9XFF0jplenk6qUE83PYfLAEtgpmgDbeoewzSptO0-M0eWdmefo86X9vt-KX8FCJJE80ChXmpw5W-4p8cwfDY7ybq-2ri7uid0g70MA0W-sH6XUZtnXweSFRWGSQ&csuir=1&mtid=WlrAaqP0FqulptQP7KPmoQE&udm=50

I just looked it up, and it's interesting that the guillotine was used in Europe well into the 20th century:

Last execution by guillotine in France: 1977
Last execution by guillotine in East Germany: 1968
Last execution by guillotine in West Germany: 1949
Last execution by guillotine in Sweden: 1910
 
This thread should be in the politics forum. In fact, there are already multiple threads about this, over there.

State executioner is probably not a good choice for a DEI hire.
 
Because members of the media were present, the state government couldn’t cover up the execution gone wrong, and what was supposed to be painless and quick has resulted in extended suffering and basically torture.
Probable Pike wishes she was dead .
She is getting something like “an eye for an eye” retribution at this point for her crime.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Massivo
10 Surefire Ways To Execute Criminals

  • Inject them with the COVID-19 vaccine: Slow, but foolproof.
  • Take them to the set of an Alec Baldwin movie: They can even operate a camera before the end comes.
  • Hand them a nice cartoon of the prophet Mohammed and drop them in London: Done and done.
  • Give a bunch of people rifles and put them in a line facing the criminal and then have them all shoot their guns at once: We could call it, and we're just spitballing here, "a firing squad."
  • Place them between JB Pritzker and a hamburger: Oof. What a way to go.
  • Call Texas: They seem to have it figured out.
  • Disguise them as Caitlin Clark and put them in a WNBA game: Decapitation guaranteed.
  • Lock them in a room with a TV that plays nothing but an endless loop of The View: Cruel and unusual, but effective.
  • Give the criminal dirt on Hillary Clinton: Sayonara, criminal.
  • Just get a dude to do it: Let's be honest.
 
10 Surefire Ways To Execute Criminals

  • Inject them with the COVID-19 vaccine: Slow, but foolproof.
  • Take them to the set of an Alec Baldwin movie: They can even operate a camera before the end comes.
  • Hand them a nice cartoon of the prophet Mohammed and drop them in London: Done and done.
  • Give a bunch of people rifles and put them in a line facing the criminal and then have them all shoot their guns at once: We could call it, and we're just spitballing here, "a firing squad."
  • Place them between JB Pritzker and a hamburger: Oof. What a way to go.
  • Call Texas: They seem to have it figured out.
  • Disguise them as Caitlin Clark and put them in a WNBA game: Decapitation guaranteed.
  • Lock them in a room with a TV that plays nothing but an endless loop of The View: Cruel and unusual, but effective.
  • Give the criminal dirt on Hillary Clinton: Sayonara, criminal.
  • Just get a dude to do it: Let's be honest.
Or do like Bruce Willis in Die Hard 3.
Go stand in the Bronx with a I HATE N-WORD sign around your neck.
That oughtta do it 😃