Do Conspiracy Theories Thrive In Religious Groups?

It's an American thing.

American rural and small town society is scared and suspicious of city folk, immigrants, blacks, Jews, democrats, latinos, communists, bankers, lawyers, doctors, university people and think all those folks are out to poison them and eat their children.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kherg007
Is the invisible person in the sky not the biggest conspiracy theory of them all?
I am not sure it qualifies. A conspiracy theory implies that too many people would have to conspire for the theory to be true. Like flat earth or 9/11 would require a huge amount of people to be in on it i.e. to know the truth but suppress it or lie etc. With religion nobody really knows the truth.
Then, of course, there is the evangelical version which seems to be more properly classified as a cult.
 
It's an American thing.

American rural and small town society is scared and suspicious of city folk, immigrants, blacks, Jews, democrats, latinos, communists, bankers, lawyers, doctors, university people and think all those folks are out to poison them and eat their children.
this is mean to ROFLMFAO! He loves these small town people! They all watch Fox!
 
Is the invisible person in the sky not the biggest conspiracy theory of them all?
Don't know about religion being a conspiracy theory but yes, if people are willing to accept one crazy story on faith, they likely will do the same with other crazy stories.
 
It's an American thing.

American rural and small town society is scared and suspicious of city folk, immigrants, blacks, Jews, democrats, latinos, communists, bankers, lawyers, doctors, university people and think all those folks are out to poison them and eat their children.
ROTFLMFAO!!! Interesting stereotype...applicable to village/small town in pretty much any fucking country. Small town people are suspicious of strangers not because they are bad people, but because, unlike in the large city, they actually know every one in their town. A stranger is just that- a stranger, an unknown quality. Having said that, if you're an alright person, you will experience no ostracism in the Small Town USA. I found the people there open, friendly and interesting. Next time you're driving down there get off the freeway and visit a local diner and you'll see. Maybe it depends what kind of person YOU are.
 
ROTFLMFAO!!! Interesting stereotype...applicable to village/small town in pretty much any fucking country. Small town people are suspicious of strangers not because they are bad people, but because, unlike in the large city, they actually know every one in their town. A stranger is just that- a stranger, an unknown quality. Having said that, if you're an alright person, you will experience no ostracism in the Small Town USA. I found the people there open, friendly and interesting. Next time you're driving down there get off the freeway and visit a local diner and you'll see. Maybe it depends what kind of person YOU are.
Well, explain why the small town folks are predominantly the ones who believe in shit like QAnon?
 
Well, explain why the small town folks are predominantly the ones who believe in shit like QAnon?
And how do you know what they believe in? Judging by your post(#2), you don't know any small town folks in America. Just wallowing in stereotypes and caricatures.
 
It's an American thing.

American rural and small town society is scared and suspicious of city folk, immigrants, blacks, Jews, democrats, latinos, communists, bankers, lawyers, doctors, university people and think all those folks are out to poison them and eat their children.

You obviously have never visited Keswick.......

But on a serious note when large corporations/stock holders/ bankers based in cities make decisions that result in foreclosures, business shut downs, insurance pay out refusals, hiked fees, low service, and those same smug city dwellers refer to them as deplorable, act shitty and self entitled when they visit on weekends to somewhere Quaint, do you expect them to like them? Trust them?

Its a very different lifestyle. I prefer the anonymity of the big city for now as well. But can see the appeal.

And the tone of your post does kinda prove their point.
 
this is mean to ROFLMFAO! He loves these small town people! They all watch Fox!
It's official, he's come out!

'ROFLMAFAO'- is his preferred pronoun now in addition to being his non gender based self identification.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knuckle Ball
Is the invisible person in the sky not the biggest conspiracy theory of them all?
I think there are similarities between religious belief systems and conspiracy theories. By their nature, they can never be proven but they can never be disproven either.

Also…they seem quite adaptable to circumstances. End of the World believers don’t stop believing just because their End of Times predictions always turn out to be wrong; nor do QANON believers shift their views every time Trump is not magically returned to office.

Believing this stuff meets a set of social and identity needs so they are not really open to rational discussion.
 
And how do you know what they believe in? Judging by your post(#2), you don't know any small town folks in America. Just wallowing in stereotypes and caricatures.

Whereas you visited one small town so now know what every single one is like?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
I think there are similarities between religious belief systems and conspiracy theories. By their nature, they can never be proven but they can never be disproven either.

Also…they seem quite adaptable to circumstances. End of the World believers don’t stop believing just because their End of Times predictions always turn out to be wrong; nor do QANON believers shift their views every time Trump is not magically returned to office.

