Who Should the Leafs Keep/Trade

What's the best approach to shaking up the Leafs roster?

  • Keep Matthews, Marner, Tavares - Trade Nylander

    Votes: 2 15.4%
  • Keep Matthews, Nylander, Tavares - Trade Marner

    Votes: 4 30.8%
  • Keep Marner, Nylander, Tavares - Trade Matthews

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Keep Matthews & Tavares - Trade Marner & Nylander

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • Keep Marner & Tavares - Trade Matthews & Nylander

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • Keep Nylander & Tavares - Trade Matthews & Marner

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • Keep Matthews & Marner - Trade Nylander & Tavares

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • Keep Matthews, Marner & Nylander - Trade Tavares

    Votes: 3 23.1%

  • Total voters
    13
  • Poll closed .

John Wick

Baba Yaga
Oct 25, 2019
2,241
2,444
113
With speculation rampant about what the Leafs could/might do to shake up the core
 
I would think they could get decent to good return from trading Matthews, Marner and/or Nylander, but the one contract that they’re stuck with is Tavares’s. He has a no movement provision so the only way to get him off the roster would be a buyout. Even if he agrees to be moved, this stage of his career no team would even trade for him unless the Leafs would eat a large portion of his salary.
 
  • Like
Reactions: John Wick
I have a hard time believing the Leafs would split up Matthews and Marner (even though I think trading Marner would get best return for upgrades). I think more likely they try to get a better scoring power forward to play with them on the top line instead of Bunting or Knies and a shutdown D-man to play with Reilly by trading Nylander in a package and getting out from under Tavares' contract somehow.
 
This thread will soon resemble sports talk radio where listeners phone in and suggest "Bunting for McDavid" type trades. If we have de-valued the "core four" why would any team give us a boat load of talented players for them? You don't sell when your assets have hit rock bottom.
 
This thread will soon resemble sports talk radio where listeners phone in and suggest "Bunting for McDavid" type trades. If we have de-valued the "core four" why would any team give us a boat load of talented players for them? You don't sell when your assets have hit rock bottom.

I don't think the discussion is around the devaluation of any one player but more that the current mix of player talent is not working for the Leafs. When trades occur, in many instances both teams are looking to add specific skills/talent/experience to their existing mix of players to sort of 'optimize the formula' they believe will work for them to be successful.

I believe many fans of the Leafs believe the current mix is wrong and if they want to be successful they need to adjust that mix by trades, promotions from their own pipeline, or through FA signings.

Four of the five core players all hold significant value on the trade market (contracts notwithstanding) so other teams will certainly be interested in entertaining trade inquiries. The problem I believe is with Tavares. Bad contract, badly eroding talent are not appealing so he'd have to be part of something pretty creative to get rid of him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: roadhog and smuddan
They can't trade Tavares unless waves the no-trade clause in his contract and nobody trades centers so its either Marner or Nylander. They need the cap space if they can't dump Murray.
Fire Sheldon
 
I don't think the discussion is around the devaluation of any one player but more that the current mix of player talent is not working for the Leafs. When trades occur, in many instances both teams are looking to add specific skills/talent/experience to their existing mix of players to sort of 'optimize the formula' they believe will work for them to be successful.

I believe many fans of the Leafs believe the current mix is wrong and if they want to be successful they need to adjust that mix by trades, promotions from their own pipeline, or through FA signings.

Four of the five core players all hold significant value on the trade market (contracts notwithstanding) so other teams will certainly be interested in entertaining trade inquiries. The problem I believe is with Tavares. Bad contract, badly eroding talent are not appealing so he'd have to be part of something pretty creative to get rid of him.
Or, the current mix is good but the person utilizing the pieces is wrong. New coach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: John Wick
Or, the current mix is good but the person utilizing the pieces is wrong. New coach.

You are exactly right...could be the coach is all wrong for the team too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tml
They can't trade Tavares unless waves the no-trade clause in his contract and nobody trades centers so its either Marner or Nylander. They need the cap space if they can't dump Murray.
Fire Sheldon

agreed, that's why I was saying it would have to be a pretty creative deal that had some upside incentives for all three parties involved for it to happen. Leafs, their trade partners, and Tavares himself would all have to agree the terms of the deal had benefits they all could enjoy.