The Israel Lobby

U.S and Israel will never break up.

AIPAC vs The Democrats


AIPAC Wants Democrats to Back Israel. Instead, They’re Turning on AIPAC.
Once the guardian of the bipartisan pro-Israel consensus, it is now a polarizing force in the party.



A photo illustration of a man in a suit (Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister) addressing Congress from a lectern. The lectern has large cracks across its front.

Credit...Photo illustration by Chantal Jahchan
Jonathan Mahler
By Jonathan Mahler
Jonathan Mahler writes frequently about politics and is a former editor at The Forward, a Jewish publication.
June 12, 2026

When Brad Lander opened his Democratic primary bid for New York’s 10th Congressional District late last year, he made a promise that would once have meant political suicide: He would not do “AIPAC’s bidding” in Washington.
Now the June 23 primary is almost here, and AIPAC has been a recurring theme throughout the campaign. A progressive Jew and self-described liberal Zionist, Lander challenged his opponent, the pro-Israel incumbent Dan Goldman, to take a “people’s pledge” to limit money from super PACs. He has sent a steady stream of text and email blasts comparing AIPAC with Wall Street and crypto — a new, unholy trinity of corrupting influences in democratic politics.
Goldman, meanwhile, has tried to assert his independence from AIPAC. He accepted its endorsement but has refused money from all political action committees. And he has said he urged AIPAC to break ranks with Israel and criticize its government when appropriate.
The 10th Congressional District, which stretches from downtown Manhattan into parts of brownstone Brooklyn, is one of the country’s most Jewish districts. It would be easy to dismiss AIPAC’s prominent role in the campaign as a parochial, only-in-New York phenomenon. But different versions of it have played out across the country during this primary cycle.



AIPAC — the American Israel Public Affairs Committee — exerts its influence by encouraging members to reject anti-Israel candidates and to support pro-Israel ones through fund-raising emails and its website, where a portal lets donors give the legal maximum to any political campaign. But the group also has a super PAC, the United Democracy Project. Donors can give as much as they want to super PACs, and those PACs can spend as much as they want promoting or attacking individual candidates. AIPAC’s has spent money freely in the Democratic primaries, with mixed results.
It wasn’t so long ago that AIPAC was bipartisan and untouchable, the guardian of America’s close relationship with a key moral and geopolitical ally. For decades after its founding in 1948, most Americans saw Israel as the best of post-World War II liberalism, a democratic Jewish state born out of the ashes of the Holocaust. And AIPAC was its proud American ambassador.
Now, this perception of Israel is unraveling, and AIPAC is under attack from both political sides. On the right, it is drawing fire from “America First” pundits like Tucker Carlson, who argue that Israel wields too much power in politics.
A line graph showing results of a Gallup poll between 2010 and 2026. Over time, Democrats surveyed were once much more sympathetic to Israelis than Palestinians in the Middle East situation, but after reaching an even split in 2022, responders’ sympathies are now much more with Palestinians than Israelis (65 percent to 17 percent).


Credit...Trend from Gallup World Affairs surveys; percentages who say both, say neither or do not have an opinion are not shown.
On the left, its position is even more precarious. In a party that is undergoing a tectonic generational shift, AIPAC has become a symbol of the old guard. “It’s about protecting the old, conservative Democratic establishment against the young, progressive upstarts,” says Matt Duss, executive vice president at the Center for International Policy and a former foreign policy adviser for Senator Bernie Sanders. “We are in an anti-system moment, and AIPAC is saying: We are here to defend the system against you crazy progressives.”



AIPAC argues that it’s not protecting “the system” against these anti-Israel progressives; it’s protecting the Democratic Party’s pro-Israel majority whose views, it believes, are in danger of being drowned out. “There is a fringe left of the Democratic Party that is trying to to use the primary system to exert an outsize and pernicious influence in politics,” says Patrick Dorton, the spokesman for the United Democracy Project.
Want to stay updated on what’s happening in Israel? Sign up for Your Places: Global Update, and we’ll send our latest coverage to your inbox.
But at a time when Democrats increasingly question unconditional military aid to Israel, here is an organization using the power of big donors and dark money (already liberal boogeymen) to defend it. Once an unassailable voice of quiet influence in American politics, AIPAC is now both a victim and a cause of the unraveling consensus on Israel.
Image
An assembly of men and women, mostly in dark suits, seated in rows facing a dais. The seats are in wood and brown leather; the carpet is blue. A man in a dark suit stands on the dais delivering a speech.

Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, addressing Congress in 2015 in an effort to derail President Barack Obama’s proposed nuclear deal with Iran.Credit...Win McNamee/Getty Images
Created several years after Israel’s founding, AIPAC leaned Democratic and liberal during its early decades, reflecting both Israel’s labor Zionist roots and the political preference of most American Jews.
It began moving to the right during the 1980s and early ’90s, with the rise of Ronald Reagan and Israel’s Likud party, naming its first Republican board president and executive director. But AIPAC retained its power on both sides of the political aisle. That power was built on a simple idea: that America and Israel shared the same values and strategic interests.



As the only liberal democracy in the Middle East — and a vital source of intelligence from the region — Israel was a critical ally during the Cold War and the global war on terror. Ensuring Israel’s security, Washington believed, was tantamount to ensuring America’s security. AIPAC had its occasional critics in politics, but they were typically well outside the mainstream.
But during Barack Obama’s presidency, the bipartisan consensus over Israel — and AIPAC — started to fracture. The precipitating event was Obama’s nuclear deal with Iran. The Israeli government opposed the agreement, arguing that it didn’t go far enough to restrict Iran’s nuclear program or to stop it from funding terrorist groups like Hamas and Hezbollah.
AIPAC spent $30 million trying, and failing, to defeat the deal. It quickly turned into a bitter partisan dispute, with the Republican House speaker, John Boehner, inviting Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel to inveigh against the deal before a joint session of Congress.
Netanyahu accepted the invitation over Obama’s objections. It was an unforgettable political moment: a foreign leader inside the House chamber, lobbying lawmakers to reject an agreement that the sitting president had negotiated, arguing that it would protect America’s national security. Netanyahu did not visit the White House on that trip — but he did make time to speak at AIPAC’s annual policy conference.
In the years that followed, many Democrats turned away from the hard-line positions of the Netanyahu government, like its persistent settlement construction in the West Bank and its perpetual (and erroneous) insistence that Iran was moments away from finishing a nuclear bomb.



In the face of this emerging divide, AIPAC continued to back Israel almost unconditionally. “AIPAC’s mission is to support the Israeli government no matter what, and there are hardly any members of Congress on the Democratic side who support this Israeli government,” says Matt Bennett, the executive vice president of Third Way, a centrist Democratic think tank.
With the emergence of “the Squad” in 2018, AIPAC’s defense of the Jewish state took on a new urgency. There had been isolated critics of Israel in Congress in the past, but here was a bloc of young, progressive legislators — some of whom supported boycotts and economic sanctions on Israel.
Concerned that it was losing control of the conversation, AIPAC answered a few years later. Its old methods of persuasion — lobbying lawmakers, showing them around Israel, funneling relatively small donations to individual campaigns — had become anachronistic in the age of big-money politics. It created its super PAC ahead of the 2022 midterms, now able to guide unlimited and anonymous donations to political campaigns. The United Democracy Project spent $26 million in that cycle, mainly targeting Democrats whom it considered insufficiently pro-Israel. At the same time, AIPAC endorsed more than 100 pro-Israel legislators who had voted to overturn the 2020 election results, sending the message that it would choose Israel’s perceived interests even over American democratic norms.
Two years later, the stakes were still higher. The Hamas-led terrorist attacks of Oct. 7, and Israel’s military response to them, had heightened the passions of Israel’s American supporters as well as its detractors. The United Democracy Project poured $23 million into unseating two members of the Squad in the 2024 primaries.
This year, the United Democracy Project’s war chest bulged with nearly $100 million to shape races around the country. “We are not going to let the Democratic Party go the way of the Labour Party in the U.K. on Israel,” Dorton says, referring to Britain’s governing party, which recently suspended some arms sales to Israel and recognized a Palestinian state.



By then, the AIPAC backlash was already underway.
Image
A man with gray-brown hair, wearing a dark blue quarter-zip sweatshirt and holding a glass of water, is speaking to an unseen audience in someone’s home.

Tom Malinowski making a campaign appearance in Randolph, N.J., in January.Credit...Brian Fraser for The New York Times

AIPAC remains a bipartisan organization. Many of the group’s largest donors are pro-Trump Republicans, but its ranks are also full of Democrats, a legacy of American Jewish voters’ historical preference for liberal leaders and policies. The problem is that a lot of Democrats are starting to rethink their views of Israel, especially after the deaths of tens of thousands of Palestinians during the Gaza war.
One example is Tom Malinowski, a former New Jersey representative who was seeking to return to the House. Malinowski is by no means in sync with the Squad; he declines to call Israel’s war in Gaza a “genocide” and believes that the United States should safeguard Israel’s security. But he also says that Netanyahu went much too far in retaliation for the terrorist attacks of Oct. 7, and he wants America to make case-by-case decisions about Israel’s requests for military aid. In February, the United Democracy Project spent more than $2.3 million to defeat him, arguing that some of his opponents were more supportive of the U.S.-Israel relationship. (As in other races, its ads did not mention Israel. In this case, they focused mostly on Malinowski’s support for ICE funding while he was in Congress.)
The effort backfired: Malinowski lost, but so did the candidates AIPAC preferred. Instead, Democrats nominated Analilia Mejia, a progressive candidate far to Malinowski’s left on Israel.
Daniel Biss, a Democratic congressional candidate in a Chicago-area district, was next. Biss saw AIPAC coming. The grandson of Holocaust survivors, he told AIPAC’s officials that he disliked the current Israeli government but was not anti-Israel; if he were elected to Congress, he said, his door would always be open to the group. But Biss wouldn’t back unrestricted military aid for Israel, which appears to have been a deal-breaker for AIPAC.



“We believe that adding new political conditions or restrictions on lifesaving security assistance to Israel, beyond the substantial conditions that already exist, is misguided, harms America’s interests and is not pro-Israel,” says Deryn Sousa, a spokeswoman for AIPAC. The United Democracy Project spent millions of dollars attacking Biss and supporting one of his opponents, Laura Fine, funneling much of the money through an innocuously named group called Elect Chicago Women.
Biss did some polling and discovered that three times as many Democratic voters in his district viewed AIPAC unfavorably as favorably, 51 percent to 17 percent. And so, having failed to persuade AIPAC to stay neutral, he highlighted its involvement in a TV spot. He credits the move with helping to deliver his primary victory in March.
This isn’t an easy line for candidates to walk. Israel and AIPAC are popular targets for conspiracy-mongers. A Democratic House candidate in Texas, Maureen Galindo, recently pledged to turn a former ICE detention facility into a prison for “American Zionists,” most of whom she says are probably pedophiles. (She denies she is antisemitic.) Criticizing AIPAC may now be good politics on the left, but it remains fraught, especially at a time of rising anti-Jewish sentiment around the world. “I feel queasy talking about it, given the antisemitic tropes at play here about Jews and money and power,” Lander says. “But I have to.”
As AIPAC sees it, the organization and its super PAC have been unfairly demonized by the left. They say that they are no different from any of the other single-issue interest groups — including anti-Israel ones — that make their voices heard in primaries. In New York, for instance, a new super PAC recently pledged to spend $2 million supporting candidates who are critical of Israel, including Lander.
But in a sense, mainstream Democrats like Biss and Malinowski pose a bigger threat to America’s pro-Israel consensus than overtly anti-Israel progressives. The Squad’s views on Israel are well to the left of most Democrats’. By contrast, Democrats who call themselves pro-Israel — while also criticizing the policies of the Netanyahu government — are harder for Israel’s defenders to dismiss. Netanyahu, after all, is not well-loved in Washington. Even President Trump called the prime minister “crazy” for his ingratitude on a call this month.



For years, AIPAC helped define what it meant to be pro-Israel in America. But in setting such an uncompromising standard for that support, it has inadvertently accelerated a debate about it, especially on the left. AIPAC argues that it is working to strengthen and expand the American-Israeli relationship. But to the group’s pro-Israel critics, like its Washington rival J Street, the hard-line stance is having the opposite effect, endangering this historic alliance. As J Street’s president, Jeremy Ben-Ami, puts it: “AIPAC is playing with fire and runs the risk of burning our whole house down.”
 
  • Love
Reactions: Frankfooter
 
Israel already going after Trump after he claimed Israel wouldn't exist without the US by saying the US wouldn't exist without Israel...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter

N.Y. Primaries: Dan Goldman Goes Down to Brad Lander

Brad was endorsed by Mamdani (and naturally) opposed by the Zionist Lobby. Both Lander & Goldman are Jews. Goldman, the incumbent, was one of the more celebrated luminaries who was a Lead in Trump's impeachment. He is young, good looking, rich (Levi Jeans), and was touted as a mensch. I was following this race with keen interest and am delighted that Lander won by a landslide 66%!!! There is hope yet.
 
Last edited:
Israel already going after Trump after he claimed Israel wouldn't exist without the US by saying the US wouldn't exist without Israel...

In fact it was Trump's own ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee who made that outlandish claim.
 
  • Like
Reactions: southpaw
In fact it was Trump's own ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee who made that outlandish claim.

You Can't Gloss Over Genocide, Even In New York


A Jewish Democrat’s Support of Israel May Cost Him His N.Y.C. House Seat
Representative Dan Goldman is being challenged over his stance on the war in Gaza as he faces Brad Lander in a contentious race in Brooklyn and Lower Manhattan.


A crowd of people, some carrying Israeli and American flags, march in a parade.

The Israel Day parade provided an example of the divide over Israel between the candidates in a closely watched House race: Representative Dan Goldman attended, while his opponent, Brad Lander, did not.Credit...Eduardo Munoz/Reuters
Liam Stack
By Liam Stack
June 17, 2026


On a recent sunny Sunday on Manhattan’s Upper East Side, Representative Dan Goldman was marching in the Israel Day parade alongside other elected Democrats and a delegation of Israeli officials.
At the same time, his primary challenger, Brad Lander, was canvassing voters in the East Village with volunteers from a group that has backed claims by human rights groups and a United Nations commission that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza.
That split-screen image underscored how the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has become an inescapable issue in the 10th District, one of the most progressive and most Jewish districts in America, at a time when New York’s Jewish community has become increasingly divided along political and generational lines.
Both candidates are Jewish and describe themselves as liberal Zionists. But Mr. Lander has marshaled shifting public attitudes to turn Mr. Goldman’s defense of Israel — which aligns with the longtime status quo in American politics — into a potent line of attack. And he seems to have found an audience: Mr. Lander appears to hold a significant lead, though polling on primary races in New York is scant.



Gili Getz, an Israeli American filmmaker in the East Village, said the race was “very personal” for many Jewish New Yorkers.
“It’s not just between Lander and Goldman — it’s between us and ourselves,” he said. “I think that voters will have to decide in this district what type of politics we prefer going forward in these very scary and horrifying times for Jews, Muslims, Palestinians and all New Yorkers.”
Two Different Visions
Mr. Lander, the former city comptroller and mayoral candidate, said he was inspired to enter the race largely because of Mr. Goldman’s support for Israel. Mr. Lander has argued that that viewpoint represents the ways in which the incumbent is out of touch with the district, which includes neighborhoods in Lower Manhattan and brownstone Brooklyn.
Polls show a majority of Americans now hold a critical view of Israel; that includes 80 percent of Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents, according to the Pew Research Center.
“There’s no doubt that the landscape has moved dramatically away from sympathy for Israel as Israel has acted in utterly unsympathetic ways,” Mr. Lander said.



Mr. Lander, 56, has spent decades immersed in the world of progressive Jewish politics, including issues related to the Middle East. On the day of the parade, he was canvassing with volunteers from Jews for Racial and Economic Justice, a left-leaning group that has backed Mayor Zohran Mamdani. While serving in the City Council — representing neighborhoods with large Jewish populations, including Park Slope and Borough Park — he worked with both conservative-leaning ultra-Orthodox groups and left-wing Jewish activists. As comptroller, he chose not to repurchase State of Israel bonds that had matured.
Image
Brad Lander speaks into a microphone at a rally in front of a sign that reads “Trump: Jews Say No More.”

Mr. Lander’s stance as a progressive Jewish candidate who objects to Israel’s conduct in Gaza has brought him both support and criticism.Credit...Scott Heins for The New York Times
Mr. Lander has said Israel committed genocide during its military campaign in Gaza after the Hamas-led terrorist attacks on Oct. 7, 2023, and has described its treatment of Palestinians as apartheid. He has urged the United States to halt aid to the country, pledged not to take money from pro-Israel lobbying groups and refused to participate in events like the Israel Day parade.
His stance has drawn both support and criticism. In the East Village, Mr. Lander was stopped on the street several times by well-wishers and admirers. But he also occasionally encountered posters opposing his campaign, including one with a message that used his own self-description as an insult — “Brad Lander is a proud Zionist!” — which made him both chuckle and sigh.
Want to stay updated on what’s happening in Israel and New York? Sign up for Your Places: Global Update, and we’ll send our latest coverage to your inbox.
“It’s a complicated world, and you try to move through it with your values intact,” he said. “I believe in the vision of a Jewish and democratic Israel, but what’s there now is not living up to Jewish or democratic values.”



His opponent, Mr. Goldman, a Levi Strauss heir, was elected to Congress in 2022 after working as a federal prosecutor and lead counsel on the 2019 impeachment inquiry into President Trump. He is estimated to be one of the wealthiest members of Congress and pledged in April to match every donation to his campaign, underscoring the seriousness of Mr. Lander’s challenge.
Image
Dan Goldman, wearing a dark suit, walks outside next to a woman at night.

Mr. Goldman has faced attacks over his friendliness toward the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, a hard-line pro-Israel lobbying group.Credit...Haiyun Jiang for The New York Times
Mr. Goldman, 50, said in an interview that he was raised to treasure Israel as a safe haven for the world’s Jews. He backs a two-state solution and says he does not support the government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and he has voted for no new U.S. military aid to Israel since 2024. But he has opposed banning such aid, saying it gives the United States leverage in the bilateral relationship.
Mr. Goldman also said he has seen no evidence that Israel has committed genocide. He objects to the use of the word “occupation” to describe its 59-year military presence in Palestinian territories, though he declined to say what term he would use.
And he has made a point of attending events like the Israel Day parade. This year, he was one of many New York Democrats forced to distance themselves from Israel’s far-right finance minister, Bezalel Smotritch, who represented the Israeli government at the event.



‘Not the Most Important Issue’
Mr. Goldman has sometimes struggled to contain his irritation when asked about Israel during the campaign. He has called the debate a distraction from the issues affecting voters, including affordability and Mr. Trump’s agenda, and has derided Mr. Lander as a cynical “career politician.”
“I am disappointed that my opponent is trying to use this issue as a campaign platform because, as he well knows, it’s very complicated,” Mr. Goldman said in the interview.
He accused Mr. Lander of deploying ideologically charged language when speaking about the war in Gaza, arguing that focusing on the “terminology” of the conflict undermined the ultimate goal of ending it, and that words like genocide “are losing their meaning because they’re being used as political footballs.”
He said the news media had become overly focused on “opinions that are not based on any historical knowledge or understanding of the region.”
During a televised debate in early June, the moderators and Mr. Lander repeatedly brought up Israel, and it dominated much of the evening.



“Israel is not the most important issue in this district,” Mr. Goldman said tersely on the debate stage. “What is most important, that I hear from the voters, is Donald Trump in the White House tearing our immigrant neighbors away, destroying our democracy, corrupting everything from the White House and taking away health care, food benefits.”
Image
Mr. Goldman speaks to a masked agent wearing a vest that says “FBI” while another masked agent stands in the background and a camera films.

Mr. Goldman has been critical of the Trump administration’s immigration policy.Credit...Yuki Iwamura/Associated Press
Despite his efforts to redirect the conversation, Mr. Goldman has also drawn fire from the left, including from Mr. Lander, over his friendliness toward the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, a hard-line pro-Israel lobbying group.
Mr. Goldman has accepted the endorsements of both AIPAC and J Street, a more liberal pro-Israel group, in the primary. His spokeswoman said he has not accepted donations from AIPAC during this electoral cycle, but that he does accept contributions from individuals who donate through the group’s website. He has accepted its donations in past campaigns and even met his wife, Corinne Levy Goldman, at an AIPAC event a decade before he held office.
Supporters of Mr. Goldman echo his concerns about the way the war in Gaza has shaped the race. Andres Spokoiny, the chief executive of a Jewish philanthropy network, accused Mr. Lander of “injecting Israel into the race at every opportunity.”



He pointed to a recent moment of tension in the district — the Park Slope Food Co-op’s vote to boycott Israeli goods, a move that both candidates said they opposed — as an example of a larger trend that has made some Jews feel unsafe.
“The context is a big part of the issue,” said Mr. Spokoiny, who lives in Park Slope. “This is a context in which mainstream Zionist Jews in Brooklyn feel unwelcome, uncomfortable and pushed away.”
‘Which Side Are You On?’
The prospect of a Lander victory has alarmed some pro-Israel Jewish leaders who reject the way Mr. Lander talks about Israel and say they are unsettled by his relationship with Mr. Mamdani, whom he cross-endorsed in last year’s Democratic mayoral primary and backed in the general election.
Mr. Goldman declined to endorse Mr. Mamdani in either the primary or in the general election, citing concerns about his response to antisemitism. He has also criticized other elected officials who have spoken about Israel in ways similar to the mayor, and voted to censure Representative Rashida Tlaib for her comments about Israel.



Mr. Mamdani won in much of the 10th District and endorsed Mr. Lander for the seat one month later, giving a lift to Mr. Lander’s candidacy.
Image
Mr. Lander leans toward Mayor Zohran Mamdani who holds a candle.

Mr. Lander and Mayor Zohran Mamdani have been allied since the Democratic mayoral primary last year.Credit...Dave Sanders for The New York Times
Mr. Lander’s critics have also expressed dismay at his association with two other progressive primary challengers whom Mr. Mamdani has endorsed: Darializa Avila Chevalier and Claire Valdez, who are both democratic socialists and strong critics of Israel. All three candidates appeared with the mayor in a recent ad promoting their campaigns.
Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch, the president of the New York Board of Rabbis and senior rabbi at the Stephen Wise Free Synagogue, a Reform temple on Manhattan’s Upper West Side, said it was “quite astonishing” that New York City’s congressional delegation could soon include Mr. Lander, Ms. Avila Chevalier and Ms. Valdez.
Rabbi Hirsch said he found Mr. Lander’s campaign to be “disturbing,” taking issue in particular with his use of the word “genocide” to describe Israel’s actions, which he said generates hatred toward Jews. He called that accusation “a modern-day blood libel” and an example of a new litmus test that pushes Democrats to embrace positions that alarm many pro-Israel Jews.
But supporters of Mr. Lander view his stance on Israel as a sign of his moral clarity.
Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum, the rabbi emeritus of Congregation Beit Simchat Torah in Chelsea, said that “arguing over specific words, I think, is not the point.” She said people should focus on the human suffering at a time of war and “the values that are violated by certain behaviors” of the Israeli government.



Rabbi Kleinbaum said she has known and liked both candidates for years but backs Mr. Lander because he is “a real mensch” who had taken “very serious and complicated positions” on difficult issues.
“He’s in a tough position,” she said. “The world wants things to be like a simplistic game between sports teams, and one side is going to win and one side is going to lose, and which side are you on?”
Liam Stack is a Times reporter who covers the culture and politics of the New York City
 
In fact it was Trump's own ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee who made that outlandish claim.
The US was founded in 1776. Israel was founded in 1948. The Israelis traveled back in time to found America.

 
You Can't Gloss Over Genocide, Even In New York


A Jewish Democrat’s Support of Israel May Cost Him His N.Y.C. House Seat
Representative Dan Goldman is being challenged over his stance on the war in Gaza as he faces Brad Lander in a contentious race in Brooklyn and Lower Manhattan.


A crowd of people, some carrying Israeli and American flags, march in a parade.

The Israel Day parade provided an example of the divide over Israel between the candidates in a closely watched House race: Representative Dan Goldman attended, while his opponent, Brad Lander, did not.Credit...Eduardo Munoz/Reuters
Liam Stack
By Liam Stack
June 17, 2026


On a recent sunny Sunday on Manhattan’s Upper East Side, Representative Dan Goldman was marching in the Israel Day parade alongside other elected Democrats and a delegation of Israeli officials.
At the same time, his primary challenger, Brad Lander, was canvassing voters in the East Village with volunteers from a group that has backed claims by human rights groups and a United Nations commission that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza.
That split-screen image underscored how the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has become an inescapable issue in the 10th District, one of the most progressive and most Jewish districts in America, at a time when New York’s Jewish community has become increasingly divided along political and generational lines.
Both candidates are Jewish and describe themselves as liberal Zionists. But Mr. Lander has marshaled shifting public attitudes to turn Mr. Goldman’s defense of Israel — which aligns with the longtime status quo in American politics — into a potent line of attack. And he seems to have found an audience: Mr. Lander appears to hold a significant lead, though polling on primary races in New York is scant.



Gili Getz, an Israeli American filmmaker in the East Village, said the race was “very personal” for many Jewish New Yorkers.
“It’s not just between Lander and Goldman — it’s between us and ourselves,” he said. “I think that voters will have to decide in this district what type of politics we prefer going forward in these very scary and horrifying times for Jews, Muslims, Palestinians and all New Yorkers.”
Two Different Visions
Mr. Lander, the former city comptroller and mayoral candidate, said he was inspired to enter the race largely because of Mr. Goldman’s support for Israel. Mr. Lander has argued that that viewpoint represents the ways in which the incumbent is out of touch with the district, which includes neighborhoods in Lower Manhattan and brownstone Brooklyn.
Polls show a majority of Americans now hold a critical view of Israel; that includes 80 percent of Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents, according to the Pew Research Center.
“There’s no doubt that the landscape has moved dramatically away from sympathy for Israel as Israel has acted in utterly unsympathetic ways,” Mr. Lander said.



Mr. Lander, 56, has spent decades immersed in the world of progressive Jewish politics, including issues related to the Middle East. On the day of the parade, he was canvassing with volunteers from Jews for Racial and Economic Justice, a left-leaning group that has backed Mayor Zohran Mamdani. While serving in the City Council — representing neighborhoods with large Jewish populations, including Park Slope and Borough Park — he worked with both conservative-leaning ultra-Orthodox groups and left-wing Jewish activists. As comptroller, he chose not to repurchase State of Israel bonds that had matured.
Image
Brad Lander speaks into a microphone at a rally in front of a sign that reads “Trump: Jews Say No More.”

Mr. Lander’s stance as a progressive Jewish candidate who objects to Israel’s conduct in Gaza has brought him both support and criticism.Credit...Scott Heins for The New York Times
Mr. Lander has said Israel committed genocide during its military campaign in Gaza after the Hamas-led terrorist attacks on Oct. 7, 2023, and has described its treatment of Palestinians as apartheid. He has urged the United States to halt aid to the country, pledged not to take money from pro-Israel lobbying groups and refused to participate in events like the Israel Day parade.
His stance has drawn both support and criticism. In the East Village, Mr. Lander was stopped on the street several times by well-wishers and admirers. But he also occasionally encountered posters opposing his campaign, including one with a message that used his own self-description as an insult — “Brad Lander is a proud Zionist!” — which made him both chuckle and sigh.
Want to stay updated on what’s happening in Israel and New York? Sign up for Your Places: Global Update, and we’ll send our latest coverage to your inbox.
“It’s a complicated world, and you try to move through it with your values intact,” he said. “I believe in the vision of a Jewish and democratic Israel, but what’s there now is not living up to Jewish or democratic values.”



His opponent, Mr. Goldman, a Levi Strauss heir, was elected to Congress in 2022 after working as a federal prosecutor and lead counsel on the 2019 impeachment inquiry into President Trump. He is estimated to be one of the wealthiest members of Congress and pledged in April to match every donation to his campaign, underscoring the seriousness of Mr. Lander’s challenge.
Image
Dan Goldman, wearing a dark suit, walks outside next to a woman at night.

Mr. Goldman has faced attacks over his friendliness toward the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, a hard-line pro-Israel lobbying group.Credit...Haiyun Jiang for The New York Times
Mr. Goldman, 50, said in an interview that he was raised to treasure Israel as a safe haven for the world’s Jews. He backs a two-state solution and says he does not support the government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and he has voted for no new U.S. military aid to Israel since 2024. But he has opposed banning such aid, saying it gives the United States leverage in the bilateral relationship.
Mr. Goldman also said he has seen no evidence that Israel has committed genocide. He objects to the use of the word “occupation” to describe its 59-year military presence in Palestinian territories, though he declined to say what term he would use.
And he has made a point of attending events like the Israel Day parade. This year, he was one of many New York Democrats forced to distance themselves from Israel’s far-right finance minister, Bezalel Smotritch, who represented the Israeli government at the event.



‘Not the Most Important Issue’
Mr. Goldman has sometimes struggled to contain his irritation when asked about Israel during the campaign. He has called the debate a distraction from the issues affecting voters, including affordability and Mr. Trump’s agenda, and has derided Mr. Lander as a cynical “career politician.”
“I am disappointed that my opponent is trying to use this issue as a campaign platform because, as he well knows, it’s very complicated,” Mr. Goldman said in the interview.
He accused Mr. Lander of deploying ideologically charged language when speaking about the war in Gaza, arguing that focusing on the “terminology” of the conflict undermined the ultimate goal of ending it, and that words like genocide “are losing their meaning because they’re being used as political footballs.”
He said the news media had become overly focused on “opinions that are not based on any historical knowledge or understanding of the region.”
During a televised debate in early June, the moderators and Mr. Lander repeatedly brought up Israel, and it dominated much of the evening.



“Israel is not the most important issue in this district,” Mr. Goldman said tersely on the debate stage. “What is most important, that I hear from the voters, is Donald Trump in the White House tearing our immigrant neighbors away, destroying our democracy, corrupting everything from the White House and taking away health care, food benefits.”
Image
Mr. Goldman speaks to a masked agent wearing a vest that says “FBI” while another masked agent stands in the background and a camera films.

Mr. Goldman has been critical of the Trump administration’s immigration policy.Credit...Yuki Iwamura/Associated Press
Despite his efforts to redirect the conversation, Mr. Goldman has also drawn fire from the left, including from Mr. Lander, over his friendliness toward the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, a hard-line pro-Israel lobbying group.
Mr. Goldman has accepted the endorsements of both AIPAC and J Street, a more liberal pro-Israel group, in the primary. His spokeswoman said he has not accepted donations from AIPAC during this electoral cycle, but that he does accept contributions from individuals who donate through the group’s website. He has accepted its donations in past campaigns and even met his wife, Corinne Levy Goldman, at an AIPAC event a decade before he held office.
Supporters of Mr. Goldman echo his concerns about the way the war in Gaza has shaped the race. Andres Spokoiny, the chief executive of a Jewish philanthropy network, accused Mr. Lander of “injecting Israel into the race at every opportunity.”



He pointed to a recent moment of tension in the district — the Park Slope Food Co-op’s vote to boycott Israeli goods, a move that both candidates said they opposed — as an example of a larger trend that has made some Jews feel unsafe.
“The context is a big part of the issue,” said Mr. Spokoiny, who lives in Park Slope. “This is a context in which mainstream Zionist Jews in Brooklyn feel unwelcome, uncomfortable and pushed away.”
‘Which Side Are You On?’
The prospect of a Lander victory has alarmed some pro-Israel Jewish leaders who reject the way Mr. Lander talks about Israel and say they are unsettled by his relationship with Mr. Mamdani, whom he cross-endorsed in last year’s Democratic mayoral primary and backed in the general election.
Mr. Goldman declined to endorse Mr. Mamdani in either the primary or in the general election, citing concerns about his response to antisemitism. He has also criticized other elected officials who have spoken about Israel in ways similar to the mayor, and voted to censure Representative Rashida Tlaib for her comments about Israel.



Mr. Mamdani won in much of the 10th District and endorsed Mr. Lander for the seat one month later, giving a lift to Mr. Lander’s candidacy.
Image
Mr. Lander leans toward Mayor Zohran Mamdani who holds a candle.

Mr. Lander and Mayor Zohran Mamdani have been allied since the Democratic mayoral primary last year.Credit...Dave Sanders for The New York Times
Mr. Lander’s critics have also expressed dismay at his association with two other progressive primary challengers whom Mr. Mamdani has endorsed: Darializa Avila Chevalier and Claire Valdez, who are both democratic socialists and strong critics of Israel. All three candidates appeared with the mayor in a recent ad promoting their campaigns.
Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch, the president of the New York Board of Rabbis and senior rabbi at the Stephen Wise Free Synagogue, a Reform temple on Manhattan’s Upper West Side, said it was “quite astonishing” that New York City’s congressional delegation could soon include Mr. Lander, Ms. Avila Chevalier and Ms. Valdez.
Rabbi Hirsch said he found Mr. Lander’s campaign to be “disturbing,” taking issue in particular with his use of the word “genocide” to describe Israel’s actions, which he said generates hatred toward Jews. He called that accusation “a modern-day blood libel” and an example of a new litmus test that pushes Democrats to embrace positions that alarm many pro-Israel Jews.
But supporters of Mr. Lander view his stance on Israel as a sign of his moral clarity.
Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum, the rabbi emeritus of Congregation Beit Simchat Torah in Chelsea, said that “arguing over specific words, I think, is not the point.” She said people should focus on the human suffering at a time of war and “the values that are violated by certain behaviors” of the Israeli government.



Rabbi Kleinbaum said she has known and liked both candidates for years but backs Mr. Lander because he is “a real mensch” who had taken “very serious and complicated positions” on difficult issues.
“He’s in a tough position,” she said. “The world wants things to be like a simplistic game between sports teams, and one side is going to win and one side is going to lose, and which side are you on?”
Liam Stack is a Times reporter who covers the culture and politics of the New York City

Good, its time the dems learned that supporting Israeli genocide will make you lose.
 
  • Like
Reactions: niniveh