you lack the stones to make a logical argument
People who pick actual positions that tend to lie in the center, and that reflect good government.
People disagree but a lot of that disagreement is based on ignorance or naked self interest.
I am not saying there is only one path to good policy, that would be were going middle of the road is important.
However there are policies that are better and policies that are worse. I'd argue the point but quite frankly it's late and I doubt it will end well.
We have a FPTP system as do jolly old England. Those third parties stick around even though it hurts their cause. Don't underestimate the Rhinos ability to ignore the world around them and be stubborn.
I don't really know 'merican history so I with withdraw my comments on the subject then fight on a hill I don't have a good map for.
However I think the US is in a position where a third party could come up the middle. I can't speak for the distant past but both the Rs and the Ds have abandoned the center and gone a but nutty.
As I mentioned, the Rhinos are too stubborn to see that if one part could be more moderate they would trash the other but the base has become more concerned with being right and passing their agenda or nothing at all than having a shot at power. The only reason Biden won was because he was running against a ratbag like Trump, that he only beat him by a few percentage points in the popular vote is telling. However the Ds are all, we won, we are running this beatch. They should be more concerned with why they didn't win 2/3 to 1/3.
That being said if a party was to come up the center, drag moderates away from both other parties and have them more dominated by the extreme wings, they would have a pretty good shot at some traction and I wouldn't see any parties being absorbed.
In the past, well the recent past at least, if you ignored the partizan whining of the true believers, one could easily refer to the republicrats and the dempublicans. We still basically have that here also. In the 90s all major parties were moved almost lock stock and barrel from being forever A Loan to being surplus happy, in the greater scheme of things they were not all that different. They still aren't for the most part today. Over and over again, to win you need to occupy the center or at least be close to it.
that meme is quite representative of reality. As pointed out earlier you dismiss it due to flawed logic based on a dumb assumption
View attachment 160845
But "I want parties to be more in the center" has nothing to do with why you will end up with only 2 parties.
stupid people fall for third party bullshit all the time.
If "stupid people" did fall for 3rd party bullshit all of the time, wouldn't there now be three parties all of the time?Mind you, stupid people fall for third party bullshit all the time.
Nice try
I addressed the structural issue and pointed out how despicable it is
More importantly you described "stupid people fall for third party bullshit"
again an extremely arrogant view of others who recognise how the current two party system is not working
Dutch Oven is far more perceptive and honest than you.
Picking a position should be based on evaluating the interests of all, not based on ideology
Hence the need for debate, compromise yet you think anyone who finds the current polarization dysfunctional and look to a 3rd party as a possible solution as "stupid people fall for third party bullshit"
history does not dictate the future
a third party which forces the democrats to take a step back towards the center would be a good thing. It is not important if that 3rd party is later absorbed
Similarly if a third party prevents another polarizing right leader like Donald Trump would be a good thing.
Are you that slow that you do not recognise the benefits of a decade where political polarization is reduced ?
the US political polarization peaked just before the civil war
A big pile of dead body's & occupation forced the democrats to change
the democrats need to change again
A step back to the right by the democrats is required & the republicans would become less defensive and more open to compromise
the republicans need a different leader than Donald Trump
If "stupid people" did fall for 3rd party bullshit all of the time, wouldn't there now be three parties all of the time?
Third party victories occur.
They surprise every one and cause a few coronaries. They usually come out of nowhere and ignored by the pundits, pollsters and party aparatchik.
Once elected the man is beaten down ( by EVERYBODY ) so he wont get a second term and disrupt their delicate world.

Your assumption that the US political system will always reduce to two parties, is not a valid reason for
again, who cares if the democrats absorb the 3rd party 10 years latter just so long as the democrats take a step right, away from their present insanity ?
- incorrectly assuming a 3rd party would not impact the current destructive political polarization
- incorrectly assuming anyone seeking to fix the current political polarization is stupid i.e
]If your position is "a third party of note would be good because it would realign the system after it gets reabsorbed" (assuming it wasn't such a huge success that one of the other two parties collapsed and it just replaced it outright) then I have no problem with that.
The next question is how to make even a strong enough showing to have that effect.
You need a real issue that neither party is addressing. (Usually because one is outright opposed and the other just doesn't want to engage with it.)
They also started a civil war which killed more US soldiers than all other wars combined.The most successful third party in US history is the Republican party. They got in and replaced the Whigs because they addressed Slavery and opposing its expansion.
You seem to think this third party will force the Democrats to the right - so what does this third party rally around to do that?
No such assumption
I simply stated if the third party positively impacted the polarization and then got absorbed so be it
it surviving independently and positively impact current polarization would be Ok as well
Of coarse there is also the scenario where a 3rd party is more heavily aligned with the right and splits the right vote resulting in a perpetual left govt.
Visa versa if to heavily aligned with the left splits the left vote resulting in a perpetual right govt.
That would be very counterproductive as the incumbent would never be healed accountable by the ballot box
Nope
I am pretty sure the reality of the Democrats energy policy, the damage their inflation is causing and Joe Bidens ineffectiveness will be sufficient for many to reject the looniie left democrats
I am pretty sure the current alternative Donald Trump is a revolting prospect for a lot of swing voters
A 3rd party who is committed to sound fiscal policy, sound energy security policy vs ideology driven policy and who is not led by Donald Trump will be quite appealing
They also started a civil war which killed more US soldiers than all other wars combined.
Yes.most successful ??
history does not always repeat itself
The issues are different
The polarization is not geographically defined as in the 1860s
They could start by simply stating
1. We are not AOC, Iliad Omar or the other two nuts.
2. We are not Joe Biden
3. We are defiantly not socialists
4. Policy will not be driven by ideology
6. Smaller govt is better
7. Our leader will not be Donald Trump
And here I thought you were making sense.
My mistake.
says you and that is not worth shitAnd that party would then collapse or be absorbed because it wasn't sustainable and was being counter productive.
(There is a reason the Greens and the Libertarians exist but don't get a lot of support. 2016 was a highwater mark for them and they didn't crack 5% combined.
mission accomplished !!!!!Hey!
At least you have a pitch.
"Republicans but not Trump" isn't going to do very well, though. All you need is the Republicans to nominate not Trump and your third party is toast.
Democrats have completely abandoned both & will pay dearly for allowing ideology to dictate policyIt is possible that "sound fiscal policy" and "sound energy security policy" can be pitched in a way that argues neither Republicans or Democrats are addressing it properly, you might have something.
Really depends on what your ideological pitch is going to be and how you make it sound like you are talking about something completely different than either major party.
If people are worried enough about fiscal policy and energy security, maybe you can make some inroads.
"started"
Yes.
They were a third party, and they replaced one of the current dominant parties of the time and have no been in existence for 170 years.
That's the most successful third party in US history.
Exactly. That makes it even harder for a third party to succeed in this structural context.
The only thing you have here is "not socialist" and "smaller government".
No one is going to vote for that ideology in any significant amount.
Do you at least mean "We don't support Trumpism" in number 7 there?
Is this just the party of Liz Cheney and Adam Kinzinger?
"It's just the same Republican Party, but without Trump" isn't going to work as a third party.
1, If they are not AOC, Iliad Omar or the other two nuts.
2. If they are not Joe Biden
3. If they are not socialists
4. If their policies will not be driven by ideology
6. If they feel Smaller govt is better
7. If their leader will not be Donald Trump
You don't understand the structural issue, as you so adeptly demonstrated.
Yes.
Because third parties that are just about "vibes" and "things aren't working" are bullshit in the current system.
Yet you are unable to describe "what is going on"At the very least, people who want a third party to rise up and replace one of the current parties and drive it from the field understand what is going on.
Calling something "Bullshit" is not an persuasive argumentPeople who talk about "third party" sticking around and offering new choices but don't understand why that doesn't happen in the US are bullshit.
Calling something "being stupid" is not an persuasive argumentPeople who treat voting as an aesthetic consumer choice are being stupid.
you assume voters are incapable of independent evaluation and all are permanently tethered to either red or blueAnd people will disagree on what those interests are and how to balance them based on their ideology.
No, people looking for solutions are good.
People pitching third party bullshit are stupid.
People pitching non-bullshit party and/or electoral reform are people I support.
Says youBut that's not what we're talking about.
Do you not believe the current political polarization & ineffective govt is a crisis ?A third party that emerges in a time of crisis and then gets reabsorbed or causes the other party to wither away is nothing I oppose and is the normal trajectory for third parties in the US.
Again - you need either a strong regional base or you need a major issue not being addressed by the current two major parties that lets the third party make the kind of headway needed.
This would then result in the system then re-stabilizing to two parties unless the entire electoral system changed.
So what is the major issue that you think this new party can run on that will give them a road to effect real change?
Similarly your rejection of less political polarization & more compromise paints you as a die hard ideologueWow. That right there says a lot about you, doesn't it.
I agree with this statement, even though I think the reasons why they do are different.
What infallible rule of physics states it would be the 3rd party which gets absorbed?
Obviously if a center left party were to be formed its because the democrats have ventured too far left into the realm of fantasy ( AKA AOC)
politics can be a nasty game - fools who bring a disaster upon their party are generally not fogiven
What infallible rule of physics states any party must get absorbed if there are three?
the reason is there platforms were just not appealing
that will happen if there are 3, 4, 5, or even 6 ... parties
there were 21 different political parties registered with elections Canada for the last election
obviously there aee a number platforms which were just not appealing
mission accomplished !!!!!
ie a reduction in political polarization & a republican victory
please start paying attention
Democrats have completely abandoned both & will pay dearly for allowing ideology to dictate policy
The number one concern of Americans is "The Cost of Living"
The inflation monster will ensure the democrats get wiped out in the mid-terms
inflation is also predicted to be sticky so they are very likly in trouble for 2024
do not read bigotry into that statement, it is simply a fact
Replacing an old party is hardly the definitive measure of success
THE NDP replaced the CFC and CLC , yet consistently finish third in a three horse race
I would have thought the abolition of slavery would have been cited as the republicans claim to success
at a cost of a civil war and more than half a million young men killed
ah no
The democrats are making a mess in all states & all Americans are experiencing the impacts of inflation on their cost of living
That is not an ideology, that is just plain common sense

What part of Donald Trump is a politically polarizing person are you not understanding ?
