Greta Thunberg to Congress: ‘You’re not trying hard enough. Sorry’

Hey, that reads totally like a Trump speech on science!
Well done.

A ridiculous response from someone who does not understand the science at all

That one bolded statement shows how faulty your Mr Science speech is, larue.
You admit that the long term water vapour levels are only ever 2-4% of the atmosphere, admitting that they can't ever increase drastically long term.
Then you post the CO2 levels we are at now, ignoring that we've nearly doubled those CO2 levels in couple of hundred years
.

So what?
The long term concentration of water vapour is 2-4% vs 0.04% Co2. What part of this do you not understand????
You could add another 0.04% CO2 and the greenhouse effect will still be dominated by water vapour. What part do this do you not understand???

In addition as I have pointed out absorption has a logarithmic relationship to concentration. diminishing returns with each addition. The 15 micrometer absorbance wavelength (the one everyone is so concerned about) is essentially saturated at 200 ppm CO2. What part do this do you not understand???. My guess is you do not understand any of that statement, so you ignore it

And you still don't understand the difference between a forcing effect and a feedback effect.
This statement is factually incorrect:
As you define them ????

Both water & CO2 absorb infrared radiation. Therefore both have a radiative forcing effect.
This statement is true ask a different honest scientist
Show us the physics which disproves this or go away

The correct statement would be:Both water & CO2 absorb infrared radiation. Therefore both have a radiative effect.

Again so what?
Both absorb Infrared radiation which traps heat, due to its higher concentration and higher absorptivity water Vapour is the more dominating greenhouse gas and by a lot

You seem hung up on the word "forcing
How you define it likely is one of the sources of your confusion. even more likely is the fact you do not understand this at all
Either way, you seem to want to ignore the radiative forcing effects of WAter Vapour despite having no physical basis for ignoring it
The physics do not support the excessive temperature predictions & neither does the actual data

If water vapour had a feedback effect then adding more water vapour in the atmosphere as the planet has warmed 1ºC would mean that water vapour would amplify those changes even more.
Instead, it turns into more rain and more clouds which have a cooling effect and then goes back to its stock 2-4% range in the atmosphere.

Well you had better tell the IPCC as you have just nullified their positive feedback:
https://www.carbonbrief.org/guest-post-understanding-climate-feedbacks
As temperatures rise, more water evaporates from the Earth’s surface and is present in the atmosphere. As water is itself a greenhouse gas, higher concentrations in the atmosphere have a warming effect, creating a positive feedback. This process is well understood by scientists.

You really do not have a clue
The whole disagreement between rational scientists and alarmists is the nature and net positive or negative effect of the feedbacks
Both agree doubling co2 might increase the temp by 1C. Nothing to be concerned about . The Alarmist though tack on another 2-3 celsius for feedback effects, which are very debatable as you just proved
You just made the rational scientist argument against your position
This is so comical


You need to do better, Mr Science.
You were saying?
 
A ridiculous response from someone who does not understand the science at all
So what?
The long term concentration of water vapour is 2-4% vs 0.04% Co2. What part of this do you not understand????
You could add another 0.04% CO2 and the greenhouse effect will still be dominated by water vapour. What part do this do you not understand???
In addition as I have pointed out absorption has a logarithmic relationship to concentration. diminishing returns with each addition. The 15 micrometer absorbance wavelength (the one everyone is so concerned about) is essentially saturated at 200 ppm CO2. What part do this do you not understand???. My guess is you do not understand any of that statement, so you ignore it
As you define them ????
Both water & CO2 absorb infrared radiation. Therefore both have a radiative forcing effect.
This statement is true ask a different honest scientist
Show us the physics which disproves this or go away
Again so what?
Both absorb Infrared radiation which traps heat, due to its higher concentration and higher absorptivity water Vapour is the more dominating greenhouse gas and by a lot
You seem hung up on the word "forcing
How you define it likely is one of the sources of your confusion. even more likely is the fact you do not understand this at all
Either way, you seem to want to ignore the radiative forcing effects of WAter Vapour despite having no physical basis for ignoring it
The physics do not support the excessive temperature predictions & neither does the actual data
Well you had better tell the IPCC as you have just nullified their positive feedback:
https://www.carbonbrief.org/guest-post-understanding-climate-feedbacks
You really do not have a clue
The whole disagreement between rational scientists and alarmists is the nature and net positive or negative effect of the feedbacks
Both agree doubling co2 might increase the temp by 1C. Nothing to be concerned about . The Alarmist though tack on another 2-3 celsius for feedback effects, which are very debatable as you just proved
You just made the rational scientist argument against your position
This is so comical
You were saying?

Its not worth responding to that post, as its incoherent in a very Trumpian/Mr Science manner.
Instead, lets take a look at your core statement:
The long term concentration of water vapour is 2-4% vs 0.04% Co2.

Nitrogen, oxygen and argon make up almost all of the atmosphere.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Earth

All three of those gases are invisible to incoming 'short wave' radiation from the sun, as well as outgoing 'long wave' radiation from the surface of earth.

So for the purposes of sunlight keeping the world warm, you're talking largely about that 0-3% of water vapour plus that 0.04% CO2 (and a couple of other, less stable in the atmosphere, greenhouse gases).

If you put more water vapour into the atmosphere what do you think happens?
Sure, there will be a bit more infrared absorbed, temporarily. As after a few days it will either turn into rain, evaporate with heat or turn into clouds and then reflect more energy back to space, cooling the planet.
Then its back to where it was before, as part of its 10 day long cycle.

Add more heat and that will increase water vapour, meaning water vapour levels change as a result of warming, not the other way around, so water vapour levels are a feedback to climate change.

Contrast that with CO2. Increase heat in the atmosphere and it won't change CO2 levels. Add more CO2 and it will absorb more IR and increase heat in the atmosphere, meaning that it forces the climate to change.

Forcing vs feedback.

Someday, Mr Science, you will understand that basic fact.
 
Its not worth responding to that post, as its incoherent in a very Trumpian/Mr Science manner.

You mean you do not understand it
Instead, lets take a look at your core statement:


My core statements are:

1. Both water & CO2 absorb infrared radiation. Therefore both have a radiative forcing effect. And water Vapour is by far the dominate green house gas
2, You just made the rational scientist argument against your position


Nitrogen, oxygen and argon make up almost all of the atmosphere.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Earth

All three of those gases are invisible to incoming 'short wave' radiation from the sun, as well as outgoing 'long wave' radiation from the surface of earth.

So for the purposes of sunlight keeping the world warm, you're talking largely about that 0-3% of water vapour plus that 0.04% CO2 (and a couple of other, less stable in the atmosphere, greenhouse gases).
It is not 0-3% water vapour it is 2-4%, 50 to 100 times the concentration by volume
ie 50 to 100 H2O molecules for every carbon dioxide molecules


If you put more water vapour into the atmosphere what do you think happens?
Sure, there will be a bit more infrared absorbed, temporarily.
Actually no the incremental radiation will be almost infinitesimal. As pointed out the 15 micrometer wavelength is essentially saturated @ 200 ppm (half of today's levels) of co2 and the water vapour spectrum appears quite saturated as well

temporarily???
Absorption is instantaneous once the correct energy level @ the correct wavelength is achieved
The propagation of the heat from the surface through the billions of billions molecules between the surface and the upper troposphere generally takes the better part of a day. Ever noticed it gets colder during the night?

As after a few days it will either turn into rain, evaporate with heat or turn into clouds and then reflect more energy back to space, cooling the planet.
Which is the offset to the positive warming feedback loop the IPCC models have
Again you argue against your own position
You really do not understand this at all do you?

Then its back to where it was before, as part of its 10 day long cycle.
There is no hard 10 day long rain cycle. Climate is far more chaotic than that

Add more heat and that will increase water vapour, meaning water vapour levels change as a result of warming, not the other way around, so water vapour levels are a feedback to climate change.

Water vapour definitely has a radiative warming effect. This is absolute. call it forcing if you like and it is far more dominate than C02 radiative warming effect
The IPCC agrres on this

Now wether water vapour has a net positive (warming) or net negative effect due to the feedback loops is the difference between the alarmists and more rational scientist
The net positive feedback represent 2/3 of the IPCC models warming. So this is contagious part.
But as you stated the water vapour feedback is negative
As after a few days it will either turn into rain, evaporate with heat or turn into clouds and then reflect more energy back to space, cooling the planet.
So again you need to contact the IPCC and advise them they are wrong

This is just too comical

Contrast that with CO2. Increase heat in the atmosphere and it won't change CO2 levels.
actually higher temperatures do produce C02 outgassing from the oceans
Add more CO2 and it will absorb more IR and increase heat in the atmosphere, meaning that it forces the climate to change.
Higher C02 levels will cause infinitesimal amounts of heating as the absorption of C02 is logarithmic and the 15 micrometer wavelength is essentially saturated @ 200 ppm
So doubling Co2 should warm thing up by 1C, far less for the next doubling

Forcing vs feedback.

Someday, Mr Science, you will understand that basic fact.
It is definitely not factual as you describe it

You seem to think each of Co2 or water molecule can exert one and only one effect.
Water Vapour has both a radiative forcing effect and a feedback loop. The debatable question is whether this feedback loop is positive or negative
The positive feedback is a runaway scenario that just does not occur in nature, did not occur when C02 levels were in the thousands ppm
Thee is some sound (more advanced) physics to rebut the runaway positive scenario, however you continue to struggle with the grade 9 level stuff, so we shall save that for later


Water Vapour and CO2 both absorb infrared and thus both contribute to radiative forcing
The water vapour feedback loop is negative as you describe it, positive as far as the IPCCs inaccurate models

You do not understand at all this subject, despite the efforts to educate you
 
3b8dip.jpg
 
18798668-7492489-image-a-29_1569193882848.jpg


using children for propaganda
 
She is sixteen but dressed like she is twelve. Her
parents could be behind this. Good for them if
Thunberg wins the Nobel Peace Prize for which
she has been nominated.
 
She is sixteen but dressed like she is twelve. Her
parents could be behind this. Good for them if
Thunberg wins the Nobel Peace Prize for which
she has been nominated.

She killed the GOP at the house today.
She's way smarter than most republicans, it appears.

‘Shameful’ and ‘Cowardly’ — Teenage Climate Activists Shame GOP Rep. for His Excuses
Jamie Margolin and Greta Thunberg were not having Rep. Garret Graves’ nonsense
https://www.rollingstone.com/politi...erg-garet-graves-climate-change-video-886908/
 
You mean you do not understand it

No, I mean that its incomprehensible.

My core statements are:

1. Both water & CO2 absorb infrared radiation. Therefore both have a radiative forcing effect. And water Vapour is by far the dominate green house gas
2, You just made the rational scientist argument against your position

Here is how the IPCC defines the terms:
"Radiative forcing is a measure of the influence a factor has in altering the balance of incoming and outgoing energy in the Earth-atmosphere system and is an index of the importance of the factor as a potential climate change mechanism. In this report radiative forcing values are for changes relative to preindustrial conditions defined at 1750 and are expressed in Watts per square meter (W/m2)."

In climatology that means that forcing is change in output or input to the planets atmospheric energy balance. Since water vapour mostly reacts to changes in temperature its doesn't drive change. While CO2 does put a forcing effect that is clearly noted by comparing global temp to CO2 levels on charts.

Your statement 1. fails because you are trying to claim that water vapour is changing the global temperature in some way, according to the IPCC definition of the term we are using, whereas water vapour is keeping the planet's temperature fairly stable.

It is not 0-3% water vapour it is 2-4%, 50 to 100 times the concentration by volume
ie 50 to 100 H2O molecules for every carbon dioxide molecules
O-3%
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Earth




Actually no the incremental radiation will be almost infinitesimal. As pointed out the 15 micrometer wavelength is essentially saturated @ 200 ppm (half of today's levels) of co2 and the water vapour spectrum appears quite saturated as well

temporarily???
Absorption is instantaneous once the correct energy level @ the correct wavelength is achieved
The propagation of the heat from the surface through the billions of billions molecules between the surface and the upper troposphere generally takes the better part of a day. Ever noticed it gets colder during the night?

Yes, temporary. Water vapour stays in the atmosphere in roughly 10 day cycles, from water vapour to rain, to evaporation to clouds. That's temporary when you're talking climate in decades and centuries.


Which is the offset to the positive warming feedback loop the IPCC models have
Again you argue against your own position
You really do not understand this at all do you?

Like I said, its why its not a forcing, because it reacts to temperature and will heat or cool depending on the state its in, but can't change its overall amount of water vapour in the atmosphere unless the atmosphere itself warms up first.


There is no hard 10 day long rain cycle. Climate is far more chaotic than that

Its not a hard 10 day cycle, its an approximate 10 day cycle.
https://pmm.nasa.gov/education/videos/water-cycle-steaming-air

Water vapour definitely has a radiative warming effect. This is absolute. call it forcing if you like and it is far more dominate than C02 radiative warming effect
The IPCC agrres on this

Yes, water vapour does warm the atmosphere. But it only reacts to change it doesn't cause it. CO2 causes change in temperatures with increases in levels, where as water vapour won't.

Now wether water vapour has a net positive (warming) or net negative effect due to the feedback loops is the difference between the alarmists and more rational scientist

Please document these 'rational scientist(s)' who don't believe that CO2 is a forcing and water vapour is a feedback effect.
Give me both of their names, if you dare.



actually higher temperatures do produce C02 outgassing from the oceans
Yes, its true. That's more positive forcing effect from CO2.

Higher C02 levels will cause infinitesimal amounts of heating as the absorption of C02 is logarithmic and the 15 micrometer wavelength is essentially saturated @ 200 ppm
Where on earth did you come up with that cuckoo idea?

You seem to think each of Co2 or water molecule can exert one and only one effect.
Water Vapour has both a radiative forcing effect and a feedback loop. The debatable question is whether this feedback loop is positive or negative
The positive feedback is a runaway scenario that just does not occur in nature, did not occur when C02 levels were in the thousands ppm
Thee is some sound (more advanced) physics to rebut the runaway positive scenario, however you continue to struggle with the grade 9 level stuff, so we shall save that for later

Of course its more complicated, but since you can't understand the basics we have to start there.


Water Vapour and CO2 both absorb infrared and thus both contribute to radiative forcing
The water vapour feedback loop is negative as you describe it, positive as far as the IPCCs inaccurate models

Water vapour's radiative absorbtion does not lead to change in globe's temperature, that's why its not a forcing effect. See the IPCC definition above.


PR_2.png
 
She has been officially invited to Montreal to join
the planned march against climate change. Hope her visit
would inspire folks there to cut down their emission for
real after the march. Meanwhile I already persuaded a
friend visiting from overseas to use GO transit for his
airport trip instead of calling a cab.
 
18798668-7492489-image-a-29_1569193882848.jpg


using children for propaganda

Dinesh D'Souza, the man who was found guilty of corruption and had to spend 5 years in community service only to be pardoned by Trumptard himself. Bahahahaha!!

Right-winger gets destroyed for comparing Greta Thunberg to the Nazis:

https://www.indy100.com/article/greta-thunberg-nazis-dinesh-dsouza-right-wing-9116311

Of course even the far right AfD attacks her:

https://www.theguardian.com/environ...-greta-thunberg-as-it-embraces-climate-denial

No wonder the right wingers follow such despicable sources!!
 
Those who have exploited this young girl should be utterly ashamed. Pure child abuse. Sickening.
 
If it is indeed Greta Thunberg's parents who encouraged or even
manipulated her (which I believe they did) into her climate change
crusade the emotional impact on her won't emerge right away.
 
If it is indeed Greta Thunberg's parents who encouraged or even
manipulated her (which I believe they did) into her climate change
crusade the emotional impact on her won't emerge right away.

True, she'll probably be basking in the glory of starting a world wide movement to make the planet better for years, and as a teen on the spectrum, she may just be left with frustration that there are still people who instead of trying to make things better complain about her.
 
She has more common sense than the leader of the most powerful nation on earth. That individual did not meet with her when he visited the UN earlier today. Maybe she would have driven some sense into him if he listened to her speech!!
 
True, she'll probably be basking in the glory of starting a world wide movement to make the planet better for years, and as a teen on the spectrum, she may just be left with frustration that there are still people who instead of trying to make things better complain about her.

Can you point to any evidence of people changing their lifestyle
upon hearing her talks of the emergency of climate change?

Speaking for myself I am walking to Metro after typing
this comment for my groceries. It is only a 15 min walk
but I feel better not having to drive. I used to walk to a
Food Basic nearby which was only 5 min walk from
my residence. Unfortunately the plaza where it was
located was demolished for construction of more
high rising condo in an already over-developed area.
 
Those who have exploited this young girl should be utterly ashamed. Pure child abuse. Sickening.

Yes, the right wingers are the sickening ones with all their online abuses and insults of this autistic child. Ultra sickening that anyone would agree with them!!