Trump has lost credibility on tariffs—economically, politically, and internationally.
Trump’s tariffs on China during his first administration failed to deliver on their core promise: reducing the trade deficit. In fact, the deficit with China continued to rise, including under Biden, exposing the long-term ineffectiveness of the policy.
U.S. manufacturing experienced only a brief uptick before declining again, particularly in agriculture and steel-dependent industries that were hit hardest by China’s retaliatory tariffs. When Beijing struck back, American farmers bore the brunt, especially soybean and pork producers. To offset the damage, Trump issued tens of billions in subsidies, effectively making taxpayers shoulder the cost of his own trade war. Meanwhile, supply chain disruptions and tariff uncertainty caused businesses to delay investments and scale back operations. Trump caused the problem, and then paid people to survive it.
In a second administration, Trump appears poised to double down on tariffs, threatening a repeat of the same failed strategy. But this time, the global economy is more fragile. Another tariff spiral could push it toward recession or worse, a depression.
What will happen in 90 days? Will tariffs on other countries be reimposed? Trump's economic aggression may only have been paused, not ended. Instead of growth and recovery, we could face creeping inflation, stalled investment, and fractured global trade relations.
China may sell less to the American market, but it still has access to the broader global market. The real question is whether Trump can withstand the pressure when the American public begins to feel the impact, especially as consumer prices rise. What happens when parents face higher costs for computers and school supplies in September? Or when families are forced to pay more for a new washing machine, or struggle with the increased cost of car repairs? Tariffs don’t just hit foreign producers—they hit American households where it hurts most.