How much long-term damage has Trump done to Canadian/American relations?

In this I see no reason we can't develop the ports, refineries and infrastructure to make various oil products other than will to do so. None. Same with critical minerals refining. And its clear that is the best long term choice.

Especially if you also want to move away from the USA..
The key point is that “will” is not the only constraint.
There are practical, economic, environmental, regulatory, and infrastructure constraints.
You can’t just ignore those things and assume that because Canada has the resources, we can simply build whatever infrastructure we want, or that we will automatically have buyers.
However, I am not opposed to the idea of developing this capacity.
I am opposed to seanzo’s suggestion that we should become autarkic.
Moving away from dependence on the US doesn’t mean Canada needs to become autarkic. We can simply diversify our trade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
We have all the energy we could possibly need, we have the ability to grow enough food to feed the nation, we have a highly educated work force, we have natural resources in abundance, we have a world class education system, we have potential for a huge manufacturing sector and in spite of the efforts of shitlibs like you we are still a very wealthy country as it stands.

Laws and regulations can be changed, infrastructure can be built and capital can be raised. None of these are reasons why we can't have nice things, as far as I'm concerned people like you are bigger threat to the future prosperity of this nation than Trump ever will be. He'll be gone in a couple years and dead not long after that. The biggest problem we face as a nation is falling victim to this crabs in a bucket mentality boomers like you keep pushing on the rest of us
"We have the resources, we have the workforce, we can change the laws, we can raise the capital” - these are just a list of things you’ve decided must be possible, followed by the assumption that everything else will somehow work itself out.
 
The key point is that “will” is not the only constraint.
There are practical, economic, environmental, regulatory, and infrastructure constraints.
You can’t just ignore those things and assume that because Canada has the resources, we can simply build whatever infrastructure we want, or that we will automatically have buyers.
However, I am not opposed to the idea of developing this capacity.
I am opposed to seanzo’s suggestion that we should become autarkic.
Moving away from dependence on the US doesn’t mean Canada needs to become autarkic. We can simply diversify our trade.

In Canada there is no reason we can't build refineries, new pipelines to bypass US territory. None. Everything you just said is about will. We built pipes through the USA and Canada already. We just need more. Refineries for oil and minerals can be built.

Its all about will. If Iran, Norway, Venezuela, Gulf States, China and numerous other nations can do it, so can we.

Time to chose. Canada sovereignty over our natural resources, or sell out to another nation.

Which do you choose?
 
"We have the resources, we have the workforce, we can change the laws, we can raise the capital” - these are just a list of things you’ve decided must be possible, followed by the assumption that everything else will somehow work itself out.

Of course it takes work, sacrifice, money and compromise. Thats what happens. We are now in an economic war. That is going to last for years. Pick a side. No fence sitting anymore.
 
I expect Gavin Newsom's first international visit to be to Canada in April/May of 2029

Both sides can be pissed at each other (Canadians rightfully so) but at the end of the day we're literally joined at the hip

We should all make sure our arses are real clean in 2030 because whoever is 48 is gonna be kissing them.

To bastardize a line from Braveheart

"I hope you washed your arse this morning...it's about to be kissed by a President"
 
Imho, it is a bell that cannot be "un-rung"...

I totally agree, 100%. I'm confident the next US president will be both a Democrat and extremely eager to repair the damage Trump has caused, but it's going to be too little too late.

Canada will move on and will diversify its trade, but the trust is shattered. Trump has proven that a US president can act with reckless, illegal impunity and not face consequences for it under the US political system. The next Republican president is definitely taking note of this today, and that means Canada could very well be one election cycle away from more of this bullshit unless we divorce ourselves from them.

Trump's America seemingly wanted to be isolationist, and boy, they're going to get it. As a country, they're becoming persona non grata.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer
In Canada there is no reason we can't build refineries, new pipelines to bypass US territory. None. Everything you just said is about will. We built pipes through the USA and Canada already. We just need more. Refineries for oil and minerals can be built.

Its all about will. If Iran, Norway, Venezuela, Gulf States, China and numerous other nations can do it, so can we.

Time to chose. Canada sovereignty over our natural resources, or sell out to another nation.

Which do you choose?

you best keep your elbows up

because non of that will ever get done in Canada

there is a reason why it wasn't done till now and it will not get done for the same reason

everything will just cost a lot more than it does now

elbows up :)
 
you best keep your elbows up

because non of that will ever get done in Canada

there is a reason why it wasn't done till now and it will not get done for the same reason

everything will just cost a lot more than it does now

elbows up :)

I think it will. We have a PM willing to. A population willing to. The environmentalists with be shut down this time. The Manitoba Premier wants to build one. He is Indigenous remember.

Cost is not a factor. Not when sovereignty is on the line. I don't think you realize what happens when Canadians decide its time for the find out portion to commence.
 
I think it will. We have a PM willing to. A population willing to. The environmentalists with be shut down this time. The Manitoba Premier wants to build one. He is Indigenous remember.

Cost is not a factor. Not when sovereignty is on the line. I don't think you realize what happens when Canadians decide its time for the find out portion to commence.

you speak from the heart, so it pains me to burst your bubble

you best listen to Shaqiulle's reasons why it will not happen

at least his reasons are debatable

mine are much more evil

Carny and Ford are not the saviours you are hoping they are

and Trump is not the only bad guy in all of this

at least he lit up a fire under our us to hope that we can do something

unfortunately we can't and we won't
 
you speak from the heart, so it pains me to burst your bubble

you best listen to Shaqiulle's reasons why it will not happen

at least his reasons are debatable

mine are much more evil

Carny and Ford are not the saviours you are hoping they are

and Trump is not the only bad guy in all of this

at least he lit up a fire under our us to hope that we can do something

unfortunately we can't and we won't

Ypu underestimate Canadians when we are pissed off.
 
The key point is that “will” is not the only constraint.
There are practical, economic, environmental, regulatory, and infrastructure constraints.
You can’t just ignore those things and assume that because Canada has the resources, we can simply build whatever infrastructure we want, or that we will automatically have buyers.
However, I am not opposed to the idea of developing this capacity.
I am opposed to seanzo’s suggestion that we should become autarkic.
Moving away from dependence on the US doesn’t mean Canada needs to become autarkic. We can simply diversify our trade.
"We have the resources, we have the workforce, we can change the laws, we can raise the capital” - these are just a list of things you’ve decided must be possible, followed by the assumption that everything else will somehow work itself out.

 
you speak from the heart, so it pains me to burst your bubble

you best listen to Shaqiulle's reasons why it will not happen

at least his reasons are debatable

mine are much more evil

Carny and Ford are not the saviours you are hoping they are

and Trump is not the only bad guy in all of this

at least he lit up a fire under our us to hope that we can do something

unfortunately we can't and we won't

Nobody ever said that Carney or Ford are going to be the ones who pull the nation out of this mess. They can, however, at the very least start the process
 
Canadian/American relations will never go back to the way they were - even after the old man is gone, dead and buried.
"Never" is a very long time, but I agree. In part, they won't return to what they were because we will have new agreements and alliances. As any business person knows, it's never a good idea to have one customer that makes up the vast majority of your business.

Honestly, I think in the long term, "this" will be good for Canada. The US will likely always be our largest customer but instead of being 95% they might be 55% with the balance being made up of other countries. We're tied to the US by way of Georgraphy so everything is simpler, and that's why port expansion will be critical.

The big lesson in all of this is in knowing that our largest and best relationship was a lot more fragile than we thought. All it took was one person to fuck it all up. THAT we will never forget.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer
They can, however, at the very least start the process

of course they can

but they won't

Ford is on vacation till November !!!

and Carney just got back from vacation and is probably getting ready to go on another world tour

to outflank Trump ;)

nothing will change

it will be business as usual util another headline hits the news and we will just forget about this
 
what are we going to do?

pout and hold our breath?

Its seems several sectors of the US economy already are feeling it as the grassroots boycott continues. Surcharges on energy, critical minerals and potash are a likely choice. No more buying of US treasuries are another(we hold 493 Billion). We can stop purchases like the F-35 and switch to the Grippen. Diversify our trade. Increase trade with new partners like Europe and China, as will as other parts of Asia. We can as Canadians point out to the world what trade deals mean to the USA, but we keep our word. And once we sort out pipelines and refineries, we can squeeze the supply, and become a competitor, instead of a partner.

The USA is now trying to force the world to boycott Iran. That won't happen. And another card in their house will fall. You really don't see the long term, that's normal for myopic Americans and their sycophants.
 
Everything you just said is about will.
What does “will” even mean?
The “will” to violate Indigenous rights and ignore environmental concerns to build refineries and pipelines?
That isn't will. It just means: “We must do something. This is something. So we must do it.”
We don’t need autarky. We need to reduce our dependence on the US, diversify our trade, and build domestic capacity where it actually makes economic sense.
Of course it takes work, sacrifice, money and compromise. Thats what happens. We are now in an economic war. That is going to last for years. Pick a side. No fence sitting anymore.
I am not against building infrastructure or domestic industry.
I am arguing against seanzo’s suggestion that we should become autarkic in the process.
Diversifying away from the US does not mean becoming self sufficient in everything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
The US will likely always be our largest customer but instead of being 95% they might be 55% with the balance being made up of other countries.


you are dreaming
the us imports 75% of our exports, mostly energy, commodities, steel, Aluminum and auto parts etc.


shipping low value , heavy weight products to any other country will be extremely expensive & non competitive vs. other exporters
We are not going to start selling steel to south Korea or auto parts to Japan to replace lost US sales quantities

there is a reason our forestry sector has shrunk >>> there are no alternative quantity buyers

it takes decades to move the needle on trade diversification
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stoo
you are dreaming
the us imports 75% of our exports, mostly energy, commodities, steel, Aluminum and auto parts etc.


shipping low value , heavy weight products to any other country will be extremely expensive & non competitive vs. other exporters
We are not going to start selling steel to south Korea or auto parts to Japan to replace lost US sales quantities

there is a reason our forestry sector has shrunk >>> there are no alternative quantity buyers

it takes decades to move the needle on trade diversification
You're right, and we'll need to diversify our economy and that isn't easy either. And things like electricity simply can't be exported obviously, but the aluminum that demands so much of that can be. Shipping by ship is actually pretty inexpensive, although not compared to trucking something 500 miles. I didn't say it would be easy, but as many of said lately, no deal is better than a bad deal. The current US government can't be trusted. Even if we successfully renegotiate CUSMA, it won't be worth the paper it's written on as long as trump is around.

But to address your comments directly, I think there are many high value commodities that can be exported effectively... LNG, rare earth minerals for example.

The US says we're ripping them off, so fuck 'em. Trump will be gone soon enough and hopefully common sense will return. But as you said, the US will always be our largest customer for things like lumber. All I"m saying is that we will benefit from expanding our markets.

I also think that Carney knows that an economy based on extraction of resources isn't where we want to be in the long term