PM Carney considers Canada a 'leader in climate change’

@Frankfooter the more you argue real data, over what "climate scientists" put out, the more you show how ignorant you really are. Add in the left/woke playbook of hurling insults and slamming anyone with a valid point.

It's all here in one of my original posts here, post #13;


Frankfooter said:
That sentence would fail you in high school science.
"Since your high school science diploma is so much better than everyone else's, then I have three questions for you;

1. What are Canada's carbon emissions, as a percentage of the worlds?


2. According the the Paris climate accord of a 30% reduction in carbon emissions, for all signatory countries, by date X.

What would the drop be for the year, for Canada, as world percentage?


3. Here's a breakdown of the Laurentide Ice Sheet; "Laurentide Ice Sheet, principal glacial cover of North America during the Pleistocene Epoch (about 2,600,000 to 11,700 years ago). At its maximum extent it spread as far south as latitude 37° N and covered an area of more than 13,000,000 square km (5,000,000 square miles). In some areas its thickness reached 2,400–3,000 metres (8,000–10,000 feet) or more. The Laurentide Ice Sheet probably originated on the Labrador-Ungava plateau and on the mountains of the Arctic islands of Canada, and it centered over Hudson Bay. As it spread, the glacial ice mass appears to have combined with other ice caps that had formed on local highlands in eastern Canada and in the northeastern United States."


What happened to the Laurentide Ice Sheet?


Simple enough that even someone that passed high school science could answer easily.

But, I'm not silly enough to argue with someone who's been socially programmed.

Canada is not even responsible for 2% of the world's carbon emissions. Some peg it between 1.5% - 1.6% and I've even seen it listed as high as a whopping 1.8%

So, a 30% reduction sounds sexy and like we're really making a difference, so I'll use the higher figure of 1.8%. That will equate to a drop of 0.0054% of the 1.8%, bringing Canada's world carbon emissions to (drum roll please) 1.7945%!!! That's a target set to be reduced, not hourly, but recorded over a year. And, China blows that reduction away, and then some, in an hour. So who's making money here off of the carbon taxes and credit shuffling?

As for the Laurentide Ice Sheet, I won't leave you in suspense. It melted...

Yes, you read that right and it was up to 4 kilometers thick in some areas, but I believe the the average was 2-3 kilometers thick. The timeline shows us that human kind had zero effect on this massive glaciers melting. That's the Hmmmm moment, where someone with even the slightest bit of science in them says; Yes, I see what you're saying. Taxing something natural will have no effect on the outcome.

Fun facts about the Laurentide Ice Sheet; The earth that it covered is still rebounding from the immense weight of it. We had mountains that were higher than Everest. It had an huge impact on climate and weather and disrupted the weather and climate worldwide, for quite some time."

The numbers don't lie and they are real world numbers. Then take those and ponder the Laurentide Ice Sheet and why it disappeared, without fictitious human caused climate change. The answer about climate change is plain and simple, those like Carney look to exploit fear and tax Canadians and Canadian industry into the ground. Canada is not the problem, if you want to tackle this issue, the problem is in Asia and developing countries. Carney is a charlatan and if you had a curious and open mind, you would be questioning what he's doing, because it looks like it falls into his "new world order" where Canada is only positioned to trade with China and mainstream media pumps the Trump derangement syndrome for all it's worth. Climate change is a scam and a WEF spawned agenda.
 
@Frankfooter the more you argue real data, over what "climate scientists" put out, the more you show how ignorant you really are. Add in the left/woke playbook of hurling insults and slamming anyone with a valid point.

It's all here in one of my original posts here, post #13;

You asked three questions that were supposed to make me look bad. I'm not playing, the answers are obvious and its just you trying to attack me personally instead of discussing the issue.

I argue with the 'real data' put out by 'climate scientists', the people who do study the climate full time.
People like Peter D Carter, who just posted about what happens at 2ºC warming, which will happen in a decade or so and re-posted about the rise in precipitation caused by a warming atmosphere being able to hold more moisture.

Those are the issues we should be concerned with right now, not the history of the Laurentide Ice Sheet.
Same with discussions about the chaos of the jet stream and the increase in polar vortexes.
Same with the decline and possible stopping of the AMOC.


 
Satellite data shows warming in the troposphere as expected, we've been over this.
Now we are on track for the worst case scenario, RCP 8.5.
We've hit 1.5ºC warming and will hit 2.0ºC in the next decade.

why do you claim we are on track for the worst case scenario, RCP 8.5., when the RCP 8.5. is virtually impossible ?

AI Overview
RCP 8.5 is increasingly considered
unrealistic as a "business-as-usual" scenario, though it remains technically plausible as an extreme, worst-case scenario. Once commonly used in media and research to represent a future with no climate policy, RCP 8.5 is now understood to be an extreme outlier that requires highly unlikely assumptions, such as a fivefold increase in coal use by the end of the century.


AI Overview
Yes, RCP 8.5 (Representative Concentration Pathway 8.5) has been widely identified by various researchers, policy analysts, and critics as being misused as a propaganda tool
. While originally designed as a high-emissions "worst-case" scenario for research purposes, it has frequently been inaccurately portrayed in media and policy reports as the "business-as-usual" or most likely outcome.

you have been informed multiple times that RCP 8.5 is a virtually impossible scenario
yet you continue to state it is done deal and defiantly going to happen

why do you ignore facts and state disproven propaganda?


That's idiotic.
i agree that stating
Now we are on track for the worst case scenario, RCP 8.5.
is not only idiotic, it is intentional deceit

0.155 degrees per decade is most defiantly within the realm of natural variability as we are still emerging from an ice age

the industrial revolution did not turn off natural variability in our extremely complex, chaotic and dynamic climate system
you obviously are having a difficult time understanding these facts



No, RCP 8.5 was the 'worst case scenario' if we did nothing. CO2 levels continue to increase as if we have done nothing.


So a trillion dollars invested in green energy and devastating inflation caused by failed climate policies have accomplishing nothing according to you
no point in in pushing this climate crisis / net zero insanity any further, jt is very destructive and harmful to billions of people


the world was shut down and the population locked down for a year and the result is ""as if we have done nothing. "according to you

the world is not going to shut down like that again, no matter what you want


RCP 8.5 has been deemed virtually impossible, yet it is a certainty,, according to you

you are factually wrong....... again

i need to remind you that increasing co2 has a logarithmic , not a linear relationship to concentration
each incremental addition has a diminishing effect

1770652081153.png

you have been shown these facts multiple times, yet you seem to having a lot of difficulty understanding them and instead pretend these facts do not exist



You've been wrong every year for decades but the models have been very accurate.

No
the models are expensive pieces of useless, misleading junk which have been the basis for propaganda and scare stories
the models use seriously flawed physics
the models do not agree with each other
the models can not reproduce the past & thus can not possibly properly predict the future

the model predictions are 0.28 degrees / decade, well above the satellite data trend of 0.155 C degrees / decade
This a pure and simple FACT
1770652290317.png
1770652351349.png
And yet you still think you're right.
yes i paid attention when graph reading was taught
the facts do not lie

you are factually wrong....... again

That's also idiotic.
pretending facts you have been shown multiple times don't exist is much much worse than the obvious characterization of idiotic
 
Last edited:
why do you claim we are on track for the worst case scenario, RCP 8.5., when the RCP 8.5. is virtually impossible ?

Who said it was impossible, you? The IPCC said it was the worst case scenario, not that it was impossible.

Here, you loves an AI summary:
AI Overview


RCP 8.5 is a high-emission "worst-case" climate scenario characterized by increasing greenhouse gas emissions, leading to a radiative forcing of 8.5 W/m² and a projected temperature increase of 5-6°C by 2100. It represents a "business as usual" future with minimal climate policy, often criticized for relying on unrealistic assumptions like a 6.5x increase in coal use.



you have been informed multiple times that RCP 8.5 is a virtually impossible scenario
yet you state it is done deal and definatly going to happen

The great larue has spoken!
All must heed his warnings!!!

Give it a rest and read the fucking IPCC reports.


why do you ignore facts and state disproven propaganda?

Give it a rest and read the fucking IPCC reports.




RCP-8.5-Neil-Craik-University-of-Waterloo.jpg
 
Who said it was impossible, you? The IPCC said it was the worst case scenario, not that it was impossible.

what part of "RCP 8.5 is now understood to be an extreme outlier that requires highly unlikely assumptions," is confusing you?

virtually impossible defines an extreme outlier that requires highly unlikely assumptions, quite nicely
i prefer intentionally misleading and extremely irresponsible propaganda tool as a better definition of RCP 8.5

AI Overview
RCP 8.5 is increasingly considered
unrealistic as a "business-as-usual" scenario, though it remains technically plausible as an extreme, worst-case scenario. Once commonly used in media and research to represent a future with no climate policy, RCP 8.5 is now understood to be an extreme outlier that requires highly unlikely assumptions, such as a fivefold increase in coal use by the end of the century.

AI Overview
Yes, RCP 8.5 (Representative Concentration Pathway 8.5) has been widely identified by various researchers, policy analysts, and critics as being misused as a propaganda tool
. While originally designed as a high-emissions "worst-case" scenario for research purposes, it has frequently been inaccurately portrayed in media and policy reports as the "business-as-usual" or most likely outcome.

and some how you are confusing the observed satellite trend of 0.155 C degrees / decade with the 0.3 C to 0.4 C degrees / decade assumption used for the intentionally misleading and extremely irresponsible propaganda tool RCP 8.5..

let me summarize for you:
0.155 C degrees / decade is not 0.3 C to 0.4 C degrees / decade
no need to thank me, however you really should be able to recognize that doubling or tripling a value means it is a different value all together.

The great larue has spoken!
All must heed his warnings!!!
The facts do not lie

climate alarmists on the other hand , well ....... Michael Mann, Phil Jones , what was it they said?? Oh yes "We need to hide the decline"


Here, you loves an AI summary:
AI Overview
RCP 8.5 is a high-emission "worst-case" climate scenario characterized by increasing greenhouse gas emissions, leading to a radiative forcing of 8.5 W/m² and a projected temperature increase of 5-6°C by 2100. It represents a "business as usual" future with minimal climate policy, often criticized for relying on unrealistic assumptions like a 6.5x increase in coal use.

Thank you for pointing out RCP 8.5 relies on unrealistic assumptions
again, you may consider reading what you intend to post before posting it

Give it a rest and read the fucking IPCC reports.
do you mean the IPCC reports that state

What the IPCC Actually Says About Extreme Weather
The IPCC has concluded that a signal of climate change has not yet emerged beyond natural variability for the following phenomena:

  • River floods
  • Heavy precipitation and pluvial floods
  • Landslides
  • Drought (all types)
  • Severe wind storms
  • Tropical cyclones
  • Sand and dust storms
  • Heavy snowfall and ice storms
  • Hail
  • Snow avalanche
  • Coastal flooding
  • Marine heat waves
Furthermore, the emergence of a climate change signal is not expected under the extreme RCP8.5 scenario by 2100 for any of these phenomena, except heavy precipitation and pluvial floods and that with only medium confidence.

oops there it is again: the extreme RCP8.5 scenario
you should consider learning what facts are
 
Last edited:
what part of "RCP 8.5 is now understood to be an extreme outlier that requires highly unlikely assumptions," is confusing you?

virtually impossible defines an extreme outlier that requires highly unlikely assumptions, quite nicely
i prefer intentionally misleading and extremely irresponsible propaganda tool as a better definition of RCP 8.5





and some how you are confusing the observed satellite trend of 0.155 C degrees / decade with the 0.3 C to 0.4 C degrees / decade assumption used for the intentionally misleading and extremely irresponsible propaganda tool RCP 8.5..

let me summarize for you:
0.155 C degrees / decade is not 0.3 C to 0.4 C degrees / decade
no need to thank me, however you really should be able to recognize that doubling or tripling a value means it is a different value all together.


The facts do not lie

climate alarmists on the other hand , well ....... Michael Mann, Phil Jones , what was it they said?? Oh yes "We need to hide the decline"





Thank you for pointing out RCP 8.5 relies on unrealistic assumptions
again, you may consider reading what you intend to post before posting it


do you mean the IPCC reports that state



oops there it is again: the extreme RCP8.5 scenario
you should consider learning what facts are

Excellent post on why nobody should every use AI for reference.
You posted and got three different answers to the same question and I got a fourth.
But understanding why AI fails would likely be harder than explaining how the greenhouse effect works to you.

The past three years we've averaged 1.5ºC warming, which puts us at the same projection as RCP 8.5.
Why?
Because governments haven't done enough.

Check the temperatures against the projections, we are currently on track for RCP 8.5 or possibly warmer.
Under RCP 8.5, the worst case scenario, we shouldn't have hit 1.5ºC for another 5 or so years.
And we are likely to hit 2ºC 5-10 years earlier than RCP 8.5.
If anything, the IPCC was conservative in their warnings.

HAmiWu2acAMasMt
 
]Excellent post on why nobody should every use AI for reference.
You posted and got three different answers to the same question and I got a fourth.
But understanding why AI fails would likely be harder than explaining how the greenhouse effect works to you.
I

no,
all AL response indicate RCP 8.5 is an extreme scenario and virtually impossible

The past three years we've averaged 1.5ºC warming, which puts us at the same projection as RCP 8.5.
Why?
Because governments haven't done enough.

no again

why can you not understand 0.155 C degrees/ decade is not 0.3 or 0.5 C degrees/ decade ??

once again doubling or tripling a value means it not the same value

AI Overview


Based on RCP8.5 (Representative Concentration Pathway 8.5), which is a high-emissions, "worst-case" climate scenario, temperatures are projected to increase by approximately
0.42°C to 0.54°C per decade in maximum temperature during the 21st century, with mean temperature increases roughly around 0.3°C to 0.5°C per decade.


Check the temperatures against the projections, we are currently on track for RCP 8.5 or possibly warmer.
no and no again
why can you not understand 0.155 C degrees/ decade is not 0.3 or 0.4 C degrees/ decade ??

once again doubling or tripling a value means it not the same value

Under RCP 8.5, the worst case scenario, we shouldn't have hit 1.5ºC for another 5 or so years.
And we are likely to hit 2ºC 5-10 years earlier than RCP 8.5.
If anything, the IPCC was conservative in their warnings.

That is total and completely illogical nonsense

you are ignoring the facts of the matter (Why you do this a mystery as it has been explained to you so many times I lost count)
RCP8.5 is not going to happen

AI Overview
RCP 8.5 is increasingly considered
unrealistic as a "business-as-usual" scenario, though it remains technically plausible as an extreme, worst-case scenario. Once commonly used in media and research to represent a future with no climate policy, RCP 8.5 is now understood to be an extreme outlier that requires highly unlikely assumptions, such as a fivefold increase in coal use by the end of the century.

please explain why you feel you can consistently just ignore facts that do support your alarmist narrative ?
 
no,
all AL response indicate RCP 8.5 is an extreme scenario and virtually impossible

It doesn't matter what AI slop you found.
CO2 levels are rising at higher than 'business as usual' and multiple feedback effects are raising temps faster.
The result is that the planet is moving faster than RCP 8.5.

GO9LXrgakAAdr_J


no again

why can you not understand 0.155 C degrees/ decade is not 0.3 or 0.5 C degrees/ decade ??

once again doubling or tripling a value means it not the same value

What are you rambling on about?


no and no again
why can you not understand 0.155 C degrees/ decade is not 0.3 or 0.4 C degrees/ decade ??

once again doubling or tripling a value means it not the same value

Surface temp projections were for 0.2ºC per decade, we are now seeing closer to 0.3ºC, or RCP 8.5.
I have no idea where those numbers come from, certainly not the IPCC.



you are ignoring the facts of the matter (Why you do this a mystery as it has been explained to you so many times I lost count)
RCP8.5 is not going to happen

Buddy, its already happening and I showed you the proof.
The experimental or experiential proof that its happening to the planet and has been for years.

CO2 levels had to decline through global actions, RCP 8.5 was 'business as usual'.
This is worse than business as usual.

HAh4MUIacAUA5Gw
 
AI Overview


RCP 8.5 is considered unrealistic because
it is an extreme, "worst-case" scenario requiring a fivefold increase in coal usage by 2100—surpassing total estimated coal reserves—which contradicts current energy trends, technological advancements, and existing climate policies. It was designed as an upper-bound scenario, not a likely "business-as-usual" forecast.
Why RCP 8.5 is Considered Unrealistic:
  • Unprecedented Coal Reliance: The scenario assumes a drastic, massive increase in global coal consumption that is largely deemed impossible due to the shift toward renewable energy.
  • Contradicts Modern Trends: Global coal use likely peaked in 2013 and has been declining, whereas RCP 8.5 requires a continuous, steep rise.
  • Outdated Assumptions: The scenario was created based on high-emission assumptions from the late 2000s and does not account for the rapid advancements in clean energy technology and the proliferation of climate policies globally.
  • Implausible Economic Growth: It predicts extreme economic growth in developing nations (leading to them being richer than current wealthy nations) while simultaneously assuming they will rely on the most carbon-intensive energy source, creating a contradiction in the model's logic.
  • "Worst-Case" Misused: Often labeled erroneously as "business-as-usual" in media and some scientific literature, RCP 8.5 represents a 90th percentile, extreme outcome rather than a plausible or likely future.
While RCP 8.5 is considered a highly improbable, "dystopian" future, some argue that it is still useful for assessing extreme, long-term, high-risk,, and catastrophic scenarios.

RCP 8.5 has been used for wide spread intentionally deception and propaganda purposes
This is way beyond irresponsible
 
Last edited:
AI Overview


RCP 8.5 is considered unrealistic because
it is an extreme, "worst-case" scenario requiring a fivefold increase in coal usage by 2100—surpassing total estimated coal reserves—which contradicts current energy trends, technological advancements, and existing climate policies. It was designed as an upper-bound scenario, not a likely "business-as-usual" forecast.
Why RCP 8.5 is Considered Unrealistic:
  • Unprecedented Coal Reliance: The scenario assumes a drastic, massive increase in global coal consumption that is largely deemed impossible due to the shift toward renewable energy.
  • Contradicts Modern Trends: Global coal use likely peaked in 2013 and has been declining, whereas RCP 8.5 requires a continuous, steep rise.
  • Outdated Assumptions: The scenario was created based on high-emission assumptions from the late 2000s and does not account for the rapid advancements in clean energy technology and the proliferation of climate policies globally.
  • Implausible Economic Growth: It predicts extreme economic growth in developing nations (leading to them being richer than current wealthy nations) while simultaneously assuming they will rely on the most carbon-intensive energy source, creating a contradiction in the model's logic.
  • "Worst-Case" Misused: Often labeled erroneously as "business-as-usual" in media and some scientific literature, RCP 8.5 represents a 90th percentile, extreme outcome rather than a plausible or likely future.
While RCP 8.5 is considered a highly improbable, "dystopian" future, some argue that it is still useful for assessing extreme, long-term, high-risk,, and catastrophic scenarios.

RCP 8.5 has been used for wide spread intentionally deceive and propaganda purposes
This is way beyond irresponsible

Remember your other favourite chart arguing that its impossible to achieve net zero?
That is what is required to maintain the planet at 1.5ºC.
You keep arguing for more than 'business as usual', you argue against EV's and against renewables.
Those policies are what is causing CO2 levels to increase instead of decrease.

Projections say we will hit 2.0ºC in 7-10 years.
Here's a chart with IPCC projections based on CO2 rates.
If we hit 2º in a decade, do you think that is higher or lower than RCP 8.5?

Global-surface-temperature-changes-relative-to-1850-1900-IPCC.jpg
 
]Remember your other favourite chart arguing that its impossible to achieve net zero?
That is what is required to maintain the planet at 1.5ºC.

no you are wrong...... again

you still have not figured out that CO2 is not the control knob for our chaotic, non linear dynamic climate system

you argue against EV's and against renewables.

of course, they are not
  1. economically viable
  2. not in demand
  3. they are not going to displace any meaning fraction of fossil fuels .
EVs and renewables are useless taxpayer money pits

Those policies are what is causing CO2 levels to increase instead of decrease.

no again you pretend that natural variability suddenly stopped during the industrial revolution

so in 2020, the entire world shut down
By late April 2020, more than 4.2 billion people (over half the world's population) were under some form of lockdown.
despite massive world economic activity, travel and human co2 generation being severely curtailed the co2 levels just keep on climbing at the same rate

so no amount of EVs, suspension of freedoms renewables ,or sequestration is going to stop that accent

the world population will not be locked down like that again

1770695788844.png





Projections say we will hit 2.0ºC in 7-10 years.
Here's a chart with IPCC projections based on CO2 rates.
If we hit 2º in a decade, do you think that is higher or lower than RCP 8.5?

wrong again
CO2 is not the control knob for our chaotic, non linear dynamic climate system
  • those projections are from the flawed climate models
  • the models run way too hot, the underlying physics programed into the models is flawed
  • Christy is measuring exactly where the Green House Gas theory says warming should occur
  • RCP 8.5 is virtually impossible ,
  • the facts do not lie

1770696429987.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
you still have not figured out that CO2 is not the control knob for our chaotic, non linear dynamic climate system

Not even the wackiest of the oil$gas funded propagandists say that the greenhouse effect isn't real.
That makes you really quite special.
The Greenhouse Effect is high school level science and has been verified for over 100 years.
You are a kook.





You post a chart that shows CO2 still climbing exponentially while declaring its impossible that we are in the 'worst case scenario'.
Very special indeed.




CO2 is not the control knob for our chaotic, non linear dynamic climate system

View attachment 548883

NASA has a page on the Greenhouse Effect for kids.
Maybe you should start there and see if you can follow the science.
Most kids can do it, so why can't you?

 
Not even the wackiest of the oil$gas funded propagandists say that he greenhouse effect isn't real.
That makes you really quite special.
The Greenhouse Effect is high school level science and has been verified for over 100 years.
You are a kook.

At no point have i ever stated that the greenhouse effect isn't real.
you still have not figured out that CO2 is not the control knob for our chaotic, non linear dynamic climate system




You post a chart that shows CO2 still climbing exponentially while declaring its impossible that we are in the 'worst case scenario'.
Very special indeed.
you still have not figured out that CO2 is not the control knob for our chaotic, non linear dynamic climate system
1770733476236.png
exponential ?? , perhaps to a small extent, however no question there is an upward trend

Are you questioning the Mauna LOA co2 graph ?
please elaborate your concerns

Again . despite massive world economic activity, travel and human co2 generation being severely curtailed in 2020, the co2 levels just keep on climbing at the same rate
so no amount of EVs, suspension of freedoms, renewables ,or sequestration is going to stop that accent

the good news is CO2 is not the control knob for our chaotic, non linear dynamic climate system

NASA has a page on the Greenhouse Effect for kids.
Maybe you should start there and see if you can follow the science.
Most kids can do it, so why can't you?

perhaps you could try a more advanced source to further your inadequate scientific understanding beyond the propaganda intended to mislead children

here you go, just to remind you the climate models are flawed
1770734271996.jpeg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
Except dirk and you have no facts, you have nothing.
Even larue has a 10 year old chart he thinks is the bible, but you two have nothing.


I gave you facts, Frank. You just don't like solid figures that can't be argued.

Climate change and all monies collected to stop it are a scam and you can continue to be scammed, of both money and your mind, because you buy into this nonsense.
 
I gave you facts, Frank. You just don't like solid figures that can't be argued.

Climate change and all monies collected to stop it are a scam and you can continue to be scammed, of both money and your mind, because you buy into this nonsense.
What money? You think Franky works or spends any income.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: MaverickPunter
At no point have i ever stated that the greenhouse effect isn't real.
you still have not figured out that CO2 is not the control knob for our chaotic, non linear dynamic climate system.

You couldn't even understand the NASA video explanation for kids on the Greenhouse Effect, could you?




you still have not figured out that CO2 is not the control knob for our chaotic, non linear dynamic climate system

the good news is CO2 is not the control knob for our chaotic, non linear dynamic climate system

Repeating something idiotic over and over again won't make it true.
CO2 is a greenhouse gas and greenhouse gases drive the Greenhouse Effect which makes the planet warmer.

Drivers-of-observed-warming-over-1850-2020-IPCC.jpg


perhaps you could try a more advanced source to further your inadequate scientific understanding beyond the propaganda intended to mislead children

I post from NASA and the IPCC.
You post one 10 year old chart from someone under the pay of the oil$gas industry.

For some reason you think every single climatologist in every country in the world has been in a conspiracy through all kinds of governments over the last 50 years working on the same conspiracy. And only a handful of plucky old people under the pay of the oil$gas industry know the real truth.