Human Rights Violations No One Talks About

1) Yes, Palestine is not apartheid because it is presently occupied by Israel and ruled through military, apartheid.

2) Back to the offer Olmert wouldn't put down on paper as the best you think Palestinians will ever get.

I'll offer to sell you some great land in Florida, but unfortunately its so top secret that I can't sign over a deed or give you a receipt.
Its down in one of the best areas, but unfortunately you can't see the map yet.
You don't have a problem with that, do you?

Hey look, Hamas is getting ready for the ICC.
What's Israel doing to prep war crimes charges or charges of apartheid?

1) Do you have your own definition of apartheid because the generally accepted definition is a system of legal discrimination based on ethnicity.

And I love how you want to excuse racism and actual apartheid from the PA.
You obviously think it wrong for Israeli Jews to enter or live in the West Bank.
You previously stated you are okay with Arab Israelis entering or living in the West Bank.
If you are okay with Arab Israelis being in the West Bank then your problem is with the Jewish part, not the Israeli part.

And that is the actual official policy of the PA, Israel Arabs are allowed in PA controlled territory while Israeli Jews are not. That is the definition of Apartheid.

2) You love making excuses for Abbas walking away from a deal that fits all the criteria of the UN, the Quartet, and the Arab league and well in line with what the PA had been demanding. There was absolutely nothing preventing him form making a counter-offer with his own map but he chose to ignore it.


p.s. I'm not surprised that instead of actually criticizing Hamas for rockets, bombings, and murders, you're here cheering on them trying to defend themselves against things that even your much-quoted groups like Amnesty have condemned them for.
 
1) Do you have your own definition of apartheid because the generally accepted definition is a system of legal discrimination based on ethnicity.


From another UN expert who has reported that Israel is apartheid.
The B'tselem and UN reports have found the same thing that other reports have, Israel is apartheid as its a system of legal discrimination based on ethnicity and/or religion.
Whatcha gonna do next, go all cultural genocidal and claim Palestinians don't exist as a people?
 

From another UN expert who has reported that Israel is apartheid.
The B'tselem and UN reports have found the same thing that other reports have, Israel is apartheid as its a system of legal discrimination based on ethnicity and/or religion.
Whatcha gonna do next, go all cultural genocidal and claim Palestinians don't exist as a people?

What a surprise, you mention another guy hand-picked by a bunch of dictators to make pre-determined statements about Israel instead of defending your own opinion.

You obviously think it wrong for Israeli Jews to enter or live in the West Bank.
You previously stated you are okay with Arab Israelis entering or living in the West Bank.
If you are okay with Arab Israelis being in the West Bank then your problem is with the Jewish part, not the Israeli part.


And if you really like the idea of peace, how come you keep defending Abbas rejecting a comprehensive peace offer completely in line with what the UN thinks fair without even bothering to make a counter-proposal
 
What a surprise, you mention another guy hand-picked by a bunch of dictators to make pre-determined statements about Israel instead of defending your own opinion.

You obviously think it wrong for Israeli Jews to enter or live in the West Bank.
You previously stated you are okay with Arab Israelis entering or living in the West Bank.
If you are okay with Arab Israelis being in the West Bank then your problem is with the Jewish part, not the Israeli part.


And if you really like the idea of peace, how come you keep defending Abbas rejecting a comprehensive peace offer completely in line with what the UN thinks fair without even bothering to make a counter-proposal

Did you enjoy your conversation with yourself, basketcase?
Let me know when you're done and we can get back to reality.

I don't really care if there is a two state or a one state solution, as long as there is an agreement with both sides.
But we both know that the two state solution is toast, there are already too many settlements, which you say 'isn't the problem'.
And if there is a two state solution all the settlements, which are illegal and war crimes, are definitely a big problem.
The one state solution is really the only way to allow those settlements to stay, though all the walls and apartheid roads would have to end.
But the ICJ already ruled the apartheid wall is illegal, so we knew that already.

Now that its apartheid, as reported by multiple UN reports, South Africans and Israel's largest human rights organization, you're going to have to figure out how to end that apartheid and move forward.
Unless you, like Netanyahu, would prefer to back ethnic cleansing instead.
 
...

I don't really care if there is a two state or a one state solution, as long as there is an agreement with both sides.
...
Yet you spend endless amounts of time trying to force the Palestinians (and Israelis) into a path they despise. You have also spend endless posts making excuses for Palestinians (and before them Arabs states) for rejecting any peace and Hamas for refusing even to consider peace talks. Just another case of your bullshit.

Olmert offered a completely contiguous Palestinian state with Jerusalem as a shared capitol with international oversight. He offered land swaps that included a land corridor between Gaza and the West bank. He offered some refugees/descendants could become Israeli while the rest would get financial compensation and help settling in Palestine, the country of their birth, or third countries. He offered to remove Jewish settlers from formerly Arab parts of the Old City and evacuate some settlements that weren't part of land swaps. Abbas walked away and cancelled the follow-up meeting that were scheduled.

And you keep making excuses for Abbas rejecting this deal and refusing to make a counter-offer.




And I notice you refuse to fess up to being the one promoting different rules base on religion.

You obviously think it wrong for Israeli Jews to enter or live in the West Bank.
You previously stated you are okay with Arab Israelis entering or living in the West Bank.
If you are okay with Arab Israelis being in the West Bank then your problem is with the Jewish part, not the Israeli part, just like the PA.
 
Last edited:
Yet you spend endless amounts of time trying to force the Palestinians (and Israelis) into a path they despise. You have also spend endless posts making excuses for Palestinians (and before them Arabs states) for rejecting any peace and Hamas for refusing even to consider peace talks. Just another case of your bullshit.

1) There was no legit peace deal. Olmert wouldn't even give Abbas a map of what he was offering.
2) The two state solution is dead and everyone knows it. There are too many settlements and their is zero chance of a legit contiguous state of Palestine being created with the bits left over.
3) The one state solution is already here, the problem is that is the apartheid one state that you seem to love and support. I just think that after 53 years its time for Palestinians to get basic human rights and freedoms on the land they live on.

Your bullshit has supported the creation of apartheid Israel and supported heinous war crimes now being investigated by the ICC.
At least I offer peaceful solutions.
You offer only anger and hate.
 
1) There was no legit peace deal. Olmert wouldn't even give Abbas a map of what he was offering.
...
1) Keep making excuses. Olmert made the offer and there was nothing stopping Abbas from creating his own map. Instead he chose to cancel the planned follow-up meetings. Obviously you don't have any interest in peace if it means Israel continuing to exist.

2) No matter how many times you claim a Two-State peace is impossible, the UN disagrees.

3) Palestinian support for a two-state peace is 5 times their support for One State. You keep talking about Palestinian rights and self-determination while telling them they need to do something they hate. Just another case of your fraud and hypocrisy.
 
1) Keep making excuses. Olmert made the offer and there was nothing stopping Abbas from creating his own map. Instead he chose to cancel the planned follow-up meetings. Obviously you don't have any interest in peace if it means Israel continuing to exist.

2) No matter how many times you claim a Two-State peace is impossible, the UN disagrees.

3) Palestinian support for a two-state peace is 5 times their support for One State. You keep talking about Palestinian rights and self-determination while telling them they need to do something they hate. Just another case of your fraud and hypocrisy.

1) 'Abbas should have made his own map' - Sure, and he should have said Olmert gave them all of Israel/Palestine while he was drawing it too.
2) The UN also says Israel should end the occupation. I assume you agree with that as well? Same with their finding that Israel is apartheid?
3) They also support bringing back all Palestinian refugees and ending the occupation. You think those are going to happen too?

Its been 53 years of occupation.
The one state solution is already there and its apartheid.

That's the status quo.


202101_this_is_apartheid_eng_top_3.jpg
 
1) 'Abbas should have made his own map' - Sure, and he should have said Olmert gave them all of Israel/Palestine while he was drawing it too.
...
So more excuses for Abbas walking away from peace. I know your sense of reality is weak but in the real world, negotiations work by one side making a proposal and the other side making a counter-proposal. Abbas cancelled follow-up meetings instead of having his own map created.

I also love how you pick and choose when to listen to the UN and how you claim to support Palestinian rights while demanding they follow your plan which only 9.3% support.


p.s. The UN doesn't say what you claim they do. the actual text:
Resolves that the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date, and that compensation should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return and for loss of or damage to property which, under principles of international law or in equity, should be made good by the Governments or authorities responsible;

Last poll I could find of refugees and their descendants say very few want to be Israeli. Just another case where you want to force Palestinians into something they don't want.
 
The UN doesn't say what you claim they do. the actual text:
Resolves that the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date, and that compensation should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return and for loss of or damage to property which, under principles of international law or in equity, should be made good by the Governments or authorities responsible;

Last poll I could find of refugees and their descendants say very few want to be Israeli. Just another case where you want to force Palestinians into something they don't want.

Its true that Israel could offer a settlement but even so, its up to the 5 million Palestinian refugees to decide whether they'd want to take a settlement or move back to their homeland.
How much do you think Israel would owe families for 53 years of being forced to live in refugee camps?

That's another problem you can't solve, isn't it?
Just like you can't figure out how to deal with the status quo, one state apartheid solution now in place.

You do know the buzz word of the year, don't you?

Decolonization.

The path to peace in Israel-Palestine is through decolonisation
Only the formation of a single decolonised state encompassing the entire territory of historical Palestine can put an end to Israel’s colonial ambitions.


 
Its true that Israel could offer a settlement but even so, its up to the 5 million Palestinian refugees to decide whether they'd want to take a settlement or move back to their homeland.
...
And overwhelmingly polls show they don't want to go to Israel no matter how much you want to force them (just like the 850,000 Jews chased from their homes and their millions of descendants don't want to go back there - that UN resolution applies as much to them as it does to Palestinians).

So any more excuses for Abbas walking away? What is clear is that neither you nor him support the idea of a negotiated peace.

p.s. the decolonization argument is bullshit and just another attempt by you (and your fellows) to claim Israel shouldn't exist and Jews shouldn't be in the Middle East, especially coming from a Canadian who is happily enjoying the fruits of a colonial system that is far more opressive.
 
And overwhelmingly polls show they don't want to go to Israel no matter how much you want to force them (just like the 850,000 Jews chased from their homes and their millions of descendants don't want to go back there - that UN resolution applies as much to them as it does to Palestinians).

Post those polls, I don't believe you.

p.s. the decolonization argument is bullshit and just another attempt by you (and your fellows) to claim Israel shouldn't exist and Jews shouldn't be in the Middle East,

Israel is the last colonial state and the only one that's still trying to increase its border through war.
 
Post those polls, I don't believe you.
...
We'll there's the ones we keep discussing where only 9.3% of Palestinians want a One State solution.

The most recent poll I can find specifically for refugees and descendants is pretty dated but is in line with the PSR. There are other polls of refugees/descendants and other polls of Palestinians in general but if you have anything more recent polls specifically about what refugees want, I'd be happy to look at it..

Seems that the vast majority of Palestinians Refugees/descendants want compensation and not become Israelis (not that you ever care about what Palestinians actually want). There are even more people who support your goals of rejecting any peace than want to live in Israel.


​
Refugees' First Choice
(for the exercise of the right of the right of return)
WBGS%Jordan%Lebanon%Total (% of total population in the three areas)
1. Return to Israel and become (or not become) an Israeli citizen1252310
2. Stay in the Palestinian state that will be established in theWest Bank and Gaza Strip and receive a fair compensation for the property taken over byIsrael and for other losses and suffering38271931
3. Receive Palestinian citizenship and return to designated areas inside Israel that would be swapped later on with Palestinian areas as part of a territorial exchange and receive any deserved compensation37102123
4. Receive fair compensation for the property, losses, and suffering and stay in host country receiving its citizenship or Palestinian citizenship-331117
Receive fair compensation for the property, losses, and suffering and immigrate to a European country or the US, Australia, or Canada and obtain citizenship of that country or Palestinian citizenship1292
6. Refuse all options9161713
7. No opinion2805


And I love how quickly you want to stop discussing why Abbas refused to continue negotiations or make his own offer about a map.
 
Last edited: