Best method for handling volatility in the market

Mandala

Well-known member
Jan 2, 2025
400
317
63
The big concern for any investor is a big downturn of 30%+

How do you weather the storm without selling as prices fall then buying back in when prices rise IE selling low and buying high?


My thoughts are put enough monies into a safe investment that you can use for anticipated expenses over 5 years as a that is a reasonable time for market cycle to compete itself
 
When the market falls 30%, there is no safe investment aside from interest earning investments like GICs, HISA, Money Market Fund. Gold will fall because margins calls will force investors to sell whatever assets they have on hand including gold, you might not trade on margin but alot of investors do.

Most of my money is in gold and the canadian stock market, I also hold berksire and have 15% in a money market fund. If the US stock market drops 30% I hope my portfolio drops at most 20%, I would sell all my safeish investments and dump it into Google and Apple, those are the only companies that I want to hold forever.
 
Its only a loss if you sell at a loss. Hold cash to buy low. Let the rest rebound in time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MattyMcG92
Its only a loss if you sell at a loss. Hold cash to buy low. Let the rest rebound in time.

Holding cash to buy low means you are not getting in on the bull

Market goes up 30% so you can buy on the 20% bear?

While the math says just go all in and hold, during a downturn having a money market fund so you are not forced to sell equity in a deep bear seems psychologically sound as you can now wait it out
 
Last edited:
Holding cash to buy low means you are not getting in on the bull

Market goes up 30% so you can buy on the 20% bear?

Holding a money market fund so you are not forced to sell equity in a deep bear seems sound

It depends if you are feeling risk adverse. You can always dollar cost buy in safe stocks and not worry over it. But nothing wrong with buying a dip if you have extra cash. No one has zero liquidity.
 
It depends if you are feeling risk adverse. You can always dollar cost buy in safe stocks and not worry over it. But nothing wrong with buying a dip if you have extra cash. No one has zero liquidity.
When everyone is selling is an excellent time to buy - warren buffet

but holding cash while waiting for a dip is timing the market which is not a good idea
 
When everyone is selling is an excellent time to buy - warren buffet

but holding cash while waiting for a dip is timing the market which is not a good idea

Dude, you can t buy without cash, or likely in his case a loan. When Buffet said that it means HE IS TIMING THE MARKET. Not totally as in holding back. But I remember reading he had massive cash reserves.

Berkshire Hathaway's Cash Pile Now Earns More in a Year Than Most S&P 500 Companies Report in Total Profit. Here's the Math. https://share.google/8XmrjsJkaHBhznHTV

So if Buffet is your guide then.......
 
Dude, you can t buy without cash, or likely in his case a loan. When Buffet said that it means HE IS TIMING THE MARKET. Not totally as in holding back. But I remember reading he had massive cash reserves.

Berkshire Hathaway's Cash Pile Now Earns More in a Year Than Most S&P 500 Companies Report in Total Profit. Here's the Math. https://share.google/8XmrjsJkaHBhznHTV

So if Buffet is your guide then.......


You are not Buffet. He does not hold cash to time the market but to buy undervalued quality companies.

His history in the last decade is the S&P has beaten him

The market moves so quickly, in days if not hours, you will miss the gains.

Buffet buys individual companies and holds, his advice to you is do not, just buy the S&P then hold.
 
You are not Buffet. He does not hold cash to time the market but to buy undervalued quality companies.

His history in the last decade is the S&P has beaten him

The market moves so quickly, in days if not hours, you will miss the gains.

Buffet buys individual companies and holds, his advice to you is do not, just buy the S&P then hold.

OK. Great. Then why mention Buffet? The stock market is gambling. On the economy, and on individual companies. So if you are risk adverse then buy conservative, hold and sit. Thats it.

Thats what I said initially. Just hold, sit and wait. And there is absolutely nothing wrong with having cash on hand. That is not timing the market either. Timing the market is trying maximize the net worth of stocks before you sell to take advantage of a crash.

.I say if you have made money great! Worried over a crash, sell at a profit, buy those Can bank stock dividend earners and keep some profit to buy later if a deal comes up.
 
OK. Great. Then why mention Buffet? The stock market is gambling. On the economy, and on individual companies. So if you are risk adverse then buy conservative, hold and sit. Thats it.

Thats what I said initially. Just hold, sit and wait. And there is absolutely nothing wrong with having cash on hand. That is not timing the market either. Timing the market is trying maximize the net worth of stocks before you sell to take advantage of a crash.

.I say if you have made money great! Worried over a crash, sell at a profit, buy those Can bank stock dividend earners and keep some profit to buy later if a deal comes up.


We are not far apart

Everything is a gamble and buying conservative is as well as inflation could destroy your wealth

Buy and hold we agree on

Banks will pay dividends in a crash but their value will fall so investors buy Canadian banks to wait out a bear while getting income but the overall market is a better buy

Putting enough money into banks so you will have income during a bear has real merit if you have enough money to spread around but remember bank stocks and their dividends are not bullet proof so an aristocrat etf of dividend payers IE companies with a strong history of dividend growth is spread out over more sectors therefore safer but to generate $1000 per month dividend income expect to tie up half a million $

so buying 100K of high interest savings account gives you 8 years of same income until you reach zero

leaving the original 400 k in the broader market for better growth

These are the decisions that make my head spin
 
This is why you should have a percentage in fixed income and alot of that should be liquid.
That way you have cash to buy the dip.
 
