Socialism seems to work

from your source
Norway & Denmark govt expenditures as % of GDP = 51% (more than half)
USA govt expenditures as % of GDP = 30%

How in the world can you say that is not dramatically different?
This look's like another intentional and deliberate attempt to mislead others by Nottyboi


That is just plain wrong

An individuals net wealth is assets less liabilities

One can not count government ownership in any venture as an asset as one can not liquidate his theoretical ownership in that govt venture

Also given how many govt ventures are bottomless money pits, which may require future tax money to operate (subsidies) a higher % of govt ownership results higher future tax liabilities for individual citizens

Where did you get 30% for the US?
I’m reading 46% from the source you referred to.
 
apparently not, as all you make are statements and you ask no questions
see below



Venezuela: A Textbook Case of How Socialism Breeds Dictatorship – Berkeley Political Review





wrong again


the only reason Venezuela went broke is socialism



gee and you get to ignore the multitude of innovations and advancements the US has brought to the world

the automobile, the tractor, refrigerators, air conditioning , the light bulb , more life saving medicines than all other countries combined, the transistor, the micro chip , computers the internet, toilet paper, efficient farming. telecommunications, posted notes, air travel, indoor plumbing, the electrical grid, clean drinking water technology etc. etc. etc..............
in addition to massive amounts of fundament research in the sciences all while maintain itself as a protector of human rights and freedoms and preventing the infection of socialism / communism

if it were not for the US you would starving under the boot of a commie dictator, assuming you did not die from an infectious disease such as malaria or yellow fever

Well, under the socialism only manual labour counts. Everything that is invented becomes public goods right away with no patent protection. So, all the stuff USA did does not count since anyone can do the same now. It is like with "take money from reach, give them to poor". The "socialists" live in the short-run: they do not understand that without patent protection and with high taxes and expropriation nothing will be done in the long run. Like what we have in Canada: the government policy to make drug cheaper resulted to the big pharmacy unwillingness to operate in Canada, an, as a result, no facility to produce COVID vaccine (do not tell me that it is because of privatisation - all big pharmaceutical companies in USA are private).
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
Where did you get 30% for the US?
I’m reading 46% from the source you referred to.
right you are
i quoted govt revenue as % of GDP, instead of expenditures as % of GDP, one column over
List of countries by government spending as percentage of GDP - Wikipedia
my mistake.
no intention to mislead anyone


however
expenditures as % of GDP
Norway, Denmark 58.1% & 55.1%
USA 46%
so still a massive difference and still not close like Nottyboi claimed they were

ideally govt revenue as % of GDP should exceed or equal govt expenditures as % of GDP

BTW government expenditures greater than 50% of GDP is not sustainable, especially debt laden countries with interest rates having only one way to go.... up
note 2020 was unique in terms of govt actions and spending
 
And yet Canada has been a socialist country since the "New Deal" of Roosevelt ???

wrong

Has Canada failed ???
just since Justin brought his clown show to Ottawa

The only reason Canada is failing ( the poor half only ) is because of capitalism.
The only reason you enjoy one of the best standards of living in history is because of capitalism

Ever since Mulroney and Mike Harris ( in Ontario ) the situation has gotten worse - as far as poverty.

heres an idea, get skills that are in demand if you do not like poverty

One of the biggest complaints against Wynne was the job growth was only happening in big cities like Toronto. Pretty much just Toronto & the GTA.
The Conservative areas LOST jobs.

Gee could that have anything to do with the world wide trend to relocate manufacturing to china ?
but do not let facts and truth get in the way of your biased and ridiculous rant

Instead of Conservatives - or should I say ConservaDUMBS - preaching about jobs and working hard and innovation - why can't these Conservatives actually GET A JOB in Conservative rural areas.

really ?
unemployed conservatives? outside of Alberta that will be a rarity
liberals now figure the world/ govt owes them, the ndp need a union to think for them
a conservative will go out and find another job

how many of the 5.9% of unemployed in our workforce are conservative vs liberal vs ndp?.

you will need to exclude Alberta as higher unemployment there was part of Gerald Butts plan to kill their industry
Something has gone very wrong when an unelected official such as Gerald Butts gets to kill thousands of Canadian jobs and not be held to account

Because no one wants to hire these sacks of shit - that's why. How dumb. Or should I say - Conserva DUMB.
your terb handle says it all
how old are you?
seriously your posts indicate a high school student who had to repeat a few grades
 
  • Like
Reactions: masspref
Gee could that have anything to do with the world wide trend to relocate manufacturing to china ?

So, you admit that SOCIALISM in China works better for manufacturing then CAPITALIST America.

unemployed conservatives? outside of Alberta that will be a rarity

You also admit that the Conservative "work" requires a natural resource that's been sitting in the ground millions of years before humans.
Otherwise these nutbars would be UNEMPLOYED.

.

Whose ignorant now ? The answer is you, btw.
 
gee and you get to ignore the multitude of innovations and advancements the US has brought to the world

Yes, it was all invented in America, but only because they bullied the world to send their brightest minds to America.

You should read a book called "Confessions of An Economic Hitman".

In the book, Mr. Hitman says he manipulated currencies to bring down 3rd world countries. Like Venezuela.

.

I found the book for you.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confessions_of_an_Economic_Hit_Man

From The Book said:
Perkins' function, according to the book, was to convince the political and financial leadership of developing countries to

accept enormous development loans

from institutions like the World Bank and USAID.

Saddled with debts they could not hope to pay, such countries would then be forced to acquiesce

to political pressure from the United States on a variety of issues. Perkins argues that these nations were effectively neutralized politically, with their wealth gaps driven wider and

their long-term economies crippled.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it was all invented in America, but only because they bullied the world to send their brightest minds to America.

What a pile of crap
maxresdefault.jpg


The vast number of discoveries mentioned were by Americans
Ford, Edison, Caruthers, Gates, Jobs, the Wright brothers, Charles Drew , George Washington Carver, John G Trump (High Voltage Generators), Kellogg, Post, Hershey, Westinghouse to name but a few


Innovative and entrepreneurial people want to come to the USA, nobody bullied the brightest minds to move to America
You are really clueless


You should read a book called "Confessions of An Economic Hitman".

You should read economics 101

In the book, Mr. Hitman says he manipulated currencies to bring down 3rd world countries. Like Venezuela.
Too funny
The FX market is the biggest and most liquid market in the world
It takes Billions to push a currency around even for a few days.
What is a Billionaire doing writing a piece of trash like "Confessions of An Economic Hitman" ?
If what you claim is true he would be setting himself up for the biggest law suit in history

Ultimately a currencies value is determined by supply and demand

Now pay attention,
An oil business is like a forage with cash flow as the bellows, you need to reinvest cash flow in order to maintain / grow production

The socialist's in Venezuela viewed oil as bottomless ATM to pay for every socialist program under the sun
They nationalized the oil companies and booted all the people who understood the business and replaced then with party stooges
The incompetent stooges (they are socialist's ) siphoned off all the cash for social programs without reinvesting any money into development or maintenance
The stooges (they are socialist's ) also borrowed heavily to spend on social programs against expect future cash flows from oil

Then production started to decline (lack of investment) and the price of oil dropped and they could not meet their borrowing obligations
Now millions have had to leave to avoid starvation
They have the largest reserves in the world but need to import oil ???? WTF ????
Thieves dismantle the oil infrastructure at night in order to sell piping as scrape metal
Others steal animals from the zoo in order to eat

Pets on the Menu as Venezuelans Starve (thedailybeast.com)

Your hitman did not bring down Venezuela, it was socialism & the stupidity that accompanies it
Time to wake up!
your socialist's experiment has been tried many times and the body count is far to high to try it again
 
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news...id-not-destroy-venezuelas-economy/3323566001/

The post relies on "picking and choosing" what parts of Venezuela's history to latch on to and avoid, Morris said. It overlooks the nuanced history of the country. By latching on to socialist policies as the root of the country's failing economy is "simplifying the argument greatly."

"It's like someone taking the 1928 to 1938 period in the United States and saying capitalism is a failure," he said.

Our ruling: Partly false

We rate this claim PARTLY FALSE because parts of it were not supported by our research. The meme is misleading in its simplicity. It is true Venezuela has socialist programs, but they were not entirely responsible for the country's economic collapse. The nation's strong ties to its oil industry led to great success then great failure.
 
So, you admit that SOCIALISM in China works better for manufacturing then CAPITALIST America.

You also admit that the Conservative "work" requires a natural resource that's been sitting in the ground millions of years before humans.
Otherwise these nutbars would be UNEMPLOYED.

.Do not tell me what I admit
You will get it wrong and that is a grade three level tactic substituting for your inability to make a coherent logical argument

both of your statements are ridiculous and illogical

Whose ignorant now ? The answer is you, btw.
not to worry , your terb handle remains as an accurate description of your understanding
 
We rate this claim PARTLY FALSE because parts of it were not supported by our research. The meme is misleading in its simplicity. It is true Venezuela has socialist programs, but they were not entirely responsible for the country's economic collapse. The nation's strong ties to its oil industry led to great success then great failure.

No actually is was as I described
They borrowed against future oil cash flows in order to spend on nanny state social programs
The future oil cash flows did not materialize due poor maintenance, lack of investment and a drop in a COMMODITY price

The biggest oil reserves in the world and yet they needed to import oil
Now that takes a whole new level of stupidity to achieve that

That level of stupidity can only occur when an ideology (socialism) drives decision making rather than practical thinking and evaluation (capitalism)
 
No actually is was as I described
They borrowed against future oil cash flows in order to spend on nanny state social programs
The future oil cash flows did not materialize due poor maintenance, lack of investment and a drop in a COMMODITY price

The biggest oil reserves in the world and yet they needed to import oil
Now that takes a whole new level of stupidity to achieve that

That level of stupidity can only occur when an ideology (socialism) drives decision making rather than practical thinking and evaluation (capitalism)

Sound like your describing ALBERTA.

Nanny state programs - like Canadian health care
Lack of investments - like the Keystone cancel
Import Oil - Canada imports lots of oil, and even refined oil from Texas
Future oil cash flows - like Alberta and the entire economy dependent on one product.

So why did Venezeula collapse while Canada is fine?

Because America is more friendly to Canada and more hostile to 3rd world countries like Venezuela. That's why.
 
So why did Venezeula collapse while Canada is fine?

Because America is more friendly to Canada and more hostile to 3rd world countries like Venezuela. That's why.

Nope capitalism vs socialism/communism , plain and simple
Just like why did the USA do just fine while the USSR collapsed.

The is a reason the USA needs walls to control the number of people getting in
socialism/communism need walls to keep their people from getting out

Time to wake up
Your experiment has been tried many times and it does not work
Too many dead bodies
 
Sound like your describing ALBERTA.

Only if one is completely ignorant of the facts

Nanny state programs - like Canadian health care
News flash for you. Our health care system is not sustainable over the long haul.
The provinces have accumulated a mountain of debt

Lack of investments - like the Keystone cancel
How incredibly stupid to characterize the investments in Canadian resource development by using a politically motivated bad decision by Joe Biden

Import Oil - Canada imports lots of oil, and even refined oil from Texas
Yeah the stupidity of the left is on display again for killing Energy east via red tape

Future oil cash flows - like Alberta and the entire economy dependent on one product.
Just keep on pretending the hundreds of Billions in royalties to governments in Canada never happened

You continue to show your handle is so appropriate
 
Nope capitalism vs socialism/communism , plain and simple

Nope. American domination, plain and simple.



Friends of America = Higher credit

Enemies of America = Lower credit

The "friends" support the American dollar by buying US Treasury notes - places like China & Japan have tons of these as well as ( formally ) Anglo-Saxon countries.

Saudi Arabia also accepts American dollars only as payment - because otherwise they become the next Iraq.

When Canada buys US Treasury notes they support the American lifestyles, and in return the currency ( Canadian dollars ) has value to America.

Meanwhile Russia sold some US treasuries - now Trump is mad at them, like how China ad Russia signed bi-lateral trade deal to BYPASS the American system.

That makes America angry.
 
Last edited:
Friends of America = Higher credit

Enemies of America = Lower credit

too funny
mis-manage the finances = lower credit

The "friends" support the American dollar by buying US Treasury notes - places like China & Japan have tons of these as well as ( formally ) Anglo-Saxon countries.

Saudi Arabia also accepts American dollars only as payment - because otherwise they become the next Iraq.

When Canada buys US Treasury notes they support the American lifestyles, and in return the currency ( Canadian dollars ) has value to America.

Meanwhile Russia sold some US treasuries - now Trump is mad at them, like how China ad Russia signed bi-lateral trade deal to BYPASS the American system.

That makes America angry.
you are one very confused communist'
money has no friends

the us dollar is the reserve currency for the world as investors know if they buy us treasuries, they will get the loan repaid
but by all means please do not let that stop you from investing your life savings into Venezuelan bolívar dominated assets

you can get 3.2 million bolivar for a greenback
toilet paper (used) is worth more

Venezuelan bolívar - Wikipedia

The bolívar soberano (sovereign bolívar, sign: Bs.S or Bs.; code: VES)[1][4] has been the official currency of Venezuela since 20 August 2018. The bolívar soberano replaced the bolívar fuerte (strong bolívar, sign: Bs.F, code: VEF) after a transition period.[5] The primary reason for replacement, at a rate of 1 Bs.S to 100,000 Bs.F, was hyperinflation.[6]

On 1 January 2008, the bolívar fuerte had itself replaced, because of inflation,[7] the original bolívar introduced in 1879 (sign: Bs.; code: VEB).[1] It did so at a rate of 1 Bs.F to 1000 Bs.

The bolívar is currently the weakest circulating currency, with 1 United States dollar converting to approximately 3.2 million bolívars as of July 1, 2021.
 
Nope capitalism vs socialism/communism , plain and simple
Just like why did the USA do just fine while the USSR collapsed.

The is a reason the USA needs walls to control the number of people getting in
socialism/communism need walls to keep their people from getting out

Time to wake up
Your experiment has been tried many times and it does not work
Too many dead bodies

The socialist experiment has been tried many times ... in CANADA.

In 1983 the government of Canada was running health care. According to this guy, the result was "too many dead bodies" ???

In 1985 the government of Canada was running the LCBO. A FAILED experiment ???

In 1988 the government was running the electric system.
In 1991 the government was running the police.
In 1994 the government was running the education system.
In 1999 the government was running the sewage and water system.

As you can see, Canada is a FAILED ??? socialist experiment run by COMMIES who refuse to make private sector market based decisions. VERY BAD. Commie Canada will collapse unless the TTC is sold for profit, the public housing buildings are sold for profit.

Everything, like the Mike Harris highway, must generate a profit or else ... "too many dead bodies" ???

Ok John Larue.
You make Canada great again.
 
The socialist experiment has been tried many times ... in CANADA.

In 1983 the government of Canada was running health care. According to this guy, the result was "too many dead bodies" ???
what part of unsustainable do you not understand?


In 1985 the government of Canada was running the LCBO. A FAILED experiment ???
The government of Canada does not run the Liquor Control Board of ONTARIO
And yes it is a failed experiment , just ask any of the wineries what a nightmare it is dealing with the LCBO

In 1988 the government was running the electric system.
In 1991 the government was running the police.
In 1994 the government was running the education system.
In 1999 the government was running the sewage and water system.

your one strange messed up dude
government has been running/ mismanaging all of those since word go
Who was running the police prior to 1991 if not the government ?

They are going to destroy the electrical system via green insanity
The loonies want to defund the police
The education system has been turned into the teachers enrichment system. Get unions out of education
Boiled water advisories for First nations... need I say more?

As you can see, Canada is a FAILED ???
what part of unsustainable do you not understand?

socialist experiment run by COMMIES who refuse to make private sector market based decisions. VERY BAD. Commie Canada will collapse unless the TTC is sold for profit, the public housing buildings are sold for profit.

gibberish by a fool
The TTC is a massive money pit, nobody in their right mind would buy that
same thing with public housing, a massive money pit

Everything, like the Mike Harris highway, must generate a profit or else ... "too many dead bodies" ???
Having to sell assets is a real life consequence of financial mis-management of the previous liberal / ndp governments
what part of unsustainable do you not understand?


Ok John Larue.
You make Canada great again.
OK the Trump references are getting kind of old, the bad man can not hurt you any more

Time for you to wake up
The socialist/ communist experiment has been tried many times and it is a failure
 
Last edited: