Trump considers changing Lake Ontario to Lake America

 
So you're saying voting for a party because you find the leader attractive doesn't make you a supporter of that party? Please explain your position. Thank you for your attention to this matter.

Do you think voting for a party automatically makes you a supporter of that party?
No matter what the reason?

Does this mean that someone who has ever voted for more than one party supports all those parties or supports none of them?
 
Do you think voting for a party automatically makes you a supporter of that party?
No matter what the reason?

Does this mean that someone who has ever voted for more than one party supports all those parties or supports none of them?

so theoretically you could be a high IQ democrat and still vote for Trump?
 
Yes it definitely makes you a supporter. Regardless of the reason. That's what a vote is, a show of support.

They support the party they voted for on the date they voted. Support may change from one election to another.

not if one is party fluid, non-fixed party identity :)
 
  • Haha
Reactions: sweeptheleg
Yes it definitely makes you a supporter. Regardless of the reason. That's what a vote is, a show of support.

They support the party they voted for on the date they voted. Support may change from one election to another.

Ok then.
So the fact she voted for Justin once because she found him attractive (assuming that is true) means nothing when she says she isn't a Liberal supporter.
As you yourself just said, that was on the date they voted and has no bearing on her statement now.
Even if she voted for him every time, there has been an election since then, so it doesn't invalidate her statement.
 
so theoretically you could be a high IQ democrat and still vote for Trump?

Of course.
You are aware that registering for a party doesn't require you to vote for all candidates of that party in the US, right?
 
Of course.
You are aware that registering for a party doesn't require you to vote for all candidates of that party in the US, right?


so you are saying that @Jenesis was wrong when she replied to @richaceg

So when Barrack and Biden won, Americans were smart...somehow their IQ dropped when they voted for Trump?

Yes.

That was an easy one. Next question;

because theoretically it could have been high IQ democrat voters who voted for Trump too
 
Well if it makes you feel better I will conceed that she has been a liberal supporter. I guess she doesn't find Carney attractive enough to continue being a supporter 🤣

You actually don't know a damn thing about if she voted for Carney or why.

Anyway. We've established that your statement didn't track according to your own criteria.
 
I do think Canada should just join the US as a State. We share the same culture, language, ethnicity, values. We were both British colonies. The separation between our two nations is artificial.
I mean you are more than welcome to join them then your separation wont be artificial you'll be a full fledged legal immigrant just watch out for ICE (y)
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
so you are saying that @Jenesis was wrong when she replied to @richaceg

1787786389320.png



because theoretically it could have been high IQ democrat voters who voted for Trump too

No.
I'll leave aside that "IQ" isn't a useful thing here, really, but let's stipulate that we are using it as a general term for "intelligent" or "smart".

The question was whether Americans - as a whole - were dumber to vote for Trump.
The answer is obviously yes.
If all we have to measure is "was this a smart or stupid thing to do" then it was obviously stupid for the vast majority of Americans, or even the smaller group which is Americans who actually voted.
Collectively, it was a different group who voted, so even if you believe in IQ as a fixed, innate trait, it probably holds that her guess is a good one.
That any given trump voter might be a high-IQ democrat doesn't change that.
 
No.
I'll leave aside that "IQ" isn't a useful thing here, really, but let's stipulate that we are using it as a general term for "intelligent" or "smart".

The question was whether Americans - as a whole - were dumber to vote for Trump.
The answer is obviously yes.
If all we have to measure is "was this a smart or stupid thing to do" then it was obviously stupid for the vast majority of Americans, or even the smaller group which is Americans who actually voted.
Collectively, it was a different group who voted, so even if you believe in IQ as a fixed, innate trait, it probably holds that her guess is a good one.
That any given trump voter might be a high-IQ democrat doesn't change that.

"The answer is obviously yes
If all we have to measure is "was this a smart or stupid thing to do" then it was obviously stupid for the vast majority of Americans, or even the smaller group which is Americans who actually voted."

how do you come to that conclusion, since you have no idea who actually voted for Trump?

it could have been "smart" or "intelligent" democrats who voted for him

I do not see any other measure of weather Trump voters were smart or stupid except maybe your own bias

that makes you think that Trump voters were stupid
 
  • Like
Reactions: sweeptheleg
"The answer is obviously yes
If all we have to measure is "was this a smart or stupid thing to do" then it was obviously stupid for the vast majority of Americans, or even the smaller group which is Americans who actually voted."

how do you come to that conclusion, since you have no idea who actually voted for Trump?

it could have been "smart" or "intelligent" democrats who voted for him

I do not see any other measure of weather Trump voters were smart or stupid except maybe your own bias

that makes you think that Trump voters were stupid

Um, its not a matter of measuring IQ s to whether its a stupid idea to vote for Trump. Lots of smart people make stupid emotional decisions. And that is what happened here.
 
"The answer is obviously yes
If all we have to measure is "was this a smart or stupid thing to do" then it was obviously stupid for the vast majority of Americans, or even the smaller group which is Americans who actually voted."

how do you come to that conclusion, since you have no idea who actually voted for Trump?

it could have been "smart" or "intelligent" democrats who voted for him

I do not see any other measure of weather Trump voters were smart or stupid except maybe your own bias

that makes you think that Trump voters were stupid

You misunderstand.
For some minority of Trump voters, it was a smart thing to do.
For Americans as a collective, it was obviously stupid.
It was stupid the first time and even stupider the second time.
Even for many Trump voters it was stupid.
Again, like you pointed out, for any individual Trump voter, it may have been smart.
We aren't talking about individuals here.
 
Um, its not a matter of measuring IQ s to whether its a stupid idea to vote for Trump. Lots of smart people make stupid emotional decisions. And that is what happened here.

I did try to point out that IQ isn't particularly useful in this context.