War with Iran

So, do you believe Jordan lied about intercepting those six missiles because it doesn't fit your narrative?

And since when does Iran get to decide Jordan's security policies? Jordan is a sovereign country. If it chooses to have American bases for security purposes, that's its decision, not Iran's.

One guess why Jordan values that security partnership so much. I'll give you a hint: it's not because it's worried about Israel. ;)

Jordan gets $1.5 billion a year from the states.
Its a small country.
 
Sure, the billions in U.S. aid are part of the relationship. Nobody disputes that. Why the hell not? Their choice, no considering it's a sovereign country?

But if you think Jordan's security concerns begin and end with U.S. money, you're ignoring the neighborhood it lives in. Jordan borders Israel, Syria, Iraq, and Saudi Arabia, and has spent decades dealing with regional instability, terrorism, refugee crises, and threats from Iranian-backed groups.

Let me repeat this so it sinks in: threats from Iranian-backed groups.

That's exactly why it has maintained close security ties with the U.S. for decades.

So no, it's not just about the money. Countries don't host foreign forces solely because they're getting a cheque. They do it because they believe it serves their own national security interests.

'Iran backed groups'

Israel is actually at war with Palestine, Iran, Lebanon and Syria.
Not linked to 'groups', whoever that is.

Why do you always argue that only Israel is allowed the right of self defence?
 
Yes, decisions do have consequences.

By that same logic, Iran should expect consequences when it bombs a neighboring country. Jordan is a sovereign state. If it decides to host U.S. forces, that's Jordan's decision. not Iran's.

And the idea that Jordan's relationship with the U.S. exists only because of a payoff is an oversimplification. Jordan has had security concerns for decades, including regional wars, terrorism, instability in Syria and Iraq, and cross-border threats. The partnership isn't just about money.

Using your logic, if your neighbor throws a grenade through your kitchen window because you're letting the neighbor on the other side park in your driveway, are you supposed to shrug and say, "Please, sir, may I have another?" Of course not. Most people would defend themselves and so should Jordan and any Gulf State that gets attacked by Iran.

Now, this may surprise you coming from me, but from a tactical standpoint, I don't blame Iran for trying to close the Strait or strike back at the US's interest in neighboring countries. Given the disparity in military power, it's one of the few ways it can try to push back against the U.S. That doesn't mean I think other countries should simply accept being attacked. They should fire right back at Iran.

Jordan is just another domino. Pretty soon the USA is going to have to evacuated there as well.
 
'Iran backed groups'

Israel is actually at war with Palestine, Iran, Lebanon and Syria.
Not linked to 'groups', whoever that is.


You're blurring the distinction between sovereign states and armed groups, but never let facts get in the way of your narrative.

Israel has fought direct exchanges with Iran, but in Lebanon its primary military opponent has been Hezbollah, not the Lebanese government as such, but you know that. Likewise, in Gaza its military campaign has been directed at Hamas, even though the war has had devastating consequences for civilians, and yes, Israel has gone too far with harming civilians. In Syria, Israel has conducted strikes against Iranian and allied military assets operating there, but once again, never let facts get in the way of your narrative.

So yes, "Iran-backed groups" is an accurate description of organizations like Hezbollah and several Iraqi and Yemeni militias. Whether you think Israel's actions are justified or have gone overboard is a separate debate which I am not going to have with you, but pretending those groups don't exist doesn't make them disappear.




Why do you always argue that only Israel is allowed the right of self defence?

Reading comprehension isn't your strong suit eh?? ;)

Now, this may surprise you coming from me, but from a tactical standpoint, I don't blame Iran for trying to close the Strait or strike back at the US's interest in neighboring countries. Given the disparity in military power, it's one of the few ways it can try to push back against the U.S. That doesn't mean I think other countries should simply accept being attacked. They should fire right back at Iran.
 
You're blurring the distinction between sovereign states and armed groups, but never let facts get in the way of your narrative.

Israel has fought direct exchanges with Iran, but in Lebanon its primary military opponent has been Hezbollah, not the Lebanese government as such, but you know that. Likewise, in Gaza its military campaign has been directed at Hamas, even though the war has had devastating consequences for civilians, and yes, Israel has gone too far with harming civilians. In Syria, Israel has conducted strikes against Iranian and allied military assets operating there, but once again, never let facts get in the way of your narrative.

So yes, "Iran-backed groups" is an accurate description of organizations like Hezbollah and several Iraqi and Yemeni militias. Whether you think Israel's actions are justified or have gone overboard is a separate debate which I am not going to have with you, but pretending those groups don't exist doesn't make them disappear.

Israel is responsible for the creation of Hezbollah through their invasion of Lebanon. Again, you think its wrong for Hezbollah to exist and defend their homeland, where Israel is now occupying and committing genocide. Israel are in the wrong here, morally and legally, not Hezbollah.




Reading comprehension isn't your strong suit eh?? ;)

Hypocrisy isn't yours.
You want Jordan to attack Iran because Iran is defending itself again american attacks and say that Iran is in the wrong to defend themselves.
You say Palestinians are not allowed to attack Israel despite illegally occupying Palestine.
You say Hezbollah is wrong to defend themselves against Israeli attacks and occupation.

You think Israel is justified in genocide to steal other people's land and that the evil people are those that just live there and try to defend themselves.

 
Israel is responsible for the creation of Hezbollah through their invasion of Lebanon. Again, you think its wrong for Hezbollah to exist and defend their homeland, where Israel is now occupying and committing genocide. Israel are in the wrong here, morally and legally, not Hezbollah.






Hypocrisy isn't yours.
You want Jordan to attack Iran because Iran is defending itself again american attacks and say that Iran is in the wrong to defend themselves.
You say Palestinians are not allowed to attack Israel despite illegally occupying Palestine.
You say Hezbollah is wrong to defend themselves against Israeli attacks and occupation.

You think Israel is justified in genocide to steal other people's land and that the evil people are those that just live there and try to defend themselves.


One question and one statement.

Would Israel have devastated Gaza and be conducting military operations in Lebanon today if Hamas and Hezbollah hadn't launched attacks against it or even existed for that matter?

And yes, I absolutely think Jordan and any other Gulf state have the right to defend themselves if Iran attacks its territory. That's called self-defence.

That said, I've also been consistent on this: Iran has the right to defend itself against the United States if the U.S. initiated military action against it. Recognizing one country's right to self-defence doesn't mean denying it to another. Think logically, Franky; you can do it.
 
So, do you believe Jordan lied about intercepting those six missiles because it doesn't fit your narrative?

And since when does Iran get to decide Jordan's security policies? Jordan is a sovereign country. If it chooses to have American bases for security purposes, that's its decision, not Iran's.

One guess why Jordan values that security partnership so much. I'll give you a hint: it's not because it's worried about Israel. ;)

The US has been lying directly or by omission for awhile now.
 
One question and one statement.

Would Israel have devastated Gaza and be conducting military operations in Lebanon today if Hamas and Hezbollah hadn't launched attacks against it or even existed for that matter?

And yes, I absolutely think Jordan and any other Gulf state have the right to defend themselves if Iran attacks its territory. That's called self-defence.

That said, I've also been consistent on this: Iran has the right to defend itself against the United States if the U.S. initiated military action against it. Recognizing one country's right to self-defence doesn't mean denying it to another. Think logically, Franky; you can do it.

I think the ethnic cleansing in the West Bank would have continued and they would have found other pretext for the rest.
 
Would Israel have devastated Gaza and be conducting military operations in Lebanon today if Hamas and Hezbollah hadn't launched attacks against it or even existed for that matter?
You've got the cause and effect backwards.
Hamas and Hezbollah didn't create the conflict.
They emerged because of decades of Israeli occupation, military action and the various crimes against humanity committed over the last 80 years.
They're a consequence of Israeli actions, not its cause.
 
You've got the cause and effect backwards.
Hamas and Hezbollah didn't create the conflict.
They emerged because of decades of Israeli occupation, military action and the various crimes against humanity committed over the last 80 years.
They're a consequence of Israeli actions, not its cause.

I never stated the cause and effect in any order, did I?

It's true that Hezbollah emerged after Israel's 1982 invasion of Lebanon, and Hamas grew out of the First Intifada during the Israeli occupation. Those historical events absolutely contributed to their rise.

But that doesn't mean they're simply passive "consequences" with no agency of their own. Both groups have made their own decisions for decades, including carrying out attacks against civilians, taking hostages, launching rockets, and rejecting various peace initiatives at different times.

History explains why groups emerge. It doesn't excuse everything they do afterward. Responsibility doesn't belong to only one side as your team likes to portray.
 
I never stated the cause and effect in any order, did I?

You certainly did. Your lack of self awareness is so obvious that it’s making you irrelevant and an object of derision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
You certainly did. Your lack of self awareness is so obvious that it’s making you irrelevant and an object of derision.

I don't worry too much about anything you have to say because it's coming from a total antisemite.
 
Both groups have made their own decisions for decades, including carrying out attacks against civilians, taking hostages, launching rockets, and rejecting various peace initiatives at different times.
Since you've already agreed that these groups emerged as a response to Israeli actions, the decisions they make are reactionary responses to Israel's continued and escalating actions, which have progressively worsened over time.
Therefore, if you want them to stop attacking Israel, Israel first needs to stop its crimes against humanity against the Palestinians.
You cannot eliminate the effect while refusing to address the cause.
 
One question and one statement.

Would Israel have devastated Gaza and be conducting military operations in Lebanon today if Hamas and Hezbollah hadn't launched attacks against it or even existed for that matter?

Yes.
Israel invaded Lebanon in the 1980's before Hezbollah was created, its why they organized, to resist Israeli occupation.
Was Israel occupying Palestinian land before Hamas? Israel funded Hamas to divide Palestinian resistance between the PLO or Fatah and Hamas, to make them divided.



And yes, I absolutely think Jordan and any other Gulf state have the right to defend themselves if Iran attacks its territory. That's called self-defence.

That said, I've also been consistent on this: Iran has the right to defend itself against the United States if the U.S. initiated military action against it. Recognizing one country's right to self-defence doesn't mean denying it to another. Think logically, Franky; you can do it.

So then you also agree that Iran has the right to hit american bases in any country that hosts them, Jordan, Kuwait, Bahrain, Iraq and Saudi Arabia. That is self defence and not attacks on those countries.

Which means you also agree that Iran now has the right to hit american assets anywhere and even to fire missiles at the UK.
Your belief in self defence means you do think Hamas as the right to attack Israel, and that Palestinians have the right to attack settlers, right?
That is the consistent application of self defence.