Socialism seems to work

This is a definition of socialism from Oxford Learner;'s dictionary:

" a set of political and economic theories based on the belief that everyone has an equal right to a share of a country's wealth and that the government should own and control the main industries "

We own some main industries.
The police.
Schools.
Medical care.
Army.
Libraries.
Tax collection the civil service.
 
We own some main industries.
The police.
Schools.
Medical care.
Army.
Libraries.
Tax collection the civil service.

So, basically, almost the entire economics is privately-owned (except for "some industries"). As I said before, police, army, and libraries are public-goods that will be owned and finance by tax in any economy (slavery, feudal, capitalism, etc.) . Schools - the government want to control the young + there is huge positive externality in education, so, it is supposed to be financed by the government. Medical - it is finance by the government, but not owned or operated (e.g., doctors have private clinics). So, all developed countries are almost purely capitalist (with a few government-owned corporations).
 
So, basically, almost the entire economics is privately-owned (except for "some industries"). As I said before, police, army, and libraries are public-goods that will be owned and finance by tax in any economy (slavery, feudal, capitalism, etc.) . Schools - the government want to control the young + there is huge positive externality in education, so, it is supposed to be financed by the government. Medical - it is finance by the government, but not owned or operated (e.g., doctors have private clinics). So, all developed countries are almost purely capitalist (with a few government-owned corporations).

Exactly my argument.
We all support some level of socialism, its just a matter of degrees how much you want to back.
 
You are failing yo distinguish between socialism and communism. The USSR was never truly a socialist society or economy. Although it may have been started following the revolution with those ideals they were never realized.
So, what kind of economy was it? Surely not communist since we did use money to buy goods. You are confusing socialism (as an economic system) with wetware (as government programs to redistribute personal income)
 
So, what kind of economy was it? Surely not communist since we did use money to buy goods. You are confusing socialism (as an economic system) with wetware (as government programs to redistribute personal income)

Not sure what you are talking about. I was talking about the USSR.
 
When the government helps you, its capitalism.

When the government helps other people, its evil socialism.

Hail comrade !!!
 
Karl Marx lived in a time when no one would have foreseen
economic growth would eventually reach a point
when majority of population in the developed parts of
the world belong to a class we call middle which by the standard
of his time were unbelievably affluent. Many people in the middle
class are even owners of a share of corporations that in Marx's world
would be oppressors of the poor. Had economy ceased to grow
the under class in society would continue to be exploited by capitalists
like the child labor in Victorian England. Of course it is capitalism
that has taken the poor out of poverty in the end.

In my view Karl Marx's critique of capitalism still has merits.
Some elements of socialism are essential in a free society.
Private charities are essential too but in a gentle and free
society the government sometimes would need to step in.
 
When the government helps you, its capitalism.

When the government helps other people, its evil socialism.

Hail comrade !!!
actually
when a government clears the path for you to help yourself to become productive and thus compensated it is called capitalism
when a government promises to take care of you without the need for you to be productive its evil socialism as it is an unsustainable lie

the problem with socialists is they are always running out of other peoples money
 
In that case a better way to put it is 'eroding away other peoples wealth'.
That is what Biden inflation will accomplish.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ignorant
212836498_5291456784280666_1828746832227559872_n.jpg
 
Because the Democrats have the support of the rich, I guess.

Wall Street banksters' dinner with Obama cost between $30,000 and $40,000
per plate. As ex-POTUS Obama's Wall Street fans were happy to pay him as
much as $400,000 for a 1 hr speech.

Democrats' lifestyle is probably more envied by the upper middle class
than Republicans. John Kerry as a civilian had to take a private jet trip
to Iceland to pick up an environmental award. Newt Gingrich as a politician
is known to be fine with flying commercial airlines. He didn't seem to be
worried about having to travel with the peasants in the same plane.
 
Last edited:
Because the rich voted for the Democrats, I guess.

Wall Street banksters' dinner with Obama cost between $30,000 and $40,000
per plate. As ex-POTUS Obama's Wall Street fans were willing to pay him as
much as $400,000 for a 1 hr speech.
They didn't vote for the Republicans too?

Obama, Biden, Clinton are pretty right wing in their economic policies.
 
If your idea of left wing politicians who would devise better
economic policies than Obama and Clinton are the likes of
AOC and Katie Porter you have to wish the U.S. going on
a joy ride to economic collapse after Biden is replaced by
a leader of your choice.
 
Exactly my argument.
We all support some level of socialism, its just a matter of degrees how much you want to back.

Well, the "public good provision" (like police or army) and schools are not a business since they do not generate any revenue. There may be some actual businesses that Canadian government owns, but it is only a very small fraction of the Economy. Same applies to all developed countries.
 
Socialism and capitalism are economic systems. Capitalism functions very well in democracy, socialism cannot function in a democracy at all. Today's lefties keep mistaking the welfare state and the social programs associated with it as socialism. Nothing could be more false because that approach would mean that leaders as different as Hitler and FDR, Adenauer and Thatcher were socialists. And that is patently ridiculous.
Socialism simply means that the economy is run and owned by the state.
As usual you righties have problems dealing with shades of grey vs black and white. There are no absolutes. Most nations own and regulate large sectors of their economies. It also goes much beyond the welfare state. It includes industrial policy, medical care and govt owned major enterprises. All western nations are socialist democracies. The biggest differences are the efficiency of wealth redistribution, but also in cultures.

Doesn't the chart indicate that your statement is FULL OF SHIT?
 
Last edited:
No he's totally right, its you that is totally wrong. As wrong as wrong can be.

Denmark, Sweden, Norway, the UK, the US, Canada etc. are real free market capitalist economies. The main area in which we differ is our ratio of public sector vs. private sector ownership of the economy.

Well I am not sure how you measure that, but in terms of govt spending as a % of GDP its not dramatically different:


and even if what you say is true, it would indicate a higher % of govt ownership results in greater financial wealth for individual citizens.
 
As usual you righties have problems dealing with shades of grey vs black and white. There are no absolutes. Most nations own and regulate large sectors of their economies. It also goes much beyond the welfare state. It includes industrial policy, medical care and govt owned major enterprises. All western nations are socialist democracies. The biggest differences are the efficiency of wealth redistribution, but also in cultures.

Doesn't the chart indicate that your statement is FULL OF SHIT?
Child, you cannot have an intelligent conversation without first establishing terminology and definitions.