Can stocks be stolen?

Rose11

Active member
Dec 28, 2022
255
191
43
Friend moved his stocks from one broker to another because he moved countries. He was surprised how little info he had to provide to move his portfolio (just filled out a simple form and provided an account statement).

Does this mean anyone that gets access to your account number and statement (like an accountant or hacker) can in effect steal your securities with ease?

Seems like a weak system
 
  • Like
Reactions: stinkynuts
Friend moved his stocks from one broker to another because he moved countries. He was surprised how little info he had to provide to move his portfolio (just filled out a simple form and provided an account statement).


Does this mean anyone that gets access to your account number and statement (like an accountant or hacker) can in effect steal your securities with ease?

Seems like a weak system
Probably, especially if they can provide a fake ID, which is very easy nowadays.
Basically, with identity theft, anyone can steal your money at any time.

That is why you never tell people how much money you have, and never boast about how much money you have in stocks. Sooner or later, someone with bad intentions and desperation will find out and find a way to get it.

A common way to lose your money is through phishing.
Read this for important information:

Basically, if you get an email or text from your “bank”, asking you to login, never ever do this. Your account information will be stolen and you will lose everything.

Never ever use public Wi-Fi to check your bank account. Many of these Wi-Fi connections are not secure, and your information can be easily stolen.

Investments are not protected from fraud, unlike credit cards.
 
Last edited:
It is possible to illegally transfer stocks from one person to another person without consent, but this would be easily trackable if it is found out.
 
It is possible to illegally transfer stocks from one person to another person without consent, but this would be easily trackable if it is found out.

By the time it is tracked, it's too late, the money is gone. I wonder why the banks have such tough measures in place to safeguard chequing, savings and credit cards accounts, which don't run large balances, often under $3000, but appear to have such a weak system in terms of checks and balances for brokerage accounts.

The easiest way to have them stolen is if hackers hack one's accountant's computer. That's where the statements, account number, name, IDs, and SIN numbers are, all in one place. Pretty pathetic.

Luckily I do my own taxes but there are a lot of people that use an accountant leaving a large loop hole in the system.
 
The question was, can stocks be stolen. The answer is yes it can be stolen. If you stole my stocks, can you run far away enough not to get caught. The answer is no.
 
Short answer. No

I do remember the days when I used to fly to New York with 50-100 million worth of bearer bonds. Short answer. Yes
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Gstep
which don't run large balances, often under $3000, but appear to have such a weak system in terms of checks and balances for brokerage accounts.

Lol. If you only knew
That’s not to say things are perfect and bulletproof. But lol.
will say, due to my “position”, the kind of things I had access to, the kind $$ (book value…in the billions) could do ( trading platforms) I could go to jail for a long time, merely because I didn’t report something……..suspicious…

you call that weak?
Curious. If while at work you saw something just a wee bit suspicious. But didn’t flag it, or report it, if you faced 6 figure fines and jail time.

 
Last edited:
you call that weak?

I meant the stock transfer transaction check appears much weaker than the cash transfer one. The cash transfer verification is much rigorous.

For example, to transfer stock portfolio across the border, he just has to fill a form and provide an account statement. That's it. His sending bank did not call him to verify the transaction, neither did the receiving bank. It was really fast. Just like 2 or 3 days.

HOWEVER,

He had $380 as cash in his checking account. Before closing that account and sending just $380 over SWIFT, the sending bank called him to verify the transaction, even though he had used this method before. They asked where it was going, the purpose of that money transfer (only $380), they verified his identity over the phone by asking personal question like DOB, address, etc. They also sent him an SMS PIN to his cell phone to confirm his identity. He verbally approved "yes" to the transaction, and then, the $380 was processed for transfer over SWIFT. Lots of safeguards in place....for just $380 in his checking.

But with his Brokerage account..... NOTHING
 
  • Like
Reactions: curr3n_c1000
I meant the stock transfer transaction check appears much weaker than the cash transfer one. The cash transfer verification is much rigorous.

For example, to transfer stock portfolio across the border, he just has to fill a form and provide an account statement. That's it. His sending bank did not call him to verify the transaction, neither did the receiving bank. It was really fast. Just like 2 or 3 days.

HOWEVER,

He had $380 as cash in his checking account. Before closing that account and sending just $380 over SWIFT, the sending bank called him to verify the transaction, even though he had used this method before. They asked where it was going, the purpose of that money transfer (only $380), they verified his identity over the phone by asking personal question like DOB, address, etc. They also sent him an SMS PIN to his cell phone to confirm his identity. He verbally approved "yes" to the transaction, and then, the $380 was processed for transfer over SWIFT. Lots of safeguards in place....for just $380 in his checking.

But with his Brokerage account..... NOTHING

As I said, the system is not perfect or bullet proof. Shit can and does happen. Without getting into a long discussion, about oversight, compliance, check and balances, KYC rules, what it takes to open accounts, or different types of accounts and so on and so forth. One it’s technical and really boring. :). Two, it’s a lot. Would be like reading tax code. Thousands of pages :)

When I broke into the industry. Very few people knew or understood what a mutual fund was. Let alone more Advanced stuff like options/futures, and more. A lot was paper based. Hence why I would periodically fly to New York with tens/hundreds of millions worth that could be stolen ( you’d still have to find a buyer willing to pay penny’s on the dollar. Or be able to use it as collateral).

I want to say, sometime during the late 90s. The banking/financial industry started getting serious ( largely so to some rather famous scandals) about such stuff. The “public trust is the be all and end all”.

I can tell you, that as someone that could write trading tickets, journal entries, make adjustments, open accounts, send stuff overseas, had access to numerous things, let alone trade hundreds of billions worth of equities, commercial paper, currencies and more….daily.

the scrutiny is insane. And these days, the “consequences” have teeth. Like 6 figure fines and jail time.
 
Last edited: