Jewish school in Canada targeted by gunfire during Yom Kippur, in 2nd attack in months

[basketcase]

Agreed. But do we know if grog and flub are white Christians? Or Geno?

Is that like the tripartite nature of the Catholic god?

Can't guarantee anything but based on his posts, he clearly despises Arabs and denies them agency while also pushes ridiculous antisemitic conspiracies. He could be a Buddhist for all I know but his posts make pretty clear he's just another elitist white guy who thinks the world needs him as their savior.

 

[basketcase]

You're arguing Palestinians chose to invade Palestine?
...

The Arab armies and Palestinian militias chose to invade the area the UN awarded to Israel and then annexed the land the UN awarded to Arab Palestinians.

 

[basketcase]

Netanyahu is right.
Why would Israel deliberately attack UN forces in Lebanon? The anti-Israel crowd's charges make no sense.
...

Considering the documented evidence of Hezbollah sites directly under the noses of UNIFIL (which UNIFIL is mandated to eliminate) it is likely that the IDF is firing at Hezbollah right beside UNIFIL sites.

 

[basketcase]

You only used antisemitic twice in that post, are you feeling ok?
...

Lets see.

You've posted about jewish money running the US, even after Omar admitted her tweet was an antisemitic trope.
You've claimed Jews have subjugated America.
You've claimed Jewish Americans aren't loyal.
You've accused a Jewish conspiracy assassinated JFK
You've posted that American Jews who worked for Biden were all secret Israeli dual citizens.

And then there are all the ways you get called out by Canada's definition of antisemitism of which you've done all except denying the Holocaust.



BTW> No surprise that you can't respond to anything I've posted

 

[basketcase]

Yes, we know you are all about schools.
...

Your refusal to answer means you clearly think Canadian Jewish schools being shot is legitimate Palestinian self defense.

 

[basketcase]

Israel struck first in every case.
...

Too bad the facts say otherwise. For example, I've posted statements directly from Hezbollah admitting they attacked Israel on Oct. 8 to 'support' Hamas, not because of any Israeli strike on them. And the Houthis clearly attacked Israel first.

Speaking of the Houthis...

Yemen: UN chief demands release of aid workers held by Houthis

UN Secretary-General António Guterres called on Tuesday for the immediate release of all United Nations staff held in Yemen by the de facto Houthi authorities, following the detention of 13 of the Organization’s personnel.

news.un.org

But as you've posted repeatedly about the Jewish presence being illegal, you consider jews simply being in the middle east as "Israeli aggression".

 

[basketcase]

...
Its a colonial settler movement ...

Except it isn't even if there are some vague similarities.

And you have no problem being part of Canada's colonial settler movement.

 

[basketcase]

Bummer about the election.
...

Celebrating Trump again.

I'm sure women, minorities, the free press, and anti-authoritarians won't suffer too badly under Trump (not to mention people in Gaza who Hamas wants "finished").

 

[basketcase]

Sounds like every other religion out there, except maybe Buddhism.

Check out Myanmar.

Extremists in every religion or movement are a problem.

 

[basketcase]

You're backing a genocidal ethnostate.
...

You mean Hamas and the PA who refuse to consider Jews as citizens, the millions of Arab Jews?

Or Saudi Arabia where non-Muslims aren't even allowed in parts of the country and it's illegal to publicly display symbols of other religions?
Or Iran where religious minorities are excluded from governance other than a token MP out of 300 or so seats and where women are executed for showing hair in public?

 

[basketcase]

I see, you won't accept anything from Muslim countries.
...

Says the guy who obsessively claims his opinions overrule Arab opinions and thinks Arabs can't be accountable for their choices.

 

[basketcase]

you don’t seem to get it.
The right of return to Israel is also based on ethnicity (Jews vs Arabs) not religion (Jews vs Muslims)....

The expedited citizenship is for all Jews whether Arab, African, Asian, or European. Half of Israeli Jews are Arabs. I guess you can argue that descendants of Jews such as the Refuseniks technically weren't practicing Jews though most probably qualified as Jewish under Jewish law.

Non-Jews can also immigrate to Israel. The dad of the Israeli NBA guy is a Bosnian Muslim who immigrated to Israel before even meeting his wife. There is also nothing unusual about offering an expedited path for people of shared background as almost every European country has a quicker path for people with ancestors from the country.

There are also plenty of countries where citizenship is based exclusively on ethnicity (unless you are stupid rich). Saudi Arabia and Japan are two such examples.

 

[basketcase]

Do you even know what a source is? It’s not an unattributed image. Try again.

How about a direct quote from someone who thinks shooting up a Canadian school is okay?

Are they taught the ideology of Zionism at this school?

 

[basketcase]

Yeah, you wish buddy.....here is just for India between years 1000-1525:
...

You can try to warp most conflicts into seeming religious but that isn't reality. The fact that the winners of some war are Muslim doesn't mean it's 'because' of Islam any more than claiming that Hitler's war was a Christian genocide (though people do try to make that claim).
Christianity has a huge death toll to which is far more just a description as many colonialists were doing so explicitly to "bring religion" to those countries. Christian missionaries were also a significant factor in the Boxer rebellions and the eventual rise of Communist China. One major cause of WWI was also Russia support of Serbia which was mainly because Russia saw themselves as the protectors of the Orthodox church.

I personally feel that most religious leaders just use religion as a means of inciting their power base; they are pragmatists using a powerful driver rather than true believers.

 

[basketcase]

You guys are going to also start a thread on how horrible this attack was, right?

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1846244936661823635

You should. It does deserve it's own. Or is this just you whining again about Jewish control.

Attacks on any group simply because of their religion should be condemned.

 

[basketcase]

There is literally no source you will accept if its critical of Israel.
You're in a cult.

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1845824097369931943

Says the guy who only uses random tweets as proof.

 

[basketcase]

I post Jewish Voices for Peace and you declare its 'Jew hating'.
...

You are a Jew hater.

The fact that there are Jews who oppose Israeli government actions doesn't make you wany less racist (especially the way you try and use token Jews to justify your hatreds).

 

[Uwauwa]

The expedited citizenship is for all Jews whether Arab, African, Asian, or European. Half of Israeli Jews are Arabs. I guess you can argue that descendants of Jews such as the Refuseniks technically weren't practicing Jews though most probably qualified as Jewish under Jewish law.

Non-Jews can also immigrate to Israel. The dad of the Israeli NBA guy is a Bosnian Muslim who immigrated to Israel before even meeting his wife. There is also nothing unusual about offering an expedited path for people of shared background as almost every European country has a quicker path for people with ancestors from the country.

There are also plenty of countries where citizenship is based exclusively on ethnicity (unless you are stupid rich). Saudi Arabia and Japan are two such examples.

By arab jews do you mean e.g. descendants of Lebanese or Iraqi jews ? They are not typically classified as arabs. They are ethnic jews.

 

[basketcase]

Are you saying everyone in the Muslim community needs to be an activist?
The violent ones are for law enforcement to deal with.
The community is not able to do anything about terrorists.
What do we individuals do anything about bad people in our individual communities? Nothing either.

If you are talking in authoritarian countries run by Islamists, sure.
If you're talking about Canada, absolutely they do have the ability to. It's not the responsibility of anyone to monitor their neighbours but they can shun the extremists.

Mosque leadership in Canada tends to be far more organic and community based than most churches and unlike priests, there is no external vetting process for Imams. That makes it important that they appoint people who support community/Canadian standards.

 

[Shaquille Oatmeal]

If you are talking in authoritarian countries run by Islamists, sure.
If you're talking about Canada, absolutely they do have the ability to. It's not the responsibility of anyone to monitor their neighbours but they can shun the extremists.

Mosque leadership in Canada tends to be far more organic and community based than most churches and unlike priests, there is no external vetting process for Imams. That makes it important that they appoint people who support community/Canadian standards.

That can be said about anyone in Canada.
The ones that need to do that the most then are the far right extremists.
Muslims and Jews are the ones on the receiving end of their extremism.