Desantis Gets a History Lesson from a Historian

That's exactly what it means when there's no desire for statehood. The truth you want to gloss over is that the west bank Arabs were just that- Arabs without the artificial colonial divisions.
Oh, yeah. If you think that the Slovaks did not want independence before 90s, that's another evidence of know nothingness.
So?...... On that theory, any country which shares strong regional linguistic and cultural resemblances with its neighbours doesn't get to be a country?

Therefore, Venezuela should belong to Colombia? And Uruguay should belong to Argentina? And they should all belong to Spain?

And the US - which is English-speaking and didn't show any desire to leave the British Empire before 1770 should still belong to Britain?
 
So?...... On that theory, any country which shares strong regional linguistic and cultural resemblances with its neighbours doesn't get to be a country?

Therefore, Venezuela should belong to Colombia? And Uruguay should belong to Argentina? And they should all belong to Spain?

And the US - which is English-speaking and didn't show any desire to leave the British Empire before 1770 should still belong to Britain?
Oh, please. Look into it instead of spitballing for the sake of spitballing.
 
Don't start a war and bad things may be avoided.

How are Palestinians, the local population, the ones who started a war against a foreign colonial movement?
I'm sure you think Palestinians were responsible for this too?

 
Comparison is a valid one, JC.

Prove me wrong.
And to continue this conversation would be to what purpose? I called your ignorance on the Slovaks and you jump to South America. And now, you seem to think that the peoples of South America were homogeneous at some point like the Arabs of the Levant. Wrong again. I'd love to have a serious conversation, but you ain't it.
 
And now 2/3's of Palestinians live as stateless refugees.
...
Too bad that the Arab states that started the war have kept their brothers locked up in camps instead of integrating them like Israel did for the 800,000 Jews chased from their Arab homes.

No surprise that you know as little about history as you do about morality.

You really should not pretend to speak for Palestinians.
Interesting coming from a guy who perpetually demands Palestinians be forced into a peace they hate.

Also worth mentioning is that polling of those stateless Palestinians says that very few of them actually want to live in Israel. The vast majority want to live either in a Palestinian state, the countries they were born in, or third countries like Canada.
 
So?...... On that theory, any country which shares strong regional linguistic and cultural resemblances with its neighbours doesn't get to be a country?
...
As I said, until 1949, there was no cultural or linguistic differences between Palestinians, Lebanese, Syrians, and many Jordanians. In fact Palestinian elite often had property all over the former Ottoman province. The Palestinian identity arose because their brethren kept them locked up as pawns and as Jordan's Hashemite leadership ruled the West Bank.

There is a Palestinian identity now but there wasn't back then. And what is telling from posters like Frank is the continual insistence that Palestinians have a right to a nation state but the generations of Israeli Jews don't.
 
How are Palestinians, the local population, the ones who started a war against a foreign colonial movement?
...
The continual asinine claims that Jews are foreign colonizers. But what can we expect from someone who believes in emotional statements to justify hatred over reality.
 
And to continue this conversation would be to what purpose? I called your ignorance on the Slovaks and you jump to South America. And now, you seem to think that the peoples of South America were homogeneous at some point like the Arabs of the Levant. Wrong again. I'd love to have a serious conversation, but you ain't it.
The people of South America not homogenous?.... Maybe, if you compare Chileans to Colombians.

But Ecuador, Venezuela and Colombia were once united in one country. As were Uruguayans and Argentinians.

And we both know that you couldn't stand up in a "serious conversation" with me for more than a couple of exchanges. That's why you insult me and then run away - like you do in every thread where I call out your bullshit.
 
Too bad that the Arab states that started the war have kept their brothers locked up in camps instead of integrating them like Israel did for the 800,000 Jews chased from their Arab homes.

No surprise that you know as little about history as you do about morality.

No surprise that you think the native population is responsible for starting a war and not the foreign colonial movement whose stated goal was to take all of Palestine.

Interesting coming from a guy who perpetually demands Palestinians be forced into a peace they hate.

You are the one demanding Palestinians submit to apartheid occupation. Are you claiming they love apartheid?
I support the Palestinian BDS movement, which only asks for the end of apartheid.

Also worth mentioning is that polling of those stateless Palestinians says that very few of them actually want to live in Israel. The vast majority want to live either in a Palestinian state, the countries they were born in, or third countries like Canada.

You shouldn't pretend to speak for Palestinians when you want to force them to live under an apartheid occupation.
 
The people of South America not homogenous?.... Maybe, if you compare Chileans to Colombians.

But Ecuador, Venezuela and Colombia were once united in one country. As were Uruguayans and Argentinians.

And we both know that you couldn't stand up in a "serious conversation" with me for more than a couple of exchanges. That's why you insult me and then run away - like you do in every thread where I call out your bullshit.
Did the Indigenous of the Amazon speak Quechua? Various parts of the South America developed distinctive cultures in the pre Columbian times, separate cultures and, in many cases, completely different and incompatible languages, beliefs, customs. The Spanish and Portuguese occupation could not even erase those differences. Even when morphed with European cultures they remained distinct. You just spew garbage for an unknown reason. It can't be all simply for my amusement. But, do yourself a favor and look into a subject before opining. At least you won't look like such a fool.
 
And the US - which is English-speaking and didn't show any desire to leave the British Empire before 1770 should still belong to Britain?
And have to go all metric?? NEVER!!!
 
Did the Indigenous of the Amazon speak Quechua? Various parts of the South America developed distinctive cultures in the pre Columbian times, separate cultures and, in many cases, completely different and incompatible languages, beliefs, customs. The Spanish and Portuguese occupation could not even erase those differences. Even when morphed with European cultures they remained distinct. You just spew garbage for an unknown reason. It can't be all simply for my amusement. But, do yourself a favor and look into a subject before opining. At least you won't look like such a fool.
Oh dear, we're upset are we?

Read my above post and explain to me whether there were differences in the creole cultures of Colombia and Venezuela.
 
Oh dear, we're upset are we?

Read my above post and explain to me whether there were differences in the creole cultures of Colombia and Venezuela.
LOL!!! The Levantine Arabs were homogenous culturally, linguistically and religiously. The West Bank Arabs didn't become "Palestinians " until Jordan lost the war in 67. There's no comparison to the people of the continental South America. Frankly, it's one of the most idiotic ideas I've ever heard.
 
LOL!!! The Levantine Arabs were homogenous culturally, linguistically and religiously. The West Bank Arabs didn't become "Palestinians " until Jordan lost the war in 67. There's no comparison to the people of the continental South America. Frankly, it's one of the most idiotic ideas I've ever heard.
So explain why?

And explain why it matters?.... Different populations that are culturally and linguistically homogenous get to have different countries. Bet you're one of those guys who think that Alberta should separate. Or the Red States should separate from the Blue States. America was culturally and linguistically homogenous with the UK in 1770. Do New Zealand and Australia get to be separate countries?

Is there a rule against non homogenous populations coming together as 1 country?..... Should Bavaria and Prussia not have joined together in 1870? How about Belgium - 2 different populations in1 country?
 
LOL!!! The Levantine Arabs were homogenous culturally, linguistically and religiously. The West Bank Arabs didn't become "Palestinians " until Jordan lost the war in 67. There's no comparison to the people of the continental South America. Frankly, it's one of the most idiotic ideas I've ever heard.

No more idiotic than 'A land without a people for a people without a land'
 
So explain why?

And explain why it matters?.... Different populations that are culturally and linguistically homogenous get to have different countries. Bet you're one of those guys who think that Alberta should separate. Or the Red States should separate from the Blue States. America was culturally and linguistically homogenous with the UK in 1770. Do New Zealand and Australia get to be separate countries?

Is there a rule against non homogenous populations coming together as 1 country?..... Should Bavaria and Prussia not have joined together in 1870? How about Belgium - 2 different populations in1 country?
What? New Zealand and Australia now? 😆 You don't see water between those countries? Water SEPARATES. Why did Germany unify? Because they were GERMANIC peoples of the same language and culture. How are Palestinian Arabs different from Syrian or the Jordanian Arabs? Anyway, stupid conversation.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: mandrill