No, what’s cowardly is pretending every civilian casualty in a war automatically proves “genocide” while completely ignoring how urban warfare actually works when one side embeds military infrastructure inside civilian areas.
You operate by your personal view of how war works.
I operate by international law and human rights.
The definition of genocide is very clear as are the laws, this isn't some kind of 'vibes' thing.
ICC, ICJ, Amnesty, UN, MSF, Unicef, HRW, B'tselem and on and on, are very clear about the law and human rights.
You keep deliberately flattening the distinction between “civilian deaths occurred” and “civilians were the intended target.” Those are not the same thing under international law, no matter how many times you repeat “terrorism” in all caps.
If you destroy 94% of the hospitals in a walled in, open air prison, like Gaza then its clearly intent to target civilians. There are thousands and thousands of videos of Israelis targeting civilians, there are multiple massive databases of evidence that in a just world would keep the ICC and ICJ busy for decades.
Again, you need to read the reports and the charges at the ICC and ICJ.
Your sole defence is arguing that because Hamas is walled in with 2 million civilians its therefore targeting Hamas to try to kill them all to get a few thousand militants. Somehow you think this also goes to intentionally starving the population, 1 million of whom are children. This is a documented part of the genocide, as is the destruction of health care and the targeting of all residential buildings. But you want to argue that all you have to say is 'Hamas' and then its ok to drop a 2,000 lb, american funded, bomb on families living in tents.
If Israel or the US intentionally bombed hospitals, schools, or universities knowing there were no military targets present, then yes, condemn it. Absolutely. That’s not difficult. But you don’t get to skip the part where Hamas has repeatedly operated from civilian infrastructure, stored weapons near protected sites, and fought from densely populated areas because it’s inconvenient to your narrative.
You added a qualifier so you wouldn't have to condemn terrorism. The 'Hamas operated from' qualifier that means every single person and building is a target and therefore its not terrorism. Would you also argue that there are therefore no civilians in Israel, since all are conscripted to join the IDF? If that's true then no act of Hamas can ever be called terrorism because they have all been military. Your logic is the worst pretzel defence of terrorism.
And no, pointing to destruction alone is not automatic proof of genocide. By your logic, every heavily bombed urban battlefield in modern history instantly becomes genocide regardless of context, military objectives, evacuation warnings, hostage situations, or enemy tactics.
Now you argue there can never be proof of genocide because no matter how many you kill and how much you destroy you have to show intent. You should read the reports and charges, there are endless statements of intent from Israeli leaders from the PM down to the army. You argue that even though Israel has dropped 14 Hiroshimas worth of explosives on a walled in compound with 1 million children there is no intent to kill. Ridiculous.
You also keep dodging the uncomfortable contradiction in your own argument. If “intent” is proven purely by civilian infrastructure being destroyed, then Hamas firing rockets from civilian zones is also demonstrating intent to maximize civilian suffering on both sides. But suddenly nuance exists again when it’s your preferred faction.
Your magic word of 'intent' means Hamas can fire their homemade rockets they can't aim and declare they aimed at soldiers and therefore its never terrorism. By your metric all Hamas has to do is say they though someone was a militant settler or IDF and its not terrorism, just war. You will never apply the same standards to both sides.
What I’m saying is actually consistent. Civilian deaths are tragic and should be investigated. Deliberately targeting civilians is wrong regardless of who does it. Using civilians as shields is also wrong. Starving civilians is wrong. Terror attacks on civilians are wrong.
Bullshit, you are intentionally justifying genocide, the most evil form of terrorism or targeting of civilians known to humans.
Your position boils down to “everything Israel does is terrorism, everything Hamas does is resistance.” That’s not balance. That’s radical Frankie ideology.
Your position boils down to Palestinians are always wrong, they don't have the right to defend themselves and whatever they do is terrorism while anytime Israel kills people its noble and just. That the Nabka and occupation are all the fault of Palestinians.
You should probably come to grips with the fact that cheering for one side no matter what they do is exactly how people end up rationalizing atrocities instead of encouraging peace.
I cheer for no occupations in Ukraine or Palestine, for no wars and stupid shite.
I cheer for humans over racist fuckwads that want to steal their land and resources.
There’s an election coming up in Israel in October, and maybe if Netanyahu finally gets shown the door, the next government will take a less confrontational approach than your boy Bibi has. Even several of his domestic political rivals have criticized both his handling of the war and his constant escalation tactics, so it’s not exactly some fringe position at this point.
Netanyahu is not the problem, polls say the majority of Israeli Jews support ethnic cleansing and genocide. Israel needs to be dismantled like nazi Germany was dismantled.
That said, peace also requires the other side to stop pretending that Hamas launching rockets, taking hostages, and embedding itself in civilian infrastructure is “resistance” while every Israeli response is automatically labeled genocide. If you actually want peace, moral standards have to apply to everyone, not just the side you dislike.
People tried that, zionists declared BDS to be antisemitic. They went to the UN where america used the veto. They went to the ICC where america sanctioned the judges and tried to get them fired. The world has protested to end the genocide. How many flotillas have gone?
If Palestinians use their right to force against an illegal occupation you call it terrorism.
THAT'S IT, you're boring me now because you are worse than a dog chasing its tail. I'm done! This is a thread about Iran, not Palestine. Stick to the topic of the thread, thank you.
Too late, trump declared he attacked Iran for Israel.
This Iran war is also the fault of Israel.
The massive recession coming will be because of Israel.
The clampdown on human rights to stop the protests will be because of Israel.
That's boring.
How long can leaders push this on people?