War with Iran

Yes, there were sunset clauses, but do you think if it were allowed to go unhindered that maybe Iran would agree to re-upping it? I mean, maybe that could have been an opportunity to make diplomatic in-roads with Iran. Build trust. I'm not saying they would become a US ally, but normalizing relations could help prevent future wars. What the vast majority of people who aren't right-wing cultists see is Trump tearing up an agreement because Obama signed it. That's it. That's the only reason. It wasn't because he was thinking ahead. We KNOW he doesn't really do that. And, because he did that, we find ourselves in this situation. Let me put it this way: say both Iran and the world followed the letter of the agreement to a "T," with nobody doing anything shady. It benefited both parties. Iran loses sanctions and is able to rejoin the global financial system. Once they get that....why would they want to stop it and face the economic hardship of sanctions again? I'm not saying Iran isn't dangerous, but the agreement called for a tight inspection program to ensure Iran wasn't fucking around. Was JCPOA perfect? No. But what it did was give time to work on better agreements or improve relations. Would there be enough time to do that? Who knows. And it probably wouldn't have worked with Trump in power.

But now, he's agreed to a Iran's ceasefire deal and trying to spin it as a great victory. Except that it offers significantly less than what the JCPOA did.



First, I do not agree with your point that the media is hostile to Trump. Reporting on the very things he says is not hostility, its accuracy. And, the reality is that some of the largest media groups are Trump supporting to an extent. Fox, which is the most watched news channel, is certainly NOT hostile to Trump. If anything, they're an arm of MAGA spinning his insanities to make them seem palpable. Then we have CBS taking a turn to more MAGA-eque coverage. And, if anything, the rest of the mainstream media is handling Trump with kid gloves. They put in weak headlines about his rants and ravings to such an extent that they've basically spun shit for him. The difference in coverage between Biden and Trump is day for night. Biden became "Sleepy Joe" after nodding off once. Trump nods off on a regular basis. There are no Op-Eds calling for him to step down because of that. We don't see the same headlines criticizing Trump like we did Biden. In fact, Biden faced a double standard. He had to be perfect, and Trump just needs to not loudly shit himself in public,

This whole premise that the media in hostile or unfair to Trump is bogus. Few US media outlets give him the scrutiny that he deserves. They whitewash his most egregious remarks for the most part, and if they do cover his insanity, they are said to have TDS. I would love to know what you consider hostile or unfair coverage of Trump, because from what I can see, as someone who has worked in the news industry for over a decade, they are giving him so many passes it is crazy.


Here's the thing: Iran was attacked. They did not start this. They did not preemptively hit any US targets. They were the victims here (and I hate to call Iran a victim). They've had billions of dollars of infrastructure and military equipment destroyed by the US and Israel. Apparently because Israel lied about how easy it would be to spark a revolution in Iran. But the idiot president believed that....partly because his advisors didn't have the balls to tell him it could or would become a fiasco.

The reality here is that Iran knows how to push the envelop without stepping over the line. Yes, they fund terror groups, which to that I say fuck them. But....the US has done the same thing, many times over. Think of how many death squads in South America or Asia were funded or supported by the US.

Finally, I am not pro-Iran or anti-US. I am someone who sees stupidity, injustice and innocent people dying, and I want it to stop. As Benjamin Franklin put it "There never was a good war or a bad peace." Now, we know this isn't always true....but this was a poorly thought out attack where the goals and strategy were faulty and foolish to begin with. In fact, things are worse now because of it. A toll on the Strait didn't exist until Trump fucked everything up...



I think you seem to miss the point about US aggression directed to Iran for over 70 years. The US overthrew a democratically elected leader and imposed the Shah. A Shah who built up a secret police force that disappeared thousands of Iranians during the 60s and 70s. A Shah who basically followed US policies and refused to nationalize the country's oil wealth so that Chevron or Imperial Oil could profit. That is what caused the Islamic revolution. Then, US ally Iraq launches a war against Iran, one where they used chemical weapons and a lot of US military hardware. Or the time a USN ship blew an Iranian passenger jet out of the air, something for which the US has never apologized for (and even gave the captain of that vessel a medal). So....maybe that could be why they are aggressive against the US.

The point here is that neither side is virtuous. Both sides have done bad things to each other. Iran cannot attack the US homeland like the Americans can to Iran. They don't have military bases or aircraft carriers that could bomb Baltimore or Miami. The US does...and launched strikes a year ago. And then a month ago.

And, as for North Korea, you do realize they attack and kidnap people from South Korea. They try to infiltrate Japanese companies. They sell arms to militias and US enemies all over the world. Did they attack Israel? No....but that doesn't mean they are not a threat. And, let's not forget that they are working on ICMBs that could reach the US. Why hasn't Trump done anything about that???
SK, your problem is you can't resist propagandizing even when you make a good point.
First, you know the British were contractually engaged in the Iran oil industry in 1953. The British asked the U.S. to help protect British oil investments. It was also a period where the West feared Soviet encroachment and expansion.

So if you think something that happened 73 years later justifies almost everything Iran has done since, that's your prerogative.

The biggest piece of propagandizing is calling the Iraqis our allies in the 1980s. Strangely, I remember the Iraqis flying Soviet planes and using a lot of Soviet military hardware.

As far as accidentally shooting down an Iranian airliner, the USN vessel was in a war zone trying to keep the Strait of Hormuz open. (See a trend.) The U.S. paid compensation to the victims families. Shooting down civilian aircraft is a terrible tragedy that can occur in hostile areas. Iran more recently shot down a civilian airliner leaving Tehran in 2020.

As far as reporting, I just want to know what is going on. I don't want media spin on a war. There are a few thoughtful commentators but most of them don't know what is happening sitting in NYC or Washington.

Here's the thing: Iran was attacked. They did not start this. They did not preemptively hit any US targets.

Again I don't know why you feel compelled to say this. Are you thinking a little (or a lot of) fudging of details makes the point.
It's simply not true. Iran has routinely attacked U.S. installations in the region and has been openly hostile to the U.S.


Nobody should want to sound like our resident radical Islamists. Posting propaganda serves no purpose towards trying to establish peace.
 
Last edited:
Sure, they can continue to keep getting their asses kicked if that's what they want
Strangely, Iran seemed to think that their proxies could fire at Israel but Israel could not fire back.
 
Strangely, Iran seemed to think that their proxies could fire at Israel but Israel could not fire back.

Even Stranger the USA is used to not being fired upon. I guess the loss of several bases, and having to back off 2 carrier groups adjusted that thinking.

Oh, and several aircraft......
 
Americans don't actually pay that much less than Canadians do because their taxes go to Israel or expensive foreign wars, while ours goes to healthcare.
But it's not free, we pay a lot of taxes and they pitched it our entire lives as "free healthcare".
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SaulGoodman777
Another 1.3 million barrels per day lost out of Saudi Arabia as a pipeline and other infrastructure hit.

The pipeline is the east/west strait bypass.

And the attacks are continuing on other gulf states.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crocket
Another 1.3 million barrels per day lost out of Saudi Arabia as a pipeline and other infrastructure hit.

The pipeline is the east/west strait bypass.

And the attacks are continuing on other gulf states.
So the ceasefire is over now?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Even Stranger the USA is used to not being fired upon. I guess the loss of several bases, and having to back off 2 carrier groups adjusted that thinking.

Oh, and several aircraft......
May I ask you what your response has to do with my post?
I don't think I'm the only one who dislikes non sequiturs especially when they step on their posts.
As repeatedly told Franky, if you have something to say just say it. Let your thought stand on its own. Don't bring me into it.

Even Stranger the USA is used to not being fired upon. I guess the loss of several bases, and having to back off 2 carrier groups adjusted that thinking.

Oh, and several aircraft......
 
Even Stranger the USA is used to not being fired upon. I guess the loss of several bases, and having to back off 2 carrier groups adjusted that thinking.

Oh, and several aircraft......
May I ask you what your response has to do with my post.
I don't think I'm the only one who dislikes nonsequiturs especially when they step on their posts.
As I use to repeatedly tell Franky, if you have something to say just say it. Let your thought stand on its own. Don't bring me into it.

Strangely, Iran seemed to think that their proxies could fire at Israel but Israel could not fire back.
 
Even Stranger the USA is used to not being fired upon.
They have for long been beating up on countries with no armies or defenseless civilians.
They've also used these as marketing to rip off the tax payer by charging exorbitant amounts for owning and operating said weapon systems.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crocket
It is free because the amount of money you would spend on doctors fees, tests, private insurance premiums and co-pays, far exceed the portion of your taxes that go towards funding public healthcare.

And for those that pay into the system and rarely use it, if at all? Still free?
 
  • Like
Reactions: SaulGoodman777
Everyone does at some point and when they don't their kids or parents or grand parents who don't pay into the system do.
And probably not enough to justify the amount the put in compared to how much they use it.
 
May I ask you what your response has to do with my post?
I don't think I'm the only one who dislikes non sequiturs especially when they step on their posts.
As repeatedly told Franky, if you have something to say just say it. Let your thought stand on its own. Don't bring me into it.

I thinks pretty clear. Whining about the use of proxies and nations defending themselves meanwhile the USA used Iraq for 8 years, used the Kurds repeatedly, set up several bases in various other bordering ME nations that were used, and then finally the very concept of what, 11 carrier groups whose sole purpose is to project power and attack nations......

Well, pretty damn stupid and disingenuous in m humble opinion.

Again. The United States of America are NOT THE GOOD GUYS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crocket and Klatuu