This is why America Burns

The Oracle

Pronouns: Who/Cares
Mar 8, 2004
32,617
71,931
113
On the slopes of Mount Parnassus, Greece
America is a great country to live in as long as you’re not old, sick, black or poor. This was the reality in the 1960s, when I immigrated from the United States to Canada, and very little has changed since.

To my mind, America’s failure to provide a more level playing field for its people redefines “American exceptionalism.” The United States is the richest country in the world, but has an underclass of at least 100 million people, the size of a Third World country, who are disenfranchised economically, educationally, socially and medically. It’s a virtual “Brazil,” with wealthier citizens living behind gates, security guards or in suburbs, away from poor neighbourhoods and their teeming populations of impoverished people. This is partly what the riots currently sweeping across the U.S., as they did two generations ago, are about, not just racism.

The street uprisings were sparked by a cellphone video that captured four Minneapolis policemen attacking, and ultimately killing, a black man who was arrested for a non-violent crime and not resisting arrest. One cop has been charged with murder and the others have been fired and are under investigation as accessories. This was a travesty that was made all the more dramatic because it took place in liberal Minnesota, not in uncivilized Mississippi.

Adding fuel to this outrage is the damage wreaked on America’s unprotected underclass by the COVID-19 pandemic. In the United States, the virus has disproportionately devastated elderly, poor and black communities. This is because they often lack access to health care, live in squalor and are crowded into substandard housing, nursing homes and congested neighbourhoods.

Worse, the lockdown “cure” was worse than the disease for them. It isolated elderly people who were unable to fend for themselves, or even dial 911 in some cases. It decimated the homeless, indigent and transient populations. It economically destroyed black, brown and impoverished communities of people who live from paycheck-to-paycheck on a measly $8-an-hour minimum wage. These people could not self-isolate and they could not set up computers at home to work remotely, collect benefits while on furlough or live off savings, because they have none.

America’s only solution is to undertake a Marshall Plan — in the form of a massive redistribution of wealth through taxation — directed at matching the world-class and egalitarian social services that other developed countries provide. This is about levelling the playing field by improving schools, health care, housing and employment prospects, so that all Americans have a fair shake. Right now, it’s a completely rigged game.

Yet this much-needed conversation isn’t even on the radar of America’s privileged. To make things worse, the Republican party, Fox News, the current occupant of the White House and other organizations have scapegoated the protesters as left-wing anarchists or criminals, while encouraging police to crack skulls, thus inciting more civil unrest. While there should be no tolerance for anyone who is violently protesting, looting or committing arson, blaming bad actors simply changes the subject and doesn’t address it.

The national conversation must start with the admission that America is not a just society and that it must change. The solution isn’t about “socialism” versus “freedom” or “free enterprise.” The European Union, Canada, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore and other enlightened nations have free societies and prosperous capitalist economies, but also provide great schools, health care and housing for a large number of their citizens.

They haven’t swallowed the American myth that low taxes for those who can afford to pay more results in “trickle down” benefits to everyone below them. The numbers prove that the taxes that individuals and corporations do not pay doesn’t create jobs for the rest. The spare cash is mostly invested in automation, offshoring to Mexico or China, buying stock back to benefit shareholders, doling out high executive salaries or flooded into offshore bank accounts to further reduce or eliminate taxes for the rich.

The only “trickle down” benefit that works is the creation of equal social services that help create equal opportunities. Until that happens, the American Dream remains a crock.

https://business.financialpost.com/diane-francis/diane-francis-this-is-why-america-burns
 
This is a very thoughtful and objective analysis.
 
The United States is the richest country in the world, but has an underclass of at least 100 million people,

The lockdown has revealed that the underclass is no longer limited to the urban people of colour.
It now includes suburban middle-class white millenials.
 
One reason you didn't point out, some people just find the whole burning thing to be fascinating. No fireworks this year? Let's torch a car or something. You don't even have to be political...
 
The United States is the richest country in the world, but has an underclass of at least 100 million people, the size of a Third World country, who are disenfranchised economically, educationally, socially and medically. It’s a virtual “Brazil,” with wealthier citizens living behind gates, security guards or in suburbs, away from poor neighbourhoods and their teeming populations of impoverished people.

This number 100 million and the comparison to Brazil doesn't pass the smell test. It kind of tips you off that the author is going for exaggeration to make her point. Many Brazilians live on wages of $250 a month. The schools and safety net barely exist for most. It also ignores the fact that many Latin Americans want to come to the U.S. That's the obvious argument that always blows away misleading statements like the one the author presents.

While I think we need to address income inequality, it is not the picture that the author is painting.
 
The two parties leadership think otherwise. They both prefer to suppress the lower classes.
 
Sigh. The "redistribution" is the old hat. It's really a code word for putting more burden on the middle class. It's the same game played in Canada where the definition of "rich" keeps getting lower for the simplest reason- there are not enough truly rich to confiscate from to make a difference. Class warfare sounds good, in theory, until one crunches the real numbers. And the conclusion is always the same: the middle class takes it up the ass. And then, they elect Trump or Ford and the lefties have a fit.
 
This number 100 million and the comparison to Brazil doesn't pass the smell test. It kind of tips you off that the author is going for exaggeration to make her point. Many Brazilians live on wages of $250 a month. The schools and safety net barely exist for most.

That's not that far off of the US for poor people and minorities.
 
Sigh. The "redistribution" is the old hat. It's really a code word for putting more burden on the middle class.

That's what right wingers tell you, but its not what its about.
1%
That's what its about.
 
Sigh. The "redistribution" is the old hat. It's really a code word for putting more burden on the middle class. It's the same game played in Canada where the definition of "rich" keeps getting lower for the simplest reason- there are not enough truly rich to confiscate from to make a difference. Class warfare sounds good, in theory, until one crunches the real numbers. And the conclusion is always the same: the middle class takes it up the ass. And then, they elect Trump or Ford and the lefties have a fit.

As opposed to the 5 trillion redistributed to the corporations? Without oversight?
 
That's not that far off of the US for poor people and minorities.

Most minorities do fine within a generation or two. African-Blacks do well too.
 
Sigh. The "redistribution" is the old hat. It's really a code word for putting more burden on the middle class. It's the same game played in Canada where the definition of "rich" keeps getting lower for the simplest reason- there are not enough truly rich to confiscate from to make a difference. Class warfare sounds good, in theory, until one crunches the real numbers. And the conclusion is always the same: the middle class takes it up the ass. And then, they elect Trump or Ford and the lefties have a fit.

jcpro, I tend to agree with your posts, but I do think the U.S. has an income inequality problem. We agree taxing people more and giving it to the underclass is not a panacea. We probably agree that taking on unfair trade and illegal immigration gives low wage earners in the economy a fighting chance. There's other measure to improve income levels for the lower quartile, but too much for a social media dissertation.

I have some empathy for taxing the 1%. Let's take away all the loopholes for sure. I fear that taxing the crap out of the 1% just gradually moves their economic activity to another domain. Why does the U.S. have a tremendously wealthy and dynamic 1%?

Give people an opportunity to catch fish. Don't take other people's fish and give them to someone else.
 
jcpro, I tend to agree with your posts, but I do think the U.S. has an income inequality problem. We agree taxing people more and giving it to the underclass is not a panacea. We probably agree that taking on unfair trade and illegal immigration gives low wage earners in the economy a fighting chance. There's other measure to improve income levels for the lower quartile, but too much for a social media dissertation.

I have some empathy for taxing the 1%. Let's take away all the loopholes for sure. I fear that taxing the crap out of the 1% just gradually moves their economic activity to another domain. Why does the U.S. have a tremendously wealthy and dynamic 1%?

Give people an opportunity to catch fish. Don't take other people's fish and give them to someone else.

I believe from seeing your posts for a while here on Terb, that you are knowledgeable and smart enough to know that you are posting diversionary words.

I do not know of anybody saying that the government should take the rich peoples money and give it to the poor. that is demagoguery.

What would make sense is for the governments to fund education, health care and general welfare, including work programs, for everybody based on need and ability.

That is not giving money to the poor, it is giving opportunities and hope to the poor. Sure, it has to be funded by either taxation or money printing, the latter being the preferred way to raise money for the rich.

Between the $3T to military and $6T to Wall St, giving the poor and disadvantaged opportunities for succeeding in life would be a drop in the bucket.

PS: Don't say it cannot be done. All other first world countries and quite a few others do it.
 
jcpro, I tend to agree with your posts, but I do think the U.S. has an income inequality problem. We agree taxing people more and giving it to the underclass is not a panacea. We probably agree that taking on unfair trade and illegal immigration gives low wage earners in the economy a fighting chance. There's other measure to improve income levels for the lower quartile, but too much for a social media dissertation.

I have some empathy for taxing the 1%. Let's take away all the loopholes for sure. I fear that taxing the crap out of the 1% just gradually moves their economic activity to another domain. Why does the U.S. have a tremendously wealthy and dynamic 1%?

Give people an opportunity to catch fish. Don't take other people's fish and give them to someone else.

I've got to hand it to you.....you packed just about every reactionary economic cliche imaginary into this drivel. These are the musings of a frightened middle class slug who's thrown in his lot in with the ruling class.
 
I've got to hand it to you.....you packed just about every reactionary economic cliche imaginary into this drivel. These are the musings of a frightened middle class slug who's throw in his lot in with the ruling class.

I've got to hand it you too ...... very well said!

Let us worry for America's 1% as they are under siege.
 
Give people an opportunity to catch fish. Don't take other people's fish and give them to someone else.

Don't charge them exorbitant fees for fishing line.
Don't charge them exorbitant fees for access to the river/lake/ocean
Don't set the rules so that bottom dragging trawlers can clear all the prime zones.
Don't set the rules so that processing their catch takes too much of their income.
Don't force them to need permits while larger boats and ships don't.
Don't let big polluters destroy the beds.
Don't let big agriculture destroy the grounds with excessive fertilizer runoff.
Don't let big companies destroy rivers and grounds with fish farms.

And so on
 
jcpro, I tend to agree with your posts, but I do think the U.S. has an income inequality problem. We agree taxing people more and giving it to the underclass is not a panacea. We probably agree that taking on unfair trade and illegal immigration gives low wage earners in the economy a fighting chance. There's other measure to improve income levels for the lower quartile, but too much for a social media dissertation.

I have some empathy for taxing the 1%. Let's take away all the loopholes for sure. I fear that taxing the crap out of the 1% just gradually moves their economic activity to another domain. Why does the U.S. have a tremendously wealthy and dynamic 1%?

Give people an opportunity to catch fish. Don't take other people's fish and give them to someone else.

Income inequality. Think about that for a while. Can the income inequality be eliminated? Of course not in a competitive economic environment. It cannot be even eliminated in North Korea or Cuba. The outcomes, manipulated or organic or everything in between, are always different. And it has nothing to do with politics or the economic systems. Inequality of outcomes is a certain as gravity. The developed world decided to mitigate the effects of inequality by producing the progressive tax system, but even that has its limits because excessive taxation produces lower productivity, growth of the underground economy and organized crime and simple tax fraud. Instead of fighting windmills of "inequality", we should strive to create opportunities for more people to join the middle class. But, we are not going in the right direction. The wages stagnated and in some areas the middle class has actually shrank. The whole point of the politics of the "income inequality" is to keep us angry, divided and distracted from the real issues like shrinking economic opportunities, the runway growth of the regulatory bodies with no benefits to the citizenry, high cost of the higher education, etc.
 
Income inequality. Think about that for a while. Can the income inequality be eliminated? Of course not in a competitive economic environment. It cannot be even eliminated in North Korea or Cuba. The outcomes, manipulated or organic or everything in between, are always different. And it has nothing to do with politics or the economic systems. Inequality of outcomes is a certain as gravity. The developed world decided to mitigate the effects of inequality by producing the progressive tax system, but even that has its limits because excessive taxation produces lower productivity, growth of the underground economy and organized crime and simple tax fraud. Instead of fighting windmills of "inequality", we should strive to create opportunities for more people to join the middle class. But, we are not going in the right direction. The wages stagnated and in some areas the middle class has actually shrank. The whole point of the politics of the "income inequality" is to keep us angry, divided and distracted from the real issues like shrinking economic opportunities, the runway growth of the regulatory bodies with no benefits to the citizenry, high cost of the higher education, etc.

Not eliminated. Mitigated. By leveling certain playing fields in healthcare and education. Give everyone equal access to healthcare and that worry is gone. More importantly over 60% of all personal bankruptcy in the USA is gone as a result.

Next in education. Both in equalization payments at the state level to see all schools in all neighbourhoods recieve equal funding. And in tuition to State funded colleges. As well fund apprentice programs for tradespersons.

Then increase employee protection laws and the minimum wage.

These three things will create two things. Opportunity for the top in any socio-economic class to rise on merit, and for the bottom to be better. So their children can have a shot.
 
Not eliminated. Mitigated. By leveling certain playing fields in healthcare and education. Give everyone equal access to healthcare and that worry is gone. More importantly over 60% of all personal bankruptcy in the USA is gone as a result.

Next in education. Both in equalization payments at the state level to see all schools in all neighbourhoods recieve equal funding. And in tuition to State funded colleges. As well fund apprentice programs for tradespersons.

Then increase employee protection laws and the minimum wage.

These three things will create two things. Opportunity for the top in any socio-economic class to rise on merit, and for the bottom to be better. So their children can have a shot.

We have lots of those things in Canada and the income inequality keeps on growing.
 
We have lots of those things in Canada and the income inequality keeps on growing.

Do you see riots?

It will never be perfect. But the USA can be a damn sight better. And as for Canada I agree. Time to add a bit more tax on the higher end.