The Day I Found Out I Should Get a New Car

I’m a buy new and drive it into the ground kind of guy. My brother is the same. We both watched our Dad flip cars every 3 years and saw the money wasted. I was the same as a young man at first trying to impress the chic…. But the GFs I hit it off with all drove 5-speed base models and didn’t car about cars. That sealed the deal.

I find that you get about 10-11 years out of a car before things just fall off or wear out. It sucks calling for a tow when a ball joint fails or an alternator dies. I’m on Year 12 and wonder if I should keep my car now that it has had stuff replaced?

The people with new cars at work all complain…. Engine recalls on $100K trucks! Crazy!
 
I’m on Year 12 and wonder if I should keep my car now that it has had stuff replaced?

As a guy that's drive his share of junk, there's always the next thing that's going to go. Historically I stayed on top of regular maintenance and would keep fixing until a repair approached the value of a car. Though, that only works if you mostly drive local, and local isn't too busy. In the GTA, especially if I was regularly on the local highways I'd get a new vehicle sooner than that.

I recently bought a new vehicle for the first time in my life. It is modest (but nice), efficient, and Japanese (though from one of the smaller manufacturers). I like it, which is good, because I fully intend to own it until it goes to the scrap yard. Then I'll buy another one (for cash).

Despite me buying new @Jenesis gave good advice.

The only other advice I'd add is: 1) Stay on top of the basic maintenance (especially oil and transmission fluid) if you intend to keep it until it's done.
2) When buying start with the base trim and work your way up to the trim with just the features you really want, and be frugal with the add ons and accessories.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: shakenbake
I’m a buy new and drive it into the ground kind of guy. My brother is the same. We both watched our Dad flip cars every 3 years and saw the money wasted. I was the same as a young man at first trying to impress the chic…. But the GFs I hit it off with all drove 5-speed base models and didn’t car about cars. That sealed the deal.

I find that you get about 10-11 years out of a car before things just fall off or wear out. It sucks calling for a tow when a ball joint fails or an alternator dies. I’m on Year 12 and wonder if I should keep my car now that it has had stuff replaced?

The people with new cars at work all complain…. Engine recalls on $100K trucks! Crazy!

Mine is 12 years old too and it still has lots of life in her. I buy a couple years old and drive into the ground as well. But I also am big on maintenance. Oil changes all the time. Tune ups, and repair when things are going, not when they are already gone if I can help it.

I would guess I have at least 3/4 year left minimum before repair costs outweighs a buying a new used car. But I might buy again then anyways, regardless of the condition of mine because things are going hybrid or complete EV and I want gas. So if the car I want goes that way, I will buy the last available gas powered.
 
Today I have matrix headlights that allows me to drive with high beams on all the time and the car will dim individual pixels so there is no glare to oncoming cars.

If you think that actually works, you are sorely mistaken. You're just the guy driving around with high beams on constantly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dvous11
I’m a buy new and drive it into the ground kind of guy. My brother is the same. We both watched our Dad flip cars every 3 years and saw the money wasted. I was the same as a young man at first trying to impress the chic…. But the GFs I hit it off with all drove 5-speed base models and didn’t car about cars. That sealed the deal.

I find that you get about 10-11 years out of a car before things just fall off or wear out. It sucks calling for a tow when a ball joint fails or an alternator dies. I’m on Year 12 and wonder if I should keep my car now that it has had stuff replaced?

The people with new cars at work all complain…. Engine recalls on $100K trucks! Crazy!
A lot of people(including the quick lube jockeys) do not know that a weak battery strains the alternator. As for the suspension(ball joints and bushings), for older cars it seems you almost have to beg a suspension shop to do the work.
Also, for older cars, sometimes hard to get a tranny flush(hook up to the cooler lines). One Mr. Lube would not do it because the car is older. Another Mr. Lube 10 minutes away did it. My check engine light went on but I just disconnected the battery to reset it. If you only change(not flush) the tranny fluid you cannot get it out of the torque converter. Yearly rustproofing is important too.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jd3402
A lot of people(including the quick lube jockeys) do not know that a weak battery strains the alternator. As for the suspension, for older cars it seems you almost have to beg a suspension shop to do the work.
Also, for older cars, sometimes hard to get a tranny flush(hook up to the cooler lines). One Mr. Lube would not do it because the car is older. Another Mr. Lube 10 minutes away did it. If you only change9not flush) the tranny fluid you cannot get it out of the torque converter.
I take my car to a local independent... His philosophy with my current car is to leave things alone until they break. I've never seen a mechanic that wants to minimize my costs. Would he have caught a dead alternator? I doubt it. I knew my battery was super old (I bought a "10 year" AGM from Crappy Tire). I like my car. It's a manual 5-speed. No-one wants to steal it. It looks very similar to the current model. Why bother replacing it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: jd3402
I take my car to a local independent... His philosophy with my current car is to leave things alone until they break. I've never seen a mechanic that wants to minimize my costs. Would he have caught a dead alternator? I doubt it. I knew my battery was super old (I bought a "10 year" AGM from Crappy Tire). I like my car. It's a manual 5-speed. No-one wants to steal it. It looks very similar to the current model. Why bother replacing it?
I agree about keeping old cars. No need to worry about a scratch. Also, super cheap insurance. Take off all the extra coverage as the insurance company will not give you anything anyway.
I raised my liability to 2 million though.
 
For the younger TERBites... Driving in the GTA is terrible. Save your money on cars and honestly spend your money on Health, Food and Travelling (and Escorts). Have fun.

Everyone seems to have a BMW and MB now and cars are built so poorly... So who really cares? I was in a brand new Camry and was impressed. (Having said that... My current dream car would be a Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing in Manual... but I'd also like a '93 Mustang.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: jd3402
Cars are like sex.
Everybody is an expert.
 
  • Like
Reactions: From0300
If you think that actually works, you are sorely mistaken. You're just the guy driving around with high beams on constantly.
Oh, I know they work. I can see them working. On coming cars and cars in front have a huge shadow around them while everything around them is bright. When my car was updated turning on the headlight feature, I played around a lot with them (me being in an oncoming car, me in the car in front, me on a bike, etc) and I can say that I cannot tell that high beams are on. This feature does not turn on in the city where everything is well lit, but are so useful driving up to the cottage where it is pitch black.
 
That day was when I looked at the outside mirror and saw my car on the flat bed of the tow truck :(

The car is old enough now that any day something else could leave me stranded again, so the day has come to buy something new that I can rely on.

Looks like fewer future SP visits are going to foot the bill for this :(
I'm sure everyone here has seen the prices for even a 'cheap' new car, I know you can get a used car for less but New is the way I'm going

Do you drive a alot? Buy an EV and the fuel savings will free up a few $$
 
I personally would never buy new and I always pay out in cash. You lose so much value when you drive a new car off the lot. It is a depreciating asset.


While used cars can be a smart option for some buyers, it’s not accurate to say that purchasing a new car is never the better choice. New cars are generally far more reliable, since they haven’t been subjected to unknown driving habits or wear and tear, which reduces the risk of breakdowns and costly repairs. They are also less troublesome overall, often coming with warranties and the latest safety and technology features, giving owners peace of mind. In the last 25 years I have only had one car warranty repair. The dealer gave me a loaner car and the inconvenience was minor. I may be spoiled, but I can not see myself driving a car without Radar cruise control, rear back up camera or traction control and anti lock brakes. These are things that all new cars come with these days, but you may not get on a used car. For many people, a new car also matters for professional appearance and personal pride, which can positively impact confidence and self-esteem. Additionally, for business owners or self-employed individuals, new vehicles may be partially tax deductible, making them financially practical rather than indulgent. Buying new isn’t just about preference, it’s a sensible and strategic decision.

I had joined apa and they could only negotiate 500 discount for the car I had wanted to buy. I went to three other dealers, outside of who they recommended and got $3000 discount for the same vehicle. Fuck apa.

The APA or Car Help Canada can not and will not strip every penny of profit off a new car deal. If they did that the car dealers would ban them from the dealerships rather than give away the cars.
 
Last edited:
I am the type of guy that never buys a new car, always a year or two old. I ended up blowing the motor on my work van in April and had to get a new one and quick. I was looking at vans with like 60/70,000 km. And they were only 10 grand cheaper in most cases. I saw one with 50,000 km on it with an accident and they wanted $40,000+ tax. I ended up buying a brand new one with the extra big motor and all the bells and whistles that a work van can have for $62,000 out the door. This is the only reason I went new and I’m happy with my purchase. The only issue is now I don’t wanna drive it because I see the kilometers going up up up lol and I notice it more as opposed to starting off with 60,000 on the odometer. lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jenesis
If you think that actually works, you are sorely mistaken. You're just the guy driving around with high beams on constantly.
Is it just me? but I see Honda civic drivers driving around all the time with their high beams on and it pisses me off. Very rarely other makes and models, just civics
 
  • Like
Reactions: opieshuffle
While used cars can be a smart option for some buyers, it’s not accurate to say that purchasing a new car is never the better choice. New cars are generally far more reliable, since they haven’t been subjected to unknown driving habits or wear and tear, which reduces the risk of breakdowns and costly repairs. They are also less troublesome overall, often coming with warranties and the latest safety and technology features, giving owners peace of mind. In the last 25 years I have only had one car warranty repair. The dealer gave me a loaner car and the inconvenience was minor. I may be spoiled, but I can not see myself driving a car without Radar cruise control, rear back up camera or traction control and anti lock brakes. These are things that all new cars come with these days, but you may not get on a used car. For many people, a new car also matters for professional appearance and personal pride, which can positively impact confidence and self-esteem. Additionally, for business owners or self-employed individuals, new vehicles may be partially tax deductible, making them financially practical rather than indulgent. Buying new isn’t just about preference, it’s a sensible and strategic decision
I never said what was a better choice. I said it lost value because it is a depreciating asset. Which is true.

Now what is the better choice is up to the individual. You want to buy new - go ahead but buying 2 years old is not a bad choice either. You can still get warranty, safety features, etc.

So buy your new car, I will be a used one. We will both be happy.
 
I never said what was a better choice. I said it lost value because it is a depreciating asset. Which is true.

Now what is the better choice is up to the individual. You want to buy new - go ahead but buying 2 years old is not a bad choice either. You can still get warranty, safety features, etc.

So buy your new car, I will be a used one. We will both be happy.

I am always happy with my new cars, especially when I do not have to deal with other peoples bodily fluids. When people sneeze they splatter phlegm and booger juice all over the steering wheel and dash.

You have to wonder why anyone would get rid of a 2 year old car. I hold on to my cars for 4-5 years, depending on when the new models come out.



 
Last edited:
I am always happy with my new cars, especially when I do not have to deal with other peoples bodily fluids. When people sneeze they splatter phlegm and booger juice all over the steering wheel and dash.

You have to wonder why anyone would get rid of a 2 year old car. I hold on to my cars for 4-5 years, depending on when the new models come out.
I don't understand why you are debating this so hard with me. LOL. Why do you care so much if I buy a 2 year old car. If I bought a car now, I could get. 2024 that was a demo model that was not sold in 2025. That would have less then 10K on it and would be cheaper then a new 2026. There are literally 2 at the dealership down the street. That is just demo models. Plenty of people need to get rid of cars. Some upgrade every two years like people upgrade phones. Some lose a job and have to go cheaper. Some but thinking they like the model but after a while they find they don’t like it as much. Again, I don’t see why you care so much about my buying habits.

I'm glad you are happy with your new car purchases. I have been happy with my used car purchase.

Oh and all the cars I have e bought have been fully detailed so I'm not worry about sneezes. LMAO. 🤣
 
  • Like
Reactions: SchlongConery