Toronto pedestrian Cross walk protocol question

Google Bill 31, Transportation Statute Law Amendment Act (Making Ontario's Roads Safer), 2015


Pedestrian crossover

Duties of driver
(1) When a pedestrian is crossing on the roadway within a pedestrian crossover, the driver of a vehicle approaching the crossover,
(a) shall stop before entering the crossover;
(b) shall not overtake another vehicle already stopped at the crossover; and
(c) shall not proceed into the crossover until the pedestrian is no longer on the roadway.
(2) Subsections 140 (3), (4) and (6) of the Act are repealed and the following substituted:
Passing moving vehicles within 30 metres of pedestrian crossover
(3) When a vehicle is approaching a pedestrian crossover and is within 30 metres of it, the driver of any other vehicle approaching from the rear shall not allow the front extremity of his or her vehicle to pass beyond the front extremity of the other vehicle.

Duty of pedestrian
(4) No pedestrian shall leave the curb or other place of safety at a pedestrian crossover and walk, run or move into the path of a vehicle that is so close that it is impracticable for the driver of the vehicle to comply with subsection (1).


It says absolutely nothing about a pedestrian having to make sure lights are lit or even point.

It does not mention the lights at all.

I didn't enter the cross walk.

It also says that the pedestrian shall not walk into the path of a vehicle that it is so close that the driver can't stop properly. If it says that, why doesn't it state that the pedestrian is free to enter the cross walk without activating the lights?

For that matter, why go to the expense of putting up the lights at all? If it's not required to activate them, why put them up?
 
And on a related note......

I am aware that the law recently changed requiring drivers to wait until the pedestrian has exited the cross walk on the other side.

But what about signalized intersections? I.e. with a traffic light.

It would seem logical by extension that drivers must wait at a signalized intersection for pedestrians to completely clear the cross walk before they (the driver) turns. But no one does that.
 
Not all. As stated in the law I just posted, the Pedestrian at a crossover is at fault if they step into the crossing when cars are too close to stop (not the case for JTK).

I'll amend "all" to "most".

I'm just calling for common sense. On a dark and stormy night, and when wearing dark clothing, the pedestrian in question should have tried to make himself as visible as possible. He had the tools at hand. He could have triggered the lights. He could have simply made sure the way was clear first.

What's harder to determine is if James wasn't paying attention or if the conditions I listed above made the guy impossible to see until when he did, at which point James responded and avoided collision. And was still flipped off.
 
And on a related note......

I am aware that the law recently changed requiring drivers to wait until the pedestrian has exited the cross walk on the other side.

But what about signalized intersections? I.e. with a traffic light.

It would seem logical by extension that drivers must wait at a signalized intersection for pedestrians to completely clear the cross walk before they (the driver) turns. But no one does that.

The reality is that if you hit a pedestrian anywhere you are in trouble.
If you hit one on a crosswalk wearing a cloak of invisibility you will still be found at fault.

When you drive the big steel box around you are responsible for not hitting other things and people with it.
 
The reality is that if you hit a pedestrian anywhere you are in trouble.
If you hit one on a crosswalk wearing a cloak of invisibility you will still be found at fault.

When you drive the big steel box around you are responsible for not hitting other things and people with it.

I'm aware of all that.

But my question was, "does a driver have to wait for pedestrians to clear a signalized crosswalk (i.e. a traffic light) as the do at a pedestrian crosswalk? "

No one does that.
 
"does a driver have to wait for pedestrians to clear a signalized crosswalk (i.e. a traffic light) as the do at a pedestrian crosswalk? "

pedestrian crosswalk are called crossovers


the answer is no as you are allowed right turn on light and waiting for all pedestrians to clear (at a traffic light) is impractical
 
http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/safety/pedestrian-safety.shtml

For pedestrians

It is up to both drivers and pedestrians to keep everyone safe on Ontario roads. Learn more about how to stay safe as a pedestrian and as a driver.
•Cross only at marked crosswalks or traffic lights. Don't cross in the middle of the block or between parked cars.
•Make sure drivers see you before you cross. If the driver is stopped, make eye contact before you step into the road.
•Wear bright or light-coloured clothing or reflective strips, especially at dusk or when it's dark.
•At a traffic light: •Cross when traffic has come to a complete stop.
•Begin to cross at the start of the green light or “Walk” signal, where provided.
•Do not start to cross if you see a flashing “Do Not Walk” symbol or the light turns yellow. If you already started to cross, complete your crossing in safety.
•Never cross on a red light.

