Iran has overplayed its hand

Wrong analogy.

Both the USA or Canada accepted Jews who survived the Holocaust, though somewhat reluctantly. My great-grandparents, who fled the Ukraine in 1895 due to antisemitism and attacks by non-Jews on their little villages, were sent by Canadian immigration authorities to Saskatchewan, and given land grants there.

For many displaced Jews from Germany and Poland, after the Holocaust there was nowhere else to go, except Israel, and even then not until 1948, several years after the end of the WWII.

Most who came to Canada didn't like Saskatchewan, had little farming knowledge, and soon moved to other Canadian cities, where they tried their best to assimilate and become good citizens of Canada.

None that I know of tried to expand the land they were granted.

Some became wealthy through innate intelligence and hard work, and were able to legally expand their holdings that way.

Had the surrounding Arab nations not tried over and over to attack and destroy Israel, the Israelis would have been content with the original borders created by the U.N. in 1948. But the Arab nations couldn't accept that.

Before Oct. 7, 2023 the only land the Israelis took is what they won during wars started by Hamas, Hezbollah, and/or the surrounding Arab nations, in an effort to destroy Israel.

It soon became evident to the Israelis that giving back the land would only encourage more attacks on them.

When Israel disengaged from Gaza in 2005, and had the IDF forcefully remove any Israelis who lived there in an effort to try to achieve peaceful co-existence, Hamas wouldn't let that be successful, with continuing terrorist attacks, culminating horrifically on Oct. 7, 2023.

Netanyahu then woke up to the realization that there would never be co-existence with Gaza as long as the radicals were in power there, and knew the only solution was to remove Hamas and other radicals from power. Hamas refused to see the light, and all Gazans are ultimately paying the price.

As are the citizens of Lebanon, due to the attacks on Israel by Hezbollah.

That said, I think the IDF should keep better control over the West Bank Israeli settlers, who are sometimes justified in their attacks on Arabs in the West bank, but often not...

Poorly educated. Brainwashed from birth.
 
Had the surrounding Arab nations not tried over and over to attack and destroy Israel, the Israelis would have been content with the original borders created by the U.N. in 1948. But the Arab nations couldn't accept that.

Bingo...The anti-Semites on here will never admit this though.
 
  • Love
Reactions: xmontrealer
By the way, the U.S. seized Mexican territory that later became parts of Texas and California.

How do you think the U.S. would respond to terrorist attacks from Mexico?

Imho, it would not be pretty...
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
One doesn't have to be anti-Semitic to oppose the U.S. invading
the Middle East to punish those who hates Israel.

Have to say I don't think that's Trump's prime motivation in his war on Iran...

And where else in the Middle East is the U.S. currently invading?

Lots of other countries in the Middle East appear to have no love for Israel and Jews, although some are coming closer to accepting Israel's existence, as a matter of political and economic convenience.
 
Hate Israel eh?...Their. literal life mission is to wipe Israel and every Jewish person off the map

That threat is as real as Trump's threat to destroy a civilization
overnight.

Israel has nukes. Not likely it will be the one destroyed first
in a war with Iran.
 
Have to say I don't think that's Trump's prime motivation in his war on Iran...

And where else in the Middle East is the U.S. currently invading?

Currently Iran is the target. The U.S. has proven to be ready to invade
over the last few decades. Iraq would have survived regime change
had Saddam been Israel-friendly. And what is the purpose of maintaining
all the military bases if the U.S. is independent of oil export from the Gulf
region? To safeguard the flow of oil to China?

Lots of other countries in the Middle East appear to have no love for Israel and Jews, although some are coming closer to accepting Israel's existence, as a matter of political and economic convenience.

It is unfortunate Israel is surrounded by hateful neighbors. It is also
unfortunate the U.S. is hated by Israel's neighbors as well.
 
Wrong analogy.

Both the USA or Canada accepted Jews who survived the Holocaust, though somewhat reluctantly. My great-grandparents, who fled the Ukraine in 1895 due to antisemitism and attacks by non-Jews on their little villages, were sent by Canadian immigration authorities to Saskatchewan, and given land grants there.

For many displaced Jews from Germany and Poland, after the Holocaust there was nowhere else to go, except Israel, and even then not until 1948, several years after the end of the WWII.

Most who came to Canada didn't like Saskatchewan, had little farming knowledge, and soon moved to other Canadian cities, where they tried their best to assimilate and become good citizens of Canada.

None that I know of tried to expand the land they were granted.

Some became wealthy through innate intelligence and hard work, and were able to legally expand their holdings that way.

Had the surrounding Arab nations not tried over and over to attack and destroy Israel, the Israelis would have been content with the original borders created by the U.N. in 1948. But the Arab nations couldn't accept that.

Before Oct. 7, 2023 the only land the Israelis took is what they won during wars started by Hamas, Hezbollah, and/or the surrounding Arab nations, in an effort to destroy Israel.

It soon became evident to the Israelis that giving back the land would only encourage more attacks on them.

When Israel disengaged from Gaza in 2005, and had the IDF forcefully remove any Israelis who lived there in an effort to try to achieve peaceful co-existence, Hamas wouldn't let that be successful, with continuing terrorist attacks, culminating horrifically on Oct. 7, 2023.

Netanyahu then woke up to the realization that there would never be co-existence with Gaza as long as the radicals were in power there, and knew the only solution was to remove Hamas and other radicals from power. Hamas refused to see the light, and all Gazans are ultimately paying the price.

As are the citizens of Lebanon, due to the attacks on Israel by Hezbollah.

That said, I think the IDF should keep better control over the West Bank Israeli settlers, who are sometimes justified in their attacks on Arabs in the West bank, but often not...

you really think Israel tossing come crumbs to the Palis should have resulted in peace. To show you the Israeli "good will" they razed EVERYTHING they left. They left dust and ashes. So don't make that BULLSHIT out as some sort of manganous act of peace. That is a complete LIE. and lies do not help with progress as you notice from your ilk like Trump.
 

Sanctions on oil exports had been lifted. Revenue had increased 20% per barrel of oil. All Iran had to do was wait 60 days for the MOU to play out by allowing ALL vessels through the Strait of Hormuz. Instead, it decided to play tough. It will pay dearly.

1. The crucial port of Banda Abbas has been effectively cut off from the rest of the country by the US. No exports and imports going through
2. Weapons infrastructure being degraded relentlessly. Frequency of counter strikes by Iran has declined significantly in recent days
3. Gulf countries accelerating pipelines to bypass oil/gas shipments through the Strait. By 2030, the Strait will be a non factor in oil/gas shipments from Gulf countries
4. The US will start using Iranian funds to pay for damages to US and Gulf facilities. Up to $50 billion could be gone
5. Iranian ports blocked. No oil shipments

Iran has overplayed its hand. It will pay dearly short term and long term

Iran was allowing ships through as long as they registered and followed the Iranian published route. The USA encouraged tankers to run the straits with their transponders off. Those ships were hit.
 
Iran was allowing ships through as long as they registered and followed the Iranian published route. The USA encouraged tankers to run the straits with their transponders off. Those ships were hit.
For the damage they have suffered from the unwarranted attack by USA and Israel, Iran deserves to be compensated. Which is why they are adamant of a toll. I get that.
But whatever the situation, they should have let it be for 60 days and let compensation be a part of the negotiations. That is my point.

Watch the stock market. Reaction to renewed hostilities has not been as extreme as when the attack started. Why? The world is learning to cope without oil through the Strait. And soon, pipelines can divert most oil from the Strait.
And blockage of Bab-el-Mandeb by the Houthis on the Red Sea can be bypassed by loading oil on smaller vessels and going north through the Suez Canal.

Who stands to be the biggest loser? Iran, because of their intransigence.
 
It's Iran that has repeatedly threatened and attacked Gulf states, either directly or through its proxies, while also targeting shipping and energy infrastructure in the region. So claiming the Gulf countries are "less safe" simply because they host U.S. forces ignores a much broader pattern of Iranian aggression, yes, IRAN AGGRESSION against their neighbors.

More importantly, the Gulf states are sovereign countries. They have every right to decide which allies they host and what security arrangements they enter into. Neither Iran nor anyone else gets to dictate their foreign or defence policy. If Tehran has a dispute with the U.S., that doesn't give it the right to threaten or attack its neighbours.

You really do think that only americans have the right to self defence.

Not Iranians after america and Israel attack them.
Not Palestine after zionists attack them.
Not Lebanese after zionists attack them.

You keep arguing that only america and its proxies have the right to self defence.
You are fine with america funding Jordan, Egypt, Israel, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and others as 'proxies'.
You are fine with Netanyahu funding Hamas.

Why are gulf countries 'sovereign' but not Hezbollah or Hamas?

Why do you keep backing terrorism?
 
For the damage they have suffered from the unwarranted attack by USA and Israel, Iran deserves to be compensated. Which is why they are adamant of a toll. I get that.
But whatever the situation, they should have let it be for 60 days and let compensation be a part of the negotiations. That is my point.

Watch the stock market. Reaction to renewed hostilities has not been as extreme as when the attack started. Why? The world is learning to cope without oil through the Strait. And soon, pipelines can divert most oil from the Strait.
And blockage of Bab-el-Mandeb by the Houthis on the Red Sea can be bypassed by loading oil on smaller vessels and going north through the Suez Canal.

Who stands to be the biggest loser? Iran, because of their intransigence.

Not if they take out the Saudi ports, refineries, and pipelines. Its all sitting duck targets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
I've always said the U.S. started the war. I've never argued otherwise and I don't blame Iran for defending itself.

As for the bad neighbour analogy, if my neighbour threw a grenade through my window, I wouldn't respond by asking for peace. I'd hit back hard enough to ensure they never tried it again, with possibly a stack of dynamite thrown through the basement window to take out the entire home. Luckily, I have great neighbors on both sides.

Does this apply to american throwing grenades and dropping bombs on Iran?
Does this mean you accept that Iran is within their rights to hit america, block the Hormuz and target all american 'proxies' in the gulf?

This Onion post was from before Oct 7

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Had the surrounding Arab nations not tried over and over to attack and destroy Israel, the Israelis would have been content with the original borders created by the U.N. in 1948. But the Arab nations couldn't accept that.

Why should Palestinians have agreed to giving up half of Palestine to foreign settlers?
They had nothing to do with the Holocaust.
Germany should have given them land.
 
That said, I think the IDF should keep better control over the West Bank Israeli settlers, who are sometimes justified in their attacks on Arabs in the West bank, but often not...

Settlers are called settlers because they are paid by the state to take land from Palestinians, to 'settle' Palestine.
They do so through terrorism with the backing of the IDF.

Every single settlement is a war crime, every settlement is illegal.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
By the way, the U.S. seized Mexican territory that later became parts of Texas and California.

How do you think the U.S. would respond to terrorist attacks from Mexico?

Imho, it would not be pretty...

You must also think that Russia is right to take as much of Ukraine as they want and calling Ukrainians 'terrorists' means they can kill them too.
Do you also think trump was right to arrest Maduro, take over Venezuela and personally bank $16 billion in oil money?

What you preach is what Germany did in WWII.

78 years of Kristallnacht.