War with Iran

Iran don't have to have massive wins. It just needs to spook the ships and insurance companies to prevent them returning. Thats why they hit the ports. No ships, no shipments.

I don't disagree that Iran is using its leverage effectively. My point is simply that, militarily, it's on the losing end. Economically and strategically, though, it doesn't necessarily have to win on the battlefield; it just has to weather the storm long enough to impose costs and pressure on the moron sitting behind the golden-covered desk at the WH.
 
Do you think trump won the first round of war with Iran?


Militarily, I'd say the U.S. had the upper hand, but strategically, it's much less clear. How many times would you like me to repeat the same thing?

The war isn't over, and during the ceasefire, neither side has achieved a decisive victory.

If Iran were able to attack U.S. or commercial ships during a ceasefire without facing any response, that would shift the strategic balance in Iran's favor.

At this point, though, it's premature to say either side has "won." Claiming that Iran has already won, or that the U.S. has already won, is simply jumping to conclusions while the conflict is still unfolding. Of course, this doesn't fit your narrative.



 
I don't disagree that Iran is using its leverage effectively. My point is simply that, militarily, it's on the losing end. Economically and strategically, though, it doesn't necessarily have to win on the battlefield; it just has to weather the storm long enough to impose costs and pressure on the moron sitting behind the golden-covered desk at the WH.

I disagree. Almost the USA can really do is bomb. And at some point they will run out of expensive ammo. They have to keep a decent t sized strategic reserve. The nation itself is a nightmare to try a ground invasion. And they spend almost 5 decades creating a massive mountain tunel system for launchers and movement.

They are on defense. That tends to favor the defender. Especially from their logistics. This isn't Ukraine which is basically Saskatchewan.

Desperation is going to set in soon. For the USA. Their biggest worry is China, India, and Europe having enough and stepping in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
I disagree. Almost the USA can really do is bomb. And at some point they will run out of expensive ammo. They have to keep a decent t sized strategic reserve. The nation itself is a nightmare to try a ground invasion. And they spend almost 5 decades creating a massive mountain tunel system for launchers and movement.

They are on defense. That tends to favor the defender. Especially from their logistics. This isn't Ukraine which is basically Saskatchewan.

Desperation is going to set in soon. For the USA. Their biggest worry is China, India, and Europe having enough and stepping in.


I disagree with the idea that the U.S. is nearing desperation. The U.S. military has a very large stockpile of precision-guided weapons, and while some munitions are expensive and require replenishment, there's no public evidence that the U.S. is close to exhausting its ability to conduct air and naval operations. Sustaining a long campaign has costs, but that's different from being unable to continue.

As for China, India, and Europe, their primary interest is regional stability and keeping global trade flowing. They're far more likely to push for de-escalation than to intervene militarily on Iran's behalf.

The bigger question isn't who can keep bombing longer; it's whether either side can achieve its political objectives. Military superiority doesn't automatically translate into strategic victory, and that's why it's still far too early to declare a winner.
 
I don't disagree that Iran is using its leverage effectively. My point is simply that, militarily, it's on the losing end. Economically and strategically, though, it doesn't necessarily have to win on the battlefield; it just has to weather the storm long enough to impose costs and pressure on the moron sitting behind the golden-covered desk at the WH.

I'd argue that we are seeing a similar strategy to Russia and Ukraine.
Where both Russia and america went in full of bluster knowing they have the air, bomb and naval advantage.
But both Ukraine and Iran used that to their advantage, both Ukraine and Iran hit logistic targets while trump/Israel did their usual terrorist/civilian targeting.
america used AI for target generation, which is why they hit a girl's school on their first strike and sports stadiums, hospitals and universities since.
Ukraine and Iran hit military and logistic targets like bases, refineries and targets that won't be made public, generally.

Iran's missile and drone defence remains, Israel is now afraid to hit nuclear or water plants knowing that Iran can strike those at will.
So trump does a few big hits and sends the jets in, he's putting in aircraft carriers to escort freighters through the Hormuz, not to fight.

 
I disagree with the idea that the U.S. is nearing desperation. The U.S. military has a very large stockpile of precision-guided weapons, and while some munitions are expensive and require replenishment, there's no public evidence that the U.S. is close to exhausting its ability to conduct air and naval operations. Sustaining a long campaign has costs, but that's different from being unable to continue.

As for China, India, and Europe, their primary interest is regional stability and keeping global trade flowing. They're far more likely to push for de-escalation than to intervene militarily on Iran's behalf.

The bigger question isn't who can keep bombing longer; it's whether either side can achieve its political objectives. Military superiority doesn't automatically translate into strategic victory, and that's why it's still far too early to declare a winner.

america and Israel burned through a big chunk of their missile stockpile in the first round.
They have bombs but they have to get them there.

 
I'd argue that we are seeing a similar strategy to Russia and Ukraine.


I do agree to an extent. Trump, against the advice of many experts, appears to have believed this would be a quick and decisive operation, similar to how Putin expected to defeat Ukraine in a matter of days. Reality has proven to be much more complicated and the orange stain isn't bright enough to have known that.

The idea that Israel is afraid to strike Iran doesn't make much sense. If anything, it's more likely that the U.S. is trying to manage the escalation. Once Israel significantly expands its operations, it becomes much harder for Washington to control where the conflict goes next.

I WILL REPEAT this: Militarily, Iran simply cannot match the conventional capabilities of either the U.S. or Israel. Where Iran does have leverage is through asymmetric means, its geography, the Strait of Hormuz with missile and drone attacks, and its ability to disrupt global shipping and raise the economic cost of the conflict.

In my opinion the only way to really secure the Strait is to have a large-scale ground invasion. Iran's terrain and defenses would make it extremely costly, and it's difficult to imagine the American public supporting the casualties such a campaign would likely entail. That's why neither side can claim victory at this point. Military superiority alone doesn't guarantee a strategic win.
 
I disagree with the idea that the U.S. is nearing desperation. The U.S. military has a very large stockpile of precision-guided weapons, and while some munitions are expensive and require replenishment, there's no public evidence that the U.S. is close to exhausting its ability to conduct air and naval operations. Sustaining a long campaign has costs, but that's different from being unable to continue.

As for China, India, and Europe, their primary interest is regional stability and keeping global trade flowing. They're far more likely to push for de-escalation than to intervene militarily on Iran's behalf.

The bigger question isn't who can keep bombing longer; it's whether either side can achieve its political objectives. Military superiority doesn't automatically translate into strategic victory, and that's why it's still far too early to declare a winner.

They are years behind now on missile production. And if China says no more rare earths then no more munitions can be produced.

Pretty soon things are going to get far more dire than anyone thinks.
 
They are years behind now on missile production. And if China says no more rare earths then no more munitions can be produced.

Pretty soon things are going to get far more dire than anyone thinks.

You're always a doom-and-gloom type of guy. We shall see. Once the midterms hit, and if the Repugs loose the House and Senate, it will be interesting to see what happens.
 
They are dropping bombs on the coast.
Why?

Here you go, Frankie. I could tell you, but I rather have AI give you the deets.


AI Overview




The U.S. military hit over 170 military targets in Iran, primarily along the southern coastline near the Strait of Hormuz, after President Trump declared the recent ceasefire over. [1, 2]
Key targets struck by U.S. forces included: [1, 2, 3]
  • Coastal & Naval Infrastructure: Air defense systems, coastal surveillance nodes, missile and drone storage sites, and military speedboats. [1]
  • Logistics & Supply Routes: Military logistics facilities along the coast and a major railway bridge in northeastern Iran used for weapons transport. [1, 2]
Plus, I added this for your viewing pleasure. Please watch it sitting down.

 
You're always a doom-and-gloom type of guy. We shall see. Once the midterms hit, and if the Repugs loose the House and Senate, it will be interesting to see what happens.

It makes no difference to the war. Congress is owed by AIPAC. They will talk big talk, do nothing. And vote is a massive defense budget increase. As always.

Stop thinking the Dems give a shit. They would rather fundraise off the problem than solve it.
 
I do agree to an extent. Trump, against the advice of many experts, appears to have believed this would be a quick and decisive operation, similar to how Putin expected to defeat Ukraine in a matter of days. Reality has proven to be much more complicated and the orange stain isn't bright enough to have known that.

The idea that Israel is afraid to strike Iran doesn't make much sense. If anything, it's more likely that the U.S. is trying to manage the escalation. Once Israel significantly expands its operations, it becomes much harder for Washington to control where the conflict goes next.

I WILL REPEAT this: Militarily, Iran simply cannot match the conventional capabilities of either the U.S. or Israel. Where Iran does have leverage is through asymmetric means, its geography, the Strait of Hormuz with missile and drone attacks, and its ability to disrupt global shipping and raise the economic cost of the conflict.

Israel is tiny compared to Iran. They can't stop Iranian missiles.
Iran is large and mountainous, they can hide sites.
Israel's water is fed by one desalination plant, they have one nuclear reactor and one main city.
Now they can't stop Iranian missiles either.

The states can't fly over Iran, Iran can't fly outside their borders. america's navy is in danger in the Hormuz and their only safe launching site is a secret site in Iraq.


In my opinion the only way to really secure the Strait is to have a large-scale ground invasion. Iran's terrain and defenses would make it extremely costly, and it's difficult to imagine the American public supporting the casualties such a campaign would likely entail. That's why neither side can claim victory at this point. Military superiority alone doesn't guarantee a strategic win.

This was an illegal war by trump in the first place.
There was no need to go to war and all it will do is make the gulf less safe.

america has no right to attack Iran, no right to invade and no right to complain about Iran controlling the Hormuz after the war.

 
Here you go, Frankie. I could tell you, but I rather have AI give you the deets.


AI Overview




The U.S. military hit over 170 military targets in Iran, primarily along the southern coastline near the Strait of Hormuz, after President Trump declared the recent ceasefire over. [1, 2]
Key targets struck by U.S. forces included: [1, 2, 3]
  • Coastal & Naval Infrastructure: Air defense systems, coastal surveillance nodes, missile and drone storage sites, and military speedboats. [1]
  • Logistics & Supply Routes: Military logistics facilities along the coast and a major railway bridge in northeastern Iran used for weapons transport. [1, 2]
Plus, I added this for your viewing pleasure. Please watch it sitting down.


Its sad you can't think for yourself and have to get some billionaire controlled AI to do it for you.
trump can't hit targets inland because of missile shortages and not being able to fly over Iran except with B52's way up in the atmosphere.

 
Its sad you can't think for yourself and have to get some billionaire controlled AI to do it for you.
trump can't hit targets inland because of missile shortages and not being able to fly over Iran except with B52's way up in the atmosphere.


You don't like the truth coming from AI and just like Trump you want to call it fake news. I think AI gathers information a lot better than you Franky.

Spreading more nonsense and lies, you get off X eh


"There is no confirmed reporting of an Iranian attack early this morning that destroyed advanced Israeli military facilities. The broader U.S.-Iran conflict has recently seen an exchange of fire between the U.S. and Iran in the Gulf region, rather than a direct Iranian strike on Israeli military sites this morning. [1, 2, 3]
Historically, during the height of the conflict, Iran claimed to have struck intelligence sites in Israel—specifically the headquarters of Israel's Military Intelligence Directorate (Aman) and operational centers belonging to Mossad in the Herzliya area. However, Israeli sources did not confirm the destruction of these facilities, stating that most missiles were intercepted or fell in open areas. [1, 2]"
 
Israel is tiny compared to Iran. They can't stop Iranian missiles.
Iran is large and mountainous, they can hide sites.
Israel's water is fed by one desalination plant, they have one nuclear reactor and one main city.
Now they can't stop Iranian missiles either.

The states can't fly over Iran, Iran can't fly outside their borders. america's navy is in danger in the Hormuz and their only safe launching site is a secret site in Iraq.




This was an illegal war by trump in the first place.
There was no need to go to war and all it will do is make the gulf less safe.

america has no right to attack Iran, no right to invade and no right to complain about Iran controlling the Hormuz after the war.

I believe Israel with the help of the US is doing a fine job stopping the limited missiles and drones Iran is firing.

The states are hitting at will and are choosing to hit where they are, stop making shit up.

Iran should not be left to control the strait and Trump can't afford to let that happen as it will be viewed as a loss.
 
Iran should not be left to control the strait and Trump can't afford to let that happen as it will be viewed as a loss.

"This can't be allowed to happen because it will bruise Trump's ego" is a fucking terrible reason for continuing military action.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
You don't like the truth coming from AI and just like Trump you want to call it fake news. I think AI gathers information a lot better than you Franky.

Spreading more nonsense and lies, you get off X eh


"There is no confirmed reporting of an Iranian attack early this morning that destroyed advanced Israeli military facilities. The broader U.S.-Iran conflict has recently seen an exchange of fire between the U.S. and Iran in the Gulf region, rather than a direct Iranian strike on Israeli military sites this morning. [1, 2, 3]
Historically, during the height of the conflict, Iran claimed to have struck intelligence sites in Israel—specifically the headquarters of Israel's Military Intelligence Directorate (Aman) and operational centers belonging to Mossad in the Herzliya area. However, Israeli sources did not confirm the destruction of these facilities, stating that most missiles were intercepted or fell in open areas. [1, 2]"

That quoted does not exist in the Reuter's article AI says its quoting.

AI makes shit up, hallucinations.
That's why its getting dropped.

Israeli censorship blocks all reporting on damages, with a 5 year sentence for SM posts.
So how do you know they weren't hit?