Anyone notice how strange it is to see the president backing protesters with rebel flags while claiming he has the power to overrule state governments?
Anyone notice how strange it is to see the president backing protesters with rebel flags while claiming he has the power to overrule state governments?
It's not really strange. Both parties argue for state's rights and the authority of Washington alternating when it suits their position. California's Democratic leaders might argue for the right of the state in one matter and then discuss the federal authority in another breath.
It's just politics. I'm guessing this happens in Canadian politics as well.
The whole "States Rights" thing also doesn't really have the same power, because no one had to make up a reason for the Civil War that was less shameful than slavery.
...
The Southern States in 1861 foresaw and rightly so an erosion of the institution of slavery by Federal power. So I'm not sure "States Rights" were a made up thing as you described it.
Let's compare. The "scary" people with guns at the Michigan's House and the one in Ohio.https://www.citizenfreepress.com/breaking/rioters-break-into-ohio-statehouse-raw/
That might be a bit of editorializing unnecessarily. Every student of American history knows that slavery was essentially codified into the U.S. Constitution. The Northern colonies had to establish an American union through some awful compromises with the States with slavery.
The Southern States in 1861 foresaw and rightly so an erosion of the institution of slavery by Federal power. So I'm not sure "States Rights" were a made up thing as you described it.
I wasn't clear then. "States Rights" isn't a made up thing. That's been bandied about for ages in US discourse.
Now I can say "States Rights" discourse is mostly bullshit. Since the Civil War, the U.S. Federal government has centralized more and more authority and power over the States. The Courts have usually obliged if at first reluctant. Many State programs are funded by Federal money as the Federal government is by far the biggest taxing body in the country. Same goes for regulation. Federal regulation is more extensive.
I find the most intriguing "States Rights" political arguments in the cultural issues. Not that I agree with them. Let's just just say they have more panache when they go through the court systems. Having checkerboard U.S. maps of states where abortion and same-sex marriage are permitted is on its face ridiculous in the 21st century. Immigration is another one where it might appeal to certain states to argue that they can ignore Federal laws. Then it's fun to see all the hoop-jumping to make a political point and court arguments.
Doesn't change that the usage of "States Rights' when referring to the civil war and the Confederate Battle Flag from it is explicitly the right to own slaves.
Let's compare. The "scary" people with guns at the Michigan's House and the one in Ohio.https://www.citizenfreepress.com/breaking/rioters-break-into-ohio-statehouse-raw/
Think about it. What do you think would have happened in the state capitol if a police man put his hands on a rabid gun nut instead of doing what they did, which was show the ultimate submission.
The image of the cop like he was about to cry when being shouted at by the gun nut was telling.
I don't think anyone here has disagreed.
Why would they? The cops in Lansing faced a legal and peaceful protest. Why would they violate the protesters' civil rights? The hoodlums burning down the cities- that's a whole other story.
Isn't this the core of the issue in the US right now? Police let armed white militia groups have their civil rights but not black guys?
When you're burning and looting you have the Miranda rights after your arrest.
Not when you are murdered in the process of being arrested.
Yawn. Straw man/off topic.
Because you can't respond to it.
ROTFLMAO.