Socialism seems to work

That’s code for: I made up this quote.
That is what you think... Chesterton wrote it... about Christianity... and it equally applies to Socialism...

I know... it takes a bit of perspective, imagination and depth... concepts totally foreign to your ways of thinking...

Perry
 
That is what you think... Chesterton wrote it... about Christianity... and it equally applies to Socialism...

I know... it takes a bit of perspective, imagination and depth... concepts totally foreign to your ways of thinking...

Perry

Plagiarism doesn’t take any perspective, imagination, or depth. Usually it’s just a lack of skill and honesty.
 
Fine, we'll stick to public roads, schools, libraries and police.
Better?

Well, these things were always "public" (i.e., government-owned) for centuries since the government wants to control police, young minds, and it has to build the roads. A better education is always private (even now everywhere on the Earth). Also, libraries and roads are public goods (look up the definition of "public good" if you do not know what it is since it has nothing to do with publicly-owned goods), which, almost by definition, have to be financed by taxes or donations.
 
I like it when people who were borne and raised in Canada try to explain to people who came from the former USSR what a socialism is.

Likewise, I find it amusing when people from former Communist countries try to to explain to people in Canada what socialism in the west is.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Well, these things were always "public" (i.e., government-owned) for centuries since the government wants to control police, young minds, and it has to build the roads. A better education is always private (even now everywhere on the Earth). Also, libraries and roads are public goods (look up the definition of "public good" if you do not know what it is since it has nothing to do with publicly-owned goods), which, almost by definition, have to be financed by taxes or donations.

Like I said, its a matter of degree and how much socialism you want.
 
I like it when people who were borne and raised in Canada try to explain to people who came from the former USSR what a socialism is. Also, do not mistake welfare from government-owned and run enterprises. Here is what 15-second Google search tells about hospital ownership:

"Although almost all Canadians believe hospitals are publicly owned and accountable institutions, under provincial legislation 95% operate on a non-profit basis. Most of Canada's approximately 850 hospitals are owned and operated by non-profit, voluntary organizations."

For people who partied in school (i.e., Frankfooter), it means that government does not own or run hospitals, it does not appoint directors, hires doctors, etc.
Who pays doctors? Now tell us that the government doesn't pay teachers or soldiers...LOL
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Likewise, I find it amusing when people from former Communist countries try to to explain to people in Canada what socialism in the west is.


Oh and you claim it is different from what they experienced

c8jw8zj48fi31.jpg




main-qimg-fcfc58dbb82f33cd2972e0df6ee862fc


Democratic%2BSocialism%2Bhas%2Bsprinkles.jpg
 
Last edited:
Now, you are saying that
1. democratic socialism is the same as socialism.
2 Socialism has never worked.

Ergo, you are saying that democratic socialism has never worked.

That is demonstrably not true. Some of the most successful countries in the world, as for example New Zealand, Scandinavia, the Netherlands and Germany are governed by Democratic Socialism principles.
 
This is a definition of socialism from Oxford Learner;'s dictionary:

" a set of political and economic theories based on the belief that everyone has an equal right to a share of a country's wealth and that the government should own and control the main industries "

As you can see, one of it main characteristics is that government owns and controls main industries. All first-world country (USA, Canada, all western European countries) are capitalist countries with different degrees of welfare. Unless, of course, you start using some different definition of "socialism"

And, by the way, here is the definition of "democratic socialism":

"In general, a label for any person or group who advocates the pursuit of socialism by democratic means. Used especially by parliamentary socialists who put parliamentarism ahead of socialism, and therefore oppose revolutionary action against democratically elected governments."

As you can see, it also has nothing to do with current regimes in developed countries since it simply say about the method of achieving socialism (which definition was above and none of the counties satisfy it)

So, to be fair, please, refer to what is going on in European countries as "welfare state" not "Socialism". I know, it may not be a sexy name and it sounds like "charity" but it is the correct name. The only big socialist countries now are China and Cuba
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jcpro
This is a definition of socialism from Oxford Learner;'s dictionary:

" a set of political and economic theories based on the belief that everyone has an equal right to a share of a country's wealth and that the government should own and control the main industries "

As you can see, one of it main characteristics is that government owns and controls main industries. All first-world country (USA, Canada, all western European countries) are capitalist countries with different degrees of welfare. Unless, of course, you start using some different definition of "socialism"

And, by the way, here is the definition of "democratic socialism":

"In general, a label for any person or group who advocates the pursuit of socialism by democratic means. Used especially by parliamentary socialists who put parliamentarism ahead of socialism, and therefore oppose revolutionary action against democratically elected governments."

As you can see, it also has nothing to do with current regimes in developed countries since it simply say about the method of achieving socialism (which definition was above and none of the counties satisfy it)

So, to be fair, please, refer to what is going on in European countries as "welfare state" not "Socialism". I know, it may not be a sexy name and it sounds like "charity" but it is the correct name. The only big socialist countries now are China and Cuba


There has never been a truly socialist country just has there has never been a truly capitalist country. There are countries that have some of each in varying proportions. The real debate is in the proportion of each that works for a particular country.
 
There has never been a truly socialist country just has there has never been a truly capitalist country. There are countries that have some of each in varying proportions. The real debate is in the proportion of each that works for a particular country.

USSR was a truly socialist country as ALL production and services was owned by the government. Even all residential apartments were government-owned. Only village houses were privately owned (but not the land) and the only allowed private economic activity was to grow and sell the produce and meat on the small "backyards" in villages. Buying something for future resale or manufacturing anything that require hiring other people were criminal activity with substantial jail time. You were allowed to sell what you make yourself (like knitting), but you were also required to be full-time employed at the regular (i.e., government-owned) sector. This is a true socialism. When almost all businesses are private with the exception of public good provision (education, defence, infrastructure), it is a true capitalism. Rarely the government runs health care, but most of the time it funds it. The latter, however, has nothing to do with socialism, it is just a welfare and income redistribution (a.k.a. charity) made by the government.
 
USSR was a truly socialist country as ALL production and services was owned by the government. Even all residential apartments were government-owned. Only village houses were privately owned (but not the land) and the only allowed private economic activity was to grow and sell the produce and meat on the small "backyards" in villages. Buying something for future resale or manufacturing anything that require hiring other people were criminal activity with substantial jail time. You were allowed to sell what you make yourself (like knitting), but you were also required to be full-time employed at the regular (i.e., government-owned) sector. This is a true socialism. When almost all businesses are private with the exception of public good provision (education, defence, infrastructure), it is a true capitalism. Rarely the government runs health care, but most of the time it funds it. The latter, however, has nothing to do with socialism, it is just a welfare and income redistribution (a.k.a. charity) made by the government.

That doesn’t seem to correlate to reality.
1625433051959.jpeg
 
They still don't seem to understand the difference between socialism and communism.
And you don't understand the difference between socialism and capitalism as economic systems.
 
There has never been a truly socialist country just has there has never been a truly capitalist country. There are countries that have some of each in varying proportions. The real debate is in the proportion of each that works for a particular country.
Actually, there's no such debate. No first world nation seeks nationalization of the whole or the parts of the economy as a cure for anything or a solution. You are simply confusing the regulatory environment around the free markets and the emergence of the welfare policies with socialism. A common mistake as witnessed even here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fall
Actually, there's no such debate. No first world nation seeks nationalization of the whole or the parts of the economy as a cure for anything or a solution. You are simply confusing the regulatory environment around the free markets and the emergence of the welfare policies with socialism. A common mistake as witnessed even here.
This.
 
Actually, there's no such debate. No first world nation seeks nationalization of the whole or the parts of the economy as a cure for anything or a solution. You are simply confusing the regulatory environment around the free markets and the emergence of the welfare policies with socialism. A common mistake as witnessed even here.
The confusion emerges because the conservatives, right wingers scream socialism, when universal health care, free tuition or anything similar is mentioned.
 
USSR was a truly socialist country as ALL production and services was owned by the government. Even all residential apartments were government-owned. Only village houses were privately owned (but not the land) and the only allowed private economic activity was to grow and sell the produce and meat on the small "backyards" in villages. Buying something for future resale or manufacturing anything that require hiring other people were criminal activity with substantial jail time. You were allowed to sell what you make yourself (like knitting), but you were also required to be full-time employed at the regular (i.e., government-owned) sector. This is a true socialism. When almost all businesses are private with the exception of public good provision (education, defence, infrastructure), it is a true capitalism. Rarely the government runs health care, but most of the time it funds it. The latter, however, has nothing to do with socialism, it is just a welfare and income redistribution (a.k.a. charity) made by the government.

You are failing yo distinguish between socialism and communism. The USSR was never truly a socialist society or economy. Although it may have been started following the revolution with those ideals they were never realized.
 
The confusion emerges because the conservatives, right wingers scream socialism, when universal health care, free tuition or anything similar is mentioned.
Hence, you should't perpetuate the rightist propaganda and misinformation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fall