ICE agents murder woman in car

Nuance requires you, rich and everyone to be true and honest with themselves and members. It would appear rich was simply mocking member(s) who seem to be inadvertently advocating for concealed carry rights.

My twisted brain recalled the movie title Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb . Previously replayed on TERB as How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Alberta Oil Patch. So now in it's latest installment it's Love the Concealed Gun.

Rich might want to pretend he was mocking a member, but he's just parroting what other right-wing commenters have said. Which is disingenuous and a bad faith argument. As is the whole oil patch nonsense.
 
He has every right to carry...he has no business interfering with law enforcement operations....when you see law enforcement conducting an arrest...do uou inject yourself in the situation? I bet uou won't. Stay behind the computer...

So, standing in front of a downed women is interfering now? And, does that deserve to take beating where you get pistol whipped and then shot 10 times? I love how you don't let facts get in the way of your opinion.
 
Rich might want to pretend he was mocking a member, but he's just parroting what other right-wing commenters have said. Which is disingenuous and a bad faith argument. As is the whole oil patch nonsense.
The oil patch is not a bad faith argument. It's just a quip.

There's nothing wrong with nuance. However, does it really make sense for people who don't support U.S. gun laws to be preaching concealed carry rights? My sense is that if this was a right wing activist shot in Minneapolis many of our members wouldn't care one bit.

I'm not necessarily the arbiter of what makes sense. However, I don't have a history of unequivocally supporting gun rights.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phil C. McNasty
I knew you would go to your rewind and repeat insult. Please explain how an observation about how different groups approach this gun death is pretzeling. Where is my post incorrect? I think most members see the curious reactions from various groups.

My guess like Butler above you're initial reaction was surely, he must be saying something that supports some conservative perspective and I have to affront him. However, Butler's response was more measured and not personal.

Guess what? You don't necessarily have to respond to every post from someone. Nothing wrong with disagreement on these pages, but I challenge you to read the post again. This time carefully without animus.

Wyatt, in your opinion, did Pretti deserve to be shot because he was carrying a holstered gun? Who is in the wrong here, Ice or Pretti?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
The oil patch is not a bad faith argument. It's just a quip.

There's nothing wrong with nuance. However, does it really make sense for people who don't support U.S. gun laws to be preaching concealed carry rights? My sense is that if this was a right wing activist shot in Minneapolis many of our members wouldn't care one bit.

I'm not necessarily the arbiter of what makes sense. However, I don't have a history of unequivocally supporting gun rights.

I disagree. First, no anti-gun advocate is suddenly changing their tune to say they now support concealed carry. What they are doing is pointing out the execution of someone with the justification that they were armed. And, if a right-wing activist was shot in a similar fashion, I'd wager dollars to donuts that they would equally condemn the government. While the right seems to change how they support something based on who is doing it, the left is far more reliable. For instance, they were seriously against (and remain so) sexual harassment and supported the Me Too movement. They forced Al Franken, a Democrat senator, to resign, even though the allegations were fairly mild and happened decades in the past. However, the GOP continued to support Matt Gaetz and other who had much more serious allegations about their behaviour.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Wyatt, in your opinion, did Pretti deserve to be shot because he was carrying a holstered gun? Who is in the wrong here, Ice or Pretti?
Of course not.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: squeezer
And, if a right-wing activist was shot in a similar fashion, I'd wager dollars to donuts that they would equally condemn the government. While the right seems to change how they support something based on who is doing it, the left is far more reliable. For instance, they were seriously against (and remain so) sexual harassment and supported the Me Too movement. They forced Al Franken, a Democrat senator, to resign, even though the allegations were fairly mild and happened decades in the past. However, the GOP continued to support Matt Gaetz and other who had much more serious allegations about their behaviour.

We don't know what is in everyone's hearts and minds.
I know the young woman climbing through a Capitol building window has been discussed at length.
Nothing is ever an exact apples to apples comparison, but she didn't deserve to be shot either.

I really don't want to discuss the Me Too movement. Not being a fan of the media allegation trials for anyone helps me keep my sanity and personal integrity.

If you think you are reliable, can I set you up with my sister? You probably wouldn't like her. She's too apolitical. ;)
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
We don't know what is in everyone's hearts and minds.
I know the young woman climbing through a Capitol building window has been discussed at length.
Nothing is ever an exact apples to apples comparison, but she didn't deserve to be shot either.
The classic "Whataboutty" argument in all its glory.
😹 😹 😹 😹
 
The classic "Whataboutty" argument in all its glory.
😹 😹 😹 😹
We were having a discussion about how people react to different events involving shootings. Are they consistent in their outrage?