•Watch for traffic turning at intersections or turning into and leaving driveways.


For drivers

Pay special attention to pedestrians as you drive. Here are some tips to follow:
•Always look for pedestrians, especially when turning.
•Watch for children. Drive slowly and cautiously through school zones, residential areas, or any other area where children could be walking or playing.
•Watch out for Community Safety Zone signs that indicate areas where public safety is a special concern, including the possibility of encountering pedestrians.
•Be patient, especially with seniors or pedestrians with disabilities who need more time to cross the road.
•Drive carefully near streetcar stops with islands or zones for passengers getting on and off. Pass them at reasonable speeds, and always be ready in case pedestrians make sudden or unexpected moves.

Fines

Drivers will be fined $150 to $500 and 3 demerit points for offences at pedestrian crossings, school crossings and at crosswalks where there are traffic signals. The maximum fine for running a red light - a practice that puts pedestrians at risk - is $200 to $1000.

Fines are doubled in Community Safety Zones, near schools and public areas. These areas are clearly marked with signs.


For parents

Show your children how to cross a road safely. Teach them to:
•Stay to the side of the road, walking as far away from traffic as they safely can
•Stop at the edge of the sidewalk, and look both ways before crossing the road
•Take extra care on roadways that have no curbs
•Watch out for blind corners (for example, a car coming out of an alley may not see a child pedestrian about to cross).
 
Irrelevant, section 4 is for a very specific situation which did NOT apply to JFK's situation.

I'm sure the police realize that most nights are dark, a lot of people wear dark clothing and almost nobody wears reflective clothing, nor do they carry foghorns or strobe lights. The police will also realize JFK failed to see a pedestrian that already had been on the road for 4-5 seconds.

But we all agree, better alive than right ..........


Section 4 does apply here and is more relevant because of the time of day and choice of clothing. If you can't be seen, how do you expect drivers to see you? Extra precautions must be taken by pedestrians at night and poor weather.

Pedestrian injuries and deaths are not always caused by the driver. Most often it is the pedestrian that is at fault for several reasons, most already stated.
 
I checked with a (Mississauga) police buddy and you might be off the hook. Based on provincial laws and city of Mississauga bylaws (Toronto may have different bylaws):

1) Did the crosswalk have pedestrian walk/no walk signals? Overhead flashing lights often come with pedestrian signals. Normally the pedestrian signal would show "no walk" until he hit the button. Once pressed (often a delay) the overhead flashing lights would go on and ~2 seconds later the pedestrian signal would show "walk". If a driver had hit the pedestrian under these circumstances then the driver would be 100% at fault and would be charged. If the pedestrian didn't hit the button and the signals showed "no walk", driver is still required to try to avoid the accident, but driver would not be charged if the accident was unavoidable*

2) If the crosswalk did not have pedestrian walk/no walk signals, the pedestrian can cross at will when it is "safe" to do so (See Section 4 for meaning of safe). Pedestrian is not legally required to use the overhead lights although it's always recommended to do so. Also considered is light failures and children who aren't able to understand the rules of the road - thus responsibility is put back on the driver.

He said if he witnessed your case where no-one was hit:
- If the crosswalk had pedestrian walk/no walk signals: pedestrian would have been educated but no ticket unless the guy aggressively resisted the lecture.
- If it didn't have walk/no walk signals: no lecture, no ticket. Because you had two lanes of distance and time to notice the pedestrian, you should have seen the pedestrian ..... which you indeed did.
- To a cop, the rain, night and dark clothing excuse would work against you - it's the driver's responsibility to slow down if road conditions are degraded or unsafe. If you aggressively argued, you would get a ticket.
- If the pedestrian was hit, in most cases he would issue a ticket. If the pedestrian didn't enter the roadway safely, he would get the ticket. Otherwise the driver gets the ticket, but not always. He would judge if the driver should have seen the pedestrian and could have avoided the hit. It's not always black and white at which point the driver gets the ticket and it's addressed in court.

There is no law requiring you to use hand signals when crossing a road. It's a concept called gestures (?) originated by the Japanese (?) It is meant to co-ordinate body and mind. Look - point - act. It's proven to work well in Japan, but it doesn't fit the NA culture.


You're way too confrontational on this. (As always.)
You need to step away from the keyboard and relax.
LOL, Says the road rager who rolled down his window and swore at a 50 year old man in a crosswalk. It's because I think you are playing loose with your facts (as always).

It would seem logical by extension that drivers must wait at a signalized intersection for pedestrians to completely clear the cross walk before they (the driver) turns. But no one does that.
All your questions were answered in the links provided. Unless there is a medium, you are required to remained stopped until the pedestrian is back up on the curb. No-one stops at stop signs anymore either - doesn't mean it's okay - we drivers are a lazy foolish bunch.
 
Last edited:
http://ontariorulesoftheroad.blogsp.../do-pedestrians-always-have-right-of-way.html


Do pedestrians always have the right of way?

Most people would say, "yes."

Before getting into the details, we should say that obviously drivers need to respect the fact that their vehicle is a "deadly weapon" and drive accordingly. Technicalities are not important when a mother or father pushing a stroller suddenly appears in front of you in the middle of the block. By slowing down and paying attention, a driver can minimize the chance of a tragedy if a pedestrian (inadvertently or otherwise) does something they shouldn't.

In one of my favorite episodes of The Simpsons, the wealthy Mr. Burns decides he should do more things for himself. This sets him up for some classic lines. When he gets a wrong number telephone call, and answers the phone himself, he says "I suspect you need more practice operating your telephone machine." In another scene, driving his own car for the first time, he tells pedestrians "Out of my way. I'm a motorist."

Thankfully, the law doesn't support Mr. Burns's attitude. Pedestrians do have the right of way, as long as they are obeying their appropriate traffic signals, and are crossing at a crosswalk - whether marked or unmarked. That last point is important. Pedestrians do not have the right of way if they step into the road at some random location, it has to be at a crosswalk, but a legal crosswalk is not necessarily two nice white lines across the road. In Ontario, any intersection with a sidewalk has a legal crosswalk. Basically, whether the lines are visible or not (not there, covered in snow) the crosswalk is there and pedestrians have the right of way.

Legal crosswalks can also be established anywhere across the road by marking them with signs, lines, or other markings. When a crosswalk has both markings and signage indicating the crosswalk, these are named "pedestrian crossovers."

a pedestrian crossover

“crosswalk” means,

(a) that part of a highway at an intersection that is included within the connections of the lateral lines of the sidewalks on opposite sides of the highway measured from the curbs or, in the absence of curbs, from the edges of the roadway, or

(b) any portion of a roadway at an intersection or elsewhere distinctly indicated for pedestrian crossing by signs or by lines or other markings on the surface; (“passage protégé pour piétons”)

“pedestrian crossover” means any portion of a roadway, designated by by-law of a municipality, at an intersection or elsewhere, distinctly indicated for pedestrian crossing by signs on the highway and lines or other markings on the surface of the roadway as prescribed by the regulations; (“passage pour piétons”)

Yielding to pedestrians

(7) When under this section a driver is permitted to proceed, the driver shall yield the right of way to pedestrians lawfully within a crosswalk. R.S.O. 1990, c. H.8, s. 144 (7).

Pedestrian crossing

(22) Where portions of a roadway are marked for pedestrian use, no pedestrian shall cross the roadway except within a portion so marked. R.S.O. 1990, c. H.8, s. 144 (22).

Pedestrian – green light

(23) Subject to subsections (24) and (27), a pedestrian approaching a traffic control signal showing a circular green indication or a straight-ahead green arrow indication and facing the indication may cross the roadway. R.S.O. 1990, c. H.8, s. 144 (23).

Pedestrian – stopping at flashing green light

(24) No pedestrian approaching a traffic control signal and facing a flashing circular green indication or a solid or a flashing left turn arrow indication in conjunction with a circular green indication shall enter the roadway. R.S.O. 1990, c. H.8, s. 144 (24).

Pedestrian – stopping at red or amber light

(25) No pedestrian approaching a traffic control signal and facing a red or amber indication shall enter the roadway. R.S.O. 1990, c. H.8, s. 144 (25).

Pedestrian control signals – walk

(26) Where pedestrian control signals are installed and show a “walk” indication, every pedestrian facing the indication may cross the roadway in the direction of the indication despite subsections (24) and (25). R.S.O. 1990, c. H.8, s. 144 (26).

Pedestrian control signals – don’t walk

(27) No pedestrian approaching pedestrian control signals and facing a solid or flashing “don’t walk” indication shall enter the roadway. R.S.O. 1990, c. H.8, s. 144 (27).

Pedestrian right of way

(28) Every pedestrian who lawfully enters a roadway in order to cross may continue the crossing as quickly as reasonably possible despite a change in the indication he or she is facing and, for purposes of the crossing, has the right of way over vehicles. R.S.O. 1990, c. H.8, s. 144 (28).
 
Section 4 does apply here and is more relevant because of the time of day and choice of clothing. If you can't be seen, how do you expect drivers to see you? Extra precautions must be taken by pedestrians at night and poor weather.

Are you referring to this:
Duty of pedestrian
(4) No pedestrian shall leave the curb or other place of safety at a pedestrian crossover and walk, run or move into the path of a vehicle that is so close that it is impracticable for the driver of the vehicle to comply with subsection (1).


I see nothing about time of day or clothing.

In JFK's case the pedestrian entered on the other side of the road. "It is 4 lanes, but there is parking on either side so cars can only utilize the 2 Centre lanes". That means the pedestrian had to cross two lanes before he even got to JFK's side of the road. Assuming 4 seconds to cross two lanes, JFK's car traveling at 50km/hr would have been AT LEAST 55 meters down the street, giving him sufficient time to see and react.

The rain, night and dark clothing excuse would work against a driver. It's the driver's legal responsibility to slow down if road conditions are degraded or unsafe.
 
Was he fiddling with his cell phone too? Fuck those people annoy me. Just cross the damn road first.
 
...
I freely admitted that I didn't see him until the point where I had to hammer on the brakes. ....

I do appreciate in the OP that you admitted he was likely right. Your yelling at him was a typical reaction due to the adrenalin.
 
It does not mention the lights at all.

I didn't enter the cross walk.

It also says that the pedestrian shall not walk into the path of a vehicle that it is so close that the driver can't stop properly. If it says that, why doesn't it state that the pedestrian is free to enter the cross walk without activating the lights?

For that matter, why go to the expense of putting up the lights at all? If it's not required to activate them, why put them up?

On lights, the law does not require them. Cities put them up to heighten pedestrian safety.

And from your description, you were not so close that it is impracticable to stop, you just weren't paying enough attention.
 
And on a related note......

I am aware that the law recently changed requiring drivers to wait until the pedestrian has exited the cross walk on the other side.

But what about signalized intersections? I.e. with a traffic light.....

The law applies only to "crossovers" and specifically excludes where there are traffic lights or stop signs.
 
I checked with a (Mississauga) police buddy and you might be off the hook. Based on provincial laws and city of Mississauga bylaws (Toronto may have different bylaws): ....

I'm sure the Provincial offense vs. city bylaws give lawyers some billable hours.
 
Are you referring to this:
Duty of pedestrian
(4) No pedestrian shall leave the curb or other place of safety at a pedestrian crossover and walk, run or move into the path of a vehicle that is so close that it is impracticable for the driver of the vehicle to comply with subsection (1).


I see nothing about time of day or clothing.

In JFK's case the pedestrian entered on the other side of the road. "It is 4 lanes, but there is parking on either side so cars can only utilize the 2 Centre lanes". That means the pedestrian had to cross two lanes before he even got to JFK's side of the road. Assuming 4 seconds to cross two lanes, JFK's car traveling at 50km/hr would have been AT LEAST 55 meters down the street, giving him sufficient time to see and react.

The rain, night and dark clothing excuse would work against a driver. It's the driver's legal responsibility to slow down if road conditions are degraded or unsafe.

You're correct, it doesn't say anything about time of day or choice of clothing. The unfortunate part for those who lack any sort of common sense are factors such as these when choosing to cross the street as a pedestrian and feel that they have the right of way, because they are a pedestrian, and all cars must stop for them because they have some loosely veiled legal right to cross as they please and that will protect them from all harm. They say you can't teach common sense, nor can you fix stupidity. When pedestrians are hit, these are determining factors in any investigation, which usually find that there was no driver error involved.
 
A lot depends upon whether as a pedestrian you want to be right or dead.

All these years later I still remember the comment of the grizzled old police sergeant who delivered one of the Freshmen Orientation talks when I arrived at University - - probably by now slightly paraphrased but in general "If you don't want to be injured by motor vehicle during your time here, always act like no vehicle can see you and no vehicle is able to make successful panic stops. Yes, vehicles are supposed to stop for pedestrians in cross walks, but when a 1,590 kg - 3,497 pd vehicle starts to skid on the ice and hits you you are going to be injured - likely severely injured, regardless of the law. But if you live according to what I've told you, that won't happen to you!

Driving instructor (long ago) told me the same about other drivers, perdestrians, cyclists - never assume they see you, never assume they will follow the rules and most important if its possible they will do something stupid they probably will.