What Carney didn’t say at Davos

oil&gas

Well-known member
Apr 16, 2002
17,202
3,464
113
Ghawar
Chris Hatch
January 26th 2026

It was a good speech. Even a great speech. Poke around online, and you’ll find people reaching for descriptions like “Churchillian” about the PM’s address in Davos. “The most important speech in Canadian history up to this point,” declared Max Fawcett in these pages. But, for all its clarity about the behaviour of the world’s great powers, it dodged one notable issue that the great powers did not shy away from themselves.

That’s not meant to sound churlish about a head of government who thoughtfully invoked both Thucydides and Václav Havel. Prime Minister Mark Carney’s address felt like a bluebird day compared to the focus-grouped pablum and three-syllable sloganeering of modern political “communications.” And it was a radical contrast to the weaving, menacing ramble from President Trump later in the program.

But it was definitely notable that he avoided any mention of climate change, apart from a sotto voce reference to “COP” and a line towards the end that “Canadians remain committed to sustainability.” Both China and the US were much more direct, in wildly different ways.

The dodge probably wasn’t terribly notable to Canadians who have heard near-nothing on the topic since Carney took office. But the absence was more jarring to those around the world who remember Carney for his bombshell speech on the risks of climate change as governor of the Bank of England and for his tenure as the United Nations Secretary-General's Special Envoy on Climate Action and Finance.

“Mark Carney’s Davos speech is indeed honest and thoughtful,” wrote Åsa Persson, chair of Sweden’s Climate Policy Council (a country that has been navigating great power rivalries for a very long time). “But where is the perspective of a planet that we all share and depend upon, being degraded at speed and scale? Where is the perspective of climate change impacting countries and economies, with no regards to borders, coalitions or transactions?”

“We can hope that a new paradigm of ’values-based realism’ can encompass countries sharing values of environmental protection,” said Persson. “But I find the ‘realism’ part lacking when it comes to truly recognizing the climate and environmental realities we are facing.”

Those realities were the literal and the geopolitical backdrop to proceedings in Switzerland — a country whose icy peaks are rapidly disappearing (40 per cent of Swiss glacier volume gone since the turn of the century) and thundering into the valleys, burying a Swiss village less than a year ago.

And the great geopolitical storm at the World Economic Forum was the US threat to take over Greenland — a crisis precipitated by melting ice, opening up the potential for oil and mineral extraction and the emergence of Arctic sea lanes.

Supriya Dwivedi articulated how this threat impacts Canada in a chilling column this week about how Trump will use the Greenland argument to grab Canada's Northwest Passage.

The beleaguered secretary general of NATO made a similar point as he tried, desperately, to fend off Trump’s designs on Greenland: “When it comes to the protection of the Arctic, with a priority on Greenland, we have to spend more energy, more time, more focus on this because we know the sea lanes are opening up,” Mark Rutte said.

Carney’s climate hushing sidestepped these realities but it was actually in line with official procedure at the World Economic Forum this year. Organizers reportedly promised the US administration they would downplay climate change in order to woo the US president back to the alpine money fest. Global warming had been a hot topic for the Davos elite a few years ago. In fact, Trump’s last appearance was the famous stare-down/Twitter spat with Greta Thunberg, who had been given a choice seat for the president’s speech in 2020.

There was certainly no hushing the US president on any topic that popped into his head as he unloaded his id for an hour and half. You’ve probably heard a lot of what he said, especially the ominous admonition of Canada for not displaying appropriate gratitude and the mafia boss-like warning that “Canada lives because of the United States.” By Thursday, Trump had withdrawn the invitation for Canada to join the US Protection Racket “Board of Peace.”

And Trump was certainly not hushed about climate and clean energy, excoriating it as: “Perhaps the greatest hoax in history, the Green New scam.” He laid into wind energy in particular, returning to the topic several times, boasting that “we’re taking them (wind turbines) down,” calling them “losers,” and claiming, preposterously, that every time they turn, “you lose $1,000.”

There was a lot of the usual fossil fuel boosterism and other tirades against wind turbines, but one wild claim was that “China makes almost all the windmills, and yet I haven't been able to find any wind farms in China,” Trump said. “They sell them to the stupid people that buy them, but they don’t use them themselves.”

This is not merely wrong, but a complete inversion of reality. China has installed the most wind turbines in the world by a huge distance, and is currently building more than the rest of the world combined. In case you run into such claims yourself, here’s a visualization of data from the Statistical Review of World Energy, which was published for over 70 years by BP and by the independent Energy Institute since 2023.

Guo Jiakun, a spokesperson for the Chinese foreign ministry responded to Trump’s claims, saying that China's installation of wind power has ranked first in the world for 15 consecutive years, and claiming that its exports of wind and solar PV had reduced carbon emissions by about 4.1 billion tons for other countries.

Which brings us to the other great power that wasn’t dodging the issues of climate and energy in its speech at Davos. Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng “doubled down on the No. 2 economy’s green messaging,” reported Bloomberg News under the headline China breaks the Davos hush on climate.

“China has put in place the world’s largest renewable energy system and the most complete new-energy industrial chain,” He said. “We invite enterprises from all over the world to embrace the opportunities from the green and low-carbon transition, and work closely with China.”

In contrast to the US withdrawals from the Paris Agreement and the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, He said that China will work to “fully and effectively implement” the agreements. It was another example of how surreal the situation has become. The “land of the free” driving headlong into disaster while the land of the great firewall argues for climate multilateralism and clean energy development.

Canada sits at the intersection for so much of this: Arctic thaw, energy ruptures, trade realignment, great-power pressure. If “values-based realism” is going to mean anything, for very long, we can’t wish the reality of climate change offstage while great powers fight over minerals, resources and sea lanes. It is the stage. And we should be asking how much more unstable we will allow it to become. It does the public no favours when leaders who have grasped the threat, refuse to name it.

 
What Carney didn't say at Davos is that Canada is dead set on
extraction of its remaining oil resources to the last drop with
no regard to the urgency of carbon emission reduction.
 
The jet stream is now way more chaotic because of climate change.
The polar stream that gave us record snow and record ice storms in america are symptomatic of jet stream instability.

snow storms have occurred before and snow storms will occur again

you have not a clue
you just copy and paste what some other fool posted
including the fool who claims climate change is highly predictable


predictably wrong


1769581121544.jpeg
 
snow storms have occurred before and snow storms will occur again

you have not a clue
you just copy and paste what some other fool posted
including the fool who claims climate change is highly predictable


predictably wrong


View attachment 542083

Holy shit, larue.
You post that one bullshit chart over and over again despite it being an apples vs oranges, bait and switch, piece of bullshit?
Comparing troposphere temperatures to surface predictions is moronic, only a total idiot would think it proves anything.

You haven't had a new idea in decades, can't understand the science and can't tell oil$gas bullshit from real science.
You are the type who would still be saying 4/5 doctors say tobacco is good for you.

We have the jet stream going nuts here while Australia nears wet bulb temperatures.
But all you've got is that one, stupid, repeatedly debunked, old chart.

 
Holy shit, larue.
You post that one bullshit chart over and over again despite it being an apples vs oranges, bait and switch, piece of bullshit?

it is not a bait and switch, piece of bullshit, you scientific illiterate, false propaganda pushing, high school drop out
the AGW theory is based upon warming in the troposphere
why do you think millions of weather balloon tests have occurred there ?

Learn some god damn science before pretending to be an expert and trying to mislead others


Comparing troposphere temperatures to surface predictions is moronic, only a total idiot would think it proves anything.

WTF ???
the AGW theory is based upon warming in the troposphere
WTF did you think the atmosphere is going to char broil the surface without the atmosphere warming up ?
you define total idiot. and you completely embarrass yourself with that stupid foolish counter argument

Now for the very last time get this through your neanderthal cranium

the climate science models are wrong
they are very expensive pieces of misleading, number noodling pieces of shit
the satellite data has been independently verified via 4 balloon data sets

if you had any scientific understanding you would know how important independent verification is
but you are a scientific illiterate and spewing false alarmism propaganda is all that matters
and that is just pure evil

1769615376879.png


Learn some god damn science before pretending to be an expert and trying to mislead others
 
it is not a bait and switch, piece of bullshit, you scientific illiterate, false propaganda pushing, high school drop out
the AGW theory is based upon warming in the troposphere

larue, you are shitty propagandist.


Its a 10 year old chart that was laughed and mocked when Christy first presented it.
And yet its your sole 'proof', you have nothing more recent.
You've been wrong about the global temperature wrong every year for what, decades now?
And still you think you are smart and right?

This was a post by legit scientists after that chart was first presented 10 years ago.

christy4-1024x768.png
 
larue, you are shitty propagandist.

yes i am a shitty propagandist. as i do not spread propaganda
you on the other hand love to spread propaganda but are not bright enough to convince anyone
so you are even a failure propagandist despite your evil motivations

Its a 10 year old chart that was laughed and mocked when Christy first presented it.
And yet its your sole 'proof', you have nothing more recent.
what a dope you are
the laws of physics do not age and become obsolete after 10 years

newtons laws of motion are over 350 years old
are you going to claim gravity does not apply because it is more than 10 years old?

the climate models were running too hot then and there has not been an admission they run too hot since
all that has transpired is more and more people are realizing the climate con for what it is

You've been wrong about the global temperature wrong every year for what, decades now?
And still you think you are smart and right?
i made no claims about temperature
climate changes, always has and likely always will


i know co2 is not a threat
the real threat is fool attempts to shut down fossil fuels. Hundreds of millions would die and a billion would be pushed into abject poverty
but alas the loonie left cares not about a billion lives - the body count from the communism / socialism disasters will just continue to grow

This was a post by legit scientists after that chart was first presented 10 years ago.

christy4-1024x768.png

[/QUOTE]
Gavin Schmidt ?
the same coward who refuses to debate the science publicly
Gavin Schmidt will go down in history as a lying fool


odd he just plain ignores the real issue
the models calculations just simply do not match direct satellite and weather balloon observations
1769657938805.png
1769658195116.png

this has all been explained to you before
you are a scientific illiterate fool and a copy and paste moron
yet you continue to believe you can mislead others
and you are failing at it

you are just not bright enough
 
Last edited:
yes i am a shitty propagandist. as i do not spread propaganda
you on the other hand low to spread propaganda but are not bright enough to convince anyone
so you are even a failure despite your evil motivations


what a dope you
the laws of physics do not age and become obsolete after 10 years

the climate models were running too hot then and there has not been an admission they run too hot since
all that has transpired is more and more people are realizing the climate con for what it is

You've been wrong about the global temperature wrong every year for what, decades now?
And still you think you are smart and right?

This was a post by legit scientists after that chart was first presented 10 years ago.

christy4-1024x768.png


Gavin Schmidt ?
the same coward who refuses to debate the science publicly

odd he just plain ignore the real issue
the models calculations do not match direct satellite and weather balloon observations
View attachment 542543
View attachment 542545

this has all been explained to you before
you are a scientific illiterate fool and a copy and paste moron
yet you continue to believe you can mislead others
and you are failing at it

you are just not bright enough

larue, you are hopelessly and intentionally ignorant.
Of course Schmidt didn't do a public debate with a fossil fuel funded troll, he does serious science.

Schmidt runs NASA GISS, he's legit and trusted.
All you can do is character assassination of real scientists, that's disgusting.

You can't debate the facts.

You were wrong when you said we wouldn't hit 1ºC, you're wrong still now that the planet has hit 1.5ºC.
You've been wrong every single year but still think you are smart.


 
virtue signalling fools
I remember back in the day a gentleman that had a hotdog cart outside of Ryerson and made a killing off of it for years. I bet anyone who opened one outside of this school would make Bitcoin look like coins you find inside of the sofa after so many years.
 
larue, you are hopelessly and intentionally ignorant.

??????

Too funny

you are the ignorant one
it shows in what you post

Of course Schmidt didn't do a public debate with a fossil fuel funded troll, he does serious science.
again you display your ignorance
serious science absolutely requires robust debate
robust debate is a fundamental cornerstone of scientific advancement

Schmidt runs NASA GISS, he's legit and trusted.
All you can do is character assassination of real scientists, that's disgusting.

real scientist do not run away from debate



You can't debate the facts.
apparently it is Schmidt that cant debate the facts
his response: Run away

You were wrong when you said we wouldn't hit 1ºC, you're wrong still now that the planet has hit 1.5ºC.
You've been wrong every single year but still think you are smart.

i have never made any specific temperature predictions

climate changes, always has, likely always will

1769747869129.jpeg
 
You can't debate the facts.
FactsFrankfooter
Dr. Judith Curry states the uncertainties in climate change are very significantClaims Dr. Judith Curry has been debunked, is on the payroll of big oil.
Dr. Richard Lindzen 200+ papers on atmospheric physics (and IPCC contributor) states there is no climate crisisClaims Dr. Richard Lindzen is on the payroll of big oil
Anthony Watts points out major flaws with the surface temp data record including the urban island heat effectClaims Anthony Watts is just a meteorologist, is on the payroll of big oil
Michael Mann, Phil Jones are caught exchanging emails about how to diddle the Data. Jones latter admits to sending the emails to hide the data,
Head of 'Climategate' research unit admits sending 'pretty awful emails' to hide data.
Professor Phil Jones said it was not 'standard practice' in climate science to release data and methodology so that other scientists could check and challenge the research.
www.dailymail.co.uk www.dailymail.co.uk

Claims the emails were illegally accessed, so ignore the facts of the matter.
Michael Mann splices together different data sets to "hide the decline" in his hockey stick graph. Macintyre and McKendrick show any data set used in Mann's program produces the same hockey stick.
Mann sues Tim Ball for stating Mann should not be in Penn sate, rather belongs in the State Penn
Mann loses the lawsuit & is ordered to pay Tim Balls legal expense. Mann does not pay, and Tim Ball dies broke
Pretends the fraudster Michael Mann is a trustworthy climate scientist
Dr. William Happer., one of the leading scientific experts on radiative energy transfer states, there is no climate crisisClaims Dr. William Happer. is on the payroll of big oil.
Dr. John Clauser, winner of 2022 Noble prize in physics states, there is no climate crisisClaims Dr. John Clauser. is not a climate scientist.
Gavin Schmidt refuses to engage in scientific debate with Dr. Roy Spencer (Former NASA recipient of achievement winner)Claims Dr. Roy Spencer. is on the payroll of big oil.
Pretends Gavin Schmidt is a trustworthy climate scientist.

Records of Burn acreage dating back to 1920s are found on the internet wayback program. the records clearly show burn acreage is down significantly in the past 100 yearHas a meltdown because the data was accessed without permission. "You can't use that “??? WTF????
Dr John Christy (state certified climatologist) shows how the climate models are a mess and fail on multiple dimensions. He also shows with verification how the models compare relative to the satellite and weather balloon dataHas a meltdown because he can not figure out what a temperature anomaly is. "You can't use that “??? WTF????
Any cold hard fact or informed decision seeking the truth of the matter"You can't use that ", you will expose the climate change propaganda for what it is
Fact and Truth
Claim any amount of character assassination and denial of the facts to preserve the propaganda.
 