We are not far apart

Everything is a gamble and buying conservative is as well as inflation could destroy your wealth

Buy and hold we agree on

Banks will pay dividends in a crash but their value will fall so investors buy Canadian banks to wait out a bear while getting income but the overall market is a better buy

Putting enough money into banks so you will have income during a bear has real merit if you have enough money to spread around but remember bank stocks and their dividends are not bullet proof so an aristocrat etf of dividend payers IE companies with a strong history of dividend growth is spread out over more sectors therefore safer but to generate $1000 per month dividend income expect to tie up half a million $

so buying 100K of high interest savings account gives you 8 years of same income until you reach zero

leaving the original 400 k in the broader market for better growth

These are the decisions that make my head spin

Yup. I basically have a medium/low risk fund now due to age and coming retirement. There is a chunk of money coming soon that will max out an unused TFSA that I will be talking to an advisor about. And then on retirement a downsize will likely result in another 500,000 for a general fund I will see placed in dividend stocks. Im still looking at REITS right now. Likely spread 50,000 buy ins to at least 3-4 for monthly income and the rest in quarterly dividend stocks.

Between that and pension income I will be fine. Its a few years off so lots of time to think about things.
 
Always be buying. You hit the highs and lows. Stretch out your cash in order to buy over years instead of waiting for a drop. If you have extra cash lying around buy the lows, but don't shoot your wad in one shot. Consistency in purchasing behavior yet taking advantage of the lows.
 
Yup. I basically have a medium/low risk fund now due to age and coming retirement. There is a chunk of money coming soon that will max out an unused TFSA that I will be talking to an advisor about. And then on retirement a downsize will likely result in another 500,000 for a general fund I will see placed in dividend stocks. Im still looking at REITS right now. Likely spread 50,000 buy ins to at least 3-4 for monthly income and the rest in quarterly dividend stocks.

Between that and pension income I will be fine. Its a few years off so lots of time to think about things.

info from the net -

REITs can be a powerful tool for generating income, but they are not a "safe" investment like a bond or a savings account. Their value can fluctuate, and their performance is tied to interest rates and the stock market.

I do not understand them so I shy away. The S&P I understand

info from the net -

REITs can be a powerful tool for generating income, but they are not a "safe" investment like a bond or a savings account. Their value can fluctuate, and their performance is tied to interest rates and the stock market.

The only real difference between a REIT and an S&P 500 company is a legal rule:
The government told REITs, "If you promise to pay out at least 90% of your rental profits to your shareholders every year, we won't tax you at the corporate level."

That's it. That is the "secret."

Because of that rule, REITs pay much bigger dividends than the average S&P 500 company. The S&P 500 currently yields about 1.3% in dividends. Many REITs yield 4% to 6%.

So, why does a REIT's stock price go up and down just like an S&P 500 stock? Because it is a stock. It trades on the exact same stock exchanges as Apple or Microsoft. When the market panics, REITs panic with it. When the market rallies, REITs usually rally too.

2% of the s&p is in reits and i pay taxes on it in my T5 slip along with reinvested dividends that is not in TFSA

REITs give more income but miss out on growth just like banks do. If I want income I just sell stock and keep it simple
 
Last edited:
Ever consider options trading? It's a good way to acquire and sell in a volatile market.


Options are derivatives meaning their value is derived from something else

I stay far away from derivatives, too complex to understand for me and too risky

I understand what an ETF is and what the stock market is and what RRSP and TSFA are
 
info from the net -

REITs can be a powerful tool for generating income, but they are not a "safe" investment like a bond or a savings account. Their value can fluctuate, and their performance is tied to interest rates and the stock market.

I do not understand them so I shy away. The S&P I understand

info from the net -

REITs can be a powerful tool for generating income, but they are not a "safe" investment like a bond or a savings account. Their value can fluctuate, and their performance is tied to interest rates and the stock market.

The only real difference between a REIT and an S&P 500 company is a legal rule:
The government told REITs, "If you promise to pay out at least 90% of your rental profits to your shareholders every year, we won't tax you at the corporate level."

That's it. That is the "secret."

Because of that rule, REITs pay much bigger dividends than the average S&P 500 company. The S&P 500 currently yields about 1.3% in dividends. Many REITs yield 4% to 6%.

So, why does a REIT's stock price go up and down just like an S&P 500 stock? Because it is a stock. It trades on the exact same stock exchanges as Apple or Microsoft. When the market panics, REITs panic with it. When the market rallies, REITs usually rally too.

2% of the s&p is in reits and i pay on my T5 slip along with reinvested dividends that is not in TFSA

REITs give more income but miss out on growth. If I want income I sell stock

and keep it simple

Sure. But these are going to be partially in TFSAs so tax free. My big issue initially was the move to WFH was causing useless, but that is settling down now. They pay monthly. And as I said, it will be about income that I don't have to think about.
 
Sure. But these are going to be partially in TFSAs so tax free. My big issue initially was the move to WFH was causing useless, but that is settling down now. They pay monthly. And as I said, it will be about income that I don't have to think about.


I understand your thinking. A lot of very bright investors buy Canadian banks for same reason as the banks are safe monthly income but my thoughts are in the long term so I stay in S&P for the higher growth potential

TSFA also means capital gains are not taxed

I enjoy our discussion