Trump's Legacy

Then you don't know what a fact is. Europe has more deaths than the U.S. is a fact. You can present other facts, but you can't say that this is not a fact nor can you say it is not a relevant fact.

In response to your post, the U.S. is not uniform in its impact from the virus. Even with all the panic over Florida and Texas, the Tri-State area (NY, NJ and CT) has been hit much harder than other regions. I'll certainly give the Germans credit for their early testing and I'm guessing they isolated the vulnerable population.

Well according to the facts today, NY, NJ, and CT are on a decidedly downward trend, and Florida and Texas have seen record numbers of new cases. Florida had more new cases yesterday than New York had t their peak of the pandemic.
 
Then you don't know what a fact is. Europe has more deaths than the U.S. is a fact. You can present other facts, but you can't say that this is not a fact nor can you say it is not a relevant fact.

In response to your post, the U.S. is not uniform in its impact from the virus. Even with all the panic over Florida and Texas, the Tri-State area (NY, NJ and CT) has been hit much harder than other regions. I'll certainly give the Germans credit for their early testing and I'm guessing they isolated the vulnerable population.

It is partly the same story in Europe.

Spain and Italy was hit hard early without much warning. I guess Belgium also.

The countries that heeded the warnings, like Germany, Denmark, Norway, and a lot of the eastern countries in Europe (and Asian countries), had much lower deaths per capita (about 100/million), while the countries that did not believe the warnings, like UK (Johnson), and USA(Trump) have had much higher deaths per capita (680 and 380 resp). I do not know the story in France.

What is important is that USA still has an increasing infection and hospitalization rate, while European countries all have much reduced infection rates.
 
Then you don't know what a fact is. Europe has more deaths than the U.S. is a fact. You can present other facts, but you can't say that this is not a fact nor can you say it is not a relevant fact.

Yes true for now. But look at the curbs. The virus is in steep decline in Europe, like in Canada, but still growing strong in the USA. So let's wait until the US has outbreak #1 under control before making comparison.

Cheers,
 
Yes true for now. But look at the curbs. The virus is in steep decline in Europe, like in Canada, but still growing strong in the USA. So let's wait until the US has outbreak #1 under control before making comparison.

Cheers,
The virus isn't going away anytime soon. Cases will go up almost everywhere in the world. The key is to keep the vulnerable population isolated. I don't think trying to keep young people locked up is the solution. I hear that even in California they are having trouble getting the younger population to socially distance and wear masks.
 
The virus isn't going away anytime soon. Cases will go up almost everywhere in the world. The key is to keep the vulnerable population isolated. I don't think trying to keep young people locked up is the solution. I hear that even in California they are having trouble getting the younger population to socially distance and wear masks.
It is simple. Half of Americans do not want to wear masks and keep social distancing, partly because they are encouraged by the President in this behavior.

The truth is, and everybody knows it, or should know it by now, that if steps to isolate the infected and trace interactions are taken and people keep social distancing and wear masks, are taken early enough, a country can keep the virus under control, if not eradicate it. Spain and Italy even managed to get the virus under control much later in the process.

It is probably too late for many areas in USA to get the virus under control. How do you trace the interactions of 5 million people. The train has left the station.
 
The virus isn't going away anytime soon. Cases will go up almost everywhere in the world. The key is to keep the vulnerable population isolated. I don't think trying to keep young people locked up is the solution. I hear that even in California they are having trouble getting the younger population to socially distance and wear masks.

True but I was just highlighting the fact that it's too soon to say Europe had more death then the USA. Look at the pattern for both:



Part of the problem is the mentality of the american people who think wearing a mask is an attempt to their liberty!! haha
 
Wyatt's right about Europe. Still higher totals. (Not sure about the per capita rate once you adjust for population.) I expect the US will pass it, but that isn't true now.

As for Legacy...

Assuming a one term presidency (and that's assuming a lot - I still expect the polls to naturally tighten and the EC advantage is nothing to sneeze at) then I'm gonna go with the judges.

The push to control the judiciary is probably the only unqualified success he has had in terms of the people who supported him getting what they want. Short of a massive impeachment program (which seems like a bad idea for any number of reasons) the US court system will be wildly Conservative for a generation at least. These are straight-up Federalist Society picks, they are young, and they are overtly ideological. Add in that with congress more and more likely to be gridlocked, policy is made in the courts and you understand that the Democrats could win elections in all three houses for 30 years and have most of their legislation blocked.

I think that is probably the single most important legacy Trump will leave (even though it isn't really about him. He just agreed to it and let the FS and McConnell move it along.)

In terms of a legacy specifically about Trump, then it is probably the erosion of US power overall by actively sabotaging alliances and trust. The US was losing its hegemony anyway, but there were ways to manage that that left the US in much better shape than we will be after this. The other is demonstrating that most of the checks and balances on power in the US structure are unenforceable. They exist as norms, and with a bad faith effort can be subverted. That may be fixable, but I think it probably isn't - which means the legacy will be a very changed system far more based on authoritarian lines. It isn't going to collapse all at once, and it may drop to a new stable level and not break down entirely, but more likely the baton will be picked up in the future and the new normal will be even less responsive to the people.
 
Wyatt's right about Europe. Still higher totals. (Not sure about the per capita rate once you adjust for population.) I expect the US will pass it, but that isn't true now.

The population of Europe is 747 million according to worldometer so more than twice that of the US.
Despite that the US has more cases, so has about twice the number per capita.
 
The population of Europe is 747 million according to worldometer so more than twice that of the US.
Despite that the US has more cases, so has about twice the number per capita.
I would probably just look at countries in Western Europe. Russia and some other Eastern European countries are unlikely to be transparent about COVID.
 
The jury is still out on Trump's responsibility in the COVID outbreak. The death toll in Europe is still far ahead of the U.S.

The death toll in Canada is much less than the US. But of course, you will point out that Canada only has 1/10th the population of the US while being ignorant that Europe depending on how you define it has 2-3 times the population of the US.
 
I would probably just look at countries in Western Europe. Russia and some other Eastern European countries are unlikely to be transparent about COVID.

Agreed. Also, that makes the comparison less balanced. I usually see Europe's population put in the 400 million range. (That's probably Western Europe). That seems a better fit.
 
In terms of a legacy specifically about Trump, then it is probably the erosion of US power overall by actively sabotaging alliances and trust. The US was losing its hegemony anyway, but there were ways to manage that that left the US in much better shape than we will be after this. The other is demonstrating that most of the checks and balances on power in the US structure are unenforceable. They exist as norms, and with a bad faith effort can be subverted. That may be fixable, but I think it probably isn't - which means the legacy will be a very changed system far more based on authoritarian lines. It isn't going to collapse all at once, and it may drop to a new stable level and not break down entirely, but more likely the baton will be picked up in the future and the new normal will be even less responsive to the people.

Some of this sounds like someone who likes to read poli-sci papers. Obama enacted many executive decrees. The Roberts' Supreme Court basically ruled in favor of Obama's DACA executive decree. If you know the U.S. Constitution, you know the Senate must ratify treaties like the Iran nuclear deal and the Paris climate agreement. So one man's Trump overreach is another man's undoing of Obama's overreach.

I am afraid as long as both parties refuse to compromise in Congress the void will be filled by whoever is President. Of course, that's all Newt Gingrich's fault, right Val?
 
I know you hate my Gingrich opinion. :)

I'm not talking about using executive orders. I'm talking about stuff likes what is going on with the DoJ. I'm talking about the role of partisanship in sabatoging basic governance, etc. He has demonstrated that the guard rails depend on the good faith of the people involved and if someone is willing to just barrel ahead, they can't really be stopped easily.

As for treaties, again, I'm not talking about his ability to pull out of treaties. I'm talking about the choices he has made to do so and how to do so. Undermining international order that favoured the US and gave it a lot of power. We don't get that position or that infrastructure back easily, if at all. That's the legacy. The world was going to be multi-polar anyway, but how strong a position the US had in that new order was (and still is) modifyable. Pissing away our advantages means the legacy will be a world where we don't have those advantages.
 
I would probably just look at countries in Western Europe. Russia and some other Eastern European countries are unlikely to be transparent about COVID.

Doesn't matter, if you take out more countries the total cases and deaths go down.
The US will still have more than double per capita.
 
In terms of a legacy specifically about Trump, then it is probably the erosion of US power overall by actively sabotaging alliances and trust. The US was losing its hegemony anyway, but there were ways to manage that that left the US in much better shape than we will be after this.
Maintaining U.S. power is ridiculously expensive. I don't have the statistics handy but think of all the costs involved in maintaining all those bases around the world and then there are the losses of treasure and blood in endless wars. I think the time is overdue for South Korea, Japan, Taiwan, the Philippines, Saudi Arabia and Western and Eastern Europe to defend themselves.
 
I think Trump will be a one term president. So, what will be his legacy?

His administration has balanced the extreme left wing bias in the judiciary with the appointment of two SCOTUS judges and 300 lower court federal judges. So, we should see some more (but not all) rational judgments in the coming years.

Your opinion on the Judiciary demonstrates you yourself are a few bricks short of a load to begin with. Trumps "legacy", already being seen, is the significant decline in US influence throughout the world. Conceivably he starts a war that a combination of powers finish. (the war and the US Govt.) Just pray there's enough left to go on existing...
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlueJays1992
Maintaining U.S. power is ridiculously expensive. I don't have the statistics handy but think of all the costs involved in maintaining all those bases around the world and then there are the losses of treasure and blood in endless wars. I think the time is overdue for South Korea, Japan, Taiwan, the Philippines, Saudi Arabia and Western and Eastern Europe to defend themselves.

That is a wonderful plan until they all decide to adopt the Chinese Yuan as their petrodollar and reserve currency.
 
I think he'll be seen as amongst the worst. Not saying that as a USA liberal (I am an Aussie liberal party, the liberal party in Australia is a conservative centre-right party, the main competitor is the labour party which is a centre-left party; far left are democrats and green, far right is country party). Many USA republicans have also agreed he is the worst (the people who ran McCain's and Romney's campaigns who are now the Lincoln Project, I'd be one of those blokes).

First, the economy was a continuation of obama, even before the pandemic (of course great depression collapse after). Economic growth roughly the same as Obama (Trump 2.23 and 2.93% first 2 years, Obama 1.57 and 2.88% last 2 years) and nowhere near previous presidents (jimmy carter averaged about 5% growth lol), Obama added more jobs in his last 3 years than trump in his first 3. The unemployment got lower under Trump, but the decrease was larger under Obama. The percentage rise in stock market higher for obama over trump, but points higher under trump. Thus the point is even if economy better under trump v. Obama, it was not significantly better than Obama and both O and T had less GDP growth than almost all other presidents since the great depression. Also add the issue of cutting regulations. Too much? Too little? Honest people can disagree. Immigration? Also mixed. Obama deported more than Bush. But too far I think. Thus not saying those were good or bad, people can honourably disagree.

Second, left and right can honestly disagree about the judges, but Trump has put forth judges rated unqualified by the ABA for the first time.

Third, more lies than all presidents combined in the last 100 years (Obama told 18, Trump approaching 20,000). Attack on truth and fact.

Fourth, elimination of checks and balances through firing inspector general's and anyone investigating him. Through ignoring subpoenas. Through obstruction of justice (10 distinct acts in Mueller report).

Fifth, biggest USA deficit/debt in history.

Sixth, destruction of alliances/nato. USA had allies. Russia does not. China does not. Thus giving up a huge usa advantage over her competitors. Gave up Asia to China. Made concessions to north korea receiving nothing in return. Treasonous kowtowing to Russia believing Putin over his own intel agencies. Seeking foriegn help for reelection. Friendly to dictators, hostile to democracies. Any survey in any country show huge declines in admiration for USA, except in Russia and Israel. I work all over the world. USA is a laughing stock. People feel pity. It's extraordinary. Smart people who want to go to USA now going to Canada and Australia and UK instead.

Seventh, legacy of anti-science, supporting racists and confederates, mean spirited attacks on military families, other civilians.

Eighth, destruction of norms. USA system mostly worked because govt stayed within the norms. Now a shit ton of laws will be passed eliminating hiring family, clarifying emoluments, forcing release of taxes (remember he promised to release them after the election), distinct criminal penalties for ignogring subpoenas. He has moved USA toward banana republic style unaccountable govt, where family business intertwined w national business.

Ninth, botching pandemic. USA and south Korea have first death on same day. Since then SK has 250 deaths, USA 125,000.

Tenth, collapse of the economy.

11th, one of most corrupt administrations in USA history. Half the cabinet resigned under cloud. Most of campaign hierarchy in gaol.

I'm afraid that's how he'll be seen. History will say:
LEGACY:
Can't count on USA to honour treaties. USA dimished as a source of freedom in the world.
It is possible for autocracy to arise in USA.
Destruction of Republican party in its current form.
A strongly conservative court.
Tons of new laws codifying various norms.
A depression.
Impressive executive summary Mr. kherg007. Ever think of publishing a book on Trump's legacy and profit from it lol?