War with Iran

Is that not war with Iran?

You know what's exhausting, squeezer. On this board i like you, I agree with a lot of your posts and what you say.

But I can't get past your 'Its Hamas' fault' rationalization. On a basic level I get it, I've been reading a lot of neuroscience of late and the idea of predictive processing. When something surprising comes up, its a prediction error. We have two choices, either we change our predictions or we change our model of the world. So when I post a report of war crimes that's a prediction error to your model of the world where Israel is noble and just. You get a choice of telling me the info I produce is wrong because it doesn't fit your model or you have to do the neurologically expensive choice of changing your model of the world. I get it, that makes it way easier to say I'm posting 'fake news' because it doesn't fit your model compared to changing your model of the world. I still have hope that people can change, that with enough real info they can change their model of the world. But there is no way into your model to provide info that might let you change it. Not the law, human rights, direct video evidence, nothing seems to work. In your mind, your model of the world says Hamas is to blame and nothing can change that view. That's sad.

Nothing I can say will make you change your mind from your views that one day of war crimes is worse than 3 years of war crimes and genocide.

And if you can't convince someone that genocide is wrong, that you are becoming the modern day equivalent of a nazi by backing genocide, can people ever change?


I've never claimed, nor have I ever thought, that Israel is "noble and just." That's a position you've attributed to me, not one I've expressed.

I have taken you to task when you post information that is demonstrably false, misleading, or lacking context. That isn't the same thing as defending Israel or dismissing legitimate reports of war crimes.

And yes, Hamas is guilty of contributing to what has happened to Gaza. Acknowledging Hamas's responsibility for its actions does not require me to believe that everything Israel does is justified, nor does criticizing Hamas mean I support the conduct of the Israeli government or military.

I think that's the distinction you're missing: I don't view this as a binary choice where acknowledging Israeli wrongdoing requires me to absolve Hamas, or where condemning Hamas requires me to defend Israel. Both can be responsible for wrongdoing, and both can be criticized.

You don't have to convince me that war crimes are wrong. I already believe they are. What you haven't convinced me of is that every claim you post is accurate simply because it supports the conclusion you want me to reach.

NOW BACK TO THE IRAN WAR!
 
Yes, its about the total war. The USA and Israel in fact just broke a ceasefire with part two we are now in. Iran was negotiating in good faith.


I don't know that I'd characterize Iran as negotiating in good faith. My read is that Iran recognizes Trumpshart is under increasing political pressure, particularly with the midterms approaching and public support for the war remaining weak.

If that's the case, it would be in Iran's interest to prolong the negotiations, keep the pressure on Trumpshart, and extract as many concessions as possible before agreeing to anything. They have very little incentive to give Trumpshart an easy diplomatic win when they can use the political situation in the U.S. as leverage.
 
Are you really trying to argue that Israel has nothing to do with the Iran war?
Yes or no?


Yes, absolutely. Israel has a role in the Iran war. I'm not disputing that.

But if we're specifically talking about the Iran war, then let's keep the discussion focused on what Israel has actually done in that conflict.

So go ahead, what exactly are you arguing Israel has done recently that is relevant to the point you're making? Has Israel conducted an air campaign against Iran? Dropped bombs on Iranian targets? Killed Iranian leadership? If so, let's talk about those actions specifically.

I'm not denying Israel's involvement. I'm asking you to demonstrate what you're claiming Israel has done in the context of the Iran war, rather than broadening the discussion to everything Israel has done elsewhere.
 
It is quite literally the US and Israel vs Iran war with both countries dropping bombs on Iran.
Heck Israel did the decapitation strike to start the war.

No, its literally Israel that started the war by attacking Iran in 2025.
In 2026 they tried a Mossad funded coup through 'protesters'.
Then Netanyahu managed to blackmail/convince trump to attack Iran themselves, since they found out in 2025 that they couldn't handle war with a country with an army.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
And yes, Hamas is guilty of contributing to what has happened to Gaza. ..... I don't view this as a binary choice where acknowledging Israeli wrongdoing requires me to absolve Hamas, or where condemning Hamas requires me to defend Israel. Both can be responsible for wrongdoing, and both can be criticized.

You did it again, you blamed Hamas and then declared that you think both sides are the problem.
If you blamed both sides you'd be agreeing with everyone else that both sides should be held to the law, you'd use human rights and international law as your basis and not some kind of racial supremacy. You'd be admitting that 80 years of occupation, apartheid and genocide is a bigger crime than one day of resistance to the occupation.

Genocide should be a 'never again' moral red line.
Nobody who commits genocide should ever be supported ever again, not nazis, not Pol Pot and not zionists.

If you truly were condemning both sides you'd condemn the genocide as a far greater evil.
 
Yes, absolutely. Israel has a role in the Iran war. I'm not disputing that.

But if we're specifically talking about the Iran war, then let's keep the discussion focused on what Israel has actually done in that conflict.

So go ahead, what exactly are you arguing Israel has done recently that is relevant to the point you're making? Has Israel conducted an air campaign against Iran? Dropped bombs on Iranian targets? Killed Iranian leadership? If so, let's talk about those actions specifically.

I'm not denying Israel's involvement. I'm asking you to demonstrate what you're claiming Israel has done in the context of the Iran war, rather than broadening the discussion to everything Israel has done elsewhere.

Lets review the war, then.
2025 - Israel unilaterally attacks Iran and gives up after 12 days
2026 - Israel arms protesters in Jan with trump and tries to foment a coup, which fails after Iran shuts down the internet and tracks all starlink/mossad agents
2026 - Israel convinces trump to attack for them. They join in the attacks for the first month or so, until Iran uses heat seeking missiles to take out jets and Israel runs low on missiles.
2026 summer - all american bases are cleared in the gulf except those in Israel and Jordan

Now you're trying to argue that because Israel left america to fight on their own they shouldn't be in the conversation. Its a ridiculous position. trump has retreated to Israeli bases and now uses the Ben Gurion airport as his last base in the region. Iran offers ceasefire deals repeatedly that include Israel stopping the genocide in Lebanon, which Israel refuses, so they were instrumental in the continuation of the war. Now the terms for ceasefire also include the end of the genocide in Palestine as well.

Israel is the root cause of this war, they will forever be in this conversation as they will be forever tarred as a genocidal, racial supremacist, settler colonial project.
 
Now you're trying to argue that because Israel left america to fight on their own they shouldn't be in the conversation.

Is reading comprehension an issue with you??

Yes, absolutely. Israel has a role in the Iran war. I'm not disputing that.

I'm not denying Israel's involvement. I'm asking you to demonstrate what you're claiming Israel has done in the context of the Iran war, rather than broadening the discussion to everything Israel has done elsewhere.
 
Yes, I have, and I've criticized BIBI and his admin as well. What's your point?

Your criticism is that 'BIBI has gone too far and should step down'.

Not that he's committed war crimes and should be tried, that he should stand for his corruption trials, that he and Israel are committing genocide, that he's repeatedly stated that he blocked and will always block the two state solution and peace, not that he started the war with Iran, not that he shouldn't be committing genocide in Lebanon or stealing land in Syria, Palestine and Lebanon.

Nor that he is arming settlers and providing IDF backup for terrorist attacks on Palestinians, with 500 Netanyahu backed terrorist attacks on the native Palestinian population last week alone.