Believing this stuff meets a set of social and identity needs so they are not really open to rational discussion.

Some more than others. Scientology is way high on that list, followed by Jehovah's witnesses and maybe the Amish or Dukabores.
The bigger question would be whether at the heart of conspiracy theories like Q, there is someone who knows its fake or truly believes its true.
If its the latter, then its a lot like religion.
 
And how do you know what they believe in? Judging by your post(#2), you don't know any small town folks in America. Just wallowing in stereotypes and caricatures.
Because there are polls and news reports, JC.

Why?.... You think I just make shit up?
 
Redneck
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article is about redneck as a pejorative. For the historical subculture, see Poor White. For different connotations, see Country (identity). For other uses, see Redneck (disambiguation).
Redneck is a derogatory term chiefly, but not exclusively, applied to white Americans perceived to be crass and unsophisticated, closely associated with rural whites of the Southern United States.[1][2] Its usage is similar in meaning to cracker (especially regarding Texas, Georgia, and Florida), hillbilly (especially regarding Appalachia and the Ozarks),[3] and white trash (but without the last term's suggestions of immorality).[4][5][6] In Britain the Cambridge Dictionary definition states: "a poor, white person without education, esp. one living in the countryside in the southern US, who is believed to have prejudiced ideas and beliefs. This word is usually considered offensive."[7] People from the white South sometimes jocularly call themselves "rednecks" as insider humor.[8]
By the 1970s, the term had become offensive slang, its meaning expanded to include racism, loutishness, and opposition to modern ways.[9]
 
You obviously have never visited Keswick.......

But on a serious note when large corporations/stock holders/ bankers based in cities make decisions that result in foreclosures, business shut downs, insurance pay out refusals, hiked fees, low service, and those same smug city dwellers refer to them as deplorable, act shitty and self entitled when they visit on weekends to somewhere Quaint, do you expect them to like them? Trust them?

Its a very different lifestyle. I prefer the anonymity of the big city for now as well. But can see the appeal.

And the tone of your post does kinda prove their point.
Both American and Canadian post election maps show that rural communities vote further to the political right of cities. Explain to me how I am wrong about small towns. They consistently vote for the Tories, rather than the Libs and the GOP rather than the Dems.

The fact that you can toss around a few of your own off-the-cuff stereotypes and take a personal shot at me - as you very often do - doesn't change that fact.

City folks get evicted and foreclosed too. But they vote for centrist and progressive parties.

I have nothing personal against small towns. I just read data. Every rural district in the US that was neither Black nor Latino voted for Trump in the last election, except in New England.

Ditto in Canada in the last election outside the Maritimes, all rural ridings voted for the Tories or BQ.

Part and parcel of voting for your "populist" buddy Trump is buying in to his package of dog whistles about immigrants and city folk. And it's the GOP voters that buy into crap like QAnon and the Big Steal. Dems don't touch that shit.

You can call elections in most states now simply by calculating the % of rural vs city electoral districts. And built into that is the factor that the % of post secondary educated voters is far higher in the cities than in the small towns.

So if you want to comment on the "tone" of my posts, go do some research first. It's a lot more informative than your own smug back-patting about "Keswick" and how much they love you there when you throw some pennies around on the weekend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
I am not sure it qualifies. A conspiracy theory implies that too many people would have to conspire for the theory to be true. Like flat earth or 9/11 would require a huge amount of people to be in on it i.e. to know the truth but suppress it or lie etc. With religion nobody really knows the truth.
Then, of course, there is the evangelical version which seems to be more properly classified as a cult.
You have a whole lot of people, most from birth, believing all kinds of really bizarre crap on a regular basis. There are all sorts of instances of religious practices devolving into cult activity, think Branch Davidians or Rev. Jim Jones. Qanon is just another cult, really...
 
Some more than others. Scientology is way high on that list, followed by Jehovah's witnesses and maybe the Amish or Dukabores.
The bigger question would be whether at the heart of conspiracy theories like Q, there is someone who knows its fake or truly believes its true.
If its the latter, then its a lot like religion.
Very many people have concluded that qanon is fundamentally a hoax, but being based on a clear hoax didn't stop the Mormons...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Some more than others. Scientology is way high on that list, followed by Jehovah's witnesses and maybe the Amish or Dukabores.
The bigger question would be whether at the heart of conspiracy theories like Q, there is someone who knows its fake or truly believes its true.
If its the latter, then its a lot like religion.

I don’t think it makes much difference either way.