When Treliving was hired Shanahan put in zero effort. It almost appeared he was the only one interviewed for the job and that was it. My personal opinion Shanahan wanted a yes man. To keep his vision. It's possible Dubas was ready to do a shift and trade Marner when he was fired but that's speculation.
Pelley will do his due diligence. He's hired a search firm. More than likely it'll be a President and not just a GM or a combined dual role. He mentioned the importance of analytics. Dubas was but Treliving obviously was not. Dubas built a very successful regular season team. They need to apply proper analytics to playoffs. Dubas has done a good job in the retool of the Penguins. They are basically on par with Boston right now. Managing assets for the now and the future.
Truth be told I was very critical of the Leafs decision to move forward with Kyle Dubas over Mark Hunter. But Dubas definitely grew on me and I came to respect his hockey knowledge and I agreed with the majority of his moves as Leafs GM. His fault was not looking at player intangibles - motivation, competitive drive etc.
Here are the major moves Kyle Dubas has done since taking over the President and GM role with Pittsburgh Penguins in the summer of 2023
1. Aug 2023 he traded for Erik Karlsson and gave up a 2024 1st round pick, MIkael Granlund and Jan Rutta. So far has looked like a solid move.
2. Jun 2024 he traded for Kevin Hayes and got a 2nd round pick from the Blues for taking on Hayes $7M annual salary for two years. In 89 games played with Pittsburgh since the deal he has 29 points and is a minus 19 rating.. With that pick, Pittsburgh selected Harrison Brunicke from the Kamloops Blazers. He was on the 2026 World Junior Canadian team. Solid prospect.
3. Signed Sidney Crosby to a 2 year deal in September 2024.
4. Selected Ben Kindel C with their 1st round pick in the 2025 Entry Draft. Kindel made the team out of camp and has posted a solid rookie season with 17G, 17A and a minus 6 rating in 72 games. Not bad for an 18 year old.
5. June 2025 Traded D Conor Timmins to Buffalo for D Connor Clifton and a 2nd round pick. Positive trade for Pittsburgh, Timmins has been terrible in Buffalo.
6. July 2025 signed F Anthony Mantha to a 1 year $2.5M contract. Mantha has been very good with 58 points so far in 2025-2026. Signed D Parker Wotherspoon to a 2 year $2 million contract. He's been very good as well for Pittsburgh, a top 4 d man. Also signed Justin Brazeau and Noel Acciari.
7. August 2025. Traded G Alex Nedeljkovic for a 3rd round pick and acquired G Arturs Silovs for a 4th round pick. I think Nedeljkovic is a better goalie so jury is out on this one.
8. Hired Dan Muse as head coach in summer of 2025. Its worked out well so far.
The challenges ahead: managing an aging nucleus. Crosby (38), Malkin (39), Letang (38), Karlsson (35) and Rust (34). Let's see what wizardry Dubas has up his sleeve.