Over 500 Israeli attacks recorded in West Bank in past week: Palestinian cabinet
Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammad Mustafa has warned of escalating settler and Israeli military attacks in the occupied West Bank and worsening conditions in Gaza.
His cabinet said in a statement on Tuesday that more than 504 attacks by settlers and Israeli forces were recorded in the past week, according to the Colonization and Wall Resistance Commission (CRRC), alongside widespread demolitions and orders to confiscate more land. It highlighted the demolition of commercial structures along the Jenin-Nablus road earlier on Tuesday.
Mustafa stressed the need to maintain essential services, particularly water and electricity, following repeated settler attacks on infrastructure and what he said were continued Israeli cuts to supplies.
On Gaza, the cabinet called for safe, unhindered delivery of food, water, shelter and medicine amid warnings of severe shortages and repeated forced displacement during extreme heat.
The cabinet also approved renewed contracts with law firms to defend Palestinians in occupied East Jerusalem, advanced e-procurement and vehicle-import regulations, and endorsed an industrial-cooperation memorandum with Turkiye.
 
I don't know that I'd characterize Iran as negotiating in good faith. My read is that Iran recognizes Trumpshart is under increasing political pressure, particularly with the midterms approaching and public support for the war remaining weak.

If that's the case, it would be in Iran's interest to prolong the negotiations, keep the pressure on Trumpshart, and extract as many concessions as possible before agreeing to anything. They have very little incentive to give Trumpshart an easy diplomatic win when they can use the political situation in the U.S. as leverage.

After the 12 day war they were negotiating in good faith. Then the US and Israel surprise attacked. Killing the Ayattolah, oh and 160 school girls.

And have since broken ceasefire repeatedly, lied about negotiating, made threats of annihilation, bombed civilian targets.....

If you were the new leadership, your family killed by them, personally injured, threatened and repeatedly betrayed in word and deed, how motivated would you be to negotiate? Seriously ask yourself this. Then add on the above you wrote.

This isn't a game. Its not scripted. There is no playbook or rules at this point. Its not "political " maneuvers or little wins. For them at this point its all or nothing. You really need to see that a negotiated settlement as long as Trump is president is now off the table. Until the USA capitulates.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Yes, absolutely. Israel has a role in the Iran war. I'm not disputing that.

But if we're specifically talking about the Iran war, then let's keep the discussion focused on what Israel has actually done in that conflict.

So go ahead, what exactly are you arguing Israel has done recently that is relevant to the point you're making? Has Israel conducted an air campaign against Iran? Dropped bombs on Iranian targets? Killed Iranian leadership? If so, let's talk about those actions specifically.

I'm not denying Israel's involvement. I'm asking you to demonstrate what you're claiming Israel has done in the context of the Iran war, rather than broadening the discussion to everything Israel has done elsewhere.

Yes, they did. In the opening days they flew bombing missions. So they are responsible for deaths, destruction.

Israel Says 200 Fighters Struck Iran, Its Largest-Ever Air Operation - Business Insider https://share.google/uOPlTU6DHzzjBMk2c

Stop defending them.
 
So then why did you post three times that we shouldn't be talking about Israel in this thread?

Israel vs Hamas/Palestine, but you know this; you're just pretending to be blind and ignorant.

Feel free to discuss Israel if they do something to affect the Iran war. At least then you are on topic for this thread.
 
Yes, they did. In the opening days they flew bombing missions. So they are responsible for deaths, destruction.

Israel Says 200 Fighters Struck Iran, Its Largest-Ever Air Operation - Business Insider https://share.google/uOPlTU6DHzzjBMk2c

Stop defending them.

When have I defended them regarding being part of the reason for this war in Iran? I've clearly stated Bibi manipulated Trumpshart. Frankism is definitely contagious and you have been infected.

As a matter of fact, I've said from the start Trump was an idiot for starting this war, but hey, keep on ranting if it makes you feel like you're accomplishing something.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Frankfooter
When have I defended them regarding being part of the reason for this war in Iran? I've clearly stated Bibi manipulated Trumpshart. Frankism is definitely contagious and you have been infected.

As a matter of fact, I've said from the start Trump was an idiot for starting this war, but hey, keep on ranting if it makes you feel like you're accomplishing something.

Good. Now say their military should not longer relieve aid for doing this.
 
Has Israel conducted an air campaign against Iran? Dropped bombs on Iranian targets? Killed Iranian leadership? If so, let's talk about those actions specifically.
What are you waiting for?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter