How does Toronto compare to Montreal?

I know, I followed this story from the beginning. It's been discussed ad nauseam. I just have friends who worked for that agency and they really did not enjoy it. We knew why it was shut down, when it happened. Personally, I just think that this seems like a surprise or an exception to clients, but agencies in Montreal are generally exploitative and shitty. From my perspective, agencies own the sex industry in many ways because they dictate rates and services we have to offer. Even if I charge higher, I still have to conform myself to a lot of standards that were decided by the agencies. I find that in other cities, nowadays, there is a bigger difference between indy clients and agency clients, or there is less animosity towards indies. This wasn't the case in the past. Even just a year and a half ago, I had a lot of clients who never used review boards or didn't spend their entire life on them.

At some point in time, perhaps gradually, life got really fucking hard and I think less enjoyable for a lot of people, especially relatively less wealthy people.

Most of it is economic, as you mentioned with the higher rents in Montreal. But some of it is psychological, with the whole #metoo and Power Imbalance stuff that confuses and also irritates most guys. And some of it is legal in that c-36 didn‘t exist in Canada and Fosta/Sesta hadn’t been enacted in the U.S.

People didn’t take life so fucking seriously 10-25 years ago. I mentioned seeing 18-year old Roller Blade girl in Montreal, who I think of when seeing the movie Boogie Nights. She talked about movies and being excited about moving to the big city for college and seemed to be enjoying life. And the lack of filter young lady who gave me the names of some bars to check out to get some of that supposedly free sex.

I am not sure an agency in Montreal would even hire 18-year old Roller Blade girl now in Montreal. And the lady who gave me the bar name would have probably tell me if I wanted another cum later that night, see her for a shorter session at 50 percent of the normal time and 75 percent of the normal cost.

The industry has perhaps gotten a bit more professional. I love the ladies I see and the range of services I get are greater.

But there are a couple of things to consider. The U.S., Toronto and Vancouver have done a lot better in the modern economy than Montreal has done. So the higher prices are easier deal with for customers outside of Montreal. And I think it is difficult for a party city like Montreal to deal with this greater professionalism. I remember having a two-hour outcall session in Montreal and only having water and soft drinks and the lady told me that alcohol was pretty standard for a longer session. I asked if we could walk somewhere to fix it, and we took off to the corner store and I bought her her favorite blackberry wine cooler. We still had plenty of time for fun, and she wasn’t in a hurry anyway, she said.

There are no sweet, educational, fun moments like that anywhere now, including Montreal. I think there is one agency in Montreal focusing on outcall, but mostly they are incall with little time between sessions. Sex work services are still outstanding everywhere I go, but the providers are a little bit older, need to make more money, and the Johns have corresponding higher expectations due to the higher prices.

It isn’t as innocent and fun as it once was for a lot of people, and that is especially noticeable in what was once a fun party city like Montreal that never used to take life so seriously. When you need every dime for rent and food, it takes a lot of fun out of life.
 
My info is dated but I enjoyed Montreal more because the ladies were more fun, less businesslike in that they were pretty relaxed, more open to talking about themselves, and did small things like clean me up after a SOG. Things might have changed since Covid but I just left more relaxed in there.
 
Maybe there's a reason why the girls were down to party. Partying doesn't mean consenting to sex, and in the past 10 years it came to light in my circle of friends that a lot of men had taken advantage of them while they were partying. A lot of people who moved to Montreal due to it's reputation as a party city went back to their home towns or the city they initially lived in as well.

Party culture has its pitfalls.

I'm really wondering what you mean by ''more individualistic provider''

Mostly just the variety of more alt/goth/kink providers and a less uniform presentation of individual style.
My impression that things are more homogeneous now may be completely wrong, of course.

.. because as far as I'm concerned, from what I hear, providers in Toronto allow themselves to upcharge, have certain boundaries and do things that here, we would be criticized for endlessly. What are we supposed to do? Do everything the client says and charge almost nothing? Like I said, a lot of providers I know who lived in Montreal left the city. I also know providers who only work in other cities, which might be me in the future.

I think you're misinterpreting what I was saying, since I wasn't referring to any of these things at all.

It's easy to put the fault on providers, instead of looking at how toxic the whole scene in general is.

I quite agree the Montreal scene is toxic (I thought I said that in my earlier post). That is one of the reasons I don't participate in it.

Pimps, exploitative employers and clients who love to gossip, coerce and push boundaries are also to blame.. In order to keep some of my clients, I have to do things I would never have done in the past. I'm not talking about ''unsafe services'' but other things that I frankly don't feel like doing and make me uncomfortable. Some Merb users have called me a client hater because I called out some behavior that is harmful to providers, but strangely, I don't see a lot of these types of behaviors nearly as much in other cities. Even Ottawa, which has a pretty negative reputation among providers, is nothing compared to how bad Montreal is and has gotten.

I believe you.
 
Mostly just the variety of more alt/goth/kink providers and a less uniform presentation of individual style.
My impression that things are more homogeneous now may be completely wrong, of course.

I don't think you're wrong. It's possible that there are less alt providers now because that look is less popular now than it used to be.. A lot of alt providers I know of have retired because the industry became too much for them, others have changed their styles. Personally over the years I've felt the pressure to conform myself to a more ''conventional'' look to reach different client bases..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
Review boards are not unique to Montreal or Canada, but Montreal's board is one of the first places that emphasizes the "menu." I've noticed that people seem very interested in not just the basic purpose of a review board such as does this person look like their photos, will they scam you, and was it an okay time, but instead please list every single abbreviation this provider is okay with up to the extreme. I also get the sense people want to get one's money worth almost like you're trying to make your money back at a buffet. Like there's emphasis on 2-3 SOG per hour. From that obviously people will want to get what the last guy got and more like you are at a mechanic checking off every inspection item. Okay, for this session I need LFK, check, then DFK, check, then BBBJ, check, then DATY, check, then position 1, check, then position 2, ... And with basically what seems to be fewer providers, it's easier to keep track of individuals as they go from one agency to another or indy and thus there's where the cliquey feeling may come from.

From what I've learned, the agencies do not set the prices and prices can be higher, but there's a fear that you would not get booked simply by raising your price from $270 per hour to $300, especially when everyone else's prices are that price. It seems that not only are clients are balking that small jump, but many SP consider their prices "high" when they raise it to that. Seems like they should all unionize and just all agree to raise prices to a set amount. Also the incentive structure is aimed towards more bookings rather than higher price. Agencies don't charge a percentage like a modeling or acting agent whose incentive is to get maximum salary, but these agencies charge a fixed price. I'm not sure how it works in Toronto, but it seems Toronto is more lax on this as there appears to be tier lists with agency rates a lot more variable.

So back the to difference between TO and MTL, if MTL was a party city and is no longer so, does that mean TO has always been very business like and impersonal?
 
  • Like
Reactions: lunaseraphim
Review boards are not unique to Montreal or Canada, but Montreal's board is one of the first places that emphasizes the "menu." I've noticed that people seem very interested in not just the basic purpose of a review board such as does this person look like their photos, will they scam you, and was it an okay time, but instead please list every single abbreviation this provider is okay with up to the extreme. I also get the sense people want to get one's money worth almost like you're trying to make your money back at a buffet. Like there's emphasis on 2-3 SOG per hour. From that obviously people will want to get what the last guy got and more like you are at a mechanic checking off every inspection item. Okay, for this session I need LFK, check, then DFK, check, then BBBJ, check, then DATY, check, then position 1, check, then position 2, ... And with basically what seems to be fewer providers, it's easier to keep track of individuals as they go from one agency to another or indy and thus there's where the cliquey feeling may come from.

From what I've learned, the agencies do not set the prices and prices can be higher, but there's a fear that you would not get booked simply by raising your price from $270 per hour to $300, especially when everyone else's prices are that price. It seems that not only are clients are balking that small jump, but many SP consider their prices "high" when they raise it to that. Seems like they should all unionize and just all agree to raise prices to a set amount. Also the incentive structure is aimed towards more bookings rather than higher price. Agencies don't charge a percentage like a modeling or acting agent whose incentive is to get maximum salary, but these agencies charge a fixed price. I'm not sure how it works in Toronto, but it seems Toronto is more lax on this as there appears to be tier lists with agency rates a lot more variable.

So back the to difference between TO and MTL, if MTL was a party city and is no longer so, does that mean TO has always been very business like and impersonal?

I certainly wasn’t implying that Toronto services are impersonal. The Toronto providers are excellent and I just don’t think there is much difference now between service levels. Toronto has more diversity in the offerings and isn’t that much more expensive now compared to Montreal.

I was just saying that Montreal once had something unique that I don’t think exists now. A decade or two ago it had an abundance of 18-25 year old providers that were inexpensive and not that concerned with time. The higher cost of living and the relative disinterest in sex work by the current generation of older teens and college ladies (almost worldwide) has changed that dynamic.

I was also explaining why some guys who once experienced that now go overboard on dissing the current Montreal scene.

The only lesson from what I posted is that if you find something that really appeals to you, ride it until the wheels come off. You can see a similar situation worldwide with guys who love clubs. Other than in Brazil, the club concept is in decline. The guys who loved FKKs wax nostalgic about the FKKs a decade or two ago, and how they are disappointed with them now.

Never let anyone tell you not to do something you enjoy because you are too young for it. Fuck that. God knows what the world will be like a decade or two from now.

But once again, services in Toronto are great, and Montreal is now very similar to Toronto. Nothing wrong with respecting her time and realizing that an hour is an hour. In the modern world where everyone needs to earn a lot to live, you just aren’t going to get an outcall provider like the one I remembered who says she is not in a hurry, can we put our clothes on and run down to the corner store to get a wine cooler before we have fun again? Those days are long gone, even in Montreal.
 