It would be best for the republicans & the USA if he did not run again
FYI: if the democrat shit show continues Trump will win if he runs again
& Joe Biden is not going to turn that ship around
Its more likely Joe Biden will have a mutinty on his hands - AOC and the other loonies are not team players
1, If they are not AOC, Iliad Omar or the other two nuts.
2. If they are not Joe Biden
3. If they are not socialists
4. If their policies will not be driven by ideology
6. If they feel Smaller govt is better
7. If their leader will not be Donald Trump
they could join
These elusive Structural issues you apparently can not explain clearly
Do you deny the ever increasing political polarization in the U.S. has resulted in a far less effective government ?
Yet you are unable to describe "what is going on"
More and more people will soon start to view voting as an opportunity to remove fools from office before they do more damage
you assume voters are incapable of independent evaluation and all are permanently tethered to either red or blue
Of course there are swing voters in such a system.Unlike die hard uncompromising ideologues such as yourself, there a lot of swing voters
Again , if a third party reduces political polarization, then it is a solution
electoral reform- sadly proposed electoral reforms will only be supported by the party which will reap the political benefit
Says you
You do not get ring fense the discussion
Do you not believe the current political polarization & ineffective govt is a crisis ?
and again, so what if one of the 3 parties does not survive the long run if political polarization is reduced?
Mission accomplished !!!!!!!!
The major issue is offering an alternative to the path to socialism while not being Donald Trump
Similarly your rejection of less political polarization & more compromise paints you as a die hard ideologue
A step back to the right by the democrats is required & the republicans would become less defensive and more open to compromise
Let's be clear then
The democrats are failing miserably (the cost of living) & Joe Biden will not be able to turn the ship around
He will become a lame duck president in November
The republicans can win in 2024 , with or without Trump as the candidate
Trump has a nasty, mean spirited, abrasive personality
He is also a polarizing person,
So best he not run in order to reduce political polarization
you are under the delusion that only Trump can derail the suicidal march towards socialism
None.
As I have said repeatedly.
Maybe you should stick to misunderstanding high school physics.
Politics may be a bit too complicated.
Especially if you think the laws of physics are involved.
Now who is misunderstanding physics ?Physics isn't really involved here.
Yes.
In the US there were 21 candidates on the ballot in Vermont.
Including federal and statewide elections there are almost 30 parties with ballot access in the US.
None of that is what we are talking about, as I've made clear repeatedly.
I am.
That one possible outcomeYour scenario means we are back to two parties, as I said would happen.
I tried in the earlier post to give you credit that you were actually arguing for what has been the successful model of a third party and then you insisted you weren't.
Not sure why you now think this is some kind of gotcha.
Besides which, "The Republicans pick someone other than Trump" is called a primary.
(I'm not going to get into "primaries as coalition negotiations pre-general election versus coalition in multi-party systems post-general" and in what ways they are meaningfully different. You're struggling enough already.)
I guess you can modify it to "Democrats have abandoned both and the Republicans are too obsessed with culture wars to focus on this properly" and it could work.
As I said the democrats has made such a mess the republicans will win in 2024 with or without TrumpBut since you just want to take over the Republican party anyway and not last long, that's fine.
Running as "the anti-inflation party" can get you a run like Perot's I bet.
One good election where you get 0 electoral votes, then be less relevant in 4 years as the other parties adopt some of your policies and rhetoric, and then irrelevant after that.
Given that the GOP refuses to have a plan for inflation, this gives you your "sound fiscal policy" schtick from earlier.
I do think this could be the basis for a successful third party run, where you are relevant for less than a decade before it collapses back to two parties.
again,No.
But that has nothing to do with whether the electoral structure of the US can support a major third party for any length of time.
Good luck with that.The major issue is offering an alternative to the path to socialism while not being Donald Trump
do not presume to speak for meSo you are rooting for any of the other candidates to unseat him in the primary, right?
But the geographical dispersal means that a third party has to have the Democrats collapse across the country to contest seriously or replace them.
Much harder to build up strength when you can get lots of votes and have no effect at all.
t let's do a thought experiment.
Trump - despite your wishes - wins the GOP nomination.
The Democrats are spiraling towards socialism.
Do you run a third party candidate on your "sound fiscal policy, anti-inflation, sound energy security" party platform since you think Trump should not be running and the Democrats are dangerous to the country
i understand physics much better than you
Yeah. I have never heard a fellow physicist say stuff like that. Hilarious....Couldn't stop laughing here so didn't read the rest.....