You're jumping into a conversation without context. While it's nice of you to join us, it's kind of an intrusion when you probably blocked most of the conversation leading up to that point.
 
He has every right to carry...he has no business interfering with law enforcement operations....when you see law enforcement conducting an arrest...do uou inject yourself in the situation? I bet uou won't. Stay behind the computer...
Some people are making some good points but their taking the discussion half way. Do you really want to normalize this idea of taking guns to a protest? We know Pretti has had recent confrontations with ICE.

Don't know about you, but there are laws I don't like. Some might not like what ICE does, but they are acting within the law. To a degree, I respect people who feel passionately and protest. But would you tell a family member or friend, take your gun with you. Take some extra ammo. You don't know when you might need it.

It doesn't really sound like civil disobedience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: richaceg
We don't know what is in everyone's hearts and minds.
I know the young woman climbing through a Capitol building window has been discussed at length.
Nothing is ever an exact apples to apples comparison, but she didn't deserve to be shot either.

I really don't want to discuss the Me Too movement. Not being a fan of the media allegation trials for anyone helps me keep my sanity and personal integrity.

If you think you are reliable, can I set you up with my sister? You probably wouldn't like her. She's too apolitical. ;)

The officer was protecting Senators, and she was creating a break for all to follow when she was being warned to stop! TO compare the 2 killings is comparing apples and oranges.
 
The officer was protecting Senators, and she was creating a break for all to follow when she was being warned to stop! TO compare the 2 killings is comparing apples and oranges.
I think it's been litigated, but I don't think she deserved to die. Similar to other heated law enforcement confrontations, the officer could have fired shots away from her to intimidate her from entering.

Some things in this world are just because impassioned people do stupid things in the moment. You don't have to shed a tear for her. It's just something to reflect on.
 
Last edited:
Some people are making some good points but their taking the discussion half way. Do you really want to normalize this idea of taking guns to a protest? We know Pretti has had recent confrontations with ICE.

Don't know about you, but there are laws I don't like. Some might not like what ICE does, but they are acting within the law. To a degree, I respect people who feel passionately and protest. But would you tell a family member or friend, take your gun with you. Take some extra ammo. You don't know when you might need it.

It doesn't really sound like civil disobedience.

It already has been normalized for right wing protesters to do it. You don't get to cherry pick, BTW, on the 2nd amendment. That is what every advocate will tell you. Including numerous political figures.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
We don't know what is in everyone's hearts and minds.
I know the young woman climbing through a Capitol building window has been discussed at length.
Nothing is ever an exact apples to apples comparison, but she didn't deserve to be shot either.

I really don't want to discuss the Me Too movement. Not being a fan of the media allegation trials for anyone helps me keep my sanity and personal integrity.

If you think you are reliable, can I set you up with my sister? You probably wouldn't like her. She's too apolitical. ;)

Let us know when this administration advocates for an actual investigation, and not just an exoneration,and vilification of the dead. Until then they have no defense, no standing, and are imo an authoritarian govt that needs to be actively defended against.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
It already has been normalized for right wing protesters to do it. You don't get to cherry pick, BTW, on the 2nd amendment. That is what every advocate will tell you. Including numerous political figures.
I don't know what you are exactly talking about. If you give me an example, I might be able to give you my thoughts.

You might walk through life thinking people are all this or all that. It's easy to think we are all in groups. The truth is most of us have very complicated thoughts on political matters.
 
I knew you would go to your rewind and repeat insult. Please explain how an observation about how different groups approach this gun death is pretzeling. Where is my post incorrect? I think most members see the curious reactions from various groups.

Only the zealots still back killing people for protecting minorities.

G_oF_NbWgAAoRHl
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
Ice is doing a great job of securing the midterms for the Dems.

Although your over-dramatizing the natural cycle of our elections, I actually agree with you to some extent. I just don't know what message the Democratic party takes away from this going into 2028. Do they campaign on issues like disband ICE, go back to the Biden border, healthcare for undocumented migrants and so on? 🤔

You know Trump won't be on the ballot in 2028. So anti-Trump rhetoric will be less impactful. Do the politics of Minneapolis translate across the U.S? I'm not sure the politics of Minneapolis even translates across Minnesota, but we will see about that next year.