Review boards are not unique to Montreal or Canada, but Montreal's board is one of the first places that emphasizes the "menu." I've noticed that people seem very interested in not just the basic purpose of a review board such as does this person look like their photos, will they scam you, and was it an okay time, but instead please list every single abbreviation this provider is okay with up to the extreme. I also get the sense people want to get one's money worth almost like you're trying to make your money back at a buffet. Like there's emphasis on 2-3 SOG per hour. From that obviously people will want to get what the last guy got and more like you are at a mechanic checking off every inspection item. Okay, for this session I need LFK, check, then DFK, check, then BBBJ, check, then DATY, check, then position 1, check, then position 2, ... And with basically what seems to be fewer providers, it's easier to keep track of individuals as they go from one agency to another or indy and thus there's where the cliquey feeling may come from.

From what I've learned, the agencies do not set the prices and prices can be higher, but there's a fear that you would not get booked simply by raising your price from $270 per hour to $300, especially when everyone else's prices are that price. It seems that not only are clients are balking that small jump, but many SP consider their prices "high" when they raise it to that. Seems like they should all unionize and just all agree to raise prices to a set amount. Also the incentive structure is aimed towards more bookings rather than higher price. Agencies don't charge a percentage like a modeling or acting agent whose incentive is to get maximum salary, but these agencies charge a fixed price. I'm not sure how it works in Toronto, but it seems Toronto is more lax on this as there appears to be tier lists with agency rates a lot more variable.

So back the to difference between TO and MTL, if MTL was a party city and is no longer so, does that mean TO has always been very business like and impersonal?

Your first paragraph is what bothers me about the Montreal board and the culture.. It's like that everywhere to an extent but I feel like ''getting your money's worth like you're trying to make your money back at a buffet'' feels dehumanizing, personally. I know from certain clients this is ideal because that's what they are looking for, but things weren't like this before, particularly for indies. It's also annoying because some people will complain about us ''being too transactional'' and complain about our rates, but they treat us like we're acronym dispensers. And frankly, it doesn't make any booking fun when we feel that way, I've said it many times. A lot of the time I also don't feel like the client is having fun because this attitude is already negative to begin with.

Agencies do set the prices in the sense that because they are so popular here and the client base at the moment is very agency focused, an indy who charges 350 to 500 is considered ''too expensive'', when in other cities that is pretty normal. When your goal is to get more bookings for lower rate, it creates exhaustion for the workers, unless you allow a type of service that is less demanding. In the past a lot of agencies did not enforce GFE. To me a GFE service for less than 200$ an hour when you have to see several clients in a row is not reasonable. I am not sure what you mean by ''agencies don't charge a percentage'' because they take a huge cut.. And from what I've heard, the SP who charge a bit more at agencies just have that privilege because they have been there longer.

I think people confuse a girl who's partying and acting unprofessional with her being more open to something more, to offer free services or to stay longer. I've often heard stories from Montreal clients and on the MTL review board about girls who stayed with clients and did unhinged things like take off their panties at the restaurant or follow them around all night acting .. uh.. in a way they normally wouldn't. To me, that isn't pure kindness or ''being a naive sweet barely legal girl''. It's somebody who is under the influence and has lost control. I also think ''business like and impersonal'' is very subjective.. some people would say I'm business like because I charge indy rates. I consider myself professional particularly during the booking process, but anyone who's met me found me friendly and welcoming.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar and Patron
IDK what it is about MTL but for me the indy selection is way more varied and interesting than here by far but mainly because I have a preference for alt-girls and natural-types that are few and far between around here. Also it's less expensive, for sure (indy-wise).
 
  • Like
Reactions: lunaseraphim
IDK what it is about MTL but for me the indy selection is way more varied and interesting than here by far but mainly because I have a preference for alt-girls and natural-types that are few and far between around here. Also it's less expensive, for sure (indy-wise).
Some of us are still there! 💘

Come to think about it, a lot of alt girls I knew retired, or they are not as accessible. One specific provider for instance really stands out to me, but she has a no review policy and she isn't always advertising. I think it's true that there is less diversity now in terms of presentation, but that's also because many of us feel less and less safe in the industry, in Montreal.. sadly.

This is also a discussion that I've had on social media recently with somebody in the US, I feel like the pressure to have a "high end" branding to avoid "buffet type clients" (as mentioned by the user above lol) has become strong. In order to get nice dates, you have to show that you're presentable. I'm not sure that if I post myself wearing dramatic eyeliner, combat boots, a holographic dress and a pink collar with spikes a gentleman over a certain age will feel comfortable taking me out to eat.. I also think that in Montreal, there is more and more hostility towards "alt styles" for some reason, meanwhile in Toronto I get complimented left and right.
 
I am not sure what you mean by ''agencies don't charge a percentage'' because they take a huge cut..

I hate to quote billionaires, but Warren Buffet's business partner said “Show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome.” This was later repeated by the likes of Bezos. Basically in film and the arts, your agent takes a percentage of your gross salary and this incentivizes them to negotiate a higher and higher wage for you so that they can get a higher and higher amount. The agencies both in call and out in MTL take a fixed amount e.g. $25 for the driver, $15 for the booker, and $xx for the agency. Thus, they only make money when you are booked and they don't care if your fee is $300 or $400. You can charge higher fee, but if everyone is charging the same amount either you won't get booked or people expect something extra for that extra charge. This is also why I assume they push volume.
 
I hate to quote billionaires, but Warren Buffet's business partner said “Show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome.” This was later repeated by the likes of Bezos. Basically in film and the arts, your agent takes a percentage of your gross salary and this incentivizes them to negotiate a higher and higher wage for you so that they can get a higher and higher amount. The agencies both in call and out in MTL take a fixed amount e.g. $25 for the driver, $15 for the booker, and $xx for the agency. Thus, they only make money when you are booked and they don't care if your fee is $300 or $400. You can charge higher fee, but if everyone is charging the same amount either you won't get booked or people expect something extra for that extra charge. This is also why I assume they push volume.

Yes, but you aren’t factoring in upsells.

These two ladies just got reviews recently on TER.



They are both excellent escorts and get great scores on reviews. The reviewer liked each of them.

Constance is exactly my type and the reviewer indicated that she told him she had a very long list of possible activities, as indicated by her ad saying she is very open to many activities.

But the reviewer indicated that Jennifer wanted $80 for CIM and $200 for anal. Constance asked $50 for rimming and $100 for anal.

Now granted Montreal agency prices start lower than Montreal independents or most Toronto agencies and Toronto independents. But personally I don’t like upsells. My favorite group in Toronto lists which ladies offer Greek and her upcharge. Beyond that, I have not been upcharged by any of their ladies.

So the agency wants volume and it would appear that many of their ladies want upsells.

Some people would still feel they got a better deal if the base price plus the upsells is less than the higher base price of another lady who doesn’t upsell. But I just find upsells during the session to be detract from the session.

It also makes it even more difficult to compare Montreal to other cities. Plus as I indicated earlier, those types of upsells just didn’t use to occur in Montreal.
 
I hate to quote billionaires, but Warren Buffet's business partner said “Show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome.” This was later repeated by the likes of Bezos. Basically in film and the arts, your agent takes a percentage of your gross salary and this incentivizes them to negotiate a higher and higher wage for you so that they can get a higher and higher amount. The agencies both in call and out in MTL take a fixed amount e.g. $25 for the driver, $15 for the booker, and $xx for the agency. Thus, they only make money when you are booked and they don't care if your fee is $300 or $400. You can charge higher fee, but if everyone is charging the same amount either you won't get booked or people expect something extra for that extra charge. This is also why I assume they push volume.

Honestly, I think your comparison shows that you don't understand what it's like to be a sex worker. Artists want to become famous, they reach out to agents for this. SP are not trying to get famous, they are trying to survive. I'm not going to get into this because it's ''negative'' and ''a turn off'' and I start getting called a ton of insults by review board users when I address reality.

I'm not saying that people who work for these establishments don't deserve to be paid. I'm just saying the escorts deserve more than 180 an hour for GFE, particularly at agencies where it's known that a large portion of clients, in Montreal at least, are aggressive, entitled, don't understand consent and are disrespectful generally. This is a generalization and not all of them are like this, but I used to charge agency rates and I have a lot of friends who worked for agencies, so I know what I'm talking about.

I think you and others should try a little bit to put yourself at our place. Would you like to work for an agency if you were an escort in Montreal?

My point isn't that the driver and booker don't deserve to be paid. It's that the escorts deserve better rates, it's fairly easy to understand. And they shouldn't feel pressured to offer extras they aren't comfortable offering to make more money. This is also why rates at agencies in Toronto and other cities are generally higher. And let's not forget those agencies that take advantage of migrant women and market towards white men who fetishize Asian women, and pressure them to offer BBFs and services like rimming... which honestly nobody wants to do.
 
Last edited:
Yes, but you aren’t factoring in upsells.

These two ladies just got reviews recently on TER.



They are both excellent escorts and get great scores on reviews. The reviewer liked each of them.

Constance is exactly my type and the reviewer indicated that she told him she had a very long list of possible activities, as indicated by her ad saying she is very open to many activities.

But the reviewer indicated that Jennifer wanted $80 for CIM and $200 for anal. Constance asked $50 for rimming and $100 for anal.

Now granted Montreal agency prices start lower than Montreal independents or most Toronto agencies and Toronto independents. But personally I don’t like upsells. My favorite group in Toronto lists which ladies offer Greek and her upcharge. Beyond that, I have not been upcharged by any of their ladies.

So the agency wants volume and it would appear that many of their ladies want upsells.

Some people would still feel they got a better deal if the base price plus the upsells is less than the higher base price of another lady who doesn’t upsell. But I just find upsells during the session to be detract from the session.

It also makes it even more difficult to compare Montreal to other cities. Plus as I indicated earlier, those types of upsells just didn’t use to occur in Montreal.

The reason why these extras are so pricy is because the rates are so low. Also a lot of escorts don't want to do these extras, they end up offering them because they are not well paid at the agency. I think it's fairly easy to understand this. Not everyone wants to offer greek or cim. There's a reason why I personally don't offer anal, it's a physical problem and hurts a lot for me. Some girls don't ''upsell'' because they are not popular enough to do it, and they get treated even worse as a result of it. If you don't want to pay for extras, then just don't ask for them, or seek somebody who you already know are including them in their rate...
 
Yes, Toronto is a lot more diverse and there is a lot more to choose from. Everything from the Allegra agency that has beautiful ladies who offer alt/kink, to Wetlands and their Asian / South American massage line-ups, to traditional agencies like Discrete Dolls.

I mention Discrete Dolls because Montreal is mostly a bunch of agencies like that but with mostly all late 20s to early 40s Quebec ladies offering very routine GFE. I have two independent favorites in Montreal that I love and see whenever I can get there, but I prefer Toronto as a tourist because there is more to choose from. Montreal in my opinion currently has kind of a boring scene and it is mentioned less than it once was in discussions of tourism for this activity.

The decline in the Montreal scene from a tourist perspective, in my opinion, stemmed from the end of the Eleganza agency. It was cookie-cutter like the agencies are now, but those were some delicious cookies. They were mostly a group of 18-25 year olds starting college or vocational training. For a decade or so, they consistently found the world’s hottest group of GFE “college girls”.

Another guy who appreciates Toronto on ISG asked why Americans don’t get to Toronto for this activity as much as they probably should, and I had no answer. With Niagara, and the Islands, and a much cleaner mini-Manhattan as a downtown, it is a great place. I think Americans like to think of going to Montreal as going to “mini-France”, but if so, that only lasts for a trip or two. And Montreal went corporate like so much of North America. There are fewer independently owned little restaurants and shops than a decade ago in Montreal. Toronto actually has more of that type of thing in its many large ethnic neighborhoods, especially the ones with great middle-eastern food. Montreal doesn’t have those types of large ethnic neighborhoods, and it shows up in the lack of diversity in its sex work scene.
This makes me want to move to Montreal.
 
This makes me want to move to Montreal.

Why is that? I was saying I think Toronto is better at the moment for this activity. But from an outsider‘s perspective, and I presume the OP is a tourist, they are both great compared to anywhere in the U.S.

And I meant no slight to 25-45 year old woman. That is the age group of ladies I mostly see. I was just saying that Montreal was once an outlier in having the youngest sex workers and that made it different than other cities for guys who like a lot of variety, but that isn’t the case now. Of course there may have been a dark side to it. Maybe the Eleganza recruiter went to freshman orientation at the local college? But they had a new crop of 18-20 year-olds every year.

There were once endless Montreal reviews and discussions on international and American review boards. I just don’t see that any longer.
 
Last edited:
Why is that? I was saying I think Toronto is better at the moment for this activity. But from an outsider‘s perspective, and I presume the OP is a tourist, they are both great compared to anywhere in the U.S.

And I meant no slight to 25-45 year old woman. That is the age group of ladies I mostly see. I was just saying that Montreal was once an outlier in having the youngest sex workers and that made it different than other cities for guys who like a lot of variety, but that isn’t the case now. Of course there may have been a dark side to it. Maybe the Eleganza recruiter went to freshman orientation at the local college? But they had a new crop of 18-20 year-olds every year.

There were once endless Montreal reviews and discussions on international and American review boards. I just don’t see that any longer.

There's a reason why there are less super young girls in the industry.. this is something I've come to understand after doing a bit of research and listening to many many different people's stories carefully. (I will never name names.. so please don't ask)

Some girls used fake ID's and were underage, some girls were underage and were being pimped and groomed, some employers didn't check ID at all. Some well seasoned clients know this and they know to avoid girls who are advertised at a certain age and look very young.. I personally don't think it's a bad thing that less barely legal girls in the industry, truthfully.. and I do think there is a dark side to this, it's just not talked about openly.

I also think there is a certain type of client who seeks the youngest girl possible and doesn't care if she is mature enough to be in the industry or can even legally work as an escort. This type of client in my opinion is predatorial. They come to Montreal for this purpose, or they are enabled by pimps and employers. Even this fear that a lot of Montreal clients seem to have about getting arrested by the police is kinda unfounded because the only stories I've heard of clients getting arrested, it was when an undercover cop told the client she was 16 or 17 during the booking process. At least this is what i've heard...

In my opinion, agency & MP owners started to understand that there is a significant client base for women between the ages of 25 and 50.

I also think like you said, because Montreal is a party city, young girls wanted access to drugs and alcohol, etc. And Montreal has lower income, which pushes people who are younger or more vulnerable into sex work. I started relatively late compared to some of my colleagues and friends, but I think starting in the industry when you're in a vulnerable position, being exploited or when you're very young can leave impact on you and groom you forever. It leads to feeling like your self worth revolves around money and how you are seen by men, or feeling like your future is depending on very unstable income, and eventually you have behavior that clients perceive as ''less transactional'', that you normally wouldnt otherwise.. like doing very wild things sexually that you don't even like, hanging out with clients off the clock, telling them very personal info, etc.

I've noticed a lot of SP are getting tired of unrealistic or unacceptable expectations and problematic behavior from clients, so they have raised their rates and changed the way they work. I know personally if I find a way to make it worthwhile, I'll be visiting Toronto and other cities a lot more often. 💗 I have amazing experiences on tour. Montreal is tough sometimes even if I do like a lot of the men I meet.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, I think your comparison shows that you don't understand what it's like to be a sex worker. Artists want to become famous, they reach out to agents for this. SP are not trying to get famous, they are trying to survive. I'm not going to get into this because it's ''negative'' and ''a turn off'' and I start getting called a ton of insults by review board users when I address reality.

I'm not saying that people who work for these establishments don't deserve to be paid. I'm just saying the escorts deserve more than 180 an hour for GFE, particularly at agencies where it's known that a large portion of clients, in Montreal at least, are aggressive, entitled, don't understand consent and are disrespectful generally. This is a generalization and not all of them are like this, but I used to charge agency rates and I have a lot of friends who worked for agencies, so I know what I'm talking about.

I think you and others should try a little bit to put yourself at our place. Would you like to work for an agency if you were an escort in Montreal?

My point isn't that the driver and booker don't deserve to be paid. It's that the escorts deserve better rates, it's fairly easy to understand. And they shouldn't feel pressured to offer extras they aren't comfortable offering to make more money. This is also why rates at agencies in Toronto and other cities are generally higher. And let's not forget those agencies that take advantage of migrant women and market towards white men who fetishize Asian women, and pressure them to offer BBFs and services like rimming... which honestly nobody wants to do.

I believe we’re largely aligned on the core issue but approaching it from different angles.

We agree that current agency rates are unsustainably low. At $180–$200 per hour for GFE, most SPs cannot maintain a healthy, long-term business without seeing a high volume of clients multiple days per week, month after month. This model leads to burnout and compromises service quality.

The current fixed-fee structure in Montreal further misaligns incentives. When the agency takes $70–$90 from a $270 base rate, the SPs are left with $180–$200. This pushes the agency to prioritize volume (more bookings) since their revenue per booking stays flat regardless of rate increases. SPs, by contrast, need to maximize earnings per client, reduce total volume, and minimize reliance on extras they may not be comfortable providing.

A single flat rate of $270 for all SPs is also neither fair nor revenue-maximizing. It treats all SPs as interchangeable, ignoring differences in demand, reputation, repeat clientele, experience, and the premium nature of the experience some offer. When everyone charges the same low rate, clients receive no pricing signal and have no incentive to treat premium providers as luxury offerings. This may be where the menu abbreviation hunting comes in as only that separates SPs. The agency is effectively providing high-end access at budget prices.

This structure resembles the traditional hair salon chair-rental model, where the venue takes a fixed fee and the stylist keeps the rest. While functional for high-volume operations, it gives the salon or agency little motivation to support rate increases. A better comparison is Airbnb, which uses a percentage-based fee. A luxury listing generates significantly more absolute revenue for the platform than a standard one — even at the same or lower commission rate.

The optimal solution is a tiered pricing model with a fixed floor and regressive percentage split:
  • Standard: $270 base
  • Mid-tier / higher-demand: $300
  • Premium: $350
  • High-demand / top-tier: $400+
The agency would keep a minimum of $70 (or ~26%) per booking, then apply a declining percentage on higher rates (e.g., 24%, 20%, 17%).

This model achieves several important goals:
  • It rewards quality, reputation, and demand.
  • It strongly incentivizes both contractors and the agency to support higher rates, since both parties earn more per booking as rates rise.
  • Contractors can see fewer clients while maintaining or increasing income.
  • The agency increases revenue per booking and attracts a higher-quality client base (similar to what we see in Toronto).
  • Riskier upsells become less necessary.
Toronto agencies appear to operate with tiered pricing, which could explain both higher average rates and better client quality. Japan’s hair salon industry uses a similar seniority-based tiering (apprentice → junior → stylist → top stylist → master), contributing to a healthier ecosystem.