FactsFrankfooter
Dr. Judith Curry states the uncertainties in climate change are very significantClaims Dr. Judith Curry has been debunked, is on the payroll of big oil.
Dr. Richard Lindzen 200+ papers on atmospheric physics (and IPCC contributor) states there is no climate crisisClaims Dr. Richard Lindzen is on the payroll of big oil
Anthony Watts points out major flaws with the surface temp data record including the urban island heat effectClaims Anthony Watts is just a meteorologist, is on the payroll of big oil
Michael Mann, Phil Jones are caught exchanging emails about how to diddle the Data. Jones latter admits to sending the emails to hide the data,
Head of 'Climategate' research unit admits sending 'pretty awful emails' to hide data.
Professor Phil Jones said it was not 'standard practice' in climate science to release data and methodology so that other scientists could check and challenge the research.
www.dailymail.co.uk www.dailymail.co.uk
Claims the emails were illegally accessed, so ignore the facts of the matter.
Michael Mann splices together different data sets to "hide the decline" in his hockey stick graph. Macintyre and McKendrick show any data set used in Mann's program produces the same hockey stick.
Mann sues Tim Ball for stating Mann should not be in Penn sate, rather belongs in the State Penn
Mann loses the lawsuit & is ordered to pay Tim Balls legal expense. Mann does not pay, and Tim Ball dies broke
Pretends the fraudster Michael Mann is a trustworthy climate scientist
Dr. William Happer., one of the leading scientific experts on radiative energy transfer states, there is no climate crisisClaims Dr. William Happer. is on the payroll of big oil.
Dr. John Clauser, winner of 2022 Noble prize in physics states, there is no climate crisisClaims Dr. John Clauser. is not a climate scientist.
Gavin Schmidt refuses to engage in scientific debate with Dr. Roy Spencer (Former NASA recipient of achievement winner)Claims Dr. Roy Spencer. is on the payroll of big oil.
Pretends Gavin Schmidt is a trustworthy climate scientist.
Records of Burn acreage dating back to 1920s are found on the internet wayback program. the records clearly show burn acreage is down significantly in the past 100 yearHas a meltdown because the data was accessed without permission. "You can't use that “??? WTF????
Dr John Christy (state certified climatologist) shows how the climate models are a mess and fail on multiple dimensions. He also shows with verification how the models compare relative to the satellite and weather balloon dataHas a meltdown because he can not figure out what a temperature anomaly is. "You can't use that “??? WTF????
Any cold hard fact or informed decision seeking the truth of the matter"You can't use that ", you will expose the climate change propaganda for what it is
Fact and TruthClaim any amount of character assassination and denial of the facts to preserve the propaganda.

That's whining, not facts.

Mann won every challenge in court and his 'hockey stick' chart has been confirmed over and over again.
Schmidt has no time for oil$gas funded bullshitters, good for him.

The fact is that the global temperature has risen alongside rises in CO2 and greenhouse gases just as scientists have warned.
While morons think they know better than NASA or the IPCC and instead do character assassination on the best scientists in the world.

G_TEVegXwAAQzM5
 
??????

Too funny

you are the ignorant one
it shows in what you post


again you display your ignorance
serious science absolutely requires robust debate
robust debate is a fundamental cornerstone of scientific advancement



real scientist do not run away from debate




apparently it is Schmidt that cant debate the facts
his response: Run away



i have never made any specific temperature predictions

climate changes, always has, likely always will

View attachment 542989

sigh

More idiotic whining and rambling while the rate of temperature is actually increasing because oil$gas funded propaganda fools morons.
We are on pace for the worst case scenario of climate change, which means billions may die.
Australia is already near wet bulb temperature, which you don't understand what that means.

 
That's whining, not facts.

Mann won every challenge in court and his 'hockey stick' chart has been confirmed over and over again.
Schmidt has no time for oil$gas funded bullshitters, good for him.

The fact is that the global temperature has risen alongside rises in CO2 and greenhouse gases just as scientists have warned.
While morons think they know better than NASA or the IPCC and instead do character assassination on the best scientists in the world.

G_TEVegXwAAQzM5
Here are some facts.

giphy.gif
 
  • Haha
Reactions: SaulGoodman777