Hey, that reads totally like a Trump speech on science!
Well done.
A ridiculous response from someone who does not understand the science at all
.That one bolded statement shows how faulty your Mr Science speech is, larue.
You admit that the long term water vapour levels are only ever 2-4% of the atmosphere, admitting that they can't ever increase drastically long term.
Then you post the CO2 levels we are at now, ignoring that we've nearly doubled those CO2 levels in couple of hundred years
So what?
The long term concentration of water vapour is 2-4% vs 0.04% Co2. What part of this do you not understand????
You could add another 0.04% CO2 and the greenhouse effect will still be dominated by water vapour. What part do this do you not understand???
In addition as I have pointed out absorption has a logarithmic relationship to concentration. diminishing returns with each addition. The 15 micrometer absorbance wavelength (the one everyone is so concerned about) is essentially saturated at 200 ppm CO2. What part do this do you not understand???. My guess is you do not understand any of that statement, so you ignore it
As you define them ????And you still don't understand the difference between a forcing effect and a feedback effect.
This statement is factually incorrect:
Both water & CO2 absorb infrared radiation. Therefore both have a radiative forcing effect.
This statement is true ask a different honest scientist
Show us the physics which disproves this or go away
The correct statement would be:Both water & CO2 absorb infrared radiation. Therefore both have a radiative effect.
Again so what?
Both absorb Infrared radiation which traps heat, due to its higher concentration and higher absorptivity water Vapour is the more dominating greenhouse gas and by a lot
You seem hung up on the word "forcing
How you define it likely is one of the sources of your confusion. even more likely is the fact you do not understand this at all
Either way, you seem to want to ignore the radiative forcing effects of WAter Vapour despite having no physical basis for ignoring it
The physics do not support the excessive temperature predictions & neither does the actual data
If water vapour had a feedback effect then adding more water vapour in the atmosphere as the planet has warmed 1ºC would mean that water vapour would amplify those changes even more.
Instead, it turns into more rain and more clouds which have a cooling effect and then goes back to its stock 2-4% range in the atmosphere.
Well you had better tell the IPCC as you have just nullified their positive feedback:
https://www.carbonbrief.org/guest-post-understanding-climate-feedbacks
As temperatures rise, more water evaporates from the Earth’s surface and is present in the atmosphere. As water is itself a greenhouse gas, higher concentrations in the atmosphere have a warming effect, creating a positive feedback. This process is well understood by scientists.
You really do not have a clue
The whole disagreement between rational scientists and alarmists is the nature and net positive or negative effect of the feedbacks
Both agree doubling co2 might increase the temp by 1C. Nothing to be concerned about . The Alarmist though tack on another 2-3 celsius for feedback effects, which are very debatable as you just proved
You just made the rational scientist argument against your position
This is so comical
You were saying?You need to do better, Mr Science.

