Denying Holocaust Will be Illegal

Status
Not open for further replies.
You’re not in charge of deciding which studies merit serious consideration. We ALL are. Which is why speech has to come first, and review and debate later. There is no way to evaluate a study before It is communicated in public.
You're right, I'm not. And as I mentioned, there is still extensive discussion of the history of the Holocaust, even in Germany. You simply seem to be yammering on about something without even bothering to get informed about it.
 
It explicitly says criticism of Israel is not necessarily anti-Semitic but thanks to your pre-existing bias, you still claim otherwise as part of the double standard quoted in Canada's definition.

You've used it to claim my criticism of Israeli government policy is antisemitic.
You disproved your own claim.


[And pathetic again, instead of talking about the overtly racist Holocaust denial, you simply want to bitch about Israel. The IHRA definition was adopted by Canada (but I'm sure I can guess your interpretation of Canada acted that way).

I am complaining about the liberals enacting on a hateful definition of antisemitism.
Your denial of the Nabka and your continual Islamaphobic attitudes towards Palestinians shows that those who focus on racism against only one people are typically exhibiting racism themselves.
 
Does that matter?
Actually, yes.

The fact that nobody questions slavery, is because everybody knows it's true and even without slavery there are enough other examples of prejudice and atrocities against blacks it wouldn't change the narrative.

The only people who want to question the Holocaust have an agenda. They are anti-Semites. The fact that it's been such a long time, means that their hateful lies may possibly seem credible to people who are not well-informed of the events of WWII. Hence, their racist BS has the potential to be spread. A strong law preventing Holocaust denial helps to prevent this spread of racism.

The Holocaust occurred and only anti-Semites want to question it to help spread their hate.
 
Wouldn't hate prompt them to celebrate the holocaust?
They probably do so, but only in private.

Nobody can publicly argue that killing 6M Jews is a good thing. It is supporting genocide. It's a bad look.

So instead, pretending that the Holocaust didn't happen washes their hands because they can't be blamed for something that didn't happen.
 
You've used it to claim my criticism of Israeli government policy is antisemitic.
...
Because you check of many of the boxes on that list. Plenty of people including myself criticize Israeli policy without justifying groups like Hamas, portraying a double standard, accusing Jews of being more loyal to Israel than their own country and denying self determination for only Israelis.
 
Because you check of many of the boxes on that list. Plenty of people including myself criticize Israeli policy without justifying groups like Hamas, portraying a double standard, accusing Jews of being more loyal to Israel than their own country and denying self determination for only Israelis.

Thanks for confirming that the IHRA definition targets criticism of Israeli government policy, as I said.
Of course if you were against racism and hate, you'd have posted about the latest rounds of mobs.

So now it's hateful to admit that there is anti-semitism? Wow.
Its hateful to claim you are against racism while supporting apartheid and these kinds of mobs.


 
Thanks for confirming that the IHRA definition targets criticism of Israeli government policy, as I said.
...
Thanks for confirming that your hatred overrides your literacy skills. You just don't like that Canada's definition of antisemitism calls out your anti-Semitic behaviour.
 
Thanks for confirming that your hatred overrides your literacy skills. You just don't like that Canada's definition of antisemitism calls out your anti-Semitic behaviour.

The IHRA definition of antisemitism would label 25% of US Jews as antisemitic.
That definition labels IJVCanada, If Not Now, Breaking the Silence, B'tselem, Amnesty, HRW and the UN as antisemitic.


Your racism on this thread is so strong that I won't even publish Palestinian views because you would instantly claim they are racist and hate filled.
Every single time.

Just stop defending apartheid.
 
But those things are never debated, because they are accepted as fact.

And if they were debated they have nothing to do with attempted destruction of a race that has hated and persecuted and there are many people who'd like to see it happen again. People who want to supposedly debate do nothing more than encourage and embolden those people. The only motivation for denial is anti-Semitism, pure and simple. It has nothing to do with any doubts or vagaries of history because there are none. The Holocaust happened just as sure as the sun came up.
They are accepted as fact because they can be proven as fact, and that requires free speech.

Your second paragraph needs to be supported by evidence, and logic. they are merely unsupported statements.

See? You still have to defend these things.
 
Yes, yes, and yes. Unless you are transparently making shit up to promote hatred.

There is nothing wrong with examining the exact number. Trying to pretend it was tens of thousands is completely false based on the facts. Trying to claim it was 100 million would be just as farcical. And more importantly, this kind of academic discussion should be done by academics, not on twitter, You know, a place where people have some level of standards and rigor to actually give evidence.

There are many documented cases of non-German people complicit in the Holocaust. There are also many documented cases of Germans who worked to prevent killings. Trying to pretend that it wasn't an organized plan by the Nazis to kill people based on ethnicity is patently false.

There are also quite a lot of study on the progression of the Holocaust from work camps, and expulsions to outright murder camps. Very few historians actually believe that the original intent was to run execution camps. To deny that can only be motivated by hatred.


The door isn't closed, at least to anyone willing to investigate using rigor. Most of the Holocaust deniers though don't do this and simply claims the evidence was simply fabricated as part of the very Jewish conspiracy the Nazis believed in.
Nonsense to the academics, they are as influenced and prone to following fads as anyone else.

Good God, please don't tell me that you are so naiive as to think that we should let academics run the world. who decides who gets to be academics, by the way? If governments control free speech, then they control academics too (if they themselves aren't already in fact controlled by academicsQ!

It is so ridiculous, you SAY YOURSEF that it is ridiculous based on the FACTs, yet you refuse to allow the facts to be discussed and debated!

If things are PATENTLY FALSE, then what's the problem?

You know, this reminds me of the LCBO and the Beer Store, in defending their monopoly.

They say, "why we have so much choice, such a huge selection, if you go to the convenience store you won't have the ability to make a selection from such a huge array of microbreweries, etc, from all over the world".

To which the onloy response is, "Well, then , why on Earth do you feel you have anything to fear if you are obviously the best?"

Look, all sorts of issues have all sorts of idiots peddling all sorts of nonsense.

But control of free speech is INSANELY DANGEROUS. YES IT IS.

And it is clearly anti-democratic.

Democracy believes in the common sense of the common man - EVENTUALLY. Academics hate that. They are hung up on their own brilliance, which surely MUST be better than the guy drinking a pint watching a Raptors game at the local bar. Authoritarians hate that. They peddle that that the common man is stupid, he can't decide intelligently, Yet - show me the planned economy, the economy run by academics, authoritarians, that performs better then free market economies? Or better still, that people of their own free will want to emigrate to?
 
Last edited:
But those things are never debated, because they are accepted as fact.

And if they were debated they have nothing to do with attempted destruction of a race that has hated and persecuted and there are many people who'd like to see it happen again. People who want to supposedly debate do nothing more than encourage and embolden those people. The only motivation for denial is anti-Semitism, pure and simple. It has nothing to do with any doubts or vagaries of history because there are none. The Holocaust happened just as sure as the sun came up.
Clearly some people don't accept them as fact.

Is your position weak?

No, it isn't.

so what's the problem?

Ah, you think they will FOOL too many people.

That is anti-democratic.
 
You're right, I'm not. And as I mentioned, there is still extensive discussion of the history of the Holocaust, even in Germany. You simply seem to be yammering on about something without even bothering to get informed about it.
so..... should TERB be censoring THIS very debate?
 
Anti-ism.

Their is anti- everything ism out there!


There is anti semitism, anti arabism, anti christianism, and muslimism, and communism, anti capitalism, anti authoritarianism, and whiteism, anti maleism, anti successism, and tallism, antifeminism, you name it.
 
Nonsense to the academics, they are as influenced and prone to following fads as anyone else.

Good God, please don't tell me that you are so naiive as to think that we should let academics run the world....
So a massive rambling strawman. Nice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.