Human Life > Duck Life

What a moron! Stopping her car in the middle of traffic and having a motorcyclist plow into her vehicle. What was she thinking? For a bunch of stupid ducks? Two people are now dead.
 
Sentence is lenient:
" A jury convicted her in June 2014 of two counts of criminal negligence causing death and two counts of dangerous driving causing death. She was sentenced in December 2014 to 90 days in jail to be served on weekends, three years' probation and 240 hours of community service, and given a 10-year driving ban."

In any road, but specially in a highway, you need to drive defensively, as if all people around you were imbeciles going to do something stupid soon.
More so if driving a motorcycle
 
that is all she got!! that sentence is a joke way to lenient
 
Why did the motorcyclist not stop?
 
What a moron! Stopping her car in the middle of traffic and having a motorcyclist plow into her vehicle. What was she thinking? For a bunch of stupid ducks? Two people are now dead.

It was not in the middle of traffic
She abandoned her vehicle in the left (passing) lane on the provincial highway
 
Why did the motorcyclist not stop?

Could be variety of reasons
Speeding, someone was tailgating him, obstructed vision, not enough distance to apply brakes safely etc

He *attempted* to stop, he just was incapable of slowing down enough to avoid fatally striking the stopped vehicle
 
She got off that easy and still appealed? Just from her original statement you could question her intelligence, the fact she appealed cements it. What is she trying to get, her license back? Did she hear about more animals that need saving ans she wants to go get em? SMH
 
To my mind, it was not that she braked for the ducklings or even that she came to a complete stop.

Rather it is that she parked in the passing lane and got out of her car, rather than either pulling completely off the roadway, or saying to herself: 'I missed the ducklings, I hope they make it, but I can't just park here in the passing lane.'
 
To my mind, it was not that she braked for the ducklings or even that she came to a complete stop.

Rather it is that she parked in the passing lane and got out of her car, rather than either pulling completely off the roadway, or saying to herself: 'I missed the ducklings, I hope they make it, but I can't just park here in the passing lane.'

Well, that explains it. Stopping in a passing lane is pretty unconsidered to other drivers.

But really, the title of the thread is misleading. This has nothing to do with the relative value of a duck and a human.
 
I think I'm missing something here.

Stopping or parking on a highway, especially in the left lane, is a nuisance to other drivers, sure. But assuming she didn't slam on the brakes suddenly and went from 100+ to zero in a matter of two seconds, anyone behind her should have been driving a proper distance behind her and saw her brake lights or the fact that the car is not moving (assuming she turned on the hazards).

If a driver couldn't stop properly because there was no enough room to apply brakes, then they were driving too close and is in effect tailgating. That's a bigger offense when it comes to unsafe driving.

What she did was stupid but I can't believe she is getting jail time for this. She did not kill those people. Those people killed themselves by driving too close and failing to see a stopped car. But again, maybe I'm missing something.
 
I think I'm missing something here.

Stopping or parking on a highway, especially in the left lane, is a nuisance to other drivers, sure. But assuming she didn't slam on the brakes suddenly and went from 100+ to zero in a matter of two seconds, anyone behind her should have been driving a proper distance behind her and saw her brake lights or the fact that the car is not moving (assuming she turned on the hazards).

If a driver couldn't stop properly because there was no enough room to apply brakes, then they were driving too close and is in effect tailgating. That's a bigger offense when it comes to unsafe driving.

What she did was stupid but I can't believe she is getting jail time for this. She did not kill those people. Those people killed themselves by driving too close and failing to see a stopped car. But again, maybe I'm missing something.

You can't assume she had hazards on. Anyone dumb enough to even THINK of stopping in the left lane of a highway is unlikely to do anything else remotely considered safe. She should never be allowed to drive again, she certainly does not have enough common sense to be trusted to operate a vehicle safely.
 
I think I'm missing something here.

Stopping or parking on a highway, especially in the left lane, is a nuisance to other drivers, sure. But assuming she didn't slam on the brakes suddenly and went from 100+ to zero in a matter of two seconds, anyone behind her should have been driving a proper distance behind her and saw her brake lights or the fact that the car is not moving (assuming she turned on the hazards).

If a driver couldn't stop properly because there was no enough room to apply brakes, then they were driving too close and is in effect tailgating. That's a bigger offense when it comes to unsafe driving.

What she did was stupid but I can't believe she is getting jail time for this. She did not kill those people. Those people killed themselves by driving too close and failing to see a stopped car. But again, maybe I'm missing something.

The driver who got killed certainly committed a traffic violation, following too closely or some such. Maybe his estate should be made to pay a few hundred bucks traffic fine.

But she also should have known that what she did was inherently dangerous hence the CRIMINAL charge of negligence causing death.

There's wrong on both sides but the guy who died is only guilty of a moving violation. She committed a crime.
 
You can't assume she had hazards on. Anyone dumb enough to even THINK of stopping in the left lane of a highway is unlikely to do anything else remotely considered safe. She should never be allowed to drive again, she certainly does not have enough common sense to be trusted to operate a vehicle safely.

Even if there were no hazards, the motorcycle driver should've seen that the car is not moving (assuming they were nowhere close and just caught up to her) or saw the brake lights go off. Either way, the motorcycle driver either decided not to slow down when they saw a stopped car or they were tailgating and couldn't stop in time. Both are dumbass moves and unfortunately they paid with their lives. But again, maybe I'm missing something.

As for her, sure strip her of her license if that's what the Quebec laws state but people have done way more stupid things on the road without having to even go near the level of repercussions as jail time. She was convicted of criminal negligence. Really? Stupid, sure but stopping on a highway is not criminal. But then again, people in Quebec drive like assholes so I don't know if their driving laws reflect that.
 
I feel sorry for her. She thought she was being a good Samaritan.

I'd have to check where it happened, what highway.

But I've been to Quebec probably 200 times and they drive like fucking idiots there. Especially the rural highways where the roads are narrow and winding and the speed limit is 90 and yet everyone does 120 or more. Tailgating is a sport. They now allow turning right on a red but Quebecers don't seem to grasp that when you have the red, you need to stop first no matter what. They all just think they can just keep going and make that right right into traffic.
 
I think I'm missing something here.

Stopping or parking on a highway, especially in the left lane, is a nuisance to other drivers, sure. But assuming she didn't slam on the brakes suddenly and went from 100+ to zero in a matter of two seconds, anyone behind her should have been driving a proper distance behind her and saw her brake lights or the fact that the car is not moving (assuming she turned on the hazards).

If a driver couldn't stop properly because there was no enough room to apply brakes, then they were driving too close and is in effect tailgating. That's a bigger offense when it comes to unsafe driving.

What she did was stupid but I can't believe she is getting jail time for this. She did not kill those people. Those people killed themselves by driving too close and failing to see a stopped car. But again, maybe I'm missing something.

You are not a very insightful driver
 
Stopping in a passing lane(or any lane) of a highway is not only extremely dangerous, but incredibly stupid thing to do. Such action is literally seconds from disaster, especially if there is even a slight obstruction to a line of sight. Drivers are just not conditioned to react in the short time in which it takes to initiate avoidance action. A driver of a vehicle moving at 30m/s can easily avoid a crash when conditions are perfect, but if there's a curve, an even small grade or another vehicle in front, can go from zero to terror in no time flat and with deadly consequences. Has anybody here noticed why 407 is the most popular highway with the cops in the whole GTA? Very wide shoulders. Them cops are not stupid when it comes to looking after their own asses.
 
Even if there were no hazards, the motorcycle driver should've seen that the car is not moving (assuming they were nowhere close and just caught up to her) or saw the brake lights go off. Either way, the motorcycle driver either decided not to slow down when they saw a stopped car or they were tailgating and couldn't stop in time. Both are dumbass moves and unfortunately they paid with their lives. But again, maybe I'm missing something.

What you seem to be missing is the fact that a stopped vehicle usually has hazzards on, and possibly even flares or a roadside cone
Those things would be unnecessary otherwise

If you are travelling 120KM on a highway you will very quickly overtake a stopped vehicle
Even driving 80KM in passing lane would be dangerous as it could very likely get rear ended

And all this is assuming perfect visibility & road conditions