War with Iran

When others carry it first.....


The difference is that established news organizations generally try to verify information through multiple sources before publishing, rather than simply repeating every claim they hear. That doesn't mean they're always right, but their editorial standards and fact-checking processes usually make them more reliable than anonymous social media accounts or state propaganda.

That's why I prefer to wait for credible, independent reporting before accepting a claim as fact.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WyattEarp
I am very careful listening to self-declared "experts".
They have a tendency to present a theme.
The theme helps them build an audience.
The theme itself might not be my issue, but when they always stick to the theme I can hear the drum beat.

The same really goes for a news media outlet like Fox or CNN.

 
Likewise, if Iran attacks a Gulf state that isn't part of the conflict, then that country has the same right to defend itself.

What about when Iran attacks an american base in another country?
Does that mean the host country can defend itself or is that still just an attack on america?
 
The difference is that established news organizations generally try to verify information through multiple sources before publishing, rather than simply repeating every claim they hear. That doesn't mean they're always right, but their editorial standards and fact-checking processes usually make them more reliable than anonymous social media accounts or state propaganda.

That's why I prefer to wait for credible, independent reporting before accepting a claim as fact.

Except when they curate by omission......
 
What about when Iran attacks an american base in another country?
Does that mean the host country can defend itself or is that still just an attack on america?


If a sovereign country is attacked on its own soil, I'd expect it to respond if they choose to.

If Iran attacked a U.S. base in another country, I don't think the host country would just stand back and pretend nothing happened. It would have every right to decide whether the attack threatened its own security and respond accordingly.

The same goes for Canada. If Iran attacked the U.S. Embassy or a U.S. military facility in Canada, I certainly wouldn't expect Canada to just say, "Oh well." There would almost certainly be a response, even possibly triggering Article 5, but who knows with Trump's hard-on for NATO if that would happen.
 
Except when they curate by omission......



Sure, media outlets can omit stories or make editorial decisions about what to cover. That's a valid criticism. But "they didn't report what I wanted them to report" isn't evidence that the opposite claim is true.

I'd still rather rely on reporting that's been verified than on social media posts or state propaganda. If there's credible evidence, it'll eventually be corroborated by multiple independent outlets.

Even when I post YouTube clips, if you notice, I rarely comment on them. I post them because I find them interesting or worth discussing, not because I automatically accept everything being said. Most of those videos are presented by biased commentators or podcasters, so I don't treat them as established fact until they're backed up by credible reporting.
 
The difference is that established news organizations generally try to verify information through multiple sources before publishing, rather than simply repeating every claim they hear. That doesn't mean they're always right, but their editorial standards and fact-checking processes usually make them more reliable than anonymous social media accounts or state propaganda.

That's why I prefer to wait for credible, independent reporting before accepting a claim as fact.

Except that the media doesn't cover much of the news and in NA, its largely right wing owned media.
Except for CBC and a few independent outlets here.

La Monde reported on this strike, as did CBC, but did any american media?



And how many reported the report of how many victims?


If a sovereign country is attacked on its own soil, I'd expect it to respond if they choose to.

If Iran attacked a U.S. base in another country, I don't think the host country would just stand back and pretend nothing happened. It would have every right to decide whether the attack threatened its own security and respond accordingly.

The same goes for Canada. If Iran attacked the U.S. Embassy or a U.S. military facility in Canada, I certainly wouldn't expect Canada to just say, "Oh well." There would almost certainly be a response, even possibly triggering Article 5, but who knows with Trump's hard-on for NATO if that would happen.

Except those countries now see those bases as a liability, they make their countries a target and offer no defence.
They also see that Iran won't hit them unless they respond directly, but if you were in charge you'd end up like Kuwait.

 
You mean like Afghanistan? 20 years and where are they?

92 million. Industrial base, weapons manufacturing, engineering, mountainous geography, 47 years of preparation. A govt that not only survived decapitation but is now on the offensive. Two allies in China and Russia. Local assistance with Houthis, Iraqi militias, and other groups. Sophisticated propaganda machine.

Meanwhile the world has turned on Isreal and the USA. The USA is actually behind on modern weapons tech. Incompetent leadership. A public who from the onset is against the war. And growing.

And I haven't even gotten to the economic geography advantage that Iran has.

Unless China and Russia turn on them, and they see this the same way the West saw Ukraine, as a drain on resources on the USA, Iran can win this. Because the time needed to end this without a world wide depression is shortening.

Seriously, this isn't about "support". This is objective reality. Cold analysis. 6 month ago I would have said no way. Now? Cripes the USA bases are done, the Aircraft carriers operational limits are a huge factor, allies are starting to turn. And ammo limits are being stressed.

The corrupt rot in the military supply chain of the USA is being exposed, its bad. Its likely they will have to fall back to Isreal soon, just to try to protect it with limited resources. And its going to become a huge election issue. No amount of AIPAC money is going to help in some cases. Israel support waning, and quickly. They are no longer thought of as an ally or proxy, but as a liability, and manipulator of events and USA elections.

I have never seen things this bad for the USA.

Iran is not Afghanistan, the people are far more sophisticated, and have already rebelled against their leadership. This is a population that WANTS democracy, unlike Afghanistan. They will not be torn apart by sectarian violence or put down by cave dwellers.

Russia has massive problems of its own to deal with in Ukraine, and China does not want to get too involved and prefers to always act in a subtle way; the most they have done so far is give Iran tracking guidance. The involvement of these two countries is not something we have to worry about because it's not going to happen. And Israel has already proven it can deal with Iran's proxies in Hezbollah and Houthis on its own.

The difference between the US & Israel VS Iran, compared to Russia VS Ukraine, is that they can end the war quickly if they actually commit. The US are not behind in modern weapons tech lol, they are by far the most advanced nation. They have the military might to do it, the administration is just hesitant because the war is not popular, but Trump is nearing the end of his second term now, and if he acts, the next administration will have no choice but to continue - regardless of who wins the next election.

US air bases are not "finished" they are closed, and can be reopened if we actually decide to go on a heavy offensive. While its true there is an ammo shortage, it's not something they can't make up for in production if they shift into a wartime economy. Iran is not equipped to deal with a full offensive from the USA. They would be reduced to the Taliban, hiding in caves, but without a "Pakistan" in which to flee.

Yes, things are bad for the US, but it's the US. Even at it's worst it is by far the most advanced nation and powerful military force on earth. They have gone easy on Iran so far, but if they ramped up aerial bombings, and decided on a ground invasion, Iran would be left helpless. A thorough campaign against the IRGC will ensure the Iranian people can finish the job.

Remember that the Iranian people ultimately do not support their government, and will fight back against them.

Protecting Israel is of paramount importance, the beacon of democracy in a sea of authoritarian, theocratic dictatorships. Our only true ally in the region and source of all our intelligence on the Islamists.
 
Fox is not news
I watch CNN on occasion. It offers a unique perspective even though it is quite theatrical at times.

That's the same reason a guy like you should turn on Fox occasionally. It's over the top at prime time, but some of the afternoon anchors are far less vitriolic. Since Neil Cavuto left, I have less reason to turn to Fox.
 
Last edited:
Iran is not Afghanistan, the people are far more sophisticated, and have already rebelled against their leadership. This is a population that WANTS democracy, unlike Afghanistan. They will not be torn apart by sectarian violence or put down by cave dwellers.

Russia has massive problems of its own to deal with in Ukraine, and China does not want to get too involved and prefers to always act in a subtle way; the most they have done so far is give Iran tracking guidance. The involvement of these two countries is not something we have to worry about because it's not going to happen. And Israel has already proven it can deal with Iran's proxies in Hezbollah and Houthis on its own.

The difference between the US & Israel VS Iran, compared to Russia VS Ukraine, is that they can end the war quickly if they actually commit. The US are not behind in modern weapons tech lol, they are by far the most advanced nation. They have the military might to do it, the administration is just hesitant because the war is not popular, but Trump is nearing the end of his second term now, and if he acts, the next administration will have no choice but to continue - regardless of who wins the next election.

US air bases are not "finished" they are closed, and can be reopened if we actually decide to go on a heavy offensive. While its true there is an ammo shortage, it's not something they can't make up for in production if they shift into a wartime economy. Iran is not equipped to deal with a full offensive from the USA. They would be reduced to the Taliban, hiding in caves, but without a "Pakistan" in which to flee.

Yes, things are bad for the US, but it's the US. Even at it's worst it is by far the most advanced nation and powerful military force on earth. They have gone easy on Iran so far, but if they ramped up aerial bombings, and decided on a ground invasion, Iran would be left helpless. A thorough campaign against the IRGC will ensure the Iranian people can finish the job.

Remember that the Iranian people ultimately do not support their government, and will fight back against them.

Protecting Israel is of paramount importance, the beacon of democracy in a sea of authoritarian, theocratic dictatorships. Our only true ally in the region and source of all our intelligence on the Islamists.

Lol. You think Trump and BiBi wouldn't finish this if they could? That is my proof. They are being pushed back. We are in month six.
 
...
Protecting Israel is of paramount importance, the beacon of democracy in a sea of authoritarian, theocratic dictatorships. Our only true ally in the region and source of all our intelligence on the Islamists.
And that's what it all comes down to for you. The six paragraphs before that were just drivel. You don't care about Iran or the West. You don't care how many die on either side. All you care about is stated in your last paragraph.
 
Lol. You think Trump and BiBi wouldn't finish this if they could? That is my proof. They are being pushed back. We are in month six.
Trump has no strategy and no planning ability and just sits there like a stunned pig on the slab in a slaughterhouse before the butcher cuts his fat throat. 🐷🐷🐷
 
Except that the media doesn't cover much of the news and in NA, its largely right wing owned media.
Except for CBC and a few independent outlets here.

La Monde reported on this strike, as did CBC, but did any american media?



And how many reported the report of how many victims?

You're attempting to muck up why I originally picked on your fake post. It was in reference to Iran bombing a ship over the weekend which DID NOT HAPPEN. Now you're switching it to a completely different military action, which, if on CBC, I'm not going to doubt that it happened. I haven't read into it but again, if it's from a reputable news source, I won't say your full of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Trump has no strategy and no planning ability and just sits there like a stunned pig on the slab in a slaughterhouse before the butcher cuts his fat throat. 🐷🐷🐷

Fuck, this just made it move, no homo but yes, it gave me a woody.

 
You're attempting to muck up why I originally picked on your fake post. It was in reference to Iran bombing a ship over the weekend which DID NOT HAPPEN. Now you're switching it to a completely different military action, which, if on CBC, I'm not going to doubt that it happened. I haven't read into it but again, if it's from a reputable news source, I won't say your full of it.

Ok, so at least you admit that Israel did target a medical warehouse and killed 300 people in the same attack.
Not that you will go as far as to say it was wrong or even a bad thing.

Otherwise you sound like trump in this thread, declaring that america is winning, Israel is good and great and the news is fake.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu