So did Backpages shutdown actually accomplish anything?

chafien

Member
Apr 17, 2012
73
20
8
Besides establishing a new "website king pin" and allow him/her to generate money until they shut that down in a few years?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Of course not. There is, and always will be, a demand for commercial sex. As long as that demand exists, there will be platforms on which to advertise said services. This is just a big, stupid cycle. Kill one, another will pop up, eventually get big enough to get on the government’s radar, then it’ll get shut down too, and the cycle continues.

Doing anything other than legalizing and regulating sex work is simply fighting against the tide. They will never accomplish anything whatsoever, but I guess as long as there are idiots who don’t understand the issue, they’ll keep trying.
 
One thing about being in control is to never allow something to get too big.

They just wanted to cut BP down because it's gotten too big.
They know another will rise up eventually.

It's just part of the cycle. What they've accomplished is keeping things in check before they get too big, too wealthy. Just to show who's boss.
 
Of course not. There is, and always will be, a demand for commercial sex. As long as that demand exists, there will be platforms on which to advertise said services. This is just a big, stupid cycle. Kill one, another will pop up, eventually get big enough to get on the government’s radar, then it’ll get shut down too, and the cycle continues.

.

yeah kinda like the "illegal download websites", either by torrents of direct downloads. Everytime one is shut down, another new one or 2 rise up.

One thing about being in control is to never allow something to get too big.

Even trough for that, usually the new player take time to expand and get recognition, until it get "too big" and is then shut down.
 
New sites have replaced those seized and shutdown.

Switter is an interesting new site that can't be seized or shutdwon.
 
It didn’t make things harder for traffickers. It pushed commercial sex farther underground, the criminal elements were already underground to begin with, that doesn’t bother them. This is why legalization and regulation is the way to go. Nothing puts criminals out of business faster than having to compete with legal, legitimate business. It’s not going to be profitable to traffick girls for the sex trade if there are legal brothels and agencies that are monitored to ensure they’re not hiring underage or trafficked girls, and if it’s not profitable, they won’t do it.
 
It will probably help some people to get elected/re-elected.