Government to introduce bill outlawing conversion therapy for adults

Says the person whose defending the torture of lgbtq young folks.
This is why you are so stupid and rude - you don't even read (or perhaps understand) the articles you post.

The focus of the new legislation is to ban conversion therapy FOR ADULTS. There was already no legal basis to force adults into such therapy, so this is about denying access to therapy that adults HAVE CHOSEN to engage in.

You start threads, but you lack the intellect to engage in any discussion of the issues your threads raise.
 
You don't understand much. My point is pretty clear. There are many, many psychological and psychiatric therapies which have been proven ineffective, or have not been proven effective. Psychiatry is a very young science with little track record of advancement. Sexuality conversion therapy is merely one example of (largely) ineffective therapy.

The Liberals are focussing on it because they are pandering to a specific voter base. It has nothing to do with protecting public health. If it did, they would not have focussed their attention so narrowly on a single type of therapy.

They are idiots whose only objective is to virtue signal. It's the ONLY thing they know how to do!

So this week your an expert in psychology too. Noted. Is your real name Cliff?
 
Some people are confused about their sexuality, and seek therapy to resolve that confusion. If someone was living as a gay person, and after therapy decided they were straight, would that therapy be "conversion therapy"?
The like was a mistake I have never ever met a gay person in this day and age who have sought therapy to decided to become straight that's reduclous. Conversion therapy is NOT therapy its torcher and brain washing. It's been responsible for suicides and permanent mental health problems. Seeking treatment for mental has been a life saver for millions
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Yes there is concensus. Gay people are born gay. Its that simple.
I beg to differ. Despite study, there is no medical consensus that there is a "gay gene".

To say otherwise is simply wrong. And the purpise of the legislation is to prevent bigots from sending their kids to to camps against their will where they are subjected to sensory deprivation, public shaming, physical abuse, being held against their will and emotional torture.

If you read the article, the focus of the NEW legislation is to prevent ADULTS from having access to therapy. That's the campaign promise that's being fulfilled. Don't tell me we're arguing just because you didn't read the article?

How do I know gay people are born gay? Because I saw what gay friends went through in the 80's and NO PERSON would choose to be ostracized, denied basic human rights, subject to physical assaults, denied healthcare, denied job access, lose their family, friends, have to leave home, all because they feel like having gay sex. Its genetic and tied into the urge of all species to procreate, the most powerful force that drives a human being.

So to say otherwise makes you a bigot.
False logic. There is no basis to conclude a strong compulsion to be gay can only arise from genetics. Some people are strongly compelled to commit crimes, even though they are aware that the consequences of doing so could ruin their lives. Would you argue that the disposition must therefore be genetic? Not logically, you wouldn't.

We all have our own anecdotal experiences with gay people, whether friends or otherwise. A careful person resists the urge to make scientific conclusions based on their own anecdotal evidence. As to your list of observations of what the landscape was in the 80's, I saw the world very differently. By the 80's:

1. There was little "ostracism" of gays in Canada. Many gay people had come out of the closet and were occupying political office, positions of authority in the business world, were members of the media, were highly paid entertainers, etc., etc. Gay people had higher disposable incomes than straight people on average. By the 80's, any period of social or economic "oppression" in Canada was over.
2. I can't think of any "human right" lawfully denied to to gay people in the 1980's. The Human Rights Code was in force since 1962. Sexual orientation was added to the Code in 1986, but was being "read into" other prohibited grounds before that.
3. By the 1980's physical assaults of gay people were extremely rare.
4. Denied healthcare? Not that I can recall.
5. Denied access to employment? No evidence of this in any macro perspective. In general, gay people were more economically prosperous than the average person.
6. Lose their family? Too many dynamics to this one. Depended on the family. That didn't happen to the gay people I'm personally familiar with.

I understand that coming out was not easy for most gay people. That's because up to that point they had been living a lie, and who likes to admit that? A lot of the conflict that happens when gay people finally come out to their family has to do with dishonesty.

Again, I'm not here to promote any theories of my own. I just know that all that exists are theories. It isn't the point. The point is that adults should be able to seek therapy they want to seek unless the therapist is fraudulently committing criminal acts upon them under the guise of therapy. I don't see that as the issue here. I think the issue is - conversion therapy can't be allowed to exist because it holds open the possibility that sexual orientation may involve some measure of personal choice, and that notion is intolerable to those who wish to believe otherwise.
 
Last edited:
So this week your an expert in psychology too. Noted. Is your real name Cliff?
If you can't respond in substance to something I post, it would be more dignified for you to say nothing than to post a childish insult.
 
If you can't respond in substance to something I post, it would be more dignified for you to say nothing than to post a childish insult.

Once you start posting substance, I will take that advice under consideration.
 
The like was a mistake I have never ever met a gay person in this day and age who have sought therapy to decided to become straight that's reduclous. Conversion therapy is NOT therapy its torcher and brain washing. It's been responsible for suicides and permanent mental health problems. Seeking treatment for mental has been a life saver for millions
Your post suggests that there's no problem for the Liberals to solve. If you're right, then it buttresses my point that this initiative is pure virtue signalling with no substance.

However, you should ask yourself whether a person seeking such therapy would ever confide in you about it.

The theories about what can be attributed to these therapies is as much junk science as the claims of the therapists, in my view.
 
Are you 12?

And remember Cliff… I am not one make wildly unsubstantiated claims about why a person is gay, or what modern psychiatry is scientific or not. That’s you. The board expert.
 
And remember Cliff… I am not one make wildly unsubstantiated claims about why a person is gay, or what modern psychiatry is scientific or not. That’s you. The board expert.
You are hopeless. I haven't made any claims about why someone is gay. In fact, my position is the opposite - that no one knows why anyone is gay. I've even said this explicitly. You have a serious reading comprehension problem.

My guess is that back in public school, your response to anyone who made a point that you didn't know how to respond to was to call them a "know it all". It didn't accomplish anything for you then, and it sure isn't accomplishing anything now. Try a more grown-up approach.
 
Last edited:
You are hopeless. I haven't made any claims about why someone is gay. In fact, my position is the opposite - that no one knows why anyone is gay. I've even said this explicitly. You have a serious reading comprehension problem.

My guess is that back in public school, your response to anyone who made a point that you didn't know how to respond to was to call them a "know it all". It didn't accomplish anything for you then, and it sure isn't accomplishing anything now. Try a more grown-up approach.

And now you’re an expert on me! What a surprise…
 
And now you’re an expert on me! What a surprise…
You're not hard to read. And everything you post just confirms my theory. Now you're going with the "you don't know me" argument so popular with 14 year olds.
 
If governments want to ban any psychological or psychiatric therapy that is not proven to be effective in the majority of cases, would any therapies remain legal? I can't think of any. Might as well make therapists and psychiatrists illegal while they're at it.

More government stupidity from the stupidest government in the history of Canada!

This is what you said. That most cases, and most therapies would not be legal. Utter fucking nonsense that you can’t prove. Just a garbage statement based on political bias.
Careful who you lob insults back at, especially with posts like this. We clear Cliff?
 
I would consider it a priority for all the kids literally kidnapped and taken to these camps where they are psychologically and even physically tortured. I'm not sure why you think this is a bad idea. A few day of work, I doubt their will be much debate, and it shuts down an industry thats needs to be shut down, and furthers gay rights.

The concept is a perpetuation of the false narrative thay being gay is a choice. It isn't. The practice needs to be debunked and stamped out.
with all canadas problems lets focus our efforts on 2-3% of the population of which what maybe .01% had therapy
 
This is what you said. That most cases, and most therapies would not be legal. Utter fucking nonsense that you can’t prove. Just a garbage statement based on political bias.
Careful who you lob insults back at, especially with posts like this. We clear Cliff?
It's like you hit rock bottom, and you just keep digging.

You claim I was advancing a theory on why people are gay. I point out that is the opposite of what I have said (how could anyone be as wrong as you are on that point?). Instead of just admitting that you failed to read (or comprehend) the posts you were responding to, you are now taking issue with my assertion that many therapies in psychology and psychiatry are not effective, and that the government seems to be banning "conversion therapy" (whatever that is exactly, a point I make in a separate post) because they believe it's hokum that doesn't work, and you can't follow the thread that ties the two points together.

I could easily prove that a number of other therapies have no tangible record of effectiveness. No self-respecting psychiatrist would even deny the point. It's for this reason that there is long history of abandoning various forms of therapy. But you, based on nothing but your gut, can't acknowledge the obvious?

As to political "bias", there is a long, long, list of virtue signalling gestures of this government. It would bore me to reproduce them for you. Just search the forum, if you are truly unaware of them.

I'm not sure what to make of your last sentence. Internet tough guy, maybe? Bottom line - you make a lot less sense than you think you do, and you think you make points that you don't.
 
Last edited:
It's like you hit rock bottom, and you just keep digging.

You claim I was advancing a theory on why people are gay. I point out that is the opposite of what I have said (how could anyone be as wrong as you are on that point?). Instead of just admitting that you failed to read (or comprehend) the posts you were responding to, you are now taking issue with my assertion that many therapies in psychology and psychiatry are not effective, and that the government seems to be banning "conversion therapy" (whatever that is exactly, a point I make in a separate post) because they believe it's hokum that doesn't work, and you can't follow the thread that ties the two points together.

I could easily prove that a number of other therapies have no tangible record of effectiveness. No self-respecting psychiatrist would even deny the point. It's for this reason that there is long history of abandoning various forms of therapy. But you, based on nothing but your gut, can't acknowledge the obvious?

As to political "bias", there is a long, long, list of virtue signalling gestures of this government. It would bore me to reproduce them for you. Just search the forum, if you are truly unaware of them.

I'm not sure what to make of your last sentence. Internet tough guy, maybe? Bottom line - you make a lot less sense than you think you do, and you think you make points that you don't.

And I quote…

“would any therapies remain legal? I can’t think of any.”

That is the assertion. You wrote off an entire field of medical science, claiming non of it has ever been effective. Tap dance out of that.
 
with all canadas problems lets focus our efforts on 2-3% of the population of which what maybe .01% had therapy

When there is human rights abuses no number is too small. Human being matter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
I beg to differ. Despite study, there is no medical consensus that there is a "gay gene".



If you read the article, the focus of the NEW legislation is to prevent ADULTS from having access to therapy. That's the campaign promise that's being fulfilled. Don't tell me we're arguing just because you didn't read the article?


False logic. There is no basis to conclude a strong compulsion to be gay can only arise from genetics. Some people are strongly compelled to commit crimes, even though they are aware that the consequences of doing so could ruin their lives. Would you argue that the disposition must therefore be genetic? Not logically, you wouldn't.

We all have our own anecdotal experiences with gay people, whether friends or otherwise. A careful person resists the urge to make scientific conclusions based on their own anecdotal evidence. As to your list of observations of what the landscape was in the 80's, I saw the world very differently. By the 80's:

1. There was little "ostracism" of gays in Canada. Many gay people had come out of the closet and were occupying political office, positions of authority in the business world, were members of the media, were highly paid entertainers, etc., etc. Gay people had higher disposable incomes than straight people on average. By the 80's, any period of social or economic "oppression" in Canada was over.
2. I can't think of any "human right" lawfully denied to to gay people in the 1980's. The Human Rights Code was in force since 1962. Sexual orientation was added to the Code in 1986, but was being "read into" other prohibited grounds before that.
3. By the 1980's physical assaults of gay people were extremely rare.
4. Denied healthcare? Not that I can recall.
5. Denied access to employment? No evidence of this in any macro perspective. In general, gay people were more economically prosperous than the average person.
6. Lose their family? Too many dynamics to this one. Depended on the family. That didn't happen to the gay people I'm personally familiar with.

I understand that coming out was not easy for most gay people. That's because up to that point they had been living a lie, and who likes to admit that? A lot of the conflict that happens when gay people finally come out to their family has to do with dishonesty.

Again, I'm not here to promote any theories of my own. I just know that all that exists are theories. It isn't the point. The point is that adults should be able to seek therapy they want to seek unless the therapist is fraudulently committing criminal acts upon them under the guise of therapy. I don't see that as the issue here. I think the issue is - conversion therapy can't be allowed to exist because it holds open the possibility that sexual orientation may involve some measure of personal choice, and that notion is intolerable to those who wish to believe otherwise.

In other words, I don't understand the basics. Its a human rights issue. But that's fine, we will move on ahead despite the best effort of bigots to stop it.