Socialism seems to work

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
Net financial assets per person in MKr


desktop-20210702094902
 
You are not really talking about true socialism but rather democratic socialism which is quite different. true socialism does not work. capitalism is much more effective provided that a social safety net is put in place to protect the people at the margins and as long as there is a more equitable and effective tax system. there should be a minimum tax and many of the provisions which unfairly favor the rich should be eliminated. But as a system of economic organization capitalism is much more effective and beneficial to all. Even the Chinese and to some extent the Cubans recognize that. Russia is a different story as it is effectively a large criminal organization.
 
Net financial assets per person in MKr


desktop-20210702094902


Please indicate what are the English translations of the x and y axis?
Please indicate the subset of countries in the sample (i do not see England, Canada, USA , nor do I see socialist Venezuela, Cuba or N Korea)
Please indicate the source

Thank You

btw socialism does not work
turning-point-usa-socialism-ideas-so-good-that-they-have-27790886.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Facman and masspref
You are not really talking about true socialism but rather democratic socialism which is quite different. true socialism does not work. capitalism is much more effective provided that a social safety net is put in place to protect the people at the margins and as long as there is a more equitable and effective tax system. there should be a minimum tax and many of the provisions which unfairly favor the rich should be eliminated. But as a system of economic organization capitalism is much more effective and beneficial to all. Even the Chinese and to some extent the Cubans recognize that. Russia is a different story as it is effectively a large criminal organization.
Of course it is social democracy, but the point is that Americans and the right wingers here consider it socialism. ( of which they have no idea)
 
Of course it is social democracy, but the point is that Americans and the right wingers here consider it socialism. ( of which they have no idea)
I agree and lament the fact that a strong definition of socialism is not widely known in the US and that lets right wingers successfully (but incorrectly) label any liberal or progressive idea as socialist. If it’s very liberal and/or progressive it becomes all too tempting for the right wing to label it communist.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shakenbake
Socialism and capitalism are economic systems. Capitalism functions very well in democracy, socialism cannot function in a democracy at all. Today's lefties keep mistaking the welfare state and the social programs associated with it as socialism. Nothing could be more false because that approach would mean that leaders as different as Hitler and FDR, Adenauer and Thatcher were socialists. And that is patently ridiculous.
Socialism simply means that the economy is run and owned by the state.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
Socialism and capitalism are economic systems. Capitalism functions very well in democracy, socialism cannot function in a democracy at all. Today's lefties keep mistaking the welfare state and the social programs associated with it as socialism. Nothing could be more false because that approach would mean that leaders as different as Hitler and FDR, Adenauer and Thatcher were socialists. And that is patently ridiculous.
Socialism simply means that the economy is run and owned by the state.

Totally wrong.
Here in Canada we have multiple socialist programs, like public schools, healthcare, publicly paid roads, police....

In a real free market/capitalist society you'd only have toll roads and private schools.
 
Of course it is social democracy, but the point is that Americans and the right wingers here consider it socialism. ( of which they have no idea)

Very true and sad. If asked about the actual workings of democratic socialism rather than the bogey-man portrayed by the right most Americans would embrace it. I am sure that Frank Luntz or someone like him has tested the phrase and found that it stirs up fears of communism etc.
 
Last edited:
Totally wrong.
Here in Canada we have multiple socialist programs, like public schools, healthcare, publicly paid roads, police....

In a real free market/capitalist society you'd only have toll roads and private schools.
I cannot help it that you have glaring gaps in your schooling and Wikipedia and Vox are not a substitute for a basic, solid education.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
Totally wrong.
Here in Canada we have multiple socialist programs, like public schools, healthcare, publicly paid roads, police....

In a real free market/capitalist society you'd only have toll roads and private schools.
No he's totally right, its you that is totally wrong. As wrong as wrong can be.

Denmark, Sweden, Norway, the UK, the US, Canada etc. are real free market capitalist economies. The main area in which we differ is our ratio of public sector vs. private sector ownership of the economy.
 
I cannot help it that you have glaring gaps in your schooling and Wikipedia and Vox are not a substitute for a basic, solid education.

You really think Canada's public school system is a capitalist vernture?
You'll never understand politics at this rate.
No wonder you still think Trump won.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Claudia Love
No he's totally right, its you that is totally wrong. As wrong as wrong can be.

Denmark, Sweden, Norway, the UK, the US, Canada etc. are real free market capitalist economies. The main area in which we differ is our ratio of public sector vs. private sector ownership of the economy.

Yes, the difference is the amount of socialism.
Public ownership is socialism.
 
Yes, the difference is the amount of socialism.
Public ownership is socialism.

I like it when people who were borne and raised in Canada try to explain to people who came from the former USSR what a socialism is. Also, do not mistake welfare from government-owned and run enterprises. Here is what 15-second Google search tells about hospital ownership:

"Although almost all Canadians believe hospitals are publicly owned and accountable institutions, under provincial legislation 95% operate on a non-profit basis. Most of Canada's approximately 850 hospitals are owned and operated by non-profit, voluntary organizations."

For people who partied in school (i.e., Frankfooter), it means that government does not own or run hospitals, it does not appoint directors, hires doctors, etc.
 
To parallel G. K. Chesterton: "The Socialist ideal has not been tried and found wanting. It has been found difficult and left untried.”

Perry
 
I like it when people who were borne and raised in Canada try to explain to people who came from the former USSR what a socialism is. Also, do not mistake welfare from government-owned and run enterprises. Here is what 15-second Google search tells about hospital ownership:

"Although almost all Canadians believe hospitals are publicly owned and accountable institutions, under provincial legislation 95% operate on a non-profit basis. Most of Canada's approximately 850 hospitals are owned and operated by non-profit, voluntary organizations."

For people who partied in school (i.e., Frankfooter), it means that government does not own or run hospitals, it does not appoint directors, hires doctors, etc.

Fine, we'll stick to public roads, schools, libraries and police.
Better?