Sued for 2.5M for Fender Bender

Cheeta

Active member
May 5, 2002
536
245
43
GTA
Hi Everyone,

I tend to be in Europe most of the time. I was involved in fender bender and now getting sued for 2.5M. My liability is 1M. Spoke to insurance lawyer today. I was recommended to see my own lawyer. Freaking people trying to make money for fender bender accident
 
The most important question, was anyone hurt?

I'm surprised that the insurance lawyer told you to take on a secondary lawyer. How far along the process are you?
 
The passenger was just released from Hospital due to hand surgery. She had pre-existing surgery but no one else but there are lots of false claims. We are going for discovery in few weeks. My insurance is TD.
 
Hi Everyone,

I tend to be in Europe most of the time. I was involved in fender bender and now getting sued for 2.5M. My liability is 1M. Spoke to insurance lawyer today. I was recommended to see my own lawyer. Freaking people trying to make money for fender bender accident

Good news is that even if they win they will never get close to that amount. People come up with these ridiculous amounts hoping that you'll settle out of court for much less and think you're getting off easy.
 
Hi Everyone,

I tend to be in Europe most of the time. I was involved in fender bender and now getting sued for 2.5M. My liability is 1M. Spoke to insurance lawyer today. I was recommended to see my own lawyer. Freaking people trying to make money for fender bender accident

Is there deportation agreements for just fiscal obligations ?
 
Your lawyer should be able to give you at least a preliminary assessment of damages. The larges component will be loss of future income and future medical expense. if the person is back to work those claims may be small or non-existent. The number in a Statement of Claim is irrelevant. It is only the damages they can prove.
 
Hi Everyone,

I tend to be in Europe most of the time. I was involved in fender bender and now getting sued for 2.5M. My liability is 1M. Spoke to insurance lawyer today. I was recommended to see my own lawyer. Freaking people trying to make money for fender bender accident

It is indeed designed to scare you to settle for a lower amount.

But TD should still be responsible for fighting the 1 million dollar part of the claim, and they should be the ones leading this; I doubt they would simply pay out a million bucks for this and just walk away and leave you on the hook for the rest. Canada is not the US. The claims for pain and suffering are counted in the thousands, not millions, unless you caused her to become disabled and deprived her of her professional earnings, like unable to practise dentistry as a result.

But it could be a good idea to retain your own lawyer, if only to make sure that your interests are defended against the insurance company itself.
 
Thanks Everyone.. TD lawyer .. 90% are settled are out of court. But I need to cover my self.
 
Hi Everyone,

I tend to be in Europe most of the time. I was involved in fender bender and now getting sued for 2.5M. My liability is 1M. Spoke to insurance lawyer today. I was recommended to see my own lawyer. Freaking people trying to make money for fender bender accident

Just curious.
Was the accident here or in Europe?
 
Unless the other party was seriously injured, like fucked up for life, there is no way in hell they will get even close to that number. They need to prove damages.

That said, if the other person required surgery, the accident was more than a "fender bender". A fender bender means that there was slight damage to the vehicle, very much still driveable and other than some stiffness maybe, there were no injuries. You also said you were charged with careless, though it was dismissed. I don't think it was just a fender bender. But I digress.

I have a good friend who is currently being sued for 2 million as well as a result of an accident she was at fault for. I called up my insurance company and asked them what was the premium cost for increasing my liability from a million to two million and was told 12 bucks a year. I was like, "sign me up". They then asked why I wanted to increase my liability, to which I responded, "because a million bucks isn't what it used to be." All of which is very true.

So for 12 bucks more a year, I can't fathom why anyone would not want the extra insurance.
 
Unless the other party was seriously injured, like fucked up for life, there is no way in hell they will get even close to that number. They need to prove damages.

That said, if the other person required surgery, the accident was more than a "fender bender". A fender bender means that there was slight damage to the vehicle, very much still driveable and other than some stiffness maybe, there were no injuries. You also said you were charged with careless, though it was dismissed. I don't think it was just a fender bender. But I digress.

I have a good friend who is currently being sued for 2 million as well as a result of an accident she was at fault for. I called up my insurance company and asked them what was the premium cost for increasing my liability from a million to two million and was told 12 bucks a year. I was like, "sign me up". They then asked why I wanted to increase my liability, to which I responded, "because a million bucks isn't what it used to be." All of which is very true.

So for 12 bucks more a year, I can't fathom why anyone would not want the extra insurance.

I only carry 1 million.

My thoughts are.....if you have 1 million coverage, or 2 million, they will go after the entire policy.

If they go after personal assets, they will do that with either coverage.

But I guess saving $12 isn't worth it......but I guess I do it on principle.
 
I only carry 1 million.

My thoughts are.....if you have 1 million coverage, or 2 million, they will go after the entire policy.

If they go after personal assets, they will do that with either coverage.

But I guess saving $12 isn't worth it......but I guess I do it on principle.

I don't think that they would know the limit on your policy. I mean, how could they? Your insurance company is NEVER going to aid and abet that kind of nonsense and even the other guy's insurance company is not going to aid in that sort of thing because today it's your insurance company, tomorrow it's them. Insurance companies will work together to prevent fraud. I've seen it when a company I worked with had an accident that resulted in truly minor damage to a car. There was never any doubt as to fault, but the "innocent driver" tried to make several fraudulent bogus claims and HER adjuster fought her. I asked our adjuster about it and he said, "no-one wants to see fraud in the industry". Which made sense actually.

And if say your policy is a million and some guy successfully sues you for 2 million, all they can do is put a lien on your house. I could be wrong, but I don't think there is anything that compels you to sell your house to pay up.
 
You also said you were charged with careless, though it was dismissed. I don't think it was just a fender bender.

You can be charged with careless driving without ever hitting someone, so I don't think that proves anything.
That said, you're right that a "fender bender" implies minor damage with very little impact, the type that doesn't cause serious injury. But if there was a prior surgery...it's possible it's legit. If there was an old hand injury and the OP hit her direct on a front wheel, the resulting jerk on the steering wheel could have caused major damage.

Still, even if she outright lost her hand I don't see how $2.5M is warranted unless she's a goddamn surgeon.
 
As long as you are covered and this case is truly some kind of hand injury requiring surgery, you have nothing to worry about.

No court is going to award someone $2.5 million.

The insurance company will fight tooth and nail to pay off the victim as little as possible. $1 million liability is plenty.

She'll be lucky if she gets $20,000.
 
You are wrong. The OP is 100% correct, take the extra coverage. Your policy limit has nothing to do with the claim amount filed against you. Further, if you are injured in an accident and the other party has insufficient coverage (or no coverage) to settle the damages your own policy will kick in to its limit. Your "thoughts" and "principles" on the matter would take a turn to the incontinent if you were only covered for $1M and looking @ a $2M action against you. Or if you were catastrophically injured and the other guy had insufficient/no coverage. Capisci?

I only carry 1 million.

My thoughts are.....if you have 1 million coverage, or 2 million, they will go after the entire policy.

If they go after personal assets, they will do that with either coverage.

But I guess saving $12 isn't worth it......but I guess I do it on principle.
 
You can be charged with careless driving without ever hitting someone, so I don't think that proves anything.
That said, you're right that a "fender bender" implies minor damage with very little impact, the type that doesn't cause serious injury. But if there was a prior surgery...it's possible it's legit. If there was an old hand injury and the OP hit her direct on a front wheel, the resulting jerk on the steering wheel could have caused major damage.

Still, even if she outright lost her hand I don't see how $2.5M is warranted unless she's a goddamn surgeon.
The OP says the person claiming the hand injury was the passenger. On the second point: Right hand or left, which of yours would you be content to 'lose outright' merely for the price of a house?

'Compensation' and cost calculations aside — and not commenting on the OP's case — part of the purpose of damages is to punish, and educate drivers who injure others in collisions they carelessly caused and then irresponsibly minimize. And to discourage others like them whose 'accidents' are still ahead; $2.5 million does get attention in way a speed-limit or amber light doesn't seem to.
 
You are wrong. The OP is 100% correct, take the extra coverage. Your policy limit has nothing to do with the claim amount filed against you. Further, if you are injured in an accident and the other party has insufficient coverage (or no coverage) to settle the damages your own policy will kick in to its limit. Your "thoughts" and "principles" on the matter would take a turn to the incontinent if you were only covered for $1M and looking @ a $2M action against you. Or if you were catastrophically injured and the other guy had insufficient/no coverage. Capisci?

Thank you for so eloquently pointing out I am wrong on your first post. Welcome to TERB.

I never said your policy limit has anything to do with the claim against you. All I am saying is if you had 1m and they sued for 2m, they would have to come after other assets.

From what I have read, the coverage applies more to frequent travellers in the US, because in Canada you rarely get claims that large.

Also, the 2m has nothing to do with your personal coverage. There is a different section in your insurance policy that covers if you are injured by an uninsured driver.

This board is about discussion and opinion, not about pointing out someone is right or wrong.

Capisci?
 

Here, you don't really have that much to worry about, but keeping a lawyer on call makes good sense. By what you've told she sustained far less injury than I did. I'm slightly miffed, my lawyer filed for only $1.8 million (did she hire Diamond and Diamond). I'm also relieved that I paid the extra coin for comprehensive coverage. During my basket case phase the coverage paid for itself. She was a passenger and she injured her hand - was she wearing a seat-belt? Did she return to Europe?


huckfinn you're wrong! It's capire. ;)