This structure creates a true win-win: the agency earns more per booking in absolute dollars, contractors retain a larger share of higher rates, everyone benefits from premium positioning, and the overall business becomes more sustainable.
 
I believe we’re largely aligned on the core issue but approaching it from different angles.

We agree that current agency rates are unsustainably low. At $180–$200 per hour for GFE, most SPs cannot maintain a healthy, long-term business without seeing a high volume of clients multiple days per week, month after month. This model leads to burnout and compromises service quality.

The current fixed-fee structure in Montreal further misaligns incentives. When the agency takes $70–$90 from a $270 base rate, the SPs are left with $180–$200. This pushes the agency to prioritize volume (more bookings) since their revenue per booking stays flat regardless of rate increases. SPs, by contrast, need to maximize earnings per client, reduce total volume, and minimize reliance on extras they may not be comfortable providing.

A single flat rate of $270 for all SPs is also neither fair nor revenue-maximizing. It treats all SPs as interchangeable, ignoring differences in demand, reputation, repeat clientele, experience, and the premium nature of the experience some offer. When everyone charges the same low rate, clients receive no pricing signal and have no incentive to treat premium providers as luxury offerings. This may be where the menu abbreviation hunting comes in as only that separates SPs. The agency is effectively providing high-end access at budget prices.

This structure resembles the traditional hair salon chair-rental model, where the venue takes a fixed fee and the stylist keeps the rest. While functional for high-volume operations, it gives the salon or agency little motivation to support rate increases. A better comparison is Airbnb, which uses a percentage-based fee. A luxury listing generates significantly more absolute revenue for the platform than a standard one — even at the same or lower commission rate.

The optimal solution is a tiered pricing model with a fixed floor and regressive percentage split:
  • Standard: $270 base
  • Mid-tier / higher-demand: $300
  • Premium: $350
  • High-demand / top-tier: $400+
The agency would keep a minimum of $70 (or ~26%) per booking, then apply a declining percentage on higher rates (e.g., 24%, 20%, 17%).

This model achieves several important goals:
  • It rewards quality, reputation, and demand.
  • It strongly incentivizes both contractors and the agency to support higher rates, since both parties earn more per booking as rates rise.
  • Contractors can see fewer clients while maintaining or increasing income.
  • The agency increases revenue per booking and attracts a higher-quality client base (similar to what we see in Toronto).
  • Riskier upsells become less necessary.
Toronto agencies appear to operate with tiered pricing, which could explain both higher average rates and better client quality. Japan’s hair salon industry uses a similar seniority-based tiering (apprentice → junior → stylist → top stylist → master), contributing to a healthier ecosystem.

This structure creates a true win-win: the agency earns more per booking in absolute dollars, contractors retain a larger share of higher rates, everyone benefits from premium positioning, and the overall business becomes more sustainable.

Once again, I'll offer a different perspective. We agree that the rate is not fair and that the way agencies function isn't either, but the solution you're offering also isn't fair or healthy in my opinion, even if I'm fully aware that your intentions are good and you are just trying to find a logical solution to a problem that sometimes goes beyond logic...

This is just me being idealistic but I think escorts should be able to determine their rates themselves, personally.. we know what our service is worth, not an employer, not clients. This is a discussion I've had very often on boards but nobody can agree with what is a ''good service'' in this industry other than a few basic things like being pleasant, clean and warm. There are hobbyists, very active on boards and avid readers and writers of reviews, who are obsessed with porn and basically want to recreate what they saw in real life, and they think that's what an escort should be doing. I've never worked for an agency but I know that this is what is encouraged. A lot of girls have no other choice but to work for an agency, and personally I don't believe in ''levels of service''. I have clients who have booked me several times over the years for multiple hours and are not interested in this type of ''porn style service'', and would not enjoy it...

I think it's a good idea to compare hair stylists to escorts in a few ways, but you are forgetting that being intimate with men you don't know is a very particular situation. When you seek a hairstylist you want someone who is original and competent, meanwhile most clients who seek agency services and book indies ''out of curiosity'' are not looking for creativity, innovation and talent, it seems to me that they actually want the girls to be stupid, and it's a turn off to hear us talk. Some don't feel that way but they know others do, so they will make us sound stupid in reviews and completely erase many parts of what happened during the booking. Personally, I know I will get a lot of hate for this, but I consider that I am being paid for companionship, not ''purely sexual services''. That doesn't just apply to indies, it applies to agency girls as well, and girls who work at massage parlors, or at least it shouldn't. In this sense, I agree that the ''extras'' system is annoying because it reinforces this idea that we are being paid for specific services and not for an all encompassing experience which includes atmosphere, shared adventures sometimes, laughter, connection & conversations.

I don't think it's fair for a less popular provider to be paid less while working at the same establishment, and that in itself can pressure the worker into doing things she didn't want to do, and to see more clients. We don't need ''incentives to act right''.. Also the owners of these places, from what I often hear, at least in Montreal, do not care how safe the services their providers are or how comfortable they are. I've seen messages that people received from their bosses and heard multiple horror stories about several agencies. This isn't a problem that can be resolved by creating even more competition, mistrust and conflict among workers with this ''tier system''. As an indy I can attest to the fact that escort's rates don't have anything to do with their worth as human beings, how attractive they are, their personality or how ''good their service is''. It has to do with how good you are at business and what you're willing to do or not do, what you're willing to sacrifice, or not, etc.

If a girl is less popular it could be because she's different, maybe she's very young and naive, maybe her personality is unusual, maybe she doesn't conform to beauty standards, maybe she's gained weight, maybe she's older, who knows, but a lot of them are given the clients that nobody wants to see, which is in my opinion also an abusive practice because these clients should not be around to begin with. I don't see why because a girl doesn't correspond to certain standards, she deserves less compensation and more abuse honestly and in this context I think it could have the opposite effect that you're anticipating... the less popular girl is also more likely to end up offering risky services or things that are more extreme because she wants to get good reviews. We know that some providers are very popular because of some services they offer.. even myself included lol if I didn't offer cimsw I think I'd have half the bookings I get now.

---

I don't think people should see sex workers as part of a purely physical transaction unless they're willing to have very low expectations. I have a friend who used to work for a low rate, comparable to what current agency girls in Montreal keep, but it was in a different city adn in a different time, and GFE was not the norm.. She saw several clients in a row but she didn't feel awful or drained because these guys didn't stick their tongue down her throat, try to finger her until she is in pain or expect to cum in her mouth and to fuck her in the ass. They didn't dump all their complex and sometimes frustrating feelings about women and sex workers on them, they didn't question her endlessly or lecture her, etc.The guys would just show up, act grateful they can do this at all, and leave. The rate was satisfying enough in that context. There were no review boards, or at least not one that was used by most.

Reality is different now. Nowadays I personally get a lot of clients who require a lot of patience & emotional work, lots of ''education'' even if they don't change their behavior, who ask a lot of questions, who sometimes become overly attached, even obsessed etc.. OR who are looking for good conversations, and someone they can spend quality time with in public places. but I ALSO get the clients who want the agency style service with, let's be frank, acronyms that most girls do not like offering and that they don't even like with people they are dating in their civilian life. Sometimes I get both. I am treated very often like a PSE provider, when I'm actually only GFE, and I think they are used to paying those higher rates at agencies after they paid for the extras they wanted so they make that connection in their mind.

Lately it's made me personally want to retire partially from escorting in Montreal by next winter. :( If it's not sustainable for me, who charges rates that are considered high for Montreal and never sees more than 6 clients a week or very rarely I can only imagine what a girl who works several days at an agency feels like.. Sometimes, escorts have high rates because they want a low volume of clients and they want to prioritize a certain type of encounter, and they have the right to do this. But not everyone has that option or the energy to build a career elsewhere.

---

Sorry for the novel. I'd be willing to continue that conversation in private messages in order to avoid getting off topic and annoying people here.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
I enjoyed reading your posts Luna.

I disagree with much of what you said, but I am from an older generation that can read a good discussion, learn something, and not get upset if someone else has a different opinion.

One of the reasons Montreal has always been less expensive is the lower incomes there. And its one-time U.S. tourist following was largely guys who drove from east coast cities who have relatively little disposable income after paying the high-cost of living in those places. Sadly, at least to me, now that rates have gone up so much for escorts, I see more reports and discussions of Asian massage parlors with women who move from place to place, which does involve Trafficking. I am glad you have a sufficient number of customers, but there are a lot of guys who would argue that the independent escort system shuts them out.

I certainly don’t think I ever saw anyone under 18 in Montreal, when there was an abundance of “college girls” in the industry. French Canadian ladies are more friendly and talkative than most ladies, and if they weren’t in college, they sure were imaginative about the classes they were supposedly attending.

It was just a different world back then. Pre-Uber, the agencies had big vehicles that they drove the ladies around in. They seemed to be great friends with the other ladies and it was one big party. If escorting-type sex work is no longer of as much interest to the “college-age” ladies, or if they have flocked to Seeking, I certainly don’t want them to do it. But long ago, before pop psych entered the vocabulary, it was more like the famous song by The Who. It wasn’t a social crisis, it was just girls having fun at an affordable price.

 
  • Like
Reactions: RobI
I’ve been going to Montreal for 20 years and without question Toronto is better today. Montreal dined out on a reputation created years and years ago. I could see some of that perhaps 10 years ago in Montreal with the clubs, strip clubs and the outcall scene was fantastic. There are certainly more chains in the highsteet now. Also, like a lot of cities they have struggled post covid. Most of the people I speak with who say Montreal is amazing have only been there once on their 18th birthday years ago. Toronto in every area of a city is far more advanced from the hobby scene, clubs, restaurants and ethnic groups. I do still love old Montreal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RobI and Patron