Dems voted for Moslem socialist Abdul El-Sayed: They threw away Michigan Senate seat

‘Muslim Brotherhood official website’ celebrates Abdul El-Sayed’s U.S. Senate primary victory



Christian nationalist influence over American politics is increasingly difficult to dismiss as a fringe phenomenon, as religious activists, conservative political organizations and elected officials continue working to expand Christianity’s formal role in government, law and public education.

The movement has gained particular traction within the Republican Party and the Trump administration, where Christian political organizations and activists have secured unprecedented access to the machinery of the federal government.

President Donald Trump established a White House Faith Office in February 2025, placing it within the Domestic Policy Council and directing it to work across the federal government with religious organizations, houses of worship and faith leaders.

The office was given responsibility for recommending changes to federal policies, programs and practices and coordinating with government agencies on religious-liberty initiatives and federal grant opportunities for faith-based organizations.

The administration simultaneously created a Justice Department-led “Task Force to Eradicate Anti-Christian Bias,” whose membership includes the secretaries of State, Defense, Treasury, Education, Homeland Security and Health and Human Services, along with the FBI director and numerous other senior officials.

The task force was directed to examine federal agencies for policies or conduct considered hostile to Christians and recommend changes across the executive branch.

The White House itself describes the initiative as an effort to end what it calls the “anti-Christian weaponization of government.”

Trump later established a Religious Liberty Commission tasked with recommending additional federal policies related to religion and public life.

The administration has also openly promoted a larger role for religion in government, declaring that it intends to protect “God in our public square” and describing faith-based organizations as essential partners of the federal government.

The developments come as polling shows Christian nationalist beliefs remain deeply embedded within American politics.

Research from the nonpartisan Public Religion Research Institute found that roughly one-third of Americans in 2025 qualified as either Christian nationalism “Adherents” or “Sympathizers.”

Among white evangelical Protestants, the figure was approximately two-thirds.

Christian nationalism was also heavily concentrated within the Republican coalition. PRRI previously found that a majority of Republicans qualified as either adherents or sympathizers of Christian nationalism.

The movement is explicitly political.

Christian nationalism generally holds that Christianity should occupy a privileged position within American national identity and government and that the country’s laws and institutions should reflect Christian values.

Polling conducted by Pew Research Center illustrates the scale of that sentiment.

In a national survey, 47 percent of Americans said they favoured or strongly favoured the federal government declaring the United States a Christian nation.

Among evangelical Protestants, support reached 78 percent.

Pew has separately found that approximately half of Americans believe the Bible should exert at least some influence over American law, including respondents who believe biblical teachings should take precedence even when they conflict with the will of voters.

The effort to expand Christianity’s role in government extends beyond Washington.

Christian conservative activists have successfully pushed legislation requiring the Ten Commandments to be displayed in public-school classrooms in multiple states, including Louisiana, Texas, Arkansas and Alabama.

One of the most influential figures behind that movement is conservative Christian activist David Barton, founder of WallBuilders, who has spent decades arguing that the United States was founded as a fundamentally Christian nation.

Barton has advised politicians and state lawmakers and has played a significant role in campaigns to reshape public-school curricula and government policy around that interpretation of American history.

His political allies have included some of the most powerful Republicans in Washington, including House Speaker Mike Johnson and Sen. Ted Cruz.

Christian nationalist ideas have also become intertwined with the broader conservative policy infrastructure.

The Heritage Foundation, which organized Project 2025 and helped develop a detailed governing agenda for a future conservative administration, explicitly grounds its current political philosophy in what it describes as “God as the source of moral order.”

Project 2025 itself brought together dozens of conservative organizations and hundreds of policy specialists to prepare an extensive blueprint for restructuring the federal government.

Its stated priorities included restoring what it called the traditional family, reshaping federal administrative power and defending “God-given” rights.

Christian political activists have additionally promoted concepts such as the Seven Mountains Mandate, which teaches that Christians should exert influence over major centres of society including government, education, media, business, family, religion and entertainment.

Some proponents of the broader Christian nationalist movement have argued openly that American government should reflect explicitly Christian principles rather than religious neutrality.

The movement’s relationship with political violence has also drawn increasing scrutiny.

Christian imagery, prayer and religious rhetoric were prominently present among portions of the crowd involved in the January 6, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol.

Researchers studying Christian nationalism have subsequently found correlations between adherence to Christian nationalist beliefs and greater acceptance of political authoritarianism and political violence.

PRRI’s national research has found Christian nationalism closely associated with support for Trump and with several strongly authoritarian political attitudes.

Among those classified as Christian nationalism adherents, large majorities supported stripping citizenship from Americans deemed threats to the country and deporting them, while substantial majorities supported deporting undocumented immigrants to foreign prisons without due process.

Christian extremist violence in the United States also predates the modern Christian nationalist movement.

Violent anti-abortion extremists have murdered physicians, bombed clinics and carried out other attacks while invoking Christian religious justifications.

White supremacist Christian Identity organizations have similarly combined explicitly Christian theology with racist and antisemitic political ideology and have been associated with terrorism, murder and other extremist violence.

Those organizations do not represent Christianity as a whole, and the existence of Christian extremists does not establish that ordinary Christian Americans support terrorism.

But the distinction becomes important when evaluating how religious political movements are described.

If membership in Muslim organizations, relationships among Muslim activists and approval from extremists elsewhere are sufficient to portray the electoral success of a Muslim politician as evidence of a Muslim Brotherhood political takeover, the same standard would produce an extraordinary picture of contemporary Christianity in the United States.

Christian organizations openly lobby American politicians.

Christian nationalist activists work to change American law.

Christian organizations help draft legislation.

Christian activists campaign to place religious texts in public schools.

Major Republican political figures openly associate with those activists.

A Republican president has established a White House office dedicated to faith, a federal task force specifically addressing anti-Christian bias and a presidential commission devoted to religious liberty.

Tens of millions of Americans hold at least some beliefs associated with Christian nationalism.

And unlike speculative chains connecting a Muslim candidate through relatives and organizations to foreign extremists, much of this Christian political infrastructure operates openly, domestically and directly inside American government.

None of this proves that “Christianity” itself is attempting to overthrow the United States.

There are hundreds of millions of Christians with radically different political and theological beliefs, including large numbers who strongly oppose Christian nationalism.

But applying the same standard frequently used to describe Muslim political participation produces an obvious question:

If a Muslim politician’s relatives, religious associations and ideological overlap with other Muslim organizations constitute evidence that the Muslim Brotherhood is infiltrating American government, what exactly should Americans call a coordinated Christian political movement that openly seeks to shape American law, education, government institutions and national identity around Christianity?

Because by that evidentiary standard, the case for a Christian political takeover is considerably easier to document.

PS.: You're a fucking idiot.
 
Obesity and proper nutrition are a factor. Not proper nutrition from a cost perspective. Proper nutrition as in better choices, eating the right things and not eating excessively.

I have had this argument with Canadian progressives. It would be nice if you could explain the difference in life expectancy between Canada and the U.S. all to Canada's healthcare system. Digging deeper into data shows that Japanese who are known for their healthy lifestyle have a higher life expectancy than Canadians. Even our state by state life expectancy data shows an inverse correlation to state obesity rates.
Yes, obesity and proper nutrition are factors. But these are all the reasons why prenatal care is essential. Rather, millions of pregnant women in the United States do not receive prenatal care and as such potential problems are not treated until too late.

Speaking of proper nutrition in the United States, there are several neighbourhoods without well stocked grocery stores within several miles. But there are fast food joints within walking distances. Guess which is the first dietary choice.
In New York City, Mamdani Marts are coming to the rescue. Major Mamdani is going to open a city owned grocery store in every borough at projected prices 30% less than current prices. The problem is they are going to decimate small to medium sized stores. Socialism's well meaning market place interference is going cause other serious problems.

Here in Canada, every pregnant woman has access to an OBG either privately or at free women's health clinics. Prenatal ultrasounds can detect potential placental abruption or strangulation for an OBG to order immediate caesarean
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
Yes, obesity and proper nutrition are factors. But these are all the reasons why prenatal care is essential. Rather, millions of pregnant women in the United States do not receive prenatal care and as such potential problems are not treated until too late.

Speaking of proper nutrition in the United States, there are several neighbourhoods without well stocked grocery stores within several miles. But there are fast food joints within walking distances. Guess which is the first dietary choice.
In New York City, Mamdani Marts are coming to the rescue. Major Mamdani is going to open a city owned grocery store in every borough at projected prices 30% less than current prices. The problem is they are going to decimate small to medium sized stores. Socialism's well meaning market place interference is going cause other serious problems.

Here in Canada, every pregnant woman has access to an OBG either privately or at free women's health clinics. Prenatal ultrasounds can detect potential placental abruption or strangulation for an OBG to order immediate caesarean
If they can't afford food, those smaller businesses are no more likely to get their business than a more expensive chain. That's the cold truth. It will force the entirety of the market to adjust accordingly. And keep in mind, these stores will carry extremely basic food and household necessities, not the broad choice most other stores will have. They won't decimate them, it will force competition while serving a very specific audience.

Each will have their place in the market and serve their specific audience. Quit the fear mongering. Let the experiment play out. Mamdani is trying what others have refused to do. I would rather see him try and fail than do nothing at all to help his constituents. He's the mayor we all deserve.

Thus far he's been very creative at problem solving. It's pretty impressive.

No one is pushing for pure socialism. But rather a better mix of offerings. People with money will always gravitate to places they feel most comfortable spending their money. Capitalism is fundamentally broken and introducing elements to help right size the problem seems rational and logical.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Yes, obesity and proper nutrition are factors. But these are all the reasons why prenatal care is essential. Rather, millions of pregnant women in the United States do not receive prenatal care and as such potential problems are not treated until too late.

I am not an expert on prenatal care, but we didn't even discuss the effect of drugs and alcohol on pregnancies. Don't get me wrong. I get some of this care enters into the picture. I have some progressive friends involved with healthcare that basically say "if we could only get the money to go into the poor neighborhoods and teach them about their health and nutrition. I don't think changing people's lifestyles is that easy or practical. It's multigenerational and it starts with the family first and then secondarily schools. As I have said here before my grandmother was poor, but amazingly her kids knew a lot about nutrition. The government didn't come to her house and say do this, eat this etc. etc.

Speaking of proper nutrition in the United States, there are several neighbourhoods without well stocked grocery stores within several miles. But there are fast food joints within walking distances. Guess which is the first dietary choice.
In New York City, Mamdani Marts are coming to the rescue. Major Mamdani is going to open a city owned grocery store in every borough at projected prices 30% less than current prices. The problem is they are going to decimate small to medium sized stores. Socialism's well meaning market place interference is going cause other serious problems.

There's more to this issue than meets the eye. Many American cities have resisted big box grocers for years. When they do move into a city, they lose a lot of money to shoplifting. So if you take a low margin business like grocery, limit their size and then they have to take large theft losses, you get what you have now in many urban areas....food deserts. Anyway, you could walk into almost any grocer anywhere in the U.S. and see they accept SNAP (food benefits). The demand is there.

I think NYC would be better off trying to fix the market rather than enter the market as a participant. My guess is opening grocery stores will work on some level, but when you factor in the city's costs it will be exorbitant per customer and sales volume. You might wind up saying you could ship a box of staples by way of Amazon to every poor household.

Interestingly, poor Mexican-American families don't suffer from obesity and metabolic syndrome at nearly the rate of poor African-Americans. These data points lead us back to cultural issues.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
Thus far he's been very creative at problem solving. It's pretty impressive.

No one is pushing for pure socialism. But rather a better mix of offerings. People with money will always gravitate to places they feel most comfortable spending their money. Capitalism is fundamentally broken and introducing elements to help right size the problem seems rational and logical.

Just about everything Mamdani and his team is proposing has been tried before. He might use different words for programs, but they are still the same at their core.

There is no creativity from what I have seen other than the government will provide more and a bizarre openness about destroying private ownership. The last part is where Mamdani and his team members can be described as extreme.

PS- With all that Mamdani wants to provide residents, even hardcore Democrats are asking why did we open the city up to a wave of migrants 2021-2024. Even Socialism must operate under the constraint of the more mouths to feed the more money it will take.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
Each will have their place in the market and serve their specific audience. Quit the fear mongering. Let the experiment play out. Mamdani is trying what others h


The problem with your argument is that it starts with a reasonable criticism and then turns it into something the facts just don’t support.

Yes, most of Mamdani’s ideas have precedents. So do Social Security, Medicare, public schools, public transit and virtually every other government program. “Someone has tried something like this before” isn’t an argument against it. The relevant question is whether it worked and whether it makes sense for New York.

And no, Mamdani is not proposing to “destroy private ownership.” His own housing plan explicitly includes privately financed development and expanded homeownership programs alongside public housing. You can absolutely argue that city-owned grocery stores or greater public intervention are bad policy. But that’s a debate about the appropriate size and role of government, not the abolition of private property.

The migrant issue is the stronger criticism. NYC spent billions sheltering and supporting asylum seekers, and anyone proposing billions in new programs has to explain how the numbers work. But NYC didn’t “open the border.” Municipal governments don’t control American immigration policy.

So criticize Mamdani’s spending, taxes, rent controls or government-run businesses all you like. Those are legitimate arguments. But if you have to turn “more public-sector involvement” into “destroying private ownership” to make the case, you’ve stopped criticising the actual policy and started arguing with a caricature of it.

You just can't be taken seriously when you do that.
 
If they can't afford food, those smaller businesses are no more likely to get their business than a more expensive chain. That's the cold truth. It will force the entirety of the market to adjust accordingly. And keep in mind, these stores will carry extremely basic food and household necessities, not the broad choice most other stores will have. They won't decimate them, it will force competition while serving a very specific audience.

Each will have their place in the market and serve their specific audience. Quit the fear mongering. Let the experiment play out. Mamdani is trying what others have refused to do. I would rather see him try and fail than do nothing at all to help his constituents. He's the mayor we all deserve.

Thus far he's been very creative at problem solving. It's pretty impressive.

No one is pushing for pure socialism. But rather a better mix of offerings. People with money will always gravitate to places they feel most comfortable spending their money. Capitalism is fundamentally broken and introducing elements to help right size the problem seems rational and logical.
Can a store operating at profit compete against a proposed Mamdani store operating without profit? If your answer is yes, then not only are you bereft of basic economic knowledge, you are out and out delusional.

Anyway, store owners have launched a lawsuit against the Mamdani Marts claiming, legitimately, unfair competition. We shall see how the court rules
 
Can a store operating at profit compete against a proposed Mamdani store operating without profit? If your answer is yes, then not only are you bereft of basic economic knowledge, you are out and out delusional.

Anyway, store owners have launched a lawsuit against the Mamdani Marts claiming, legitimately, unfair competition. We shall see how the court rules

If the government, with all it's built in inefficiencies, high pay and benifits can operate a business more effectively than a hyper-efficient private business, than that private business does not deserve to operate.

This was functionally the social contract until a Hollywood Actor, a British Lesbian, and a Big-Chinned Criminal lied to us about Trickle Down economics.

We pay taxes to the government because the government can deliver services more efficiently than we can individually. Where the government CAN'T or chooses not to deliver a service, the private sector steps in to cover the deficiency.

Since the 80's we've abandoned that philosophy, and just decided it can't work that way. Mamdani is proving that it CAN work that way. It makes him a huge threat to the capital class, hence the new US moral panic about Socialism/Communism/DSA candidates.

My take: Oil up the guillotines boys. If the US government is going to feed you contaminated horse meat, it's time to explore the nutritional value of the Billionaires.
 
Can a store operating at profit compete against a proposed Mamdani store operating without profit? If your answer is yes, then not only are you bereft of basic economic knowledge, you are out and out delusional.

Anyway, store owners have launched a lawsuit against the Mamdani Marts claiming, legitimately, unfair competition. We shall see how the court rules

Oh, I understand the economics just fine, I used to be a Bay Street dick swinger. You just seem to think “free market” means private businesses are entitled to their customers, pricing power and margins forever.

Of course a subsidized store can sell certain staples more cheaply. Congratulations, you’ve discovered what a subsidy is. That is literally the point.

And store owners alleging unfair competition is not a court finding unfair competition. They’re asking the government to protect them from a lower-cost alternative created because some people are struggling to afford the existing one. That’s protectionism dressed up as free-market economics.

These stores aren’t even designed to replace conventional supermarkets or bodegas. They’re bare-bones operations providing basic necessities. Private stores still compete on selection, convenience, prepared food, premium products and everything else these stores don’t provide.

And here’s the part you keep avoiding: if someone can’t afford your prices now, you weren’t getting their grocery dollars anyway.

By your logic, food banks should be “unfair competition” because they charge nothing at all. And while you’re explaining basic economics to me, perhaps explain why bookstores haven’t successfully demanded that public libraries be abolished. Libraries use taxpayer money to let people read books for free while bookstores have to sell them at a profit. Yet somehow bookstores continue to exist.

Why? Because public and private services can coexist, serve overlapping but different needs, and compete on entirely different value propositions. Apparently capitalism survives the existence of a library.

Capitalism works when markets serve people. When “capitalism” becomes an argument that government must protect existing businesses from any public alternative because it might pressure their margins, you’re no longer defending competition. You’re defending incumbents from competition.

So let the court rule. Let the experiment play out. If it fails, kill it. If it works, learn from it.

And if five bare-bones grocery stores can supposedly destroy New York’s private grocery market simply by making basic food more affordable, perhaps the problem isn’t Mamdani.

Perhaps your supposedly magnificent free market wasn’t working particularly well in the first place.

Lesson over.
 
Last edited:
Yes, obesity and proper nutrition are factors. But these are all the reasons why prenatal care is essential. Rather, millions of pregnant women in the United States do not receive prenatal care and as such potential problems are not treated until too late.

Speaking of proper nutrition in the United States, there are several neighbourhoods without well stocked grocery stores within several miles. But there are fast food joints within walking distances. Guess which is the first dietary choice.
In New York City, Mamdani Marts are coming to the rescue. Major Mamdani is going to open a city owned grocery store in every borough at projected prices 30% less than current prices. The problem is they are going to decimate small to medium sized stores. Socialism's well meaning market place interference is going cause other serious problems.

Here in Canada, every pregnant woman has access to an OBG either privately or at free women's health clinics. Prenatal ultrasounds can detect potential placental abruption or strangulation for an OBG to order immediate caesarean

Food in america is over processed, GMO laden and generally crap compared to EU countries.
Even Canada suffers this with overlap of legislation.

Now, on top of that, you've got trump letting companies pay him off to get away with selling diarrhea lettuce and even letting MAGA allies sell them rotten beef.

 
Oh, I understand the economics just fine, I used to be a Bay Street dick swinger. You just seem to think “free market” means private businesses are entitled to their customers, pricing power and margins forever.

Of course a subsidized store can sell certain staples more cheaply. Congratulations, you’ve discovered what a subsidy is. That is literally the point.

And store owners alleging unfair competition is not a court finding unfair competition. They’re asking the government to protect them from a lower-cost alternative created because some people are struggling to afford the existing one. That’s protectionism dressed up as free-market economics.

These stores aren’t even designed to replace conventional supermarkets or bodegas. They’re bare-bones operations providing basic necessities. Private stores still compete on selection, convenience, prepared food, premium products and everything else these stores don’t provide.

And here’s the part you keep avoiding: if someone can’t afford your prices now, you weren’t getting their grocery dollars anyway.

By your logic, food banks should be “unfair competition” because they charge nothing at all. And while you’re explaining basic economics to me, perhaps explain why bookstores haven’t successfully demanded that public libraries be abolished. Libraries use taxpayer money to let people read books for free while bookstores have to sell them at a profit. Yet somehow bookstores continue to exist.

Why? Because public and private services can coexist, serve overlapping but different needs, and compete on entirely different value propositions. Apparently capitalism survives the existence of a library.

Capitalism works when markets serve people. When “capitalism” becomes an argument that government must protect existing businesses from any public alternative because it might pressure their margins, you’re no longer defending competition. You’re defending incumbents from competition.

So let the court rule. Let the experiment play out. If it fails, kill it. If it works, learn from it.

And if five bare-bones grocery stores can supposedly destroy New York’s private grocery market simply by making basic food more affordable, perhaps the problem isn’t Mamdani.

Perhaps your supposedly magnificent free market wasn’t working particularly well in the first place.

Lesson over.
I think you are very good at making a seemingly articulate argument. The problem is that the grocery business is not a high margin business. Most of what we pay for groceries are baked into the cost structure. The cost to produce food, process food and transport food is what drives the price. It also ignores that 37 million Americans have govt. food benefits.

Grocers have to deal with low margins, high NYC costs and even NYC taxation and regulation. Now the city government can eat or evade the costs of the last two, but it will likely be costly.
 
The problem with your argument is that it starts with a reasonable criticism and then turns it into something the facts just don’t support.

Yes, most of Mamdani’s ideas have precedents. So do Social Security, Medicare, public schools, public transit and virtually every other government program. “Someone has tried something like this before” isn’t an argument against it. The relevant question is whether it worked and whether it makes sense for New York.

And no, Mamdani is not proposing to “destroy private ownership.” His own housing plan explicitly includes privately financed development and expanded homeownership programs alongside public housing. You can absolutely argue that city-owned grocery stores or greater public intervention are bad policy. But that’s a debate about the appropriate size and role of government, not the abolition of private property.

The migrant issue is the stronger criticism. NYC spent billions sheltering and supporting asylum seekers, and anyone proposing billions in new programs has to explain how the numbers work. But NYC didn’t “open the border.” Municipal governments don’t control American immigration policy.

So criticize Mamdani’s spending, taxes, rent controls or government-run businesses all you like. Those are legitimate arguments. But if you have to turn “more public-sector involvement” into “destroying private ownership” to make the case, you’ve stopped criticising the actual policy and started arguing with a caricature of it.

You just can't be taken seriously when you do that.
Mamdani might be clever in the way he speaks, but it's only fair to think that the people around him might be telling us more about where his Administration is at on private ownership.

Mamdani's tenant director: "We'll transition from treating property as an individual good to a collective good. Whites especially will be impacted."


You might say that's rhetoric and it will never come to government eliminating private ownership. I tend to agree, but I sense the Mamdani Administration will pester and harass homeowners in the middle and upper classes causing harm to property values. Every city comes to this same bridge. How do we make it more easier for poor residents to live in a city while not alienating middle and upper classes who pay the lion's share of property taxes? This not to mention the middle and upper classes drive the restaurant business and other services.

I'd still love to hear from you what Mamdani is proposing to do that's so creative. Things that we have never seen over the last sixty years in urban government.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
I think you are very good at making a seemingly articulate argument. The problem is that the grocery business is not a high margin business. Most of what we pay for groceries are baked into the cost structure. The cost to produce food, process food and transport food is what drives the price. It also ignores that 37 million Americans have govt. food benefits.

Grocers have to deal with low margins, high NYC costs and even NYC taxation and regulation. Now the city government can eat or evade the costs of the last two, but it will likely be costly.

There are ways to make it look like they don't make big profit, which helps them argue against tax raixes.

 
Mamdani might be clever in the way he speaks, but it's only fair to think that the people around him might be telling us more about where his Administration is at on private ownership.

Mamdani's tenant director: "We'll transition from treating property as an individual good to a collective good. Whites especially will be impacted."


You might say that's rhetoric and it will never come to government eliminating private ownership. I tend to agree, but I sense the Mamdani Administration will pester and harass homeowners in the middle and upper classes causing harm to property values. Every city comes to this same bridge how do we make it more easier for poor residents to live in a city while not alienating middle and upper classes who pay the lion's share of property taxes. This not to mention the middle and upper classes drive the restaurant business and other services.

I'd still love to hear from you what Mamdani is proposing to do that's so creative. Things that we have never seen over the last sixty years in urban government.

Mamdani, like Dolly Parton, says people are just people and you don't take away their rights for being an asshole.
That's one of the reasons he's the most popular politician in america, the other thing is that he actually does his job and makes things better for the city.
 
If the government, with all it's built in inefficiencies, high pay and benifits can operate a business more effectively than a hyper-efficient private business, than that private business does not deserve to operate.

This was functionally the social contract until a Hollywood Actor, a British Lesbian, and a Big-Chinned Criminal lied to us about Trickle Down economics.

We pay taxes to the government because the government can deliver services more efficiently than we can individually. Where the government CAN'T or chooses not to deliver a service, the private sector steps in to cover the deficiency.

Since the 80's we've abandoned that philosophy, and just decided it can't work that way. Mamdani is proving that it CAN work that way. It makes him a huge threat to the capital class, hence the new US moral panic about Socialism/Communism/DSA candidates.

My take: Oil up the guillotines boys. If the US government is going to feed you contaminated horse meat, it's time to explore the nutritional value of the Billionaires.
I am talking about small to medium sized stores that operate on thin margins. Those are the ones to be decimated by the not for profit Mamdani Marts. And there are hundreds of them in New York City.
Will Mamdani provide for their owners and their families after their stores are shuttered?

Big chains like Trader Joe's, Costco, Whole Foods Market will do just fine. Their footprint in New York City is relatively small compared to their national outlook. And they will take a hit, if they have to, to retain market share.
Moreover, their customers will not suffer the indignity of stepping inside a Mamdani Mart.
 
Oh, I understand the economics just fine, I used to be a Bay Street dick swinger. You just seem to think “free market” means private businesses are entitled to their customers, pricing power and margins forever.

Of course a subsidized store can sell certain staples more cheaply. Congratulations, you’ve discovered what a subsidy is. That is literally the point.

And store owners alleging unfair competition is not a court finding unfair competition. They’re asking the government to protect them from a lower-cost alternative created because some people are struggling to afford the existing one. That’s protectionism dressed up as free-market economics.

These stores aren’t even designed to replace conventional supermarkets or bodegas. They’re bare-bones operations providing basic necessities. Private stores still compete on selection, convenience, prepared food, premium products and everything else these stores don’t provide.

And here’s the part you keep avoiding: if someone can’t afford your prices now, you weren’t getting their grocery dollars anyway.

By your logic, food banks should be “unfair competition” because they charge nothing at all. And while you’re explaining basic economics to me, perhaps explain why bookstores haven’t successfully demanded that public libraries be abolished. Libraries use taxpayer money to let people read books for free while bookstores have to sell them at a profit. Yet somehow bookstores continue to exist.

Why? Because public and private services can coexist, serve overlapping but different needs, and compete on entirely different value propositions. Apparently capitalism survives the existence of a library.

Capitalism works when markets serve people. When “capitalism” becomes an argument that government must protect existing businesses from any public alternative because it might pressure their margins, you’re no longer defending competition. You’re defending incumbents from competition.

So let the court rule. Let the experiment play out. If it fails, kill it. If it works, learn from it.

And if five bare-bones grocery stores can supposedly destroy New York’s private grocery market simply by making basic food more affordable, perhaps the problem isn’t Mamdani.

Perhaps your supposedly magnificent free market wasn’t working particularly well in the first place.

Lesson over.

The same New York City Council and labour unions were vehemently against Walmart setting up shop in the city on the basis the low margin Walmart model will decimate local shops. And now a not for profit Mamani Mart is okay? I have attached an article from 2011 on this subject for your reference.

Most of the books sold by book stores are unavailable in public libraries. And those that are available in libraries take much longer time to arrive whereas a book by a popular author is instantaneously available in a bookstore. Which is why the two models continue to thrive. So this analogy of yours is useless and dumb.

Food banks are not a threat because they serve just a tiny segment of the population. In fact, most grocery stores contribute to food banks. So this is yet another dumb analogy of yours.

Someone who worked on Bay Street has such a shallow understanding of capitalism. So let me offer you a free lesson. The privately owned grocery stores have to pay exorbitant New York City rents. The Mamdani Mart will have an unfair advantage because they will not pay rent. Capitalism is about an equal playing field. Mamdani will use unfair advantage to decimate hundreds of small to medium sized shops most of which are owned and operated by minorities.

And by the way, the effect of the Mamdani Marts on larger chains like Whole Foods, Trader Joe's, Costco will be negligible. They can eat up margins in New York City and make it up elsewhere if they have to. Moreover, the Mamdani Mart cannot match their selections. It is the one shop immigrant shop owner with limited selections who will be hit hardest.

Understood?
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
There are ways to make it look like they don't make big profit, which helps them argue against tax raixes.

This is so typical. Just shooting from the hip without any real life experience.

I, on the other hand, know an owner of a grocery shop in Mississauga. The biggest benefit is the store employs her mom and cousin. But real profit is so low she is still at her daytime job. Cheers
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
I am not an expert on prenatal care, but we didn't even discuss the effect of drugs and alcohol on pregnancies. Don't get me wrong. I get some of this care enters into the picture. I have some progressive friends involved with healthcare that basically say "if we could only get the money to go into the poor neighborhoods and teach them about their health and nutrition. I don't think changing people's lifestyles is that easy or practical. It's multigenerational and it starts with the family first and then secondarily schools. As I have said here before my grandmother was poor, but amazingly her kids knew a lot about nutrition. The government didn't come to her house and say do this, eat this etc. etc.



There's more to this issue than meets the eye. Many American cities have resisted big box grocers for years. When they do move into a city, they lose a lot of money to shoplifting. So if you take a low margin business like grocery, limit their size and then they have to take large theft losses, you get what you have now in many urban areas....food deserts. Anyway, you could walk into almost any grocer anywhere in the U.S. and see they accept SNAP (food benefits). The demand is there.

I think NYC would be better off trying to fix the market rather than enter the market as a participant. My guess is opening grocery stores will work on some level, but when you factor in the city's costs it will be exorbitant per customer and sales volume. You might wind up saying you could ship a box of staples by way of Amazon to every poor household.

Interestingly, poor Mexican-American families don't suffer from obesity and metabolic syndrome at nearly the rate of poor African-Americans. These data points lead us back to cultural issues.
Obesity, poor nutrition, drugs and alcohol all have negative impact on pregnancies. But, again, these are the reasons why prenatal care should be available to pregnant moms with these issues.

Prenatal care should be a right in an advanced country like the US. Not the privilege that it is.
 
Food in america is over processed, GMO laden and generally crap compared to EU countries.
Even Canada suffers this with overlap of legislation.

Now, on top of that, you've got trump letting companies pay him off to get away with selling diarrhea lettuce and even letting MAGA allies sell them rotten beef.

Even the Secretary of Agriculture refused to name the country of origin of the 300,000 tons of meat Trump is allowing into the US. But it doesnt take any imagination to know it is Argentina.

The cattle ranchers and farmers who are/were strong supporters of Trump are furious. To which I say, it serves you m'fuckers right
 
Mamdani might be clever in the way he speaks, but it's only fair to think that the people around him might be telling us more about where his Administration is at on private ownership.

Mamdani's tenant director: "We'll transition from treating property as an individual good to a collective good. Whites especially will be impacted."


You might say that's rhetoric and it will never come to government eliminating private ownership. I tend to agree, but I sense the Mamdani Administration will pester and harass homeowners in the middle and upper classes causing harm to property values. Every city comes to this same bridge how do we make it more easier for poor residents to live in a city while not alienating middle and upper classes who pay the lion's share of property taxes. This not to mention the middle and upper classes drive the restaurant business and other services.

I'd still love to hear from you what Mamdani is proposing to do that's so creative. Things that we have never seen over the last sixty years in urban government.
You can certainly believe that’s where this is headed, but at the moment that conclusion is based considerably more on your gut and your existing view of Mamdani’s politics than on what his administration has actually done.

And yes, Weaver’s rhetoric deserves scrutiny. Calling private property a “weapon of white supremacy” is inflammatory, and I don’t particularly like it either.

But there’s also a reality here that shouldn’t be waved away just because her language is provocative. Some slumlords are bigots. Some absolutely use housing, tenant screening, neglect and displacement in ways that keep racialized people trapped in worse conditions and worse neighbourhoods. Housing discrimination is not some theoretical academic construct. It has a long, documented history, and parts of it are still happening.

So I’m not going to pretend the underlying grievance is invented simply because I think Weaver expresses it badly.

Where I draw the line is the leap from “there are racist and exploitative actors in the housing market” to “private property itself is white supremacy” or “therefore Mamdani intends to eliminate private ownership.” Those are two very different claims.

As for what Mamdani has done that I think is genuinely creative, I’d start with the Chief Savings Officer initiative.

Rather than simply imposing an across-the-board austerity target, he required every city agency to appoint a senior employee responsible for going through its own operations, identifying waste, inefficient contracts, redundant programs and opportunities to bring outsourced work back in-house. They have to repeat that exercise every six months. The first round identified roughly $1.77 billion in savings over FY26 and FY27.

And these weren’t imaginary accounting savings. They found things like unnecessary consultants and IT contracts, underused office space, duplicate software and hardware, health-plan dependents who weren’t actually eligible, contracts that could be renegotiated and functions that were cheaper to perform internally.

That is a pretty interesting piece of municipal management, particularly coming from the guy who keeps getting caricatured as a socialist who thinks the answer to everything is simply spending more money.

The housing program is another example. Rather than treating affordable housing exclusively as a subsidy problem, his administration is trying to use the city itself as a developer and financial participant: city-owned land, a revolving loan fund, city-backed insurance, new financing mechanisms, accelerated approvals and a substantially larger public-housing capital program.

You can absolutely argue about whether those ideas will work. Some may fail spectacularly. But that’s a different argument from saying there are no new ideas there.

And there’s another inconvenient piece of evidence here. Mamdani inherited a massive fiscal hole, and his administration still managed to produce a balanced budget while adding to reserves rather than simply reaching immediately for a broad property-tax increase.

So I think there’s a perfectly legitimate debate to be had about Mamdani’s ideology, his personnel choices and whether some of his housing policies will distort the market. I’m happy to have that debate.

But “I sense they’re going to pester and harass homeowners and damage their property values” isn’t evidence of that happening. It’s a prediction based on what you already believe about him.

And politically, Democrats also have to get better at making these distinctions forcefully. The right has spent years communicating in emotionally blunt, highly effective language. You don’t counter that by bringing a policy memo to a knife fight. You call actual abuse what it is, defend the policy on the facts, and stop ceding the emotional argument before it even starts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter