How much long-term damage has Trump done to Canadian/American relations?

What does “will” even mean?
The “will” to violate Indigenous rights and ignore environmental concerns to build refineries and pipelines?
That isn't will. It just means: “We must do something. This is something. So we must do it.”
We don’t need autarky. We need to reduce our dependence on the US, diversify our trade, and build domestic capacity where it actually makes economic sense.

I am not against building infrastructure or domestic industry.
I am arguing against seanzo’s suggestion that we should become autarkic in the process.
Diversifying away from the US does not mean becoming self sufficient in everything.

That is exactly what will means. And as I said, the Indigenous premier in Manitoba is building a pipeline and port to ship LNG to Europe. Essentially its about paying off the right chiefs and shit will get done.

It makes economic sense and autonomous sense to bypass the USA for our crude, process and ship it from our ports. You can't get around that. You have to accept the fact that for the good of the nation, you will have to piss some people off.
 
You're right, and we'll need to diversify our economy and that isn't easy either. And things like electricity simply can't be exported obviously, but the aluminum that demands so much of that can be. Shipping by ship is actually pretty inexpensive, although not compared to trucking something 500 miles. I didn't say it would be easy, but as many of said lately, no deal is better than a bad deal. The current US government can't be trusted. Even if we successfully renegotiate CUSMA, it won't be worth the paper it's written on as long as trump is around.

But to address your comments directly, I think there are many high value commodities that can be exported effectively... LNG, rare earth minerals for example.

The US says we're ripping them off, so fuck 'em. Trump will be gone soon enough and hopefully common sense will return. But as you said, the US will always be our largest customer for things like lumber. All I"m saying is that we will benefit from expanding our markets.

I also think that Carney knows that an economy based on extraction of resources isn't where we want to be in the long term


that denies reality

we are a decade behind in the LNG race and the rare earth metal race (thanks to the Trudeau liberals)

.....the aluminum that demands so much of that can be. Shipping by ship is actually pretty inexpensive, although not compared to trucking something 500 miles. I didn't say it would be easy

who is the marginal buyer of Aluminum ?
the U.S.
China exports more than it imports
German manufacturing is shrinking (due to insanely stupid net zero policies), they will likely become net exporters

1787637158071.png

1787637877229.png


All I"m saying is that we will benefit from expanding our markets
that is and always has been the case

saying we should diversify our customer base is one thing, actually doing it is another
we will not be able to replace the lost orders due to the tariffs >>>>not even close
 
Last edited:
HQgi0VlWgAAUU5j.jpeg
 
That is exactly what will means. And as I said, the Indigenous premier in Manitoba is building a pipeline and port to ship LNG to Europe. Essentially its about paying off the right chiefs and shit will get done.

It makes economic sense and autonomous sense to bypass the USA for our crude, process and ship it from our ports. You can't get around that. You have to accept the fact that for the good of the nation, you will have to piss some people off.
That's okay, you can piss some people off as long as it is economically justifiable, doesn't violate citizens rights and aren't in violation of laws and regulations.
It still doesn't mean you are an autarky.
 
Last edited:
I’d like to see what the deal was. Thus far we only have what the Americans are saying. Show us the deal.
To what end?

It wasn't equitable. They wanted to control who we traded with. What country would accept that? They wanted to meddle in our sovereignty. What country would accept that?

Fuck Trump. Fuck the United States. Fuck the morons that voted that criminal in to power.
 
That's okay, you can piss some people off as long as it is economically justifiable, doesn't violate citizens rights and aren't in violation of laws and regulations.
It still doesn't mean you are an autarky.

Let's be clear. Laws and regulations can be changed.
 
Let's be clear. Laws and regulations can be changed.
That's fine. That is a process.
I am just saying we shouldn't aim to become an autarky or embark on initiatives that violate the law or citizen's rights in an act of desperation.
There is more than one way to skin a cat.
 
That's fine. That is a process.
I am just saying we shouldn't aim to become an autarky or embark on initiatives that violate the law or citizen's rights in an act of desperation.
There is more than one way to skin a cat.

Please you don't want anybody to do anything that will reduce or even take away your precious entitlements so those resources can be focused on building a future for the children of this country but fear not old man...you can always seek medical assistance in death 🤪
 
CPP and OAS for starters, both are going to have to be severely curtailed. That means billions of dollars freed up to put towards things like building oil refineries and pipelines, investing in manufacturing and resource extraction
 
CPP and OAS for starters, both are going to have to be severely curtailed. That means billions of dollars freed up to put towards things like building oil refineries and pipelines, investing in manufacturing and resource extraction

CPP is a separate fund completely funded by payroll contribution and investment. It is currently funded for the next 75 years. It cannot be touched by the govt. Its not social security. Which may collapse in 2035. Its considered to be highly successful.

The way to fund refineries is borrow and keep a public stake to pay them off and the contribution after to national debt repayment and a sovereign wealth fund.

OAS is fine. And once the boomers die off better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
CPP is a separate fund completely funded by payroll contribution and investment. It is currently funded for the next 75 years. It cannot be touched by the govt. Its not social security. Which may collapse in 2035. Its considered to be highly successful.

The way to fund refineries is borrow and keep a public stake to pay them off and the contribution after to national debt repayment and a sovereign wealth fund.

OAS is fine. And once the boomers die off better.

Speaking as a boomer, I resemble that remark! :mad:
 
Speaking as a boomer, I resemble that remark! :mad:

Its a general comment on the size of the cohort, although they are a selfish bunch. Aren't you pretty much on the high end cusp?
 
Its a general comment on the size of the cohort, although they are a selfish bunch. Aren't you pretty much on the high end cusp?

Born Nov. 1945.

Very early boomer, as many people say 1946 is the first year for true boomers...

I would hate to be born after 2000, despite that it would make me a much younger guy.

Imo I got to live in the best of times, as a youth, and further on, in Canada.
 
Born Nov. 1945.

Very early boomer, as many people say 1946 is the first year for true boomers...

I would hate to be born after 2000, despite that it would make me a much younger guy.

Imo I got to live in the best of times, as a youth, and further on, in Canada.

You were born in the war time mindset. Not the entitlement period the started in the 50's.