Dems voted for Moslem socialist Abdul El-Sayed: They threw away Michigan Senate seat

I think you are very good at making a seemingly articulate argument. The problem is that the grocery business is not a high margin business. Most of what we pay for groceries are baked into the cost structure. The cost to produce food, process food and transport food is what drives the price. It also ignores that 37 million Americans have govt. food benefits.

Grocers have to deal with low margins, high NYC costs and even NYC taxation and regulation. Now the city government can eat or evade the costs of the last two, but it will likely be costly.
See, this is where you keep arguing against something I didn’t say.

I never said grocery stores are high-margin businesses. They’re not. Grocery retail is notoriously low-margin, and yes, food production, processing, transportation, labour, rent, refrigeration, spoilage and all the other costs of operating in New York are baked into the price.

I understand all of that.

But none of it answers my argument. We call that filibustering: keep piling up adjacent facts until everyone forgets the question you were supposed to answer.

The question isn’t why a private grocery store charges what it charges. The question is whether the government is prohibited from subsidizing access to a basic necessity because doing so might compete with private businesses.

And SNAP doesn’t answer that either. SNAP subsidizes the consumer’s purchasing power, while leaving the existing retail cost structure largely intact. A publicly supported grocery model is testing whether subsidizing or restructuring parts of the delivery system itself can lower the price of certain staples. Those are two different policy interventions.

Maybe it works. Maybe the economics are terrible. Maybe taxpayers discover they’re spending $4 to save somebody $1 at the checkout. If that’s what the evidence eventually shows, I’ll happily call it a failure.

But that’s what an experiment is for.

And you’ve actually identified part of the rationale yourself. If operating a grocery store in New York involves extraordinary rents, taxes, regulations and other fixed costs, then experimenting with a model that removes or reduces some of those costs to see whether basic food can be delivered more cheaply isn’t economically illiterate. It’s testing which parts of the cost structure can be changed.

Your argument still boils down to: private grocers operate on thin margins, therefore government shouldn’t create a subsidized alternative that might put additional pressure on those margins.

That’s a perfectly understandable position for the grocers to take. It’s also protectionism.

And we’re talking about five stores in a city of eight million people. If they’re inefficient, they’ll become expensive little municipal curiosities and I’ll happily say Mamdani got it wrong.

But if five stripped-down stores selling a limited basket of staples can materially undercut the private market, remain fiscally sustainable and attract enough customers that private grocers consider them an existential competitive threat, then we’ve learned something rather important about the market.

That’s the part I find interesting.

I’m not declaring the experiment successful before it begins.

You’re declaring it a failure before it begins.

Only one of us is actually proposing we let the economics decide.
 

The same New York City Council and labour unions were vehemently against Walmart setting up shop in the city on the basis the low margin Walmart model will decimate local shops. And now a not for profit Mamani Mart is okay? I have attached an article from 2011 on this subject for your reference.
The Walmart comparison is at least worth discussing, but you’re flattening the history to make it fit your argument. New York’s opposition to Walmart wasn’t simply that it could sell things more cheaply than local stores. The fight was also about wages, benefits, unionization, labour practices, supplier power and the impact of a giant national retailer using scale against smaller competitors.

If you want to argue that some politicians were inconsistent then, fine. That’s a legitimate point. But Walmart and five bare-bones municipal grocery stores are not economically equivalent just because both might sell cheaper groceries.

Your bookstore rebuttal is more interesting because you actually make my point for me. You say bookstores survive alongside libraries because they offer greater selection, faster access and things libraries do not. Yes. Exactly. That is the argument. Public and private models can coexist because they serve overlapping needs differently. You didn’t disprove the analogy. You explained why it works.

Same with food banks. You say they’re not a serious competitive threat because they serve a limited population. Again, yes. We’re talking about five stores in a city of more than eight million people, not the municipal takeover of the grocery sector.

The part I really struggle with is your claim that capitalism is about an “equal playing field.” It isn’t. Hasn't been for a very long time. Costco has purchasing power a corner grocer can never match. Walmart has logistics and supplier leverage an independent shop does not. Chains spread costs across hundreds of locations. One retailer owns its building while another pays Manhattan rent. Capitalism has never guaranteed competitors identical cost structures or identical advantages.

Your concern about small immigrant-owned grocers is the strongest part of your argument, and I’d take it seriously. If these stores expand and the evidence shows they are materially harming neighbourhood businesses, then that should absolutely be measured and addressed. Track closures. Track revenues. Track customer migration. Track the subsidy per transaction. Then judge the policy on actual results.

What I’m not going to do is accept “this will decimate hundreds of stores” as a fact before the experiment has even begun. That’s a prediction based on your politics.

I’m not claiming the program will work. I’m saying let it run, measure it properly and decide from there. If it becomes an expensive vanity project that harms small grocers, kill it. If it lowers the cost of basic food for people who need it without materially damaging the surrounding market, keep it.

That is a much more defensible position than insisting the government must protect existing businesses from a new competitor before the doors even open.

And yes, you’re still explaining capitalism to a former Bay Street guy while accidentally making his library analogy for him.
 
This is so typical. Just shooting from the hip without any real life experience.

I, on the other hand, know an owner of a grocery shop in Mississauga. The biggest benefit is the store employs her mom and cousin. But real profit is so low she is still at her daytime job. Cheers

I was talking about the chains.
 
The Walmart comparison is at least worth discussing, but you’re flattening the history to make it fit your argument. New York’s opposition to Walmart wasn’t simply that it could sell things more cheaply than local stores. The fight was also about wages, benefits, unionization, labour practices, supplier power and the impact of a giant national retailer using scale against smaller competitors.

If you want to argue that some politicians were inconsistent then, fine. That’s a legitimate point. But Walmart and five bare-bones municipal grocery stores are not economically equivalent just because both might sell cheaper groceries.

Your bookstore rebuttal is more interesting because you actually make my point for me. You say bookstores survive alongside libraries because they offer greater selection, faster access and things libraries do not. Yes. Exactly. That is the argument. Public and private models can coexist because they serve overlapping needs differently. You didn’t disprove the analogy. You explained why it works.

Same with food banks. You say they’re not a serious competitive threat because they serve a limited population. Again, yes. We’re talking about five stores in a city of more than eight million people, not the municipal takeover of the grocery sector.

The part I really struggle with is your claim that capitalism is about an “equal playing field.” It isn’t. Hasn't been for a very long time. Costco has purchasing power a corner grocer can never match. Walmart has logistics and supplier leverage an independent shop does not. Chains spread costs across hundreds of locations. One retailer owns its building while another pays Manhattan rent. Capitalism has never guaranteed competitors identical cost structures or identical advantages.

Your concern about small immigrant-owned grocers is the strongest part of your argument, and I’d take it seriously. If these stores expand and the evidence shows they are materially harming neighbourhood businesses, then that should absolutely be measured and addressed. Track closures. Track revenues. Track customer migration. Track the subsidy per transaction. Then judge the policy on actual results.

What I’m not going to do is accept “this will decimate hundreds of stores” as a fact before the experiment has even begun. That’s a prediction based on your politics.

I’m not claiming the program will work. I’m saying let it run, measure it properly and decide from there. If it becomes an expensive vanity project that harms small grocers, kill it. If it lowers the cost of basic food for people who need it without materially damaging the surrounding market, keep it.

That is a much more defensible position than insisting the government must protect existing businesses from a new competitor before the doors even open.

And yes, you’re still explaining capitalism to a former Bay Street guy while accidentally making his library analogy for him.
The typical small store is 1500 square feet. Monthly rents in New York City run from $3000 in the Bronx to $15,000 in east side Manhattan. Mamdani Mart wont have this significant cost. Despite this disparity, you want the Mamdani Marts to open and inflict obviously predictable damage on small store owners. Will Mamdani find means of sustenance for the decapitated store owners?

Again, libraries and food banks serve only a tiny segment of the population. That is not what the Mamdani Mart is intending to do. The South Bronx location at the Peninsula in Hunts Point is 20,000 square feet. And there is going to be one in each borough. Finally got the difference?

Your ignorance has been brutally exposed despite your Bay Street experience. So let me give you free advise which has been passed down for generations. It is called the Law of Holes: When in a hole, stop digging.

Good luck
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
The typical small store is 1500 square feet. Monthly rents in New York City run from $3000 in the Bronx to $15,000 in east side Manhattan. Mamdani Mart wont have this significant cost. Despite this disparity, you want the Mamdani Marts to open and inflict obviously predictable damage on small store owners. Will Mamdani find means of sustenance for the decapitated store owners?

Again, libraries and food banks serve only a tiny segment of the population. That is not what the Mamdani Mart is intending to do. The South Bronx location at the Peninsula in Hunts Point is 20,000 square feet. And there is going to be one in each borough. Finally got the difference?

Your ignorance has been brutally exposed despite your Bay Street experience. So let me give you free advise which has been passed down for generations. It is called the Law of Holes: When in a hole, stop digging.

Good luck

You think Mamdani's stores will be big enough to put all the delis out of business?
Like food banks do?
 
Big chains like Trader Joe's, Costco, Whole Foods Market will do just fine. Their footprint in New York City is relatively small compared to their national outlook.

That's a big part of the problem. They're not avoiding parts of New York City because they are racist or don't take SNAP benefits.

It's a very difficult place to operate. It will also be a very difficult place for NYC to operate markets. They will just paper over them as much as they can.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
The typical small store is 1500 square feet. Monthly rents in New York City run from $3000 in the Bronx to $15,000 in east side Manhattan. Mamdani Mart wont have this significant cost. Despite this disparity, you want the Mamdani Marts to open and inflict obviously predictable damage on small store owners. Will Mamdani find means of sustenance for the decapitated store owners?
Good luck
Yes, the Hunts Point location is 20,000 square feet. You got me on the size. I’m quite comfortable correcting myself when I get a fact wrong. You should try it sometime.

Unfortunately, correcting the square footage doesn’t magically prove the rest of your argument.

You keep using words like “decimate” and “obviously predictable” as substitutes for evidence. Yes, the municipal store will have a significant cost advantage if it occupies city-owned property rent-free. Nobody is disputing that. That is the subsidy. We established this several comments ago.

What you haven’t established is that this necessarily results in the destruction of the surrounding independent grocery market.

There’s a rather important piece of context you left out while measuring the building. Hunts Point was chosen specifically because it is underserved. There is currently only one full-service supermarket within a quarter-mile of the site, roughly 150,000 people live in the Hunts Point area, and 77% of households in the surrounding neighbourhoods struggle to afford basic necessities.

That seems moderately relevant when predicting the imminent decapitation of the local grocery industry.

And no, the fact that there will eventually be one store in each borough doesn’t establish your argument either. New York has more than eight million residents and well over a thousand existing grocery stores. Five subsidized stores are not, merely by existing, proof that hundreds of independent businesses will disappear.

Could they hurt some nearby stores? Absolutely. That’s a legitimate concern and one I’ve now acknowledged repeatedly. The city should measure it. In fact, that’s precisely why I keep saying measure the results rather than declaring them in advance.

You, on the other hand, have apparently achieved something economists have struggled with for centuries: the ability to predict the precise market consequences of a policy before the businesses have even opened.

And you’re still doing something rather peculiar with the library analogy. You originally told me libraries and bookstores coexist because they offer different selections and serve somewhat different needs. That was my point. Now you’ve changed the argument to libraries serving only a tiny segment of the population, which isn’t even true in any meaningful sense. Public libraries are available to everyone. They are a universally accessible, taxpayer-subsidized public alternative to buying books. Most people simply choose to use both markets differently.

But the larger problem remains the same. You’ve decided that because the municipal stores possess an advantage, their competitors must necessarily be destroyed by it.

That simply does not follow.

If that were true, every independent grocery store in America would already have been wiped out by Costco, Walmart and other enormous chains with purchasing, logistics and capital advantages that dwarf anything available to a neighbourhood grocer.

Your concern for immigrant-owned businesses is legitimate. Your certainty about what happens to them is not.

If these stores open and independent grocers around them start closing at substantially higher rates than comparable neighbourhoods, that’s evidence. If taxpayers are spending absurd amounts subsidizing each grocery bill, that’s evidence. If the stores simply transfer affluent shoppers from private stores into subsidized ones, that’s evidence.

Bring me that and I’ll change my position.

Until then, you’re not presenting economic outcomes. You’re predicting them, declaring your predictions “obvious,” and then congratulating yourself for having proved them.

As for the Law of Holes, I’m familiar with it.

There’s a companion principle worth remembering: when you find yourself repeatedly declaring victory instead of demonstrating it, you probably haven’t won the argument.

So very Trumpian.
 
Something new doesnt mean jumping from the frying pan into the fire.

Joe Biden was a terrible communicator and did not sell his many laudable achievements: student loans, drug benefits, TPS, etc., etc. The Biden Way is a template for success. Not cheap sloganeering like Medicare For All, Defund the Police and all that nonsense
True, yeah, but at the same time people see a lot of dems actively against a better way of life for them that they just get disheartened and vote for solganeering
 
True, yeah, but at the same time people see a lot of dems actively against a better way of life for them that they just get disheartened and vote for solganeering

Its brutal in the US. Millions have no healthcare. And 59% of Americans cannot cover a $1000 emergency expense without borrowing or using a credit card. So I get why there is so much frustration.

But the aim should be something that is achievable. Medicare for All is not achievable. Ever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter

Its brutal in the US. Millions have no healthcare. And 59% of Americans cannot cover a $1000 emergency expense without borrowing or using a credit card. So I get why there is so much frustration.

But the aim should be something that is achievable. Medicare for All is not achievable. Ever.

Yes it is. Its just a matter of will to do so. Medicare already exists. Medicaid already exists. Its just a matter of scheduled expansion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
We have gone over this already. The merits dont matter because the insurance industry has the Senators in their pocket. It will never pass. Ever

And watch how Republicans are trying to steal the midterms. First, through advantage in gerrymandering. And second, disenfranchisement of mail in balloters approved by the Supreme Court
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
Obesity, poor nutrition, drugs and alcohol all have negative impact on pregnancies. But, again, these are the reasons why prenatal care should be available to pregnant moms with these issues.

Prenatal care should be a right in an advanced country like the US. Not the privilege that it is.
From what I understand, U.S. Medicaid for lower income families includes comprehensive prenatal and postpartum care. Medicaid recipients have much higher infant mortality rates than the rest of the population.

The U.S. health agencies recognize shrinking this gap is a priority, but they are also aware of problematic lifestyle choices. Medicaid recipients have much higher rates of obesity, drug usage, alcoholism and smoking.

I think overall infant mortality rates are an important statistic. When you did deeper into stats, lifestyle choices greatly impact infant mortality rates and life expectancy. That's why I typically contrast Canada's life expectancy with Japan's higher life expectancy. There's much more to life expectancy than healthcare.

I have never had an issue with the Canadian healthcare system. Canada has a more successful healthcare model. The U.S. likely move closer to the Canadian model. However, the U.S. will probably always spend much more and have higher degrees of private healthcare.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
We have gone over this already. The merits dont matter because the insurance industry has the Senators in their pocket. It will never pass. Ever

So you think it can't pass now because the current Senators are corrupted.
Or is this an permanent state of affairs that can never change?

And watch how Republicans are trying to steal the midterms. First, through advantage in gerrymandering. And second, disenfranchisement of mail in balloters approved by the Supreme Court

It's very concerning.
 
I think overall infant mortality rates are an important statistic. When you did deeper into stats, lifestyle choices greatly impact infant mortality rates and life expectancy. That's why I typically contrast Canada's life expectancy with Japan's higher life expectancy. There's much more to life expectancy than healthcare.

Can you say more about this?