How much long-term damage has Trump done to Canadian/American relations?

xmontrealer

(he/him/it)
May 23, 2005
13,385
11,840
113
As we head into this weekend, with the potential of a less severe trade deal with the U.S. than Trump originally threatened, it got me to thinking about, since he began his second term as POTUS, how much lasting damage he has done to what used to be one of the friendliest international relationships that has ever existed between neighbouring countries.

Since Trump became President, he has imposed and threatened Canada with punishing tariffs, that affected our industries, level of employment, and general cost of living.

He has disrespected our nationhood, suggesting that we become the 51st state of the USA, and has disrespectfully called our Prime Minister the “Governor of Canada”.

He has caused dissension between ordinary citizens in both countries, with citizens of each country actively booing the other’s national anthems at sporting events.

He has caused Canada to retaliate to his tariff impositions and threats with reciprocal trade restrictions and tariffs, most of which did not exist prior to Trump’s second term in office.

He has made leisure travel to the USA far more difficult and restrictive than it has ever been in the past.

He broke agreements he made in his first term for mutual projects, such as the Gordie Howe Bridge, and then changed the fair terms of the deal to unfair terms that we had to accept to get those projects completed.

Even now, despite the good news on a possible new trade deal, he has not officially signed off on it, and we are left hoping that he will not change the terms of the negotiated deal before the new deadline this Friday.

The list goes on…

The only very simple analogy I can think of is if I invited a life-long friend to lunch, with another mutual friend invited to also attend, and when my friend arrived, I sucker-punched him with a hard fist to the face. I have to imagine that would forever change my relationship with that friend, no matter how much I apologized to him after, as that single act would forever destroy the inherent trust that had built up in our lengthy relationship. And that would be added to his embarrassment of his being attacked by me, out of the blue, in front of the other invited mutual friend.

I have to say that Trump has forever destroyed my positive view of our relationship with the USA, especially in how so many American citizens have supported how he has treated us.

I have to wonder how it has affected other Canadians, especially younger ones over 18 years of age, who can understand what has been going on, and for how many years, or even generations, that damage will persist.

Imho, it is a bell that cannot be "un-rung"...
 
I think whoever is boycotting will continue until he is out of office. Then there will be a gradual increase back in travel. I think certain sectors will have great difficulties. California wines are not going to recover for a decade imo. They have been replaced on wine lists. Its going to take some serious discounts to bring back what they had. Bourbon etc will recover to a better degree as its a unique product.

I think some grocery brands will gradually recover as well.

But overall we just ategoing to trust them. The diversifying is going to continue. It will be gradual. We will no longer give any special consideration to US customers.
 
If putin is out of power and peace is made with Ukraine, I have no doubt the EU will get back to buying Russian energy and normalize relations.

Once Trump is gone, things will go back to normal for Canada.

Money has a poor memory.
 
If putin is out of power and peace is made with Ukraine, I have no doubt the EU will get back to buying Russian energy and normalize relations.

Once Trump is gone, things will go back to normal for Canada.

Money has a poor memory.

What the big money boys do is only part of "relations".
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer
I think you are looking at this in the wrong way. What Trump has done is given us best opportunity to diversify our export markets and build infrastructure to facilitate trade with those new markets we will ever have. That alone is a wonderful gift just laid at our feet but I fear it will inevitably be squandered by brainwashed boomers who still think for whatever reason that our economy cannot exist without the Americans being the recipients of the vast majority of our exports.

Autarky should be our goal. We should be refining out own oil, growing our own food, manufacturing as much of our own goods as is practically possible and relying on others as little as possible. We have all the resources a nation could possibly need to achieve such goals, we have the highly educated population required for innovation and the entrepreneurial spirit of the nation is still strong we simply need to get out of our own way and allow for it to happen.

Instead what I fear will happen is a continuation of the last half century of policies that has lead us to be in the completely compromised position we are in today. A deal will be signed that heavily favours the Americans because reasons. Our natural resources will be exported almost entirely to the Americans at discounted prices. Our manufacturing and agriculture sectors will continue to flounder in large part due to bad trade deals. In essence we will continue to be the 51st state in all but name as we are now.

As for our relationship with the Americans personally....that I am not concerned about in the least. Things will be rough while Trump is still alive but once he is gone relations will slowly return to normal. Inspite of all the "damage" he's purportedly done, the fact remains that Canadians and Americans are still very closely linked, often bonded through marriage, and that will continue into the future.
 
[QUOTE="seanzo, post: 9540732, I fear it will inevitably be squandered by brainwashed boomers who still think for whatever reason that our economy cannot exist without the Americans
[/[/QUOTE]
 
[QUOTE="seanzo, post: 9540732, I fear it will inevitably be squandered by brainwashed boomers who still think for whatever reason that our economy cannot exist without the Americans
[/
As a boomer myself, I find you way off with this comment.. have you read some of my comments? And most of my friends, all boomers, feel the same
 
  • Like
Reactions: peteeey
I think whoever is boycotting will continue until he is out of office. Then there will be a gradual increase back in travel. I think certain sectors will have great difficulties. California wines are not going to recover for a decade imo. They have been replaced on wine lists. Its going to take some serious discounts to bring back what they had. Bourbon etc will recover to a better degree as its a unique product.

I think some grocery brands will gradually recover as well.

But overall we just ategoing to trust them. The diversifying is going to continue. It will be gradual. We will no longer give any special consideration to US customers.

I disagree. Unless the new President does a concerted outreach and mea culpa Canadians will not forgive and forget.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rgkv and shakenbake
I disagree. Unless the new President does a concerted outreach and mea culpa Canadians will not forgive and forget.

I think a section will never forgive. Im not going to try to guess percentage. I think a larger swath will continue to do so when convenient. But it will taper off. There is a section that won't care and will continue to travel, both for business and pleasure.

I'm inclined myself to not travel there until after 2028, and to see what is going on down there. I will add that while a deal has at this time failed, that doesn't mean we can't have one in a month. Or three months. The larger question is will it be worth the paper its written on.

Its essentially why I said we need to just not be overly concerned about things. We need to sign a deal but have it ratified after 2028.
 
I think a section will never forgive. Im not going to try to guess percentage. I think a larger swath will continue to do so when convenient. But it will taper off. There is a section that won't care and will continue to travel, both for business and pleasure.

I'm inclined myself to not travel there until after 2028, and to see what is going on down there. I will add that while a deal has at this time failed, that doesn't mean we can't have one in a month. Or three months. The larger question is will it be worth the paper its written on.

Its essentially why I said we need to just not be overly concerned about things. We need to sign a deal but have it ratified after 2028.

It really depends on the next US admins attitude. If its President Vance or Rubio you can forget it.
 
I think a section will never forgive. Im not going to try to guess percentage. I think a larger swath will continue to do so when convenient. But it will taper off. There is a section that won't care and will continue to travel, both for business and pleasure.

I'm inclined myself to not travel there until after 2028, and to see what is going on down there. I will add that while a deal has at this time failed, that doesn't mean we can't have one in a month. Or three months. The larger question is will it be worth the paper its written on.

Its essentially why I said we need to just not be overly concerned about things. We need to sign a deal but have it ratified after 2028.

The problem with making a deal with the lying , cheating [ golf ] SCUM in the White House it is meaningless since he may void it or change it on a daily basis. Please have a fatal heart attack tonight TRUMP.
 
Remember that many Americans are free trade advocates and we still love our long-time friends in Canada. We are working to restore normalcy, sanity, and honesty.

Sorry to say but we don't see it. Posting on social media at this point is not enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rgkv
Well JD Vance and Pete Hegseth are planning to run after Trump completes his third term beginning in 2028 so don't hope for too much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer
Well JD Vance and Pete Hegseth are planning to run after Trump completes his third term beginning in 2028 so don't hope for too much.

Neither has said they are going to run for president however on the bright side both know what a woman is.
 
the biggest long term damage Trump caused is long TDS in some Canadians

this song perfectly illustrates long TDS sufferers strugle :)

 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: Roe Jogan