Crime and Punishment

Nor should the families of the victims be forced to relive the horrors by the virtue of the parole hearings- no matter how unlikely the outcome.
WARNING: The following is very graphic.
Not to be too graphic but what could be worse than tying another human, strangling him to death, staging his dead body to be photographed, cutting up the body and putting the body parts in planters on someone's property?

For that he gets 8 life sentences to be served concurrently. Why not just give him one life sentence?

I'm not sure but I think he can request/demand a parole hearing every two years. So even after he is denied parole he can demand a hearing again and again and again. Why subject the families, friends and the community to this pain again and again?
 
WARNING: The following is very graphic.
Not to be too graphic but what could be worse than tying another human, strangling him to death, staging his dead body to be photographed, cutting up the body and putting the body parts in planters on someone's property?

For that he gets 8 life sentences to be served concurrently. Why not just give him one life sentence?

I'm not sure but I think he can request/demand a parole hearing every two years. So even after he is denied parole he can demand a hearing again and again and again. Why subject the families, friends and the community to this pain again and again?
He got eight life sentences because he said he was guilty of eight murders. The thought of picking just one of the eight as the only one to result in a sentence is as abhorrent as not sentencing the guilty murderer for the other seven at all. Not to mention the possibility — far-fetched though it might be — that if the one conviction he was sentenced for was later overturned for some reason, he'd walk away scot-free.

The friends and community need not pay attention to his application, nor to the hearing if there is one in two and a half decades. But I believe the only sure thing if he lives to 91 is that he will then have a right to assemble and present an application for parole., which the Board must consider, but may also reject without a hearing.
 
Why not just give him 8X25= 200 years?? Yes obviously he wont live that long, but it would be totally justified

Some people will argue that he did get 8x25=200 years. It's just that all 8 life sentences are served concurrently.

Article on the Paul Bernardo's first parole hearing. I think he is allowed to apply again in 2 years.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/bernardo-parole-mahaffy-french-1.4866556

Robert Pickton will be eligible for his first parole hearing in 11 years.
He was convicted in only 6 of his suspected murders.
 
Some people will argue that he did get 8x25=200 years. It's just that all 8 life sentences are served concurrently.

Article on the Paul Bernardo's first parole hearing. I think he is allowed to apply again in 2 years.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/bernardo-parole-mahaffy-french-1.4866556

Robert Pickton will be eligible for his first parole hearing in 11 years.
He was convicted in only 6 of his suspected murders.

Just because he can apply doesn't mean that he will, and it certainly doesn't mean he will get out. He won't see the light of day again.

A friend said that sentencing him to 25 is smart since it takes away his chance to appeal it. He pled guilty, so no trial. Give him the minimum so no appeal. Bernardo dragged things out for YEARS if you remember, so to that end it's pretty smart.
 
He can appeal his conviction, and he can also separately appeal the sentence. If he's sentenced to the minimum, he can't appeal that it's unreasonable so this takes that avenue away from him.
 
He can appeal his conviction, and he can also separately appeal the sentence. If he's sentenced to the minimum, he can't appeal that it's unreasonable so this takes that avenue away from him.
Nor can he appeal the eight convictions that are the consequence of his guilty pleas.
 
He can appeal his conviction, and he can also separately appeal the sentence. If he's sentenced to the minimum, he can't appeal that it's unreasonable so this takes that avenue away from him.

Nor can he appeal the eight convictions that are the consequence of his guilty pleas.

So, as long as the criminal (no matter how heinous the crime) is given the minimum sentence allowed by law, then he/she would most likely not appeal. I heard that the Crown might appeal the McArthur sentence as there is no downside.
 
I heard that the Crown might appeal the McArthur sentence as there is no downside
He should.

If you're gonna give Dillon Millard (or whatever his name was) 3 consecutive life sentences, you gotta give the same to MacArthur