I was wrong about Olivia Chow — and I am glad I was
By advocating for the city, Toronto's mayor delivered a master class in talking nice while acting tough, in playing it smart and getting results.
ByAndrew PhillipsStaff Columnist
Tuesday, February 6, 2024
When you’re wrong, you’re wrong. And boy, was I ever wrong about Olivia Chow.
Back in June, just before Chow was elected mayor of Toronto, I worried she’d be left helpless in dealing with senior levels of government that control the money the city needs so badly.
With a low turnout and a split vote, went my sage argument, she’d squeak in with the support of only a small fraction of Torontonians. She’d be in an even weaker position with Ottawa and Queen’s Park than John Tory, who won a smashing mandate the previous October. “The new mayor is being dealt a bad hand at the start of this game,” I wrote.
Well, so much for that. Mayor Chow may have been holding only a low pair at the federal-provincial-municipal poker table. But as any poker player knows, it’s not mostly about the cards, it’s how you play them. And Chow has played her hand like a Vegas veteran.
Late last year she managed to strike a historic deal with the Ford government that will free up billions in capital funding for the city by having the province take over financial responsibility for the Gardiner Expressway and Don Valley Parkway.
The “New Deal for Toronto” (capital letters and all) will bring another billion or so in capital expenses for housing and new subway cars. As well as $1.2 billion in operating expenses for transit operations and shelter spaces. As much as $9 billion over a decade.
Tory had been pushing for a big deal along these lines but it was Chow who delivered it, and only five months after she took office. The only concession she had to make was to stop fussing over Doug Ford’s plans for Ontario Place — a battle the city couldn’t have won in any case.
So much for the province. Things weren’t going so well with the feds, with Toronto facing skyrocketing costs for dealing with the influx of refugees into the city. Here, again, the mayor played her cards like an expert.
Toronto’s budget chief, Shelley Carroll, came out with a draft budget proposing a tax increase of 10.5 per cent — plus a stinger to the effect that if Ottawa didn’t cover $250 million in refugee expenses then the hike for property owners would soar to 16.5 per cent. She even called that extra six-point increase the “Federal Impacts Levy.”
In poker, like any other game, you hope your opponents will make their share of mistakes — and that was certainly the case this time. Liberal MPs from Toronto started whining to the media that the city’s move was “outrageous” and their government wasn’t getting credit for all the nice things it does for Toronto. Yvan Baker of Etobicoke Centre publicly accused Chow of conducting a “shakedown.”
The mayor, smartly, stayed quiet. Note that the 10.5-per-cent proposal and the 6-point federal levy didn’t come from her, but from her budget chief. She didn’t personally endorse those numbers. Nor did she get drawn into an insult battle with the touchy Liberal MPs; she let them rail on and put their political desperation on display.
Which brings us to last Friday, when Chow and Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland were all smiles as another deal was announced — this one involving $162 million in federal cash to help Toronto house refugee claimants. With more money pledged for the rest of the year, the mayor happily agreed the city was being fully compensated for asylum expenses while Freeland was able to claim Ottawa is “Toronto’s greatest partner.”
Yvan Baker, let it be said, was right that Toronto was conducting a shakedown of sorts. Chow cleverly put the feds on the spot and forced them to cough up money for costs they were imposing on the city. Plus her own proposed tax increase is now just 9.5 per cent, which looks like a bargain after those bigger numbers were tossed around.
It was a master class in talking nice while acting tough, in playing it smart and getting results. I was wrong about Mayor Chow, and I’m glad I was.
By advocating for the city, Toronto's mayor delivered a master class in talking nice while acting tough, in playing it smart and getting results.
ByAndrew PhillipsStaff Columnist
Tuesday, February 6, 2024
When you’re wrong, you’re wrong. And boy, was I ever wrong about Olivia Chow.
Back in June, just before Chow was elected mayor of Toronto, I worried she’d be left helpless in dealing with senior levels of government that control the money the city needs so badly.
With a low turnout and a split vote, went my sage argument, she’d squeak in with the support of only a small fraction of Torontonians. She’d be in an even weaker position with Ottawa and Queen’s Park than John Tory, who won a smashing mandate the previous October. “The new mayor is being dealt a bad hand at the start of this game,” I wrote.
Well, so much for that. Mayor Chow may have been holding only a low pair at the federal-provincial-municipal poker table. But as any poker player knows, it’s not mostly about the cards, it’s how you play them. And Chow has played her hand like a Vegas veteran.
Late last year she managed to strike a historic deal with the Ford government that will free up billions in capital funding for the city by having the province take over financial responsibility for the Gardiner Expressway and Don Valley Parkway.
The “New Deal for Toronto” (capital letters and all) will bring another billion or so in capital expenses for housing and new subway cars. As well as $1.2 billion in operating expenses for transit operations and shelter spaces. As much as $9 billion over a decade.
Tory had been pushing for a big deal along these lines but it was Chow who delivered it, and only five months after she took office. The only concession she had to make was to stop fussing over Doug Ford’s plans for Ontario Place — a battle the city couldn’t have won in any case.
So much for the province. Things weren’t going so well with the feds, with Toronto facing skyrocketing costs for dealing with the influx of refugees into the city. Here, again, the mayor played her cards like an expert.
Toronto’s budget chief, Shelley Carroll, came out with a draft budget proposing a tax increase of 10.5 per cent — plus a stinger to the effect that if Ottawa didn’t cover $250 million in refugee expenses then the hike for property owners would soar to 16.5 per cent. She even called that extra six-point increase the “Federal Impacts Levy.”
In poker, like any other game, you hope your opponents will make their share of mistakes — and that was certainly the case this time. Liberal MPs from Toronto started whining to the media that the city’s move was “outrageous” and their government wasn’t getting credit for all the nice things it does for Toronto. Yvan Baker of Etobicoke Centre publicly accused Chow of conducting a “shakedown.”
The mayor, smartly, stayed quiet. Note that the 10.5-per-cent proposal and the 6-point federal levy didn’t come from her, but from her budget chief. She didn’t personally endorse those numbers. Nor did she get drawn into an insult battle with the touchy Liberal MPs; she let them rail on and put their political desperation on display.
Which brings us to last Friday, when Chow and Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland were all smiles as another deal was announced — this one involving $162 million in federal cash to help Toronto house refugee claimants. With more money pledged for the rest of the year, the mayor happily agreed the city was being fully compensated for asylum expenses while Freeland was able to claim Ottawa is “Toronto’s greatest partner.”
Yvan Baker, let it be said, was right that Toronto was conducting a shakedown of sorts. Chow cleverly put the feds on the spot and forced them to cough up money for costs they were imposing on the city. Plus her own proposed tax increase is now just 9.5 per cent, which looks like a bargain after those bigger numbers were tossed around.
It was a master class in talking nice while acting tough, in playing it smart and getting results. I was wrong about Mayor Chow, and I’m glad I was.





