Sea commerce warfare commences?

I highly doubt that. They may seize a few, but if it every gets to the choking of Russian oil exports the Russian can and will retaliate
Won't even have to sink the ship, just a small explosion to cause a hole on the side so that crude spews onto the coastline as the pirates bring the ship in. Just a few billion in ecological damage.

I don't think you have realized the breakdown occurring. And how will Russia retaliate with no navy?,,
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
And that's all that matters, isnt it? What the Zionists want.

Well remember Russia is interconnected there. Iran is selling them arms. So that supply would get compromised as well. Then there is the possible ecfe t on Nodth Korea. I doubt t they have pipelines so their oil comes in by Shadow tanker as well.

That fleet being gone deletes a lot of rogue nation commerce.

We could be seeing a lot of crazy things come out of this.
 
Rogue nations? Like Israel?

In the context of nations without access to oil. North Korea, Cuba, some others buying it on the cheap.
 
I don't think you have realized the breakdown occurring. And how will Russia retaliate with no navy?,,

Russia has a navy, not as powerful as the USA but they can certainly cause serious damage to the USN. If they take out a carrier group with a single nuclear warhead is the USA gonna start WWIII? I doubt it.
 
Russia has a navy, not as powerful as the USA but they can certainly cause serious damage to the USN. If they take out a carrier group with a single nuclear warhead is the USA gonna start WWIII? I doubt it.

Lol. There is no way Russia uses a nuke. Stop fantasizing. And their navy is decrepit. And btw it was a FRENCH ship. It opens the door to multiple navies doing this.

The USA can't come close to being everywhere. You think Russia can? These boats can be picked off at leisure in international waters and there is Jack shit Russia can do about it.
 
Lol. There is no way Russia uses a nuke. Stop fantasizing. And their navy is decrepit. And btw it was a FRENCH ship. It opens the door to multiple navies doing this.

The USA can't come close to being everywhere. You think Russia can? These boats can be picked off at leisure in international waters and there is Jack shit Russia can do about it.

there navy is not decrepit they have the second largest nuclear submarine fleet in the world with some pretty new boats and some that can launch hypersonic missiles. How many navies have submarines that can fire cruise missiles that can hit targets 2000km away? USA, Russia, Israel, China. Thats it. How many navies have subs that can hit a ship over 1000 km away USA, and Russia. THAT IS IT. They also have a few frigates that are equipped with the new Tsirkon hypersonic missile that can strike from 1500 km. In any case they have put Wagner commandos on some ships so when a helo tries to board the next one it may get shot at. Then they have to decide if they wanna attack a tanker and cause a massive oil spill.
 
there navy is not decrepit they have the second largest nuclear submarine fleet in the world with some pretty new boats and some that can launch hypersonic missiles. How many navies have submarines that can fire cruise missiles that can hit targets 2000km away? USA, Russia, Israel, China. Thats it. How many navies have subs that can hit a ship over 1000 km away USA, and Russia. THAT IS IT. They also have a few frigates that are equipped with the new Tsirkon hypersonic missile that can strike from 1500 km. In any case they have put Wagner commandos on some ships so when a helo tries to board the next one it may get shot at. Then they have to decide if they wanna attack a tanker and cause a massive oil spill.

God your funny.

These are rogue fake flagged ships remember? The only way to intervene is to claim them. And state publicly its Russian oil.

Which defeats the whole purpose of secret oil delivery.

Russia is not going to start a war over that. Be serious. These ships are all over the world. Russia can barely cover their shores at this point. Analysis is even the Royal navy could take them. Estimates are 295 ships. Many in disrepair and bad states of readiness. And they are split over large areas. The Black Sea fleet is fucked.

They are not going to do shit. They will sit back and have to watch, as will Iran, and any other nation shipping oil, if they start picking them off.
 
God your funny.

These are rogue fake flagged ships remember? The only way to intervene is to claim them. And state publicly its Russian oil.

Which defeats the whole purpose of secret oil delivery.

Russia is not going to start a war over that. Be serious. These ships are all over the world. Russia can barely cover their shores at this point. Analysis is even the Royal navy could take them. Estimates are 295 ships. Many in disrepair and bad states of readiness. And they are split over large areas. The Black Sea fleet is fucked.

They are not going to do shit. They will sit back and have to watch, as will Iran, and any other nation shipping oil, if they start picking them off.

So what if a french Helo flies over it and wagner troops (not Russian military but private contractors) shoots it down? International waters eh!! No law. They say all kinda shit about these ships but they seem in pretty good shape they say they are around 15 y old which means they have another 10Y useful life. But yes they are not primo but decent ships with lower residual value. The ship can also change hands with the oil and the value of the oil is very murky in that transaction. Its all part of the sanctions game of obfuscating the cargo, the buyer, what was sold its value etc. Any country can claim any ship if it has the guns, Its that simple. If a Russian destroyer says a ship is under its protection in international waters, it has the guns. Its up to the other side if they also wanna bring their guns and contest that.
 
Last edited:
So what if a french Helo flies over it and wagner troops (not Russian military but private contractors) shoots it down? International waters eh!! No law. They say all kinda shit about these ships but they seem in pretty good shape they say they are around 15 y old which means they have another 10Y useful life. But yes they are not primo but decent ships with lower residual value. The ship can also change hands with the oil and the value of the oil is very murky in that transaction. Its all part of the sanctions game of obfuscating the cargo, the buyer, what was sold its value etc. Any country can claim any ship if it has the guns, Its that simple. If a Russian destroyer says a ship is under its protection in international waters, it has the guns. Its up to the other side if they also wanna bring their guns and contest that.

And my point stands. At any time there are about 1000 ghost tankers out there. Even if Russia only accounts for 25% of them that's the total fleet of Russia.

See Russia needs those tankers. The west doesn't. Russia cant protect them. It's commerce warfare at its finest. The best part is the privateers can always claim its Iranian. Take them.

There are now offers to take the captured tankers for the breakers. So what happens when there are less of them?

Do the math. There is no scenario where Russia can win this game if the West decides to play it hard.
 
And my point stands. At any time there are about 1000 ghost tankers out there. Even if Russia only accounts for 25% of them that's the total fleet of Russia.

See Russia needs those tankers. The west doesn't. Russia cant protect them. It's commerce warfare at its finest. The best part is the privateers can always claim its Iranian. Take them.

There are now offers to take the captured tankers for the breakers. So what happens when there are less of them?

Do the math. There is no scenario where Russia can win this game if the West decides to play it hard.

you really think Russia has no means of hurting these people? What if they sink the ship in deep water on the way to the breakers? What if they just use Russian flags on the ship and switch to a false flag closer to destination? This is just starting. There will be counters actions. You also forget that the West has a TON of ships registers under Panama, Ganbon etc. What is to stop Russia from seizing these ships in retaliation for seizing RUssian ships? What if they start to convoy them?
 
you really think Russia has no means of hurting these people? What if they sink the ship in deep water on the way to the breakers? What if they just use Russian flags on the ship and switch to a false flag closer to destination? This is just starting. There will be counters actions. You also forget that the West has a TON of ships registers under Panama, Ganbon etc. What is to stop Russia from seizing these ships in retaliation for seizing RUssian ships? What if they start to convoy them?

They aren't Russian ships remember?

I don't think they have the ability to affect this. Use subs? They will know. Ships? They will know.

Russia doesn't have the ships to spare. Mostly they have Cirvettes which are inner water patrol boats. The days of them having foreign bases are over, no no supply chain for long range operations.


Dude, they are a third tier power now, and due to demographics and economics headed for third world status.
 
They aren't Russian ships remember?

I don't think they have the ability to affect this. Use subs? They will know. Ships? They will know.

Russia doesn't have the ships to spare. Mostly they have Cirvettes which are inner water patrol boats. The days of them having foreign bases are over, no no supply chain for long range operations.


Dude, they are a third tier power now, and due to demographics and economics headed for third world status.

Deep sink from a sub, they may know, but they can't prove it. Many US ships are flagged in Panama and elsewhere. Russia can easily target or capture those ships in retaliation for the US seizing their foreign flagged ships. If Russia was a third tier power then Ukraine would already have defeated them with NATO assistance. Name me a 3rd tier power that can destroy every city in the USA at a push of a button and hit any target in the EU in under 15 min with non-nuclear weapons.
 
They aren't Russian ships remember?

I don't think they have the ability to affect this. Use subs? They will know. Ships? They will know.

Russia doesn't have the ships to spare. Mostly they have Cirvettes which are inner water patrol boats. The days of them having foreign bases are over, no no supply chain for long range operations.


Dude, they are a third tier power now, and due to demographics and economics headed for third world status.
I dunno. The Russians might not be able to go toe to toe with NATO…but that doesn’t mean they can’t retaliate in other ways.

And as for Iran…apparently they are talking about shutting down the Strait of Hormuz.

I believe that getting these tankers out of circulation is indeed a good thing but I would not want to underestimate the consequences.
 
The biggest con would be for Russia to allow a few of these ships to be taken willingly to distract, while they smuggle more undetected. We'd never know. lol.
By the way I would take Zeihan with a grain of salt.
His analysis always presumes that nations won't and can't react to changing circumstances and only the US will come out of any situation victorious.
 
The biggest con would be for Russia to allow a few of these ships to be taken willingly to distract, while they smuggle more undetected. We'd never know. lol.
By the way I would take Zeihan with a grain of salt.
His analysis always presumes that nations won't and can't react to changing circumstances and only the US will come out of any situation victorious.

Always. I'm looking beyond his myopic American centric take. France taking this boat opens up the possibility of commerce warfare again. That was the point.
 
Deep sink from a sub, they may know, but they can't prove it. Many US ships are flagged in Panama and elsewhere. Russia can easily target or capture those ships in retaliation for the US seizing their foreign flagged ships. If Russia was a third tier power then Ukraine would already have defeated them with NATO assistance. Name me a 3rd tier power that can destroy every city in the USA at a push of a button and hit any target in the EU in under 15 min with non-nuclear weapons.

I question the validity of most of the nuke stockpiles, USA included. Decades old, maintenance questionable. Mostly on the rockets themselves.
 
I dunno. The Russians might not be able to go toe to toe with NATO…but that doesn’t mean they can’t retaliate in other ways.

And as for Iran…apparently they are talking about shutting down the Strait of Hormuz.

I believe that getting these tankers out of circulation is indeed a good thing but I would not want to underestimate the consequences.

It's a matter of worth. Is it worth it to go after commerce warfare. Mind there might not be a choice. But I do question the Russian Navy's ability to operate extended periods outside of its territory.