Maine School Social Worker Secretly Gender-Transitioned 13-Year-Old Girl with Chest binder to flatten her breast.

I bet if you as a social worker did that to my child . I will launch a civil suit against you or the school board!

You mean if a social worker listened to your child and tried to help them, you would sue that social worker?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
If this happened it is indeed outrageous.

The social worker should have reached out to her parents not given the girl a chest binder. If I was the parent, I would be livid.

The kid should have also been counselled, along with her parents, to give it a few more years until she was mature enough to truly know whether or not she wanted a transition.
 
If this happened it is indeed outrageous.

The social worker should have reached out to her parents not given the girl a chest binder. If I was the parent, I would be livid.

The kid should have also been counselled, along with her parents, to give it a few more years until she was mature enough to truly know whether or not she wanted a transition.

But you don't know what the kid told the social worker.
That's the thing here - the social worker's responsibility is to the kid, not the parents.
If the kid says they can't have the parents know, the social worker is going to default to the kid's version of events absent other evidence.

That this is being framed as if the social worker somehow forced the kid to transition is silly. If there is evidence of that, sure, let's see it, but with all we know now (the kid wore a binder, the social worker helped get it, the mom didn't know) the most likely story is the kid asked for help and the social worker helped the kid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: toguy5252
But you don't know what the kid told the social worker.
That's the thing here - the social worker's responsibility is to the kid, not the parents.
If the kid says they can't have the parents know, the social worker is going to default to the kid's version of events absent other evidence.

That this is being framed as if the social worker somehow forced the kid to transition is silly. If there is evidence of that, sure, let's see it, but with all we know now (the kid wore a binder, the social worker helped get it, the mom didn't know) the most likely story is the kid asked for help and the social worker helped the kid.

I think that is why I mentioned that the parents and the kid should have been counselled.

It is just as likely that the social worker was a woke SJW and took matters into his own hands. It is further troubling that he asked her to keep it secret from her parents.

And regardless, even if a 13 year old says they cant have the parents know, the parents should have been informed and counselled provided there was no physical danger to the kid.


 
Last edited:
I think that is why I mentioned that the parents and the kid should have been counselled.

If the kid comes in and says the parents will kill him for transitioning, what benefit does telling the parents do?

It is just as likely that the social worker was a woke SJW and took matters into his own hands. It is further troubling that he asked her to keep it secret from her parents.

Considering the mom said that this was them sexually grooming the kid, then keeping it hidden from the mom to minimize danger to the child seems very reasonably.
And since the mom is accusing the whole school of having been in on it, "a woke SJW" who "took matters into his own hands" doesn't seem likely.


Now, according to this article, the new social worker never reached out to introduce themselves and the parents weren't informed there had been a change in social workers and that I agree should have been done.


I wonder if we will see threats against him.
 
If the kid comes in and says the parents will kill him for transitioning, what benefit does telling the parents do?

Then the solution is not a chest binder and secrecy but for child protective services to get involved in light of such impending physical harm.

Considering the mom said that this was them sexually grooming the kid, then keeping it hidden from the mom to minimize danger to the child seems very reasonably.
And since the mom is accusing the whole school of having been in on it, "a woke SJW" who "took matters into his own hands" doesn't seem likely.

Now, according to this article, the new social worker never reached out to introduce themselves and the parents weren't informed there had been a change in social workers and that I agree should have been done.

I wonder if we will see threats against him.

Any parent would be livid and say those words. Apparently there was a social transitioning of some sort that was going on with the school using male pronouns to address the kid etc.,The kid is 13 years old, and just reaching puberty. Sexual impulses and preferences develop and change at this age. For the school to just take matters into their own hands, and not even inform the parents of a SW change, is not acceptable procedure. Parents should have the final say in anything regarding their kids and if the kids were in actual physical harm, then child protective services and legal help should be sought.

The SW kid does look like one of these woke gay hippies btw. I wouldn't be surprised if this was just a case of jumping the gun in an attempt to be woke and do the right thing.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mellowjello
Then the solution is not a chest binder and secrecy but for child protective services to get involved in light of such impending physical harm.

If it was an actual threat of murder, sure.
If it was a kid describing what life at home was like, then no.

Any parent would be livid and say those words.

No.
Any parent isn't going to immediately accuse everyone of sexually grooming their kid - get real.

Apparently there was a social transitioning of some sort that was going on with the school using male pronouns to address the kid etc.,The kid is 13 years old, and just reaching puberty.

Which is why social transitioning is appropriate.

Sexual impulses and preferences develop and change at this age.

Exactly. And giving the child a safe space to figure this shit out is important.

For the school to just take matters into their own hands, and not even inform the parents of a SW change, is not acceptable procedure.

I completely agree the parents should be made aware of who the social worker is and not being informed of the change was bad.

Parents should have the final say in anything regarding their kids and if the kids were in actual physical harm, then child protective services and legal help should be sought.

Fuck no, parents should not have final say in everything regarding their kids.

The SW kid does look like one of these woke gay hippies btw. I wouldn't be surprised if this was just a case of jumping the gun in an attempt to be woke and do the right thing.

That remains possible.
But there are a lot of unanswered questions here.
How long has the kid been trying to transition?
What resistance were they seeing at home?
What happened with the previous social worker?
Why was the case transferred.

Right now, this looks like "kid has been wanting to transition for a while, social worker helped out". Very common for someone to transition in one space (friend group, school, whatever) and not another as they work out their identity.

The fact that this is being framed as "the social worker made my kid transition" makes it seem very likely that the kid is the one who wanted this and this has been going on for a while with the parents opposed to it.
There is a political agenda to push about the "evil woke transgender agenda" so a narrative has to be crafted.

I would like to think we would learn more details over time, but the point of these stories is to have the headline stick with people because the reality doesn't help the political agenda.
 
If it was an actual threat of murder, sure.
If it was a kid describing what life at home was like, then no.

Then the kid and the parents like I said should have been counselled in that case.

No.
Any parent isn't going to immediately accuse everyone of sexually grooming their kid - get real.
What will they say then? A 13 year old kid is given a chest binder, different pronouns are being used etc with the parents not even being informed. What do you expect the mother to call that?

Which is why social transitioning is appropriate. Exactly. And giving the child a safe space to figure this shit out is important.
It is not appropriate one bit. Especially not without the parents knowledge. A 13 year old kid needs time to mature and then make a decision on whether or not they want to transition.

Fuck no, parents should not have final say in everything regarding their kids.
They absolutely should and be responsible for their kids especially when they are 13.

That remains possible.
But there are a lot of unanswered questions here.
How long has the kid been trying to transition?
What resistance were they seeing at home?
What happened with the previous social worker?
Why was the case transferred.
Underage kids should not be allowed to transition in the first place. The kid is 13, let them go through puberty first. Let them mature and then figure out whether or not they want to transition at 18 or something.

Agreed there are lots of unanswered questions, but given the lack of evidence that there was something wrong at home, we have to assume that everything at home was okay. At best the parents were conservative, in which case they could have been counselled. The kid wasn't having issues in school, had a mother who actually looked through things and talked to the kid to find out what happened. Cared enough to show up to the meeting. I am pretty sure they were good parents.

I dont care about the political agenda. And am not anti-trans. But a) Parents should always be kept informed b) Gender transitions on 13 year olds should not be done socially or otherwise, without parents consent and without giving the kid an opportunity to mature and really know that, that is what they want.

Schools and other educational institutions are performative woke these days which is a valid criticism.
 
Do you think the child is wearing the binder behind their parents' back because they aren't scared of their mom's disapproval?
So why would the social worker allow the child to return home? Why not call children's aid if you believe the child is in danger?

Hell, I'll even go as far to say what gives a social worker the medical right to mentally diagnose a child?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: krealtarron
There was nothing wrong with this until she said "If your parents find it in the laundry...." And "If you're a YOUNG PERSON needing a discreet binder ..."

This is how they low key groom.

A REAL activist promotes truthful and honest opinions and does not promote SECRETLY being who you think you are.
Nah. You're clearly not aware that teenagers have their own constitutional right to privacy - which trumps mom and dad's nosiness. I posted the case link a few weeks back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
So then why would the social worker allow the child to return home? Why not call children's aid if you believe the child is in danger?

Hell, I'll even go as far to say what give a social worker the medical right to mentally diagnose a child?

Exactly this social worker isn't some expert in anything.

Just a kid who has still not graduated out of college.

He most likely was just being woke and jumped the gun. People are now jumping over hoops to find a possible reason why doing something to an underage kid behind their parents back should be acceptable.

The mom did the right thing pulling the kid out of school. Hope they find a better school than this where parents are always kept updated.
 
Not if they wanted to keep their job.


p.s. This isn't any kind of medical 'transitioning', it's wearing a sturdy shirt.

Even socially transitioning a kid, or giving them chest binders is inappropriate without the parents knowledge and consent.
 
Even socially transitioning a kid, or giving them chest binders is inappropriate without the parents knowledge and consent.
WTF is "socially transitioning"? Is that a new buzzword from people trying to dictate what kids can wear?


I know it's confusing but pre-puberty, there's not a huge physical difference between boys and girls. So what if a kid wants to continue that until they are old enough to figure out who they are?



And I'm glad that Canada allows children to make their own medical choices when capable to prevent overzealous adults like you trying to impose their own will.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
WTF is "socially transitioning"? Is that a new buzzword from people trying to dictate what kids can wear?

I know it's confusing but pre-puberty, there's not a huge physical difference between boys and girls. So what if a kid wants to continue that until they are old enough to figure out who they are?

That was the word in the article. Not something I invented.

This was not about a kid wanting to act a different gender etc., This was about being transgender, and this social worker helping the kid be so in some way, without the parents consent.

My issue is that the parents weren't informed.

Even in Canada medical transition meaning surgery wont be performed until parental/guardian permission is given if under 18.
 
Last edited:
That was the word in the article. Not something I invented.
This was not about a kid wanting to act a different gender etc., This was about being transgender,
...
How is wearing a sturdy shirt to hide breasts any different from wearing a baggy sweater to do the same? There is absolutely nothing medical here, just making a suggestion about clothes that make the kid feel comfortable. I'm sure a generation ago you'd be complaining that a school said it was okay for girls to wear pants instead of skirts if the alt-right decided to push the trans/grooming narrative.

And are you really trying to compare figure hiding clothes to surgery?


No hormones, no surgery, just a kid wearing clothes they want to wear. Do you think a school should inform the parents if a girl decided to take off their hijab during the day too?
 
How is wearing a sturdy shirt to hide breasts any different from wearing a baggy sweater to do the same? There is absolutely nothing medical here, just making a suggestion about clothes that make the kid feel comfortable. I'm sure a generation ago you'd be complaining that a school said it was okay for girls to wear pants instead of skirts if the alt-right decided to push the trans/grooming narrative.



And are you really trying to compare figure hiding clothes to surgery?

It is not about what the girl was wearing. It is about the fact that this social worker gave this girl a chest binder, and the school started using male pronouns to address the kid, advised the kid to keep it secret from her parents, and did it all behind the parents back. Let us not digress from the issue.
 
So why would the social worker allow the child to return home? Why not call children's aid if you believe the child is in danger?

Hell, I'll even go as far to say what gives a social worker the medical right to mentally diagnose a child?

Exactly. Many questions which are not answered in the inflammatory article and no one on this board has the answers. This was likely a very difficult situation for both the child and the social worker.