You're having anal sex with someone with a penis.
Your friend is correct. Banging trannies doesn't automatically make you gay. There are tons of guys who cross that particular line from time to time.
By your rationale then, there is nothing gay about having vaginal sex with Buck Angel. FTM with a vagina.
Has the Dan White Society taken a position?...
Sure it's gay, if you don't say no homo after. Also gay if you push back or don't beat him up after or if it's not part of a three way.
More seriously, yeah it's gay, who gives a fuck. It isn't full opening a bread and breakfast in Vermont with your male lover while watching NPH and George Takei porn level gay, but it's still a dude.
By your rationale then, there is nothing gay about having vaginal sex with Buck Angel. FTM with a vagina.
![]()