See, this is where you keep arguing against something I didn’t say.I think you are very good at making a seemingly articulate argument. The problem is that the grocery business is not a high margin business. Most of what we pay for groceries are baked into the cost structure. The cost to produce food, process food and transport food is what drives the price. It also ignores that 37 million Americans have govt. food benefits.
Grocers have to deal with low margins, high NYC costs and even NYC taxation and regulation. Now the city government can eat or evade the costs of the last two, but it will likely be costly.
I never said grocery stores are high-margin businesses. They’re not. Grocery retail is notoriously low-margin, and yes, food production, processing, transportation, labour, rent, refrigeration, spoilage and all the other costs of operating in New York are baked into the price.
I understand all of that.
But none of it answers my argument. We call that filibustering: keep piling up adjacent facts until everyone forgets the question you were supposed to answer.
The question isn’t why a private grocery store charges what it charges. The question is whether the government is prohibited from subsidizing access to a basic necessity because doing so might compete with private businesses.
And SNAP doesn’t answer that either. SNAP subsidizes the consumer’s purchasing power, while leaving the existing retail cost structure largely intact. A publicly supported grocery model is testing whether subsidizing or restructuring parts of the delivery system itself can lower the price of certain staples. Those are two different policy interventions.
Maybe it works. Maybe the economics are terrible. Maybe taxpayers discover they’re spending $4 to save somebody $1 at the checkout. If that’s what the evidence eventually shows, I’ll happily call it a failure.
But that’s what an experiment is for.
And you’ve actually identified part of the rationale yourself. If operating a grocery store in New York involves extraordinary rents, taxes, regulations and other fixed costs, then experimenting with a model that removes or reduces some of those costs to see whether basic food can be delivered more cheaply isn’t economically illiterate. It’s testing which parts of the cost structure can be changed.
Your argument still boils down to: private grocers operate on thin margins, therefore government shouldn’t create a subsidized alternative that might put additional pressure on those margins.
That’s a perfectly understandable position for the grocers to take. It’s also protectionism.
And we’re talking about five stores in a city of eight million people. If they’re inefficient, they’ll become expensive little municipal curiosities and I’ll happily say Mamdani got it wrong.
But if five stripped-down stores selling a limited basket of staples can materially undercut the private market, remain fiscally sustainable and attract enough customers that private grocers consider them an existential competitive threat, then we’ve learned something rather important about the market.
That’s the part I find interesting.
I’m not declaring the experiment successful before it begins.
You’re declaring it a failure before it begins.
Only one of us is actually proposing we let the economics